This article is from the source 'guardian' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at https://www.theguardian.com/politics/live/2020/jan/22/labour-leadership-pmqs-johnson-corbyn-nandy-criticises-blairbrown-governments-for-keeping-elements-of-thatcherism-live-news
The article has changed 17 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 13 | Version 14 |
|---|---|
| Brexit bill close to becoming law after MPs vote to remove Dubs amendment protecting child migrants – live news | Brexit bill close to becoming law after MPs vote to remove Dubs amendment protecting child migrants – live news |
| (32 minutes later) | |
| Rolling coverage of the day’s political developments as they happen | Rolling coverage of the day’s political developments as they happen |
| In his “People’s PMQs” on Facebook Boris Johnson falsely claimed that the proposed cut in national insurance contributions would disproportionately benefit people on lower incomes. He said: | |
| This is not true. This is what the Institute for Fiscal Studies said in an analysis it published during the election campaign covering the proposed Tory national insurance cut. It said (bold type added by me): | |
| And here is the IFS chart showing the distributional impact of Johnson’s tax plan. | |
| Rebecca Long-Bailey, the Labour leadership candidate, has given a lengthy interview to the BBC’s Laura Kuenssberg. Long-Bailey is seen as the Corbynite candidate in the contest (although she is trying to play down the idea that she would be continuity Corbyn - see 11.02am), but she has also talked about aspiration and at one point she ended up sounding uncannily like Tony Blair. | |
| It came when she was talking about why she thought Labour should have done more at the election to tell people that it wanted to help them improve their lives. She said: | |
| Does that sound familiar? In 1996, in his last speech to Labour conference before the election that made him prime minister, Blair said: | |
| Even though Blair did not use the phrase, that 1992 voter became known as “Mondeo man” and finding a message, and polices, that appealed to Mondeo man became key to New Labour’s success. It sounds as if Long-Bailey has met him too. | |
| Here is this week’s Guardian Politics Weekly podcast. My colleague Rowena Mason is joined by Katy Balls, Stewart Wood and Lisa O’Carroll to discuss the latest on the prime minister’s Brexit withdrawal bill, and Jess Phillips’s decision to drop out of the Labour leadership race. Plus Larry Elliott rings in from Davos, and Kate Proctor sits down with Gina Miller. | Here is this week’s Guardian Politics Weekly podcast. My colleague Rowena Mason is joined by Katy Balls, Stewart Wood and Lisa O’Carroll to discuss the latest on the prime minister’s Brexit withdrawal bill, and Jess Phillips’s decision to drop out of the Labour leadership race. Plus Larry Elliott rings in from Davos, and Kate Proctor sits down with Gina Miller. |
| Q: Do you prefer tea or coffee? | Q: Do you prefer tea or coffee? |
| Johnson says he is drinking tea. But he has nothing against coffee. | Johnson says he is drinking tea. But he has nothing against coffee. |
| Q: Will five year be enough? | Q: Will five year be enough? |
| Johnson says he wants to crack on. | Johnson says he wants to crack on. |
| He says he has to go now to a meeting. | He says he has to go now to a meeting. |
| But he will do this again next week, he says. | But he will do this again next week, he says. |
| And that’s it. | And that’s it. |
| Q: What will you do to fix potholes? | Q: What will you do to fix potholes? |
| Johnson says the government is spending £2nb on potholes. | Johnson says the government is spending £2nb on potholes. |
| Q: How will you keep police on the streets? | Q: How will you keep police on the streets? |
| Johnson says he wants to keep police numbers on the streets high. | Johnson says he wants to keep police numbers on the streets high. |
| Johnson says he wants to improve mental health services. | Johnson says he wants to improve mental health services. |
| Q: Why won’t you give the NHS the funding it needs? | Q: Why won’t you give the NHS the funding it needs? |
| Johnson says he is giving record sums to the NHS. It is getting the biggest ever cash boost it has had. | Johnson says he is giving record sums to the NHS. It is getting the biggest ever cash boost it has had. |
| (That is misleading. In real terms, the NHS spending increase is only the biggest since the mid-200s.) | (That is misleading. In real terms, the NHS spending increase is only the biggest since the mid-200s.) |
| And he is building 40 new hospitals, and upgrading another 20, he says. | And he is building 40 new hospitals, and upgrading another 20, he says. |
| Q: Do you support lower tax for working people? | Q: Do you support lower tax for working people? |
| Yes, says Johnson. He says he will cut national insurance for everybody. He says that will disproportionately cut tax for people on lower incomes. | Yes, says Johnson. He says he will cut national insurance for everybody. He says that will disproportionately cut tax for people on lower incomes. |
| (That is not true. Average and higher earners gain the most. I will post the data later.) | (That is not true. Average and higher earners gain the most. I will post the data later.) |
| Q: Will the next budget cut VAT on tampons? | Q: Will the next budget cut VAT on tampons? |
| Johnson says he cannot say what will be in the budget. But he appreciates the importance of keeping period products low. He says an MP asked about this in the Commons today. When the UK leaves the EU, it will be able to cut VAT on tampons. That is one of the advantages of Brexit, he says. | Johnson says he cannot say what will be in the budget. But he appreciates the importance of keeping period products low. He says an MP asked about this in the Commons today. When the UK leaves the EU, it will be able to cut VAT on tampons. That is one of the advantages of Brexit, he says. |
| Q: Can you commit fully to the union? | Q: Can you commit fully to the union? |
| Yes, says Johnson. He says he commits to it 1,000%. He says when he criticises the SNP, he is not criticising Scotland. He says Scottish education is legendary. It produced Michael Gove, he says. It is a fantastic system. But recently Scotland has been slipping down the Pisa rankings, he says. The SNP should focus on the priorities of the people of Scotland. | Yes, says Johnson. He says he commits to it 1,000%. He says when he criticises the SNP, he is not criticising Scotland. He says Scottish education is legendary. It produced Michael Gove, he says. It is a fantastic system. But recently Scotland has been slipping down the Pisa rankings, he says. The SNP should focus on the priorities of the people of Scotland. |
| He says the SNP have got no really clear idea of how breaking up the union would work. | He says the SNP have got no really clear idea of how breaking up the union would work. |
| (Some might say that criticism could be applied to other breaking up long-standing political unions.) | (Some might say that criticism could be applied to other breaking up long-standing political unions.) |
| He says people were told that the 2014 referendum was a once in a generation event. He says five years does not constitute a generation. Nor does 10 years, he says. | He says people were told that the 2014 referendum was a once in a generation event. He says five years does not constitute a generation. Nor does 10 years, he says. |
| Q: What shampoo do you use? | Q: What shampoo do you use? |
| Johnson says he does not know. But it is blue. And it comes in a plastic tube. | Johnson says he does not know. But it is blue. And it comes in a plastic tube. |
| Johnson is reading out his own questions. | Johnson is reading out his own questions. |
| Q: Will we take back control of fishing? | Q: Will we take back control of fishing? |
| Yes, says Johnson. He says the UK will not trade away its fishing rights. | Yes, says Johnson. He says the UK will not trade away its fishing rights. |
| Johnson says he does not accept that he won’t be able to get a good trade deal from the EU. | Johnson says he does not accept that he won’t be able to get a good trade deal from the EU. |
| Boris Johnson is now hosting his People’s PMQs on Facebook from Downing Street. | Boris Johnson is now hosting his People’s PMQs on Facebook from Downing Street. |