Should rubbish be taxed?
1378 published comments with 35 censored.
The following comments were censored from this thread on the BBC's 'Have Your Say' section of their news website.
Should rubbish be taxed?
"Send your trash somewhere else, like Texas."
Julie P, Marietta, United States
White trash only, I suppose?
Should rubbish be taxed?
WHY do we put up with being the most spied upon nation on earth! What next - microchips in the lavatory pan to see how many craps we take a week?
Should rubbish be taxed?
To Andrew Howlett, Manchester
If I find a bug in my bin it will go straight back to the council offices.
My bin had a 'chip, the enphasis on HAD. If you have the same wheelie bins as me, the 'chip is at the front under the rim inside a circular recess
Should rubbish be taxed?
Read my lips.
It already is taxed!
When I see one of those bar-coded chips on the lid of my bin... It's going straight in the bin!
Should rubbish be taxed?
The day I get a chipped bin is the day I start flytipping.
Should rubbish be taxed?
WHY do we put up with being the most spied upon nation on earth! What next - microchips in the lavatory pan to see how many craps we take a week?
Elizabeth Straker
Good idea then they can charge us for how much we dispose of! I didn't know you were in the council ideas group.
Should rubbish be taxed?
Any RFID tag placed on my wheelie bin will be removed and placed in the said bin for recycling.
Should rubbish be taxed?
If I find a bug in my bin it will go straight..... in the microwave, 2 seconds on high should be sufficient to protect my anonymity.
Should rubbish be taxed?
Microwave the bug for 1 second in a microwave. Too long and it will show burn marks, just long enough to zap its antenna.
Should rubbish be taxed?
It seems not many people are aware of this but there is a Mail Preference thingy on the net that let's you cancel all junk mail. I signed on yesteday... I only hope my message doesn't get rejected again as this is my second attempt to post on this topic.
Should rubbish be taxed?
Jackie Scott,
Can you read?
My post is against this tax, as presumably are you being a tory. I make no suggestions of laziness. I recycle and I'll bet your carbon footprint is higher than mine. Your post is needlessly offensive, so get some perspective and actually read comments and try to understand them before posting such tripe.
Should rubbish be taxed?
Spudcat Dave ...or is that " Dave Spart" ?
Everything in your world is them and us and bosses and workers...that's why I will vote Conservative next time. I bet you were a binman once..the sort that wont walk 2 yds to get the bin off the driveway.
Should rubbish be taxed?
This is brilliant. Britain's Tories/Conservatives have turned into the unrealistic, grabbing little scroungers that they used to accuse single mums and benefit claimants of being. The points here are even sillier than the pap Labour people on the street were talking in 78 and 79. Full circle! Hilarious. You know what: Thatcherism didn't make the UK more middle class: it made the middle classes working class - and the knee-jerk reaction continues!
Should rubbish be taxed?
Cassandra, it's called CHRISTMAS!!!
Please use it!
Should rubbish be taxed?
This is an outrage! They are treating thei town citizens like common criminals. Recycle, yes. Microships, no, unless local authoritird are going to fit themselves with microchips too, so that people will know if they are really working.
Julie P, Marietta, United States
And just what the hell does this have to do with you massive polluting yanks, pray?
Should rubbish be taxed?
I support this. I don't think we pay enough tax. I would vote for any party who increases our taxes and then puts it to good use. Improving the health service, the police, the roads, the environment. Isn't that we what we all want? The trouble is so many of the idiots on here want all this but aren't prepared to pay for it. "What! Me? Nothing to do with me!"
Should rubbish be taxed?
Fat people cause more fuel to be used in cars, they use more space on the tube, they eat more and so produce more sewage waste. These microchips should be installed into fat people, an additional tax would be levied per day for every Kg over a predefined limit.
Should rubbish be taxed?
i think that you should put tax on RUBBISH ! you can start by TAXING OUR CORRUPT LYING MURDERING GOVERNMENT FIRST! they are the biggest LOAD OF RUBBISH in this country! doesnt matter if they are labour , coningservatives or liberal hipocrites ,they are all the same , down with government & their theiving policies , they are a load of drug taking paedophiliac corrupt gangsters , its time for a revolution against these menacing criminals . its time to put the rubbish out people , wake up & smell the bullsh*t for what it really is !it explains why tony blair wants to quickly run away from the troubles he's started . how many people have you killed mr bLIAR ? may god have mercy on your soul
Should rubbish be taxed?
if i am to be charged on the amount of rubbish i create does this mean that the post office for instance will be stopped from posting unsolisted mail in my postbox which i have not requested, and which they are being paid by companies to post
Should rubbish be taxed?
"and the street cleaners only pick up small bits of paper with their pickers for hours"
A street cleaner?!
LUXURY!
/Monty Python
But seriously, they got rid of the street cleaner here years ago. There is mouldy dog poo on the pavement, it's been there so long.
Should rubbish be taxed?
What the **** are we supposed to be paying council tax for?????
Should rubbish be taxed?
they should tax rubbish, i mean think about it!!
if we tax rubbish, the Labour party would pay the most!!.............
everything they do, touch, think about, say and imply is rubbish!!..........
what a load of Rubbish - full stop!
Should rubbish be taxed?
"Why should childless single people and couples (who are contributing just as much to the economy) have to subsidise your life choices?" ... warrior goddess
How about one of the children of that family you so deride being the surgeon who treats you for breast cancer?
Do try to think a little before typing!
[ascylto], Manchester, United Kingdom
The point I was trying to make was that I am already contributing towards their schooling, and their parents' child allowance (and I do not begrudge this) but I am NOT prepared to pay for their rubbish!
Should rubbish be taxed?
I like others are already paying to have my rubbish taken away through Council Tax. Like others I got fed up with a poor collection service where general waste is only collected fortnightly... My tip for the day is.... On alternate weeks just cover the general waste in the green wheelie bin with a few grass cuttings and it all gets collected! ;-)
Should rubbish be taxed?
I thought I already paid tax for the council to pick up my rubbish.
I won't pay twice. I'll simply fly tip the lot along with millions of other folks.
Should rubbish be taxed?
We recycle as much as possible and are given plastic boxes for the recycled waste. These weight upto 22kg meaning many people cannot lift them. I currently sell to the public a set of wheels (ezi-wheels)which simply attach to the base of the box (no tools reqd)which then allows it to be pulled around extremely easily even when extremely full.
It is estimated that £18m/annum could be saved from reducing assisted lifts currently undertaken by councils, but their take up rate is very slow. We should be encouraging more recycling for adults, disabled and children alike and making it easier to do, not trying to add extra charges to our already greatly taxed house hold.
Should rubbish be taxed?
Of course we should all pay in proportion to the amount of rubbish that we produce. But councils are proposing to add charges on top of already inflated council tax bills. It would be better to incentivise people to recycle more by giving a DISCOUNT against council tax bills on a stepped basis. But the public sector is wedded to a punitive approach to change, rather than a motivational one. This is based in 1950s thinking about animal behaviour that has been entirely dicredited. Encourage us, don't punish us!
Should rubbish be taxed?
I saw the show last night.
I could not believe the utter arrogance of that fool representing concils. How Fiona resisted smacking him, I simply don't know.
If he is a public servant he should be dimissed.
Should rubbish be taxed?
I saw the show last night.
I could not believe the utter arrogance of that fool representing concils. How Fiona resisted smacking him, I simply don't know.
If he is a public servant he should be dimissed.
Should rubbish be taxed?
Well move then
Local Services! What Services?
Museums - 15m
Sports Centre - 5m (1 gym, 2 x squash)
Swimming Baths - 5m
Post office Box (Not Post office) - 1/2m
Public Telephone - 1/2m
Recycling centre - 5m
Last bus - 6.00pm
School - 2m
Bin Emptying 1 x per week
Police - 5m away…no patrol cars, no one on foot, no Police Community Support Officers
Hospital 4m
Doctors 4m
Bins provided :-
1 x black wheelie bin
1 x recycling box, holds aprox 8-10 bottles
Recycling box emptied fortnightly
Council tax £1200 ..why? for what service ?
Roads - Already Pay £180 a year for road tax
Street lighting? Wire the ones in my street up to the house and ill pay fore it on my Electricity b
Should rubbish be taxed?
Watch out people... I hear there's another cunning plan to introduce microchipped toilets as part of the new pay-as-you-poo scheme!
;)
Should rubbish be taxed?
The next time your ordinary rubbish starts to smell and attract flies. Block in the next recycle collecting lorry with some cars, and refuse to release it until an ordinary rubbish collection is made.
Should rubbish be taxed?
"Lets Revolt! It is time to replace this corrupt government and ALL politicians who feather their nests at our cost.
A revolution is needed!
Corruption in this country has gone too far.
Charles Blanchard, Cheltenham, United Kingdom"
If you believe that the average polician is out to make money out of bribes - i.e. endemic corruption, you are already revolting.
Should rubbish be taxed?
And do you seriously believe that if councils did save money as you say then *us* the council tax payers will benefit? They will just become even more reckless with our hard-earned cash.
Serena A
You'll benefit in the respect that the extra costs won't be passed onto *you* or that you local public services won't be cut to pay for it.
In addition, if you're so unhappy with the 'reckless' way your council spends money, why don't you do soemthing about it? How about lobbying support from like minded inviduals an stand as an independent? It's easy to moan, much harder to try and be positive and think of solution to difficult problems.
Should rubbish be taxed?
The only possible action I can think of is to TRY and change shopping-habits, and hope main suppliers swing round quickly when they see where money is going. As usual this will be far easier for the rich than the poor, and comes back to the dreaded 'IF' (as in IF we all did X Y or Z then things would be etc. etc. etc). Britain is not noted for it's cohesive actions however, and boycott is fine if there IS an alternative.
More than 30 local authorities are fitting microchips to wheelie bins in a bid to work out how much households are throwing away.
The move is an attempt to encourage more recycling and curb the amount of rubbish that ends up in landfill.
Later this year, the Local Government Association is expected to propose councils be given greater powers to change the way people remove rubbish.
Should councils be given powers to charge households for getting rid of non-recyclable rubbish? Do you live in any of the areas affected? What can be done to improve waste recycling? Send us your views.
Click here to read the main story
Link to the BBC website for this thread