This article is from the source 'guardian' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at https://www.theguardian.com/law/2020/apr/26/non-jury-trials-could-help-clear-coronavirus-backlog-says-geoffrey-robertson-qc
The article has changed 3 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 1 | Version 2 |
|---|---|
| Non-jury trials could help clear coronavirus backlog, says QC | Non-jury trials could help clear coronavirus backlog, says QC |
| (about 2 hours later) | |
| Geoffrey Robertson recommends Australian model allowing defendants to opt for trial by judge only | Geoffrey Robertson recommends Australian model allowing defendants to opt for trial by judge only |
| Defendants should be allowed to opt for trial by judge rather than in front of a jury, a prominent human rights lawyer has proposed, as a means of partially restarting the criminal justice system. | Defendants should be allowed to opt for trial by judge rather than in front of a jury, a prominent human rights lawyer has proposed, as a means of partially restarting the criminal justice system. |
| Geoffrey Robertson QC, a barrister who has served as an international tribunal judge, believes British courts could follow many Australian states that permit the accused to choose a hearing without the traditional jury of 12 men and women. | Geoffrey Robertson QC, a barrister who has served as an international tribunal judge, believes British courts could follow many Australian states that permit the accused to choose a hearing without the traditional jury of 12 men and women. |
| Jury trials in England and Wales have stopped due to the coronavirus lockdown. Even before then, backlogs were building up in the criminal justice system because the Ministry of Justice rationed the number of sitting days in order to save money. | Jury trials in England and Wales have stopped due to the coronavirus lockdown. Even before then, backlogs were building up in the criminal justice system because the Ministry of Justice rationed the number of sitting days in order to save money. |
| Jury trials involve packing a dozen people in close proximity into a court and retiring room. Like pubs and restaurants, juries may be one of the last institutions to resume if the threat of coronavirus lingers. | Jury trials involve packing a dozen people in close proximity into a court and retiring room. Like pubs and restaurants, juries may be one of the last institutions to resume if the threat of coronavirus lingers. |
| In an article for the Guardian, Robertson, who was born in Australia, argues: “We believe sentimentally that trial by jury is a defendant’s fundamental right – but why not give them the additional right to choose instead a reasoned verdict from a judge – as they have, for example, in most Australian states. | In an article for the Guardian, Robertson, who was born in Australia, argues: “We believe sentimentally that trial by jury is a defendant’s fundamental right – but why not give them the additional right to choose instead a reasoned verdict from a judge – as they have, for example, in most Australian states. |
| “That would get some courts back and running, even if barristers and judges have to argue through their face mask,s and it would be a boon to defendants with good cases who do not want justice delayed,” he wrote. | “That would get some courts back and running, even if barristers and judges have to argue through their face mask,s and it would be a boon to defendants with good cases who do not want justice delayed,” he wrote. |
| Furthermore, Robertson said: “There are cases in Britain where justice would be better served, and defendants would be better off, if they could choose trial by judge alone. | Furthermore, Robertson said: “There are cases in Britain where justice would be better served, and defendants would be better off, if they could choose trial by judge alone. |
| “Provision of [the Australian states’] jury waiver option will not lead to the demise of a form of trial that has so much public acceptance, in particular because it involves the public in the delivery of justice. None of the Australian states which allow defendants (but not prosecutors) to waive jury trials have moved on to abolish juries.” | “Provision of [the Australian states’] jury waiver option will not lead to the demise of a form of trial that has so much public acceptance, in particular because it involves the public in the delivery of justice. None of the Australian states which allow defendants (but not prosecutors) to waive jury trials have moved on to abolish juries.” |
| Trial by a jury is a venerated practice, dating back to Anglo-Saxon times. However, there are already significant exceptions. | Trial by a jury is a venerated practice, dating back to Anglo-Saxon times. However, there are already significant exceptions. |
| During the Troubles in Northern Ireland, cases involving paramilitaries were heard without a jury for fear of jury intimidation. Judges would hear evidence then sum up as though addressing a jury before delivering a verdict. | During the Troubles in Northern Ireland, cases involving paramilitaries were heard without a jury for fear of jury intimidation. Judges would hear evidence then sum up as though addressing a jury before delivering a verdict. |
| In 2007, Diplock courts, as they were known, were abolished except where Northern Ireland’s director of public prosecutions certifies the administration of justice might be impaired by a jury trial. A former soldier, Dennis Hutchings, is due to face trial in Belfast in a Diplock court this year. | In 2007, Diplock courts, as they were known, were abolished except where Northern Ireland’s director of public prosecutions certifies the administration of justice might be impaired by a jury trial. A former soldier, Dennis Hutchings, is due to face trial in Belfast in a Diplock court this year. |
| Non-jury trials are also permitted in England and Wales where jury tampering is suspected. In one 2011 case, a recorder in north London had to discharge a jury and complete the trial on her own. | Non-jury trials are also permitted in England and Wales where jury tampering is suspected. In one 2011 case, a recorder in north London had to discharge a jury and complete the trial on her own. |
| Early in the lockdown, the Scottish government suggested abandoning jury trials temporarily but had to drop the proposal following an outcry. | Early in the lockdown, the Scottish government suggested abandoning jury trials temporarily but had to drop the proposal following an outcry. |
| This month, Justice, a legal reform organisation, experimented with online trials in which jury members heard a case remotely from their homes. HM Courts and Tribunals Service (HMCTS) has said it has no plans for trials with juries participating from home. | This month, Justice, a legal reform organisation, experimented with online trials in which jury members heard a case remotely from their homes. HM Courts and Tribunals Service (HMCTS) has said it has no plans for trials with juries participating from home. |
| Last week, it was announced “a judicial working group” has been established “to consider ways to restart some jury trials once it is safe to do so”. It includes representatives from the Law Society, Bar Council, Criminal Bar Association (CBA), HMCTS, Crown Prosecution Service and other agencies. | Last week, it was announced “a judicial working group” has been established “to consider ways to restart some jury trials once it is safe to do so”. It includes representatives from the Law Society, Bar Council, Criminal Bar Association (CBA), HMCTS, Crown Prosecution Service and other agencies. |
| The Lord Chief Justice, Lord Burnett of Maldon, has said: “I personally don’t think it realistic to think the jury could be in a different place ... jury trials are the clearest example of what will be most difficult to get back to normal.” | The Lord Chief Justice, Lord Burnett of Maldon, has said: “I personally don’t think it realistic to think the jury could be in a different place ... jury trials are the clearest example of what will be most difficult to get back to normal.” |
| The CBA, which represents barristers in England and Wales, fears jury trials are under threat. Its chair, Caroline Goodwin QC, said: “There is no substitution for both open and efficient justice by having a live trial in a physical space with jurors, barristers, a judge, witnesses and defendants all able to engage fully and solemnly with the full range of verbal, non-verbal and visual cues.” | The CBA, which represents barristers in England and Wales, fears jury trials are under threat. Its chair, Caroline Goodwin QC, said: “There is no substitution for both open and efficient justice by having a live trial in a physical space with jurors, barristers, a judge, witnesses and defendants all able to engage fully and solemnly with the full range of verbal, non-verbal and visual cues.” |
| • This article was amended on 30 April 2020 because an earlier version was incorrect to refer to the latest edition of the Crown Court Compendium as making changes to the language judges can use when addressing jurors about the standard of proof. |