This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-51194109
The article has changed 4 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
Version 1 | Version 2 |
---|---|
Brexit: Government defeated by peers over child refugees | Brexit: Government defeated by peers over child refugees |
(32 minutes later) | |
The government has lost another vote in the House of Lords over its Brexit legislation - this time on the issue of child refugees. | The government has lost another vote in the House of Lords over its Brexit legislation - this time on the issue of child refugees. |
Peers supported Lord Dubs' amendment to protect the rights of refugee children to join their families in the UK after Brexit. | Peers supported Lord Dubs' amendment to protect the rights of refugee children to join their families in the UK after Brexit. |
The government insisted it was "intent" on protecting family reunification. | The government insisted it was "intent" on protecting family reunification. |
It will seek to reverse the change - and others voted for on Monday - when the bill returns to the Commons. | It will seek to reverse the change - and others voted for on Monday - when the bill returns to the Commons. |
With an 80-strong majority of MPs, the government is likely to get its way. | With an 80-strong majority of MPs, the government is likely to get its way. |
The Brexit bill - officially called the EU (Withdrawal Agreement) Bill - ensures the UK leaves the EU on 31 January with a deal. | The Brexit bill - officially called the EU (Withdrawal Agreement) Bill - ensures the UK leaves the EU on 31 January with a deal. |
It was approved by MPs without amendment but has faced a tougher battle in the House of Lords. | It was approved by MPs without amendment but has faced a tougher battle in the House of Lords. |
On Monday, peers defeated the government on EU citizens, EU Court of Justice rulings and court independence. | On Monday, peers defeated the government on EU citizens, EU Court of Justice rulings and court independence. |
And ministers have now suffered a fourth defeat with the House of Lords voting 300 votes to 220 to support a change on child refugees. | And ministers have now suffered a fourth defeat with the House of Lords voting 300 votes to 220 to support a change on child refugees. |
What is the amendment about? | What is the amendment about? |
A previous version of the Brexit bill required the government to seek agreement with the EU to ensure that unaccompanied children could continue to come to the UK to join a relative. | A previous version of the Brexit bill required the government to seek agreement with the EU to ensure that unaccompanied children could continue to come to the UK to join a relative. |
However, following Boris Johnson's election victory, this guarantee was weakened, instead only requiring the government to make statements to Parliament on the subject after Brexit. | However, following Boris Johnson's election victory, this guarantee was weakened, instead only requiring the government to make statements to Parliament on the subject after Brexit. |
Lord Dubs - who came to the UK as a child to escape the Nazis - put down the amendment seeking to reinsert the original commitment. | Lord Dubs - who came to the UK as a child to escape the Nazis - put down the amendment seeking to reinsert the original commitment. |
Speaking during the debate, he urged the government not to "close the door" on refugee children, arguing that offering a safe, legal route into the UK would "thwart the traffickers". | Speaking during the debate, he urged the government not to "close the door" on refugee children, arguing that offering a safe, legal route into the UK would "thwart the traffickers". |
"I believe we are essentially on the side of public opinion and on the side of humanity," he argued. | "I believe we are essentially on the side of public opinion and on the side of humanity," he argued. |
Supporting the Labour peer's amendment, Liberal Democrat Baroness Hamwee said her party "will not stand by while the Conservative government uses Brexit to undermine the UK's proud tradition of providing sanctuary to some of the world's most vulnerable people". | Supporting the Labour peer's amendment, Liberal Democrat Baroness Hamwee said her party "will not stand by while the Conservative government uses Brexit to undermine the UK's proud tradition of providing sanctuary to some of the world's most vulnerable people". |
And the Bishop of Durham called the issue a "moral bellwether for the future of our country". | And the Bishop of Durham called the issue a "moral bellwether for the future of our country". |
"We want to be known as a country that is welcoming and passionate and committed to playing our full part in responding to the deep issues that arise from the reality of refugees around the world," he added. | "We want to be known as a country that is welcoming and passionate and committed to playing our full part in responding to the deep issues that arise from the reality of refugees around the world," he added. |
What has the government said? | What has the government said? |
Arguing against the amendment, Baroness Williams of Trafford insisted the government was committed to supporting vulnerable children, adding: "No one group has the monopoly on humanitarianism." | Arguing against the amendment, Baroness Williams of Trafford insisted the government was committed to supporting vulnerable children, adding: "No one group has the monopoly on humanitarianism." |
Defending the government's record, she said more than 41,000 children had been given protection in the UK since 2010. | Defending the government's record, she said more than 41,000 children had been given protection in the UK since 2010. |
Ministers say they are "intent" on reaching a deal with the EU on family reunification, but do not want an obligation to negotiate on the matter included in the Brexit bill. | Ministers say they are "intent" on reaching a deal with the EU on family reunification, but do not want an obligation to negotiate on the matter included in the Brexit bill. |
They have promised to protect the rights of refugee children in a separate, as yet unseen, immigration bill. | They have promised to protect the rights of refugee children in a separate, as yet unseen, immigration bill. |
What happens now? | What happens now? |
A Downing Street spokesman said the government was "disappointed" by the defeat and confirmed it would not accept the amendment. | A Downing Street spokesman said the government was "disappointed" by the defeat and confirmed it would not accept the amendment. |
"Protecting vulnerable children will remain our priority after Brexit - and the Withdrawal Agreement Bill reaffirms our commitment while clarifying the role of parliament and government in negotiations." | |
The bill is expected to pass the House of Lords and will then return - with amendments - to the House of Commons. | The bill is expected to pass the House of Lords and will then return - with amendments - to the House of Commons. |
In all likelihood, MPs will reject the changes and send the bill back to the Lords - a parliamentary process known as ping pong - but ultimately, the government is expected to get its way. | In all likelihood, MPs will reject the changes and send the bill back to the Lords - a parliamentary process known as ping pong - but ultimately, the government is expected to get its way. |
Following his victory, Lord Dubs tweeted: "It's now the turn of the Commons to show what they're made of." | Following his victory, Lord Dubs tweeted: "It's now the turn of the Commons to show what they're made of." |