This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-34071842
The article has changed 3 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 1 | Version 2 |
|---|---|
| Did French media put lives at risk? | Did French media put lives at risk? |
| (about 2 months later) | |
| How far can broadcast journalists go in live coverage of terrorist incidents when their reports might influence the course of events or even endanger lives? | How far can broadcast journalists go in live coverage of terrorist incidents when their reports might influence the course of events or even endanger lives? |
| In France, the question has particular relevance after two legal investigations were launched into media organisations over their handling of the January attacks in Paris. | In France, the question has particular relevance after two legal investigations were launched into media organisations over their handling of the January attacks in Paris. |
| In one case, six people who hid in the cold room at the HyperCacher supermarket have taken legal action claiming that live broadcasts could have tipped off the gunman Amedy Coulibaly to their presence. | In one case, six people who hid in the cold room at the HyperCacher supermarket have taken legal action claiming that live broadcasts could have tipped off the gunman Amedy Coulibaly to their presence. |
| In the second, Lilian Lepere - who hid beneath a sink at the print works where the Kouachi brothers were eventually cornered - says his life was jeopardised by reports of an employee on the premises. Had the terrorists been listening, they could have sought him out and killed him. | In the second, Lilian Lepere - who hid beneath a sink at the print works where the Kouachi brothers were eventually cornered - says his life was jeopardised by reports of an employee on the premises. Had the terrorists been listening, they could have sought him out and killed him. |
| In both cases, the Paris prosecutor's office has opened preliminary investigations. | In both cases, the Paris prosecutor's office has opened preliminary investigations. |
| If it feels there is enough evidence, then several radio and television stations could be brought to trial. | If it feels there is enough evidence, then several radio and television stations could be brought to trial. |
| Beyond the purely legal aspect, there are huge ethical questions at stake. | Beyond the purely legal aspect, there are huge ethical questions at stake. |
| In recent years, technology has made possible the instant reporting of dramatic and often tragic events. | In recent years, technology has made possible the instant reporting of dramatic and often tragic events. |
| As the shootings in Virginia on Wednesday showed, criminals or terrorists now regularly factor in the media when they plan their actions. | As the shootings in Virginia on Wednesday showed, criminals or terrorists now regularly factor in the media when they plan their actions. |
| By providing regular coverage, are broadcasters falling in with their game plan? | By providing regular coverage, are broadcasters falling in with their game plan? |
| In the event of a fast unfolding situation like the January attacks in Paris, should broadcasters be made to sit on information? Should they defer to a police censor in case they say something dangerous? | In the event of a fast unfolding situation like the January attacks in Paris, should broadcasters be made to sit on information? Should they defer to a police censor in case they say something dangerous? |
| And should they hold back on certain images, even when the same images may be freely circulating on the social media, after being taken by a private citizen on his mobile phone? | And should they hold back on certain images, even when the same images may be freely circulating on the social media, after being taken by a private citizen on his mobile phone? |
| In fact, French broadcasters already feel themselves to be unfairly under attack over the January events, after they were nearly all delivered formal warnings from the state watchdog, the CSA. | In fact, French broadcasters already feel themselves to be unfairly under attack over the January events, after they were nearly all delivered formal warnings from the state watchdog, the CSA. |
| Some were chastised for revealing the presence of the hidden hostages, some for showing distressing images, some for reporting the start of the shootout at the print works when this might have tipped Coulibaly into carrying out a massacre. | Some were chastised for revealing the presence of the hidden hostages, some for showing distressing images, some for reporting the start of the shootout at the print works when this might have tipped Coulibaly into carrying out a massacre. |
| According to the lawyer Patrick Klugman, who represents the HyperCacher six: "We need to look much more closely at the chain of decision-making in the broadcast media. | |
| "The way they function when there is breaking news is an actual encouragement to crime." | "The way they function when there is breaking news is an actual encouragement to crime." |
| The live broadcasters are united in rejecting the decision of the CSA and have filed an appeal at the State Council (the highest administrative court). | The live broadcasters are united in rejecting the decision of the CSA and have filed an appeal at the State Council (the highest administrative court). |
| In an open letter, the news editors of 14 organisations - private and public - asked: "How in the light of these sanctions can we continue to inform? In what other major democracy are the media brought to book for recounting events in real time?" | In an open letter, the news editors of 14 organisations - private and public - asked: "How in the light of these sanctions can we continue to inform? In what other major democracy are the media brought to book for recounting events in real time?" |
| Herve Beroud, who is head of news at BFMTV, told me the rebukes were unfair and counterproductive. | Herve Beroud, who is head of news at BFMTV, told me the rebukes were unfair and counterproductive. |
| "If the responsible, organised media - the ones with chains of command and professional reporters - if they are the ones who are punished and made to self-censor, then what will happen is that viewers will go elsewhere: to the social media and the internet, where there is no control on content whatsoever," he said. | "If the responsible, organised media - the ones with chains of command and professional reporters - if they are the ones who are punished and made to self-censor, then what will happen is that viewers will go elsewhere: to the social media and the internet, where there is no control on content whatsoever," he said. |
| "We put out 70 hours of live broadcasting non-stop in January. There was one mistake of 23 seconds, when we revealed that there were people in the cold room. | "We put out 70 hours of live broadcasting non-stop in January. There was one mistake of 23 seconds, when we revealed that there were people in the cold room. |
| "That was an error, and we admit it. But beyond that there were no factual mistakes. And we held back from broadcasting a load of information that we had - because we felt it was unethical. Like the interviews we had with the gunmen." | "That was an error, and we admit it. But beyond that there were no factual mistakes. And we held back from broadcasting a load of information that we had - because we felt it was unethical. Like the interviews we had with the gunmen." |
| Success unlikely | Success unlikely |
| Legal experts feel there is little chance the cases being brought in the courts will succeed. | Legal experts feel there is little chance the cases being brought in the courts will succeed. |
| Media lawyer Christophe Bigot told me that there was simply too little evidence that the reports had put lives in danger. | Media lawyer Christophe Bigot told me that there was simply too little evidence that the reports had put lives in danger. |
| "But it's an alarm signal," he added. | "But it's an alarm signal," he added. |
| "Of course journalists will continue to cover live terrorist events, but maybe they will be more careful when lives could be at risk." | "Of course journalists will continue to cover live terrorist events, but maybe they will be more careful when lives could be at risk." |
| At BFMTV Mr Beroud said the procedures that had been in place in January had worked fine, and still worked today. | At BFMTV Mr Beroud said the procedures that had been in place in January had worked fine, and still worked today. |
| "When the film of the Virginia shootings came in yesterday, we viewed it and made a decision: 'No.' | "When the film of the Virginia shootings came in yesterday, we viewed it and made a decision: 'No.' |
| "Before any sensitive piece of information is broadcast, our journalists know to refer it up the editorial chain. | "Before any sensitive piece of information is broadcast, our journalists know to refer it up the editorial chain. |
| "But it is true. Since the events in January, we all have a little bulb in our heads that says, 'Be extra careful.' | "But it is true. Since the events in January, we all have a little bulb in our heads that says, 'Be extra careful.' |
| "The new technology has created awesome new possibilities for journalists. | "The new technology has created awesome new possibilities for journalists. |
| "But it also means we have extra responsibilities every time we press the red button." | "But it also means we have extra responsibilities every time we press the red button." |
| Paris attack victims: | Paris attack victims: |
| Charlie Hebdo offices: | Charlie Hebdo offices: |
| Montrouge shooting | Montrouge shooting |
| HyperCacher supermarket: | HyperCacher supermarket: |