This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-asia-china-40778384
The article has changed 2 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
Previous version
1
Next version
Version 0 | Version 1 |
---|---|
China gripped by censored essay on Beijing | |
(35 minutes later) | |
A candid opinion piece describing the growing difficulties of living in Beijing appears to have become the target of Chinese government censorship. | |
The essay, entitled "Beijing has 20 million people pretending to have a life", says industrialisation, migration and rising costs mean that many people in the city merely survive from day to day, rather than enjoying life. | |
It spread widely on social media in China after being published last week. Author Zhang Guochen has since issued an apology, though many people are saying he was coerced into this. | |
Meanwhile, media reports have emerged stressing the positives of life in the Chinese capital and playing down the original piece. | |
'Beijing is a tumour' | |
Zhang Guochen (pen name Zhang Wumao) posted his article on 23 July on mobile messenger WeChat. | |
Mr Zhang, originally from northern Shaanxi province, has previously written about the story of migration in China and the experience of displacement. | Mr Zhang, originally from northern Shaanxi province, has previously written about the story of migration in China and the experience of displacement. |
His latest article pulls no punches. It says that "Beijing is a tumour; nobody can control how fast it is growing" and describes how the city has "no human warmth", "belongs to outsiders" and has become a place where many are "pretending to have a life". | His latest article pulls no punches. It says that "Beijing is a tumour; nobody can control how fast it is growing" and describes how the city has "no human warmth", "belongs to outsiders" and has become a place where many are "pretending to have a life". |
According to Sohu News more than seven million people read the article before it was deleted from his WeChat account. | According to Sohu News more than seven million people read the article before it was deleted from his WeChat account. |
Users trying to access the article received a message saying it "cannot be displayed because it violates content regulations". | |
Posts that are critical of China and its governance are often targeted by government censors. In March 2015, a Chinese documentary film that highlighted China's pollution problem, "Under the Dome", was removed from online platforms after it was viewed 100 million times. | Posts that are critical of China and its governance are often targeted by government censors. In March 2015, a Chinese documentary film that highlighted China's pollution problem, "Under the Dome", was removed from online platforms after it was viewed 100 million times. |
Many online users have since reposted Mr Zhang's article on online forums. | Many online users have since reposted Mr Zhang's article on online forums. |
But state media have given little attention to the original article. Instead, outlets like the Beijing Youth Daily have focused on a 27 July article in which Mr Zhang appears to apologise for his piece. | But state media have given little attention to the original article. Instead, outlets like the Beijing Youth Daily have focused on a 27 July article in which Mr Zhang appears to apologise for his piece. |
Mr Zhang told The Economic Observer that his article "has many holes in it" and that it was intended to be just "a piece of mischief, a humorous expression". | Mr Zhang told The Economic Observer that his article "has many holes in it" and that it was intended to be just "a piece of mischief, a humorous expression". |
"I made a mistake; most of the media have criticised me, thank you for giving me the opportunity to explain, and to apologise," he said. | "I made a mistake; most of the media have criticised me, thank you for giving me the opportunity to explain, and to apologise," he said. |
Many on social media suspect that Mr Zhang had been pressured into saying sorry. | Many on social media suspect that Mr Zhang had been pressured into saying sorry. |
"It looks as though the author's got scared," says "Ningcai4620". Another user says they suspect he came under pressure "because his content was sensitive and related to national policy". | "It looks as though the author's got scared," says "Ningcai4620". Another user says they suspect he came under pressure "because his content was sensitive and related to national policy". |
"Everyone has the right to freedom of expression," adds "Huasheng Wenzhujiao". "Why did he need to apologise?" | "Everyone has the right to freedom of expression," adds "Huasheng Wenzhujiao". "Why did he need to apologise?" |
"Is this the new Chinese literary inquisition?" one user adds, a sentiment which is echoed by many others. | "Is this the new Chinese literary inquisition?" one user adds, a sentiment which is echoed by many others. |
Some social media users are responding with sarcasm. "How dare you tell us to wake up from 'the China dream'?" one says, referencing a slogan associated with Chinese President Xi Jinping. | Some social media users are responding with sarcasm. "How dare you tell us to wake up from 'the China dream'?" one says, referencing a slogan associated with Chinese President Xi Jinping. |
BBC Monitoring reports and analyses news from TV, radio, web and print media around the world. You can follow BBC Monitoring on Twitter and Facebook. | BBC Monitoring reports and analyses news from TV, radio, web and print media around the world. You can follow BBC Monitoring on Twitter and Facebook. |
Previous version
1
Next version