This article is from the source 'independent' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/europe/the-fake-refugee-images-that-are-being-used-to-distort-pubic-opinion-on-asylum-seekers-10503703.html
The article has changed 4 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 1 | Version 2 |
|---|---|
| The fake refugee images that are being used to distort public opinion on asylum seekers | The fake refugee images that are being used to distort public opinion on asylum seekers |
| (about 2 hours later) | |
| As debate about how to solve Europe's refugee crisis continues, right-wing groups and commentators are using photos and memes to demonise the desperate people risking their lives to reach the continent. | |
| But many of the photos are being faked, twisted, edited or taken out of context in an effort to support the following myths and arguments. | |
| Several photos have surfaced online claiming to show Isis militants arriving in Europe, comparing images of men in battle dress and pictures of people arriving on the continent. This man and several others 'outed' as Isis militants fought against the group, not with it | Several photos have surfaced online claiming to show Isis militants arriving in Europe, comparing images of men in battle dress and pictures of people arriving on the continent. This man and several others 'outed' as Isis militants fought against the group, not with it |
| But even in cases where the photos do appear to be of the same person, claims that they are members of the so-called Islamic State have been wrong. | But even in cases where the photos do appear to be of the same person, claims that they are members of the so-called Islamic State have been wrong. |
| A widely shared picture claiming to be of refugees attacking police with an Isis flag actually showed a protest in Germany in 2012 – before the rise of the so-called Islamic State. This photo is one of the many being wrongly used as 'proof' Isis militants are arriving in Europe | A widely shared picture claiming to be of refugees attacking police with an Isis flag actually showed a protest in Germany in 2012 – before the rise of the so-called Islamic State. This photo is one of the many being wrongly used as 'proof' Isis militants are arriving in Europe |
| Several other images claiming to show refugees fighting for Isis wearing assault rifles and fatigues have also been debunked, with at least two of the men shown actually being part of groups fighting the jihadist group, including Kurdish forces and the Free Syrian Army. | Several other images claiming to show refugees fighting for Isis wearing assault rifles and fatigues have also been debunked, with at least two of the men shown actually being part of groups fighting the jihadist group, including Kurdish forces and the Free Syrian Army. |
| Another meme shared by an anti-immigration group in Croatia claims to show another "Islamist" arriving in Europe. But online analysts said his uniform and equipment identified him as an anti-Isis fighter. | Another meme shared by an anti-immigration group in Croatia claims to show another "Islamist" arriving in Europe. But online analysts said his uniform and equipment identified him as an anti-Isis fighter. |
| Ovo nije izbjeglička kriza, ovo je premještanje trupa, dijelite...⬇⬇⬇⬇⬇Islamist refugees are NOT welcome in Croatia | Ovo nije izbjeglička kriza, ovo je premještanje trupa, dijelite...⬇⬇⬇⬇⬇Islamist refugees are NOT welcome in Croatia |
| While there is a strong possibility that some of the people migrating to Europe may have been involved in armed conflict or linked with extremist groups, the UN has repeatedly dismissed claims that “thousands” of jihadists are arriving. | While there is a strong possibility that some of the people migrating to Europe may have been involved in armed conflict or linked with extremist groups, the UN has repeatedly dismissed claims that “thousands” of jihadists are arriving. |
| Following a Lebanese government minister’s assertion that one in 50 Syrians entering Europe could be Isis members, a spokesperson for refugee agency the UNHCR said: “This kind of statement is extremely unhelpful. | Following a Lebanese government minister’s assertion that one in 50 Syrians entering Europe could be Isis members, a spokesperson for refugee agency the UNHCR said: “This kind of statement is extremely unhelpful. |
| “A refugee has a genuine fear of persecution, if you have any military connection at all then you lose your status as a refugee. There are over a million Syrians in Lebanon there is no legitimate way of providing figures like that.” | |
| Pegida UK, a branch of the German group known for its huge “anti-Islamism” protests, has been sharing numerous photos claiming to show “fake” or undeserving refugees. | Pegida UK, a branch of the German group known for its huge “anti-Islamism” protests, has been sharing numerous photos claiming to show “fake” or undeserving refugees. |
| Many of the assertions are based on the fact people in the pictures appear not to be malnourished. | Many of the assertions are based on the fact people in the pictures appear not to be malnourished. |
| In one post spotted by news website France 24, photos of a muscular man are sarcastically labelled: “Please help feed and house this poor, defenceless refugee…’I heard we can get free steroids in England – don’t be racist and let me in!’” | In one post spotted by news website France 24, photos of a muscular man are sarcastically labelled: “Please help feed and house this poor, defenceless refugee…’I heard we can get free steroids in England – don’t be racist and let me in!’” |
| ." Please help these defenceless women and children"! | ." Please help these defenceless women and children"! |
| But the photos were actually taken in 2013 on Christmas Island in Australia. | But the photos were actually taken in 2013 on Christmas Island in Australia. |
| In other images taken at the same time, the border police’s blue uniforms can clearly be seen with “Australian Customs and Border Protection” written on them. | In other images taken at the same time, the border police’s blue uniforms can clearly be seen with “Australian Customs and Border Protection” written on them. |
| These poor refugees have gone nearly 10 hours without a protein shake. | These poor refugees have gone nearly 10 hours without a protein shake. |
| Numerous images of mainly Syrian refugees carrying smartphones have also been shared by right-wing blogs and commentators on social media arguing they do not need Europe’s help. | |
| But as James O’Malley wrote in a comment piece for The Independent, possessing a phone is no indicator of how deserving an asylum seeker is of refuge, and middle-income countries like Syria are clearly just as susceptible to conflict as anywhere else. | |
| “The answer to how surprised should we be that many of the Syrian refugees have smartphones is a resounding ‘not very’,” he said. | “The answer to how surprised should we be that many of the Syrian refugees have smartphones is a resounding ‘not very’,” he said. |
| “The world isn't a binary split between 'rich' and 'poor' – and we should adjust our assumptions about the countries in the middle accordingly.” | |
| In one of the most heartless conspiracy theories circulating online, people are claiming that the body of three-year-old Aylan Kurdi was “staged” on a Turkish beach as part of a political plot to garner global sympathy. | In one of the most heartless conspiracy theories circulating online, people are claiming that the body of three-year-old Aylan Kurdi was “staged” on a Turkish beach as part of a political plot to garner global sympathy. |
| So the staged photo of poor little Aylan worked then? 20,000 Syrian. Not so much outcry if they used the original. pic.twitter.com/pLiBfZQIRc | So the staged photo of poor little Aylan worked then? 20,000 Syrian. Not so much outcry if they used the original. pic.twitter.com/pLiBfZQIRc |
| People have seized on an image of a Turkish police officer picking up a child’s body on a markedly different section of beach to argue that the child’s body was moved for a photo opportunity. | People have seized on an image of a Turkish police officer picking up a child’s body on a markedly different section of beach to argue that the child’s body was moved for a photo opportunity. |
| “Little Aylan Kurdi, if he is dead, did not drown. He was killed. And the picture is a set-up fake. His body has been arranged in position,” one person wrote on Twitter. | “Little Aylan Kurdi, if he is dead, did not drown. He was killed. And the picture is a set-up fake. His body has been arranged in position,” one person wrote on Twitter. |
| @TheSun Aylan picture is a fake!!!!!!!!!!! pic.twitter.com/x28DcrL33V | @TheSun Aylan picture is a fake!!!!!!!!!!! pic.twitter.com/x28DcrL33V |
| Knights Templar International wrote: “Goulish (sic) propagandists moved and used the dead body of the little boy drowned on a Turkish beach to get pictures that would ‘best’ manipulate public opinion.” | |
| “The media, who buy in to the UN’s politics, can not only advance its ideological aim, they can also financially benefit from twisting the true facts of the death of poor little Aylan Shenu,” a conspiracy blog added. | “The media, who buy in to the UN’s politics, can not only advance its ideological aim, they can also financially benefit from twisting the true facts of the death of poor little Aylan Shenu,” a conspiracy blog added. |
| “And if there ever was a doubt about this being anything else, please, consider this, most telling fact: before the most heart-wrenching photos of little Aylan were taken, his body was specifically and intentionally posed!” Aylan Kurdi (L) and his brother Galip both died in the disaster | “And if there ever was a doubt about this being anything else, please, consider this, most telling fact: before the most heart-wrenching photos of little Aylan were taken, his body was specifically and intentionally posed!” Aylan Kurdi (L) and his brother Galip both died in the disaster |
| But the photo used as “evidence” of the alleged forgery is actually of Aylan’s older brother, five-year-old Galip, who also drowned alongside his mother as they tried to cross the Aegean Sea. | But the photo used as “evidence” of the alleged forgery is actually of Aylan’s older brother, five-year-old Galip, who also drowned alongside his mother as they tried to cross the Aegean Sea. |
| His body, washed up on a different stretch of beach nearby, is visibly larger and dressed in different clothing and shoes. | His body, washed up on a different stretch of beach nearby, is visibly larger and dressed in different clothing and shoes. |
| And far from it being a “staged” shot, the photographer who took the now iconic image of Aylan has told how she was in Bodrum to await refugee arrivals and noticed “lifeless bodies” on the beach by chance. | And far from it being a “staged” shot, the photographer who took the now iconic image of Aylan has told how she was in Bodrum to await refugee arrivals and noticed “lifeless bodies” on the beach by chance. |
| Although the number of refugees and migrants arriving in Europe is undeniably huge – with estimates for this year so far hitting 500,000 people – many of the alarmist photos being circulated are fake. | Although the number of refugees and migrants arriving in Europe is undeniably huge – with estimates for this year so far hitting 500,000 people – many of the alarmist photos being circulated are fake. |
| quand des responsables soufflent sur les braises dans un jeu politicien écoeurant, CA SUFFIT !!! cc @OChastel pic.twitter.com/yM5Y7fkSkN | quand des responsables soufflent sur les braises dans un jeu politicien écoeurant, CA SUFFIT !!! cc @OChastel pic.twitter.com/yM5Y7fkSkN |
| Belgian television station RTBF revealed that this image, claiming to show the “invasion of Italy” by “illegal immigrants” actually dates from 1991 and showed “La Vlora” bringing 20,000 migrants to the Italian port of Bari. | Belgian television station RTBF revealed that this image, claiming to show the “invasion of Italy” by “illegal immigrants” actually dates from 1991 and showed “La Vlora” bringing 20,000 migrants to the Italian port of Bari. |
| Zakia Khattabi, co-president of the country’s Ecolo party, reposted the photo on Twitter, writing that she’d had “enough” of the “disgusting political game” being played in Europe. | Zakia Khattabi, co-president of the country’s Ecolo party, reposted the photo on Twitter, writing that she’d had “enough” of the “disgusting political game” being played in Europe. |
| Another image of La Vlora, showing desperate Albanians climbing ion to the ship before it set off, was shared by Pegida UK on its Facebook page in a post that garnered comments calling for it to be “torpedoed”. | Another image of La Vlora, showing desperate Albanians climbing ion to the ship before it set off, was shared by Pegida UK on its Facebook page in a post that garnered comments calling for it to be “torpedoed”. |
| A much-shared meme posted on Facebook by far-right group the English Defence League (EDL) contrasts photos of British soldiers and male refugees arriving in Germany. | A much-shared meme posted on Facebook by far-right group the English Defence League (EDL) contrasts photos of British soldiers and male refugees arriving in Germany. |
| Above the soldiers, the caption reads: “Go to warzone. Leave women and children in safe country.” By the refugees, the writing says: “Go to safe country. Leave women and children in warzone.” | Above the soldiers, the caption reads: “Go to warzone. Leave women and children in safe country.” By the refugees, the writing says: “Go to safe country. Leave women and children in warzone.” |
| The image, which has been “liked” more than 2,200 times, summed up widely circulating claims that many of the people arriving are male “economic migrants” rather than asylum seekers. | The image, which has been “liked” more than 2,200 times, summed up widely circulating claims that many of the people arriving are male “economic migrants” rather than asylum seekers. |
| But as Vice pointed out, it appears to have been taken from Reuters footage that shows dozens of women and children of all ages arriving on the same train. | But as Vice pointed out, it appears to have been taken from Reuters footage that shows dozens of women and children of all ages arriving on the same train. |
| Where are the women and children? Why aren't gulf nations accepting refugees? Don't be fools! #NeverForget911 pic.twitter.com/nNkwsmLksv | Where are the women and children? Why aren't gulf nations accepting refugees? Don't be fools! #NeverForget911 pic.twitter.com/nNkwsmLksv |
| The argument has been made by politicians across the world, including David Davies, the Conservative MP for Monmouth, who told BBC Radio Wales that refugees attempting to reach the UK were “mostly young men, mostly with mobile phones, chancing their luck”. | The argument has been made by politicians across the world, including David Davies, the Conservative MP for Monmouth, who told BBC Radio Wales that refugees attempting to reach the UK were “mostly young men, mostly with mobile phones, chancing their luck”. |
| According to UNHCR figures, around 72 per cent of refugees and migrants arriving in Europe across the Mediterranean are men, with 13 per cent women and 15 per cent children. | According to UNHCR figures, around 72 per cent of refugees and migrants arriving in Europe across the Mediterranean are men, with 13 per cent women and 15 per cent children. |
| Some aid workers have suggested the demographics may be caused by the danger of the journey, causing men to go ahead of their families in attempt to secure refuge in Europe and a home before more vulnerable relatives set off. | Some aid workers have suggested the demographics may be caused by the danger of the journey, causing men to go ahead of their families in attempt to secure refuge in Europe and a home before more vulnerable relatives set off. |