This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.

You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-scotland-politics-38304774

The article has changed 4 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.

Version 1 Version 2
Tories warn firms may leave Scotland in tax debate Stalemate after Holyrood taxation debate
(about 1 hour later)
Companies forced to pay higher wages could be pushed out of Scotland, the Scottish Conservatives have warned. A Scottish parliament debate about tax has ended in stalemate after no party was able to win a majority of votes.
The Tories are leading a Holyrood debate on tax, and are unhappy with SNP plans not to implement a UK government tax cut for high earners. MSPs were talking tax ahead of the government's draft budget on Thursday.
The party says this will force firms to top up salaries to keep highly skilled staff, warning that some may move elsewhere in order to avoid this. The Tories put forward a motion voicing opposition to SNP plans not to replicate a UK government tax cut for high earners.
The Scottish government said its tax plans were "fair and progressive". Amendments from all parties, including the SNP, were rejected in a series of votes, before the motion itself also fell.
Finance Secretary Derek Mackay, who will set out his first draft budget on Thursday, said tax powers had been devolved to Holyrood to "allow Scotland to make its own decisions". As a minority government, the SNP would need to win support from at least one party to back its budget.
Mr Mackay's budget plans, making use of newly devolved tax powers, are expected to draw a distinction between the tax regimes in Scotland and the rest of the UK. However, there was no consensus on show at Holyrood following the tax debate.
There will be a formal vote on the government's tax proposals prior to the final vote on the budget in February, so both the tax plans and the budget itself will need to win backing.
Finance Secretary Derek Mackay will set out his first budget on Thursday, and is expected to use new powers to draw a distinction between the tax regimes in Scotland and the rest of the UK.
This is because the Scottish government does not plan to replicate a tax cut for higher earners proposed by the UK government, via the raising of the threshold for the higher rate.This is because the Scottish government does not plan to replicate a tax cut for higher earners proposed by the UK government, via the raising of the threshold for the higher rate.
While the UK government plans to up the threshold for the 40p tax rate to £45,000 and eventually £50,000, the SNP has pledged to raise it by no more than the rate of inflation. This means some Scots will pay more tax than those earning the same amount south of the border.While the UK government plans to up the threshold for the 40p tax rate to £45,000 and eventually £50,000, the SNP has pledged to raise it by no more than the rate of inflation. This means some Scots will pay more tax than those earning the same amount south of the border.
The Tories say this will "make Scotland the highest-taxed part of the UK" - and, citing a report from chartered accountancy firm Johnston Carmichael, warn it may force firms to top up salaries of high earners affected by the changes. The Tories said this would "make Scotland the highest-taxed part of the UK" - and, citing a report from chartered accountancy firm Johnston Carmichael, warn it may force firms to top up salaries of high earners affected by the changes.
Finance spokesman Murdo Fraser said: "The reality of the SNP's tax grab is that firms may end up having to pay high quality staff a 'Scottish supplement' simply to persuade them to stay and work here.Finance spokesman Murdo Fraser said: "The reality of the SNP's tax grab is that firms may end up having to pay high quality staff a 'Scottish supplement' simply to persuade them to stay and work here.
"What kind of message does that send out?"What kind of message does that send out?
"As Johnston Carmichael make clear, if these costs get too high, many firms will conclude that they're better off moving to a part of the UK that actually welcomes employers - not one that punishes them."As Johnston Carmichael make clear, if these costs get too high, many firms will conclude that they're better off moving to a part of the UK that actually welcomes employers - not one that punishes them.
"It is utterly self-defeating. The SNP claim the high moral ground, yet if enacted their policies will only end up starving our schools and hospitals of the tax revenues they need to survive.""It is utterly self-defeating. The SNP claim the high moral ground, yet if enacted their policies will only end up starving our schools and hospitals of the tax revenues they need to survive."
'Fair and progressive''Fair and progressive'
Mr Fraser is leading MSPs in a chamber debate on taxation ahead of Thursday's budget announcement, with the motion simply reading "that the parliament believes business and families in Scotland should not be taxed more than those elsewhere in the UK". Mr Fraser's motion for the Holyrood debate read "that the parliament believes business and families in Scotland should not be taxed more than those elsewhere in the UK".
He said the SNP had "lurched to the left" under Nicola Sturgeon, and said the SNP "has 24 hours to think again".
Mr Mackay put forward an amendment, arguing that powers were devolved so they could be used.Mr Mackay put forward an amendment, arguing that powers were devolved so they could be used.
He said: "The purpose of the devolution of powers over income tax is to allow Scotland to make its own decisions on tax rates. The finance secretary said: "The purpose of the devolution of powers over income tax is to allow Scotland to make its own decisions on tax rates. Powers over personal and business taxation should be used in a fair and progressive way that supports a sustainable economy."
"Powers over personal and business taxation should be used in a fair and progressive way that supports a sustainable economy." He told MSPs: "The Tories are showing their true colours today. Not the tax position, but their position on devolution in Scotland. They have revered to type - do as Westminster does.
He added that parliament should "note the proposals from all parties on future tax rates, and acknowledge that taxation as a whole must be considered alongside spending plans to be meaningful." "They have reverted to type - London-controlled, tax cuts for the rich, abandon universal services and talk Scotland down. If divergence on tax is coming, it's because we want a different way for Scotland, and I'll be proud to propose that budget tomorrow."
Other opposition parties lodged amendments of their own promoting their own tax policies, with Labour, the Lib Dems and the Greens all backing more radical schemes. Other opposition parties lodged amendments promoting their own tax policies, with Labour, the Lib Dems and the Greens all backing more radical schemes.
Labour's Kezia Dugdale said parliament should agree to a 50p top rate of tax for those earning over £150,000 a year, "so that the richest 1% pay their fair share to help stop the cuts and invest in public services".Labour's Kezia Dugdale said parliament should agree to a 50p top rate of tax for those earning over £150,000 a year, "so that the richest 1% pay their fair share to help stop the cuts and invest in public services".
Lib Dem leader Willie Rennie also backs a tax increase, with his amendment reading: "Investing in skills is the best way to strengthen the economy, and calls for a modest penny on income tax for this purpose, raising £500 million to transform Scottish education." She said Holyrood had "substantial powers" which meant it could make "different choices" to those made at Westminster, but said the Scottish government was guilty of just "tinkering around the edges".
Ms Dugdale said this meant any cuts to services resulting from Mr Mackay's budget would not be "trickling down" from the UK government, but would be "SNP cuts".
Lib Dem leader Willie Rennie also backed a tax increase, with his amendment reading: "Investing in skills is the best way to strengthen the economy, and calls for a modest penny on income tax for this purpose, raising £500 million to transform Scottish education."
He said Scottish education needed a "boost" in order to get back to being the best again, having been ranked "average" in recent international scores.
And Patrick Harvie from the Scottish Greens put forward an amendment saying "the SNP's manifesto proposals on tax make no significant changes to current income tax rates and thresholds", saying Holyrood should "support a tax system that will challenge inequalities in wealth and income".And Patrick Harvie from the Scottish Greens put forward an amendment saying "the SNP's manifesto proposals on tax make no significant changes to current income tax rates and thresholds", saying Holyrood should "support a tax system that will challenge inequalities in wealth and income".
He said it was "absurd" for the Tories to oppose there being different tax rates in Scotland and the rest of the UK, saying they were effectively arguing against the devolution of tax powers.
In the final votes, none of the amendments were passed, with Mr Mackay's falling by 61 votes to 60 before the others were all also defeated.
The motion itself was subsequently also rejected, by a vote of 92 to 29.