This article is from the source 'guardian' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at https://www.theguardian.com/world/2018/sep/26/trudeau-romeo-saganash-indigenous-rights-parliament
The article has changed 4 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 0 | Version 1 |
|---|---|
| Canadian MP says Trudeau 'doesn't give a fuck' about indigenous rights | Canadian MP says Trudeau 'doesn't give a fuck' about indigenous rights |
| (35 minutes later) | |
| A Canadian member of parliament has said that Justin Trudeau “doesn’t give a fuck” about the rights of indigenous people, amid mounting tensions between the country’s First Nations and at the federal government. | A Canadian member of parliament has said that Justin Trudeau “doesn’t give a fuck” about the rights of indigenous people, amid mounting tensions between the country’s First Nations and at the federal government. |
| Romeo Saganash, a Cree lawmaker, made the comments in parliament during a discussion of the the Trans Mountain pipeline project that was recently halted after the federal court of appeals ruled that the government had failed to adequately address the concerns of some First Nations. | Romeo Saganash, a Cree lawmaker, made the comments in parliament during a discussion of the the Trans Mountain pipeline project that was recently halted after the federal court of appeals ruled that the government had failed to adequately address the concerns of some First Nations. |
| The Liberal government insists that the pipeline will go ahead. | The Liberal government insists that the pipeline will go ahead. |
| “When the prime minister says that this pipeline expansion will be done no matter what, and his minister adds that Canada will not be able to accommodate all indigenous concerns, what that means is that they have decided to willfully violate their constitutional duties and obligations,” said Saganash. “Mr Speaker, sounds like a most important relationship, doesn’t it? Why doesn’t the prime minister just say the truth and tell indigenous peoples that he doesn’t give a fuck about their rights?” | |
| Saganash was quickly admonished by the speaker of the House, Geoff Regan, for the use of the language and was given the opportunity to withdraw his comment. | Saganash was quickly admonished by the speaker of the House, Geoff Regan, for the use of the language and was given the opportunity to withdraw his comment. |
| “Mr Speaker, what is happening is so insulting, it makes me so angry, but I do withdraw the word,” Saganash said. | “Mr Speaker, what is happening is so insulting, it makes me so angry, but I do withdraw the word,” Saganash said. |
| His outburst resonated on social media, with several prominent indigenous voices expressing support. | |
| “I’m team F-bomb, I heard not a single lie,” tweeted academic Chelsea Vowel. | “I’m team F-bomb, I heard not a single lie,” tweeted academic Chelsea Vowel. |
| “Colonial respectability politics in canada is: a history of violently disciplining Indigenous folks into ‘polite’, ‘civil’ subjects of a state actively dispossessing us & destroying our homelands. Fuck that,” said writer Erica Violet Lee on Twitter. | “Colonial respectability politics in canada is: a history of violently disciplining Indigenous folks into ‘polite’, ‘civil’ subjects of a state actively dispossessing us & destroying our homelands. Fuck that,” said writer Erica Violet Lee on Twitter. |
| Colonial respectability politics in canada is:a history of violently disciplining Indigenous folks into “polite”, “civil” subjects of a state actively dispossessing us & destroying our homelands.Fuck that. 🔥 https://t.co/yGYD1ypwMZ | Colonial respectability politics in canada is:a history of violently disciplining Indigenous folks into “polite”, “civil” subjects of a state actively dispossessing us & destroying our homelands.Fuck that. 🔥 https://t.co/yGYD1ypwMZ |
| “A clear sign that our collective frustration with a real lack of progress on our life and death issues is mounting. We need action, not tired platitudes about reconciliation,” wrote professor Pam Palmater. | “A clear sign that our collective frustration with a real lack of progress on our life and death issues is mounting. We need action, not tired platitudes about reconciliation,” wrote professor Pam Palmater. |
| Others argued that the use of profanity was insignificant when set against the numerous challenges facing indigenous communities across the country. | |
| “And if the F-word offends you, wait until you hear about the state of potable water on First Nations communities across the country,” wrote one user, in a reference to the more than 50 indigenous communities that are required to boil their water due to health and safety concerns. | |
| In February, Trudeau announced an overhaul of the federal government’s relationship with indigenous peoples. “We have listened and learned and we will work together to take concrete action to build a better future and a new relationship,” he said. | In February, Trudeau announced an overhaul of the federal government’s relationship with indigenous peoples. “We have listened and learned and we will work together to take concrete action to build a better future and a new relationship,” he said. |
| But in its August ruling on the Trans Mountain pipeline, the appeals court admonished the government for an inadequate consultation with First Nations. | But in its August ruling on the Trans Mountain pipeline, the appeals court admonished the government for an inadequate consultation with First Nations. |
| Saganash, a parliamentarian representing northern Quebec for the progressive New Democratic party, was forcibly taken from his home at age seven to attend a residential school – part of a policy later described by the country’s Truth and Reconciliation Commission as “cultural genocide”. | Saganash, a parliamentarian representing northern Quebec for the progressive New Democratic party, was forcibly taken from his home at age seven to attend a residential school – part of a policy later described by the country’s Truth and Reconciliation Commission as “cultural genocide”. |
| “I can never be normal,” Saganash testified before the commission. ‘‘And none, none of those kids who were sent to residential schools can claim to be normal today. It’s impossible.” He is the first Cree to receive a law degree from Quebec and is the first indigenous person to run for leadership of a federal party. | |
| Trudeau, who was not present during the session in the House, is no stranger to the use of “unparliamentary” language. | |
| Last week, he apologized for saying “damn” during question period. In 2011, prior to leading the Liberal party, he apologized to the environment minister, Peter Kent, after an outburst in which he called Kent a “piece of shit”. | Last week, he apologized for saying “damn” during question period. In 2011, prior to leading the Liberal party, he apologized to the environment minister, Peter Kent, after an outburst in which he called Kent a “piece of shit”. |
| Justin Trudeau | Justin Trudeau |
| Canada | Canada |
| Indigenous peoples | Indigenous peoples |
| Americas | Americas |
| news | news |
| Share on Facebook | Share on Facebook |
| Share on Twitter | Share on Twitter |
| Share via Email | Share via Email |
| Share on LinkedIn | Share on LinkedIn |
| Share on Pinterest | Share on Pinterest |
| Share on Google+ | Share on Google+ |
| Share on WhatsApp | Share on WhatsApp |
| Share on Messenger | Share on Messenger |
| Reuse this content | Reuse this content |