This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-glasgow-west-33959101
The article has changed 7 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 3 | Version 4 |
|---|---|
| Glasgow bin lorry crash: Families intend to prosecute driver | |
| (about 5 hours later) | |
| The families of two women who died in the Glasgow bin lorry crash have told an inquiry they intend to seek a private prosecution against the driver. | |
| Jacqueline Morton's family have sought an adjournment so they can begin action against 58-year-old Harry Clarke. | Jacqueline Morton's family have sought an adjournment so they can begin action against 58-year-old Harry Clarke. |
| The motion is being backed by relatives of Gillian Ewing. Both women were among the six people who died in the crash on 22 December last year. | |
| A decision on whether the inquiry will be halted will be made on Thursday. | A decision on whether the inquiry will be halted will be made on Thursday. |
| In the meantime, evidence at the fatal accident inquiry (FAI), which is now in its fifth week at Glasgow Sheriff Court, will continue. | In the meantime, evidence at the fatal accident inquiry (FAI), which is now in its fifth week at Glasgow Sheriff Court, will continue. |
| Previous blackout | Previous blackout |
| The inquiry is looking at Mr Clarke's health, the bin lorry and its route. | The inquiry is looking at Mr Clarke's health, the bin lorry and its route. |
| The FAI has previously heard that Mr Clarke was unconscious at the wheel when the Glasgow City Council bin lorry crashed on 22 December last year. | The FAI has previously heard that Mr Clarke was unconscious at the wheel when the Glasgow City Council bin lorry crashed on 22 December last year. |
| The inquiry has also heard that he suffered a previous blackout in 2010 at the wheel of a bus, while employed as a driver for First Bus. | The inquiry has also heard that he suffered a previous blackout in 2010 at the wheel of a bus, while employed as a driver for First Bus. |
| In the past four weeks, the FAI has been told that Mr Clarke lied about the circumstances surrounding the 2010 blackout in his council application form, subsequent health assessments and in dealings with the Driver and Vehicle Licensing Agency (DVLA). | In the past four weeks, the FAI has been told that Mr Clarke lied about the circumstances surrounding the 2010 blackout in his council application form, subsequent health assessments and in dealings with the Driver and Vehicle Licensing Agency (DVLA). |
| Scotland's Crown Office stated in February that it would not bring criminal proceedings against Mr Clarke over the incident, which it said was a tragic accident. | Scotland's Crown Office stated in February that it would not bring criminal proceedings against Mr Clarke over the incident, which it said was a tragic accident. |
| The Crown Office later clarified at the inquiry that this decision stood, even after it had emerged at the FAI that Mr Clarke may have lied about the state of his health to obtain driving jobs. | The Crown Office later clarified at the inquiry that this decision stood, even after it had emerged at the FAI that Mr Clarke may have lied about the state of his health to obtain driving jobs. |
| Some families have been highly-critical of the decision not to prosecute Mr Clarke and have stated they would consider a private prosecution against him. | Some families have been highly-critical of the decision not to prosecute Mr Clarke and have stated they would consider a private prosecution against him. |
| On Monday, the first move towards a private prosecution began at the inquiry. | On Monday, the first move towards a private prosecution began at the inquiry. |
| What does a private prosecution involve? | What does a private prosecution involve? |
| In Scotland, prosecutions are normally brought by the Lord Advocate, who heads the Crown Office. | In Scotland, prosecutions are normally brought by the Lord Advocate, who heads the Crown Office. |
| Private prosecutions are extremely unusual, with only two in the 20th Century. | Private prosecutions are extremely unusual, with only two in the 20th Century. |
| To bring one, an individual must apply to the High Court for a "Bill of Criminal Letters," which can be opposed by the Lord Advocate - and the alleged offender. | To bring one, an individual must apply to the High Court for a "Bill of Criminal Letters," which can be opposed by the Lord Advocate - and the alleged offender. |
| If the court grants the application, they have 21 days to lodge answers, after which a hearing is fixed for a later date to decide whether the prosecution can proceed. | If the court grants the application, they have 21 days to lodge answers, after which a hearing is fixed for a later date to decide whether the prosecution can proceed. |
| At each stage there is the possibility of an appeal, which makes the process extremely costly as legal aid would not be available for an individual bringing a case. | At each stage there is the possibility of an appeal, which makes the process extremely costly as legal aid would not be available for an individual bringing a case. |
| The last private prosecution was the so-called Carole X case in 1982 in which defence lawyers gave their services pro bono - free of charge. | The last private prosecution was the so-called Carole X case in 1982 in which defence lawyers gave their services pro bono - free of charge. |
| A Glasgow woman prosecuted three men who she claimed had raped her. One was found guilty. | A Glasgow woman prosecuted three men who she claimed had raped her. One was found guilty. |
| The other case was in 1909, and involved a coal company and allegations of fraud. | The other case was in 1909, and involved a coal company and allegations of fraud. |
| Dorothy Bain QC, acting for the family of Ms Morton, from Glasgow, told Sheriff John Beckett she had been instructed to seek an adjournment in order to seek authority to bring a private prosecution against Mr Clarke. | Dorothy Bain QC, acting for the family of Ms Morton, from Glasgow, told Sheriff John Beckett she had been instructed to seek an adjournment in order to seek authority to bring a private prosecution against Mr Clarke. |
| Ms Bain said it could take up to three months to establish whether a private prosecution could proceed. | Ms Bain said it could take up to three months to establish whether a private prosecution could proceed. |
| Alistair Forsyth, acting for the bereaved Ewing family, supported Ms Bain's motion. | Alistair Forsyth, acting for the bereaved Ewing family, supported Ms Bain's motion. |
| Ronald Conway, representing the Tait family, said they would not be pursuing a private prosecution as the family felt that the inquiry should focus on the "systemic failures which have been made plain" during the course of evidence. | Ronald Conway, representing the Tait family, said they would not be pursuing a private prosecution as the family felt that the inquiry should focus on the "systemic failures which have been made plain" during the course of evidence. |
| 'Profound implications' | 'Profound implications' |
| Mr Clarke's advocate, Ronnie Clancy QC, said the driver supported the motion to adjourn, but stressed that he was keen to return to the inquiry to give evidence once the issue of legal proceedings had been resolved. | Mr Clarke's advocate, Ronnie Clancy QC, said the driver supported the motion to adjourn, but stressed that he was keen to return to the inquiry to give evidence once the issue of legal proceedings had been resolved. |
| Solicitor General Lesley Thomson QC, who is leading the inquiry, said there was a "clear public interest" in seeing the inquiry through to the sheriff's determination. | Solicitor General Lesley Thomson QC, who is leading the inquiry, said there was a "clear public interest" in seeing the inquiry through to the sheriff's determination. |
| She said that if Mr Clarke was going to be prosecuted then he would have to be given a warning before giving evidence, meaning he may not answer all questions. | She said that if Mr Clarke was going to be prosecuted then he would have to be given a warning before giving evidence, meaning he may not answer all questions. |
| Ms Thomson said there would be "profound implications" in adjourning the inquiry. | Ms Thomson said there would be "profound implications" in adjourning the inquiry. |
| Sheriff Beckett said he would consider the motion for adjournment and the inquiry would hear the evidence of the other remaining witnesses in the meantime. | Sheriff Beckett said he would consider the motion for adjournment and the inquiry would hear the evidence of the other remaining witnesses in the meantime. |
| This means that Mr Clarke, who was expected to begin giving evidence on Tuesday, will not appear until Thursday at the earliest. | This means that Mr Clarke, who was expected to begin giving evidence on Tuesday, will not appear until Thursday at the earliest. |
| Six people died and 15 others were injured when the Glasgow City Council bin lorry veered out of control on Queen Street on 22 December last year before crashing into the Millennium Hotel in George Square. | Six people died and 15 others were injured when the Glasgow City Council bin lorry veered out of control on Queen Street on 22 December last year before crashing into the Millennium Hotel in George Square. |
| The inquiry continues. | The inquiry continues. |