This article is from the source 'guardian' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.

You can find the current article at its original source at https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/live/2017/aug/17/politics-turnbull-shorten-citizenship-australia

The article has changed 20 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.

Version 10 Version 11
Sarah Hanson-Young criticises Barnaby Joyce: 'No one is surprised at his incompetence' – politics live Pauline Hanson wears black burqa in Senate chamber – politics live
(35 minutes later)
5.43am BST
05:43
Meanwhile in the lower house, three Labor members have been thrown out and when Barnaby Joyce rose to speak, Labor moved to gag him. They are voting now.
5.42am BST
05:42
Remember the last great cunning stunt that Pauline Hanson pulled? The video in which she said:
If you are seeing me now it means I have been murdered.
It was the beginning of the end of the last great caper. #justsaying
5.35am BST
05:35
Penny Wong also congratulated George Brandis. The Senate tries to do what all good parents do when the kid chucks itself on the floor or holds its breath – that is carry on calmly.
Updated
at 5.40am BST
5.28am BST
05:28
Brandis gets a standing ovation from Labor and the Greens.
Strangely, he doesn’t get the standing ovation from his own side.
5.28am BST
05:28
George Brandis gets a standing ovation after he carpets Pauline Hanson
George Brandis says:
No we will not be banning the burqa.
I am not going to ignore the stunt of arriving in this chamber ...
Be careful of the offence you may do to the religious sensibilities of other Australians.
He says there are almost half a million adherents to Islam and they are law-abiding citizens.
Brandis carpets her. HE IS VERY EMOTIONAL.
GO GEORGE!
His voice is shaking.
Updated
at 5.35am BST
5.25am BST
05:25
Pauline Hanson stands and takes off the burqa. She asks attorney general George Brandis whether he will work to ban the burqa in Australia.
5.24am BST
05:24
In the Senate, it feels a bit like your two-year-old sitting in the middle of the living room with a bag over her head to get attention. This really is a strange week.
Updated
at 5.34am BST
5.18am BST
05:18
Pauline Hanson wears a burqa in senate #qt @gabriellechan @GuardianAus #politicslive pic.twitter.com/KvJyLQlmbf
5.14am BST
05:14
The Senate question time carries on with Hanson sitting there in a black burqa. We cannot show you a pic at the moment but will endeavour to get you one shortly.
Updated
at 5.27am BST
5.12am BST
05:12
Pauline Hanson has turned up to question time in a black burqa
Labor’s Emma Husar to Turnbull: Shop assistants had their penalty rates cut after the House voted with a majority of just one. Does the prime minister acknowledge his decision to accept his deputy’s vote when it may have been unconstitutional for him to be here is having an impact on every Australian?
Meanwhile in the Senate, Pauline Hanson has turned up in a black burqa.
Updated
at 5.28am BST
5.09am BST
05:09
The first government question is on delivering its commitments in an open and transparent manner.
He lists school needs based funding via Gonski 2.0, tax cuts for small and medium businesses, more jobs.
Jobs and growth is not just a slogan, it is an outcome.
5.05am BST5.05am BST
05:0505:05
Labor’s Nick Champion to Turnbull: Despite the fact his deputy has admitted he was a citizen of a foreign power right up until the weekend, the Prime Minister has spent all week fighting to keep his own job which relies on a one-seat majority that his deputy provides. What’s the Prime Minister’s response to factory workers in Elizabeth in my electorate who every day watch this Prime Minister do absolutely everything to protect his job and nothing to protect theirs? Labor’s Nick Champion to Turnbull: Despite the fact his deputy has admitted he was a citizen of a foreign power right up until the weekend, the prime minister has spent all week fighting to keep his own job which relies on a one-seat majority that his deputy provides. What’s the prime minister’s response to factory workers in Elizabeth in my electorate who every day watch this prime minister do absolutely everything to protect his job and nothing to protect theirs?
Turnbull says the greatest threat to his constituents was rising energy prices.Turnbull says the greatest threat to his constituents was rising energy prices.
Nothing has done more to undermine the jobs of factory workers and manufacturing workers in SouthAustralia than the high prices of energy and the unreliability of that energy in the honourable member’s state. He knows that is a direct consequence of what the Labor Premier Jay Weatherill described as his great experiment. I will tell the member for Wakefield what Jay Weatherill was experimenting with: the lives of his constituents. Nothing has done more to undermine the jobs of factory workers and manufacturing workers in SouthAustralia than the high prices of energy and the unreliability of that energy in the honourable member’s state. He knows that is a direct consequence of what the Labor premier Jay Weatherill described as his great experiment. I will tell the member for Wakefield what Jay Weatherill was experimenting with: the lives of his constituents.
Updated
at 5.11am BST
4.54am BST4.54am BST
04:5404:54
Question time. Grab a beverage.Question time. Grab a beverage.
4.48am BST4.48am BST
04:4804:48
Greens senator Sarah Hanson-Young is excoriating Barnaby Joyce, suggesting he is unfit for office.Greens senator Sarah Hanson-Young is excoriating Barnaby Joyce, suggesting he is unfit for office.
I don’t think anyone is surprised that the deputy prime minister did not check his paper work. I don’t think anyone is surprised at his incompetence...this has made the government a joke....a protection racket is going on here.I don’t think anyone is surprised that the deputy prime minister did not check his paper work. I don’t think anyone is surprised at his incompetence...this has made the government a joke....a protection racket is going on here.
She says in a couple of weeks when the prime minister goes overseas, Joyce will be acting prime minister.She says in a couple of weeks when the prime minister goes overseas, Joyce will be acting prime minister.
The Senate divides to vote on the suspension of standing orders. The Greens vote is lost.The Senate divides to vote on the suspension of standing orders. The Greens vote is lost.
UpdatedUpdated
at 4.57am BSTat 4.57am BST
4.40am BST4.40am BST
04:4004:40
@gabriellechan "At the Barnaby Bank our dedicated team of professionals will partner you through the business facilitation process." #auspol pic.twitter.com/S3NdZpbzHu@gabriellechan "At the Barnaby Bank our dedicated team of professionals will partner you through the business facilitation process." #auspol pic.twitter.com/S3NdZpbzHu
4.28am BST4.28am BST
04:2804:28
In the senate, the Greens senator Nick McKim is trying to suspend standing orders because the government has not produced legal advice which supports Barnaby Joyce’s right to remain as a cabinet minister. (This has been said by various ministers as justification of the deputy PM not standing down.)In the senate, the Greens senator Nick McKim is trying to suspend standing orders because the government has not produced legal advice which supports Barnaby Joyce’s right to remain as a cabinet minister. (This has been said by various ministers as justification of the deputy PM not standing down.)
The senate passed the motion yesterday ordering the government to produce the advice. The government has not acted.The senate passed the motion yesterday ordering the government to produce the advice. The government has not acted.
Attorney general George Brandis has three points:Attorney general George Brandis has three points:
McKim did not give notice of the suspension which is senate practice and poor form.McKim did not give notice of the suspension which is senate practice and poor form.
Governments never release advice through history, especially given there is a court case arising.Governments never release advice through history, especially given there is a court case arising.
It will be sorted in coming weeks so no need to go there.It will be sorted in coming weeks so no need to go there.
Labor says they will not support the motion at this stage. Labor’s Jacinta Collins says its bollocks that notice of suspensions is always given. And it’s bollocks that governments never show legal advice.Labor says they will not support the motion at this stage. Labor’s Jacinta Collins says its bollocks that notice of suspensions is always given. And it’s bollocks that governments never show legal advice.
Collins warns she will watch the case closely and may pursue it in the next sitting period (in September).Collins warns she will watch the case closely and may pursue it in the next sitting period (in September).
So given Labor will not support the suspension, it is deceased for the time being.So given Labor will not support the suspension, it is deceased for the time being.
UpdatedUpdated
at 4.30am BSTat 4.30am BST
4.17am BST4.17am BST
04:1704:17
The former Labor treasurer Wayne Swan and former UK chancellor Ed Balls have been speaking at the National Press Club. I am trying to catch up with the breadth of their presentations while doing a few other things but in the mean time, enjoy Katharine Murphy’s podcast with them from yesterday.The former Labor treasurer Wayne Swan and former UK chancellor Ed Balls have been speaking at the National Press Club. I am trying to catch up with the breadth of their presentations while doing a few other things but in the mean time, enjoy Katharine Murphy’s podcast with them from yesterday.
3.56am BST3.56am BST
03:5603:56
3.49am BST3.49am BST
03:4903:49
Barnaby Bank Bill minus BarnabyBarnaby Bank Bill minus Barnaby
The lower house is currently voting on the Regional Investment Corporation bill - the so-called Barnaby Bank - which amalgamates all the various buckets of concessional loans in one glorious fund.The lower house is currently voting on the Regional Investment Corporation bill - the so-called Barnaby Bank - which amalgamates all the various buckets of concessional loans in one glorious fund.
This is what the bill officially does:This is what the bill officially does:
Establishes the Regional Investment Corporation to administer farm business loans and financial assistance granted to states and territories in relation to water infrastructure projects, and any future programs prescribed by rules; provides for the corporation’s functions, operating mandate, ministerial directions, board membership and appointment of a chief executive officer and staff; and provides for miscellaneous matters, including the recovery of costs, delegations, power to make rules, and an independent review of the operation of the Act before 1 July 2024.Establishes the Regional Investment Corporation to administer farm business loans and financial assistance granted to states and territories in relation to water infrastructure projects, and any future programs prescribed by rules; provides for the corporation’s functions, operating mandate, ministerial directions, board membership and appointment of a chief executive officer and staff; and provides for miscellaneous matters, including the recovery of costs, delegations, power to make rules, and an independent review of the operation of the Act before 1 July 2024.
It is sort of a Nationals version of One Belt One Road, a bloody great bucket of existing funding in the form of cheap loans and grants, that will provide a whole lot of announceables with very large numbers attached.It is sort of a Nationals version of One Belt One Road, a bloody great bucket of existing funding in the form of cheap loans and grants, that will provide a whole lot of announceables with very large numbers attached.
Labor’s Joel Fitzgibbon is opposed because they say it is just a pork-barrelling exercise.Labor’s Joel Fitzgibbon is opposed because they say it is just a pork-barrelling exercise.
Barnaby has pushed this – it is a pet project. But it is interesting to see he is not presenting it to the house. Instead Nationals assistant minister Luke Hartsuyker is doing the job.Barnaby has pushed this – it is a pet project. But it is interesting to see he is not presenting it to the house. Instead Nationals assistant minister Luke Hartsuyker is doing the job.
The bill is expected to pass the house on the numbers.The bill is expected to pass the house on the numbers.
UpdatedUpdated
at 4.13am BSTat 4.13am BST
3.32am BST
03:32
Labor trolls Greens on education
Paul Karp
There’s an interesting motion to be brought by Labor’s Jenny McAllister today according to the Senate notice paper.
On its surface, it’s just another Labor attack against the Coalition’s Gonski 2.0 education package, which passed in late June. But look more closely and the motion appears to reproduce the language of a leaflet distributed by Greens senator, Lee Rhiannon, against the package while the Greens were negotiating with the government.
This sparked Rhiannon’s temporary suspension from the Greens party room and a Four Corners episode in which her colleagues and former colleagues Bob Brown, Christine Milne, Richard Di Natale and Nick McKim criticised her for being a team-wrecker.
The motion asks the Senate to acknowledge that the package “cuts $17bn from Australian schools”, and “cancels the current New South Wales agreement on schools funding, locking in a lower 2017 level of funding for the next ten years”.
It also calls on the government to “commit to the full, original Gonski needs-based funding model” and for parliamentarians to “take a stand for public education” and “vote against the Australian Education Amendment Bill 2017, and properly fund the Gonski reforms put in place by the Commonwealth Government in 2013”.
It’s all a bit academic now because the package passed but it will be interesting to see how the Greens in general and Rhiannon in particular vote on Labor’s trolling motion.
3.29am BST
03:29
Anthony Albanese is campaigning for the yes vote on marriage equality.
Enrol 💻Vote 🗳Win 🎉 Enrol now ➡️ www.aec.gov.au (link in bio) #throwbackthursday #marriageequality #sayyes 🏳️‍🌈
A post shared by Anthony Albanese (@albomp) on Aug 16, 2017 at 7:05pm PDT
I was hoping he would post a photo of the him in Game of Thrones regalia. Yesterday David Speers called him the Jon Snow (the bastard king of Game of Thrones) of Australian politics. Albo had been pointing out he was clear on citizenship because his single mother was many generations Australian and his father was “unknown”. Given Snow is one of the hotties of Game of Thrones, Albo was delighted with this comparison.
3.17am BST
03:17
The Spycatcher Trial gets better. Neil Kinnock is pursued by the Tories for asking a question after speaking to the brash young Australian lawyer.
On page 143, Turnbull writes:
Kinnock took off on a trip to America and allowed the Tories to pursue him for the terrible crime of having spoken with me ...
I could never understand why Kinnock was subject to criticism for having spoken with me. I asked [British Conservative MP] Jonathon Aitken about it and he said that in Australia or America no one would think less of Kinnock for making inquiries as widely as he like but in England people were different.
(I really must get back to parliament here.)
Updated
at 3.48am BST
3.01am BST
03:01
As I transition to more breathing space, I am hoping to increase my book pile. One of the absences has been Malcolm Turnbull’s The Spy Catcher Trial: The Scandal Behind The #1 Best Seller.
This is an explanation of the book from the Publishers Weekly.
The British government’s efforts to block publication of Peter Wright’s Spycatcher: Candid Autobiography of a Senior Intelligence Agent climaxed in a sensational trial in Australia in 1986 that cast a shadow of disrepute on the British legal system, the Official Secrets Act and the government itself.
The author of this engrossing, suspenseful account is the Australian attorney who represented Wright and his would-be Australian publisher. Excerpts from the trial testimony reveal that Turnbull uncovered mendacity, hypocrisy and cynicism at the highest levels of the British government, principally during his cross-examination of Sir Robert Armstrong, cabinet secretary and adviser on intelligence matters.
In 1987 the High Court at Canberra dismissed the case and ordered the Thatcher government to reimburse legal costs to Wright and Heinemann Publishers Australia. Turnbull calls the Britishers’ conduct in the affair “quite disgraceful” and adds that the experience “galvanized my determination to see Australia rid herself of its [sic] remaining constitutional links with England”.
It has some interesting observations in it, especially when read in the light of the accusations of the ALP’s colluding with a “foreign party” with NZ Labour on Barnaby Joyce’s citizenship.
Here is the young author on p118. The British PM at the time was Margaret Thatcher and the young Turnbull writes:
Students of political science have been told for many years how superior is the Westminster system of parliamentary democracy to the presidential system in the United States or France. They are told that English prime ministers are directly answerable to Parliament. Yet throughout this affair when the integrity of her Attorney General and her Cabinet secretary were put into serious doubt, she managed to avoid giving any explanation to parliament.
Later that day, English time, [Labor leader Neil] Kinnock rose to ask a question of the prime minister. It was precisely in the form we had discussed.
The now prime minister would probably argue that he was not an MP at the time but the lawyer representing his client Peter Wright but it goes to show how this business works.
2.21am BST
02:21
Nick Xenophon has a private bill in the Senate to restore shortwave radio in the Northern Territory and parts of the Pacific and Papua New Guinea, after ABC cut off the service earlier this year.
Nationals senator Bridget McKenzie has spoken in favour of the bill.
Updated
at 2.26am BST
2.12am BST
02:12
And while we are on the postal survey, the second directions hearing of the high court challenge to the government’s postal plebiscite on marriage equality will happen this afternoon.
Updated
at 2.14am BST
1.51am BST
01:51
I note there is comment in the blog over the postal survey committee hearings I mentioned earlier.
This is indeed, as comments have pointed out, a Labor/Greens-dominated committee which means the government had its arm twisted.
It is headed by the Labor senator Jenny McAllister and presumably is designed to address and react to the various roiling boiling issues that surface in the heat of the postal survey.
Updated
at 1.52am BST
1.47am BST
01:47
I want to go back to hypothecation (because it’s such a alluring term) and the idea that the Medicare levy increase for the NDIS goes into a locked box.
Fairfax’s Peter Martin addressed this issue back in February.
In reality there are no locked boxes. Clause 81 of the constitution says “all revenues or moneys raised or received by the executive government of the commonwealth shall form one consolidated revenue fund, to be appropriated for the purposes of the commonwealth in the manner and subject to the charges and liabilities imposed by this constitution”.
There are no separate jam jars.
But it hasn’t stopped the governments of all persuasion from acting as if there are. The best-known is the Medicare levy, which we are told funds Medicare and the National Disability Insurance Scheme, but which in reality goes straight into consolidated revenue (and couldn’t anywhere near fully fund them in any event).
Updated
at 2.33am BST
1.42am BST
01:42
Bill Shorten was asked whether the constitution should be changed to allow dual citizens in parliament and he suggests MPs should simply make sure they comply with the rules.
He says he will not back down on the Medicare NDIS levy – he will only support the increase on salaries over $87,000.
It is horribly wrong for the government the hold the NDIS hostage and say that the only way to fund it is through increasing taxes on people who earn $50,000 and $60,000 a year. There is many other ways to fund the functioning of government.
Updated
at 1.44am BST
1.39am BST
01:39
Shorten dismisses the New Zealand Labour conspiracy theory.
I think we have all seen the mad conspiracy theories of the last 48 hours and I don’t think the prime minister or foreign minister have done themselves any favours whatsoever.
Let’s be clear here. Labor didn’t ask the government to refer their deputy prime minister to the high court. The government did that. Labor didn’t ask the government to make their deputy prime minister come out and declare that he was the citizen of a foreign power.
Updated
at 1.43am BST