This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-london-34549700
The article has changed 7 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 2 | Version 3 |
|---|---|
| Uber taxi-hailing app does not break law, High Court rules | Uber taxi-hailing app does not break law, High Court rules |
| (35 minutes later) | |
| The taxi-hailing app operated in London by the US firm Uber does not break the law, the High Court has found. | The taxi-hailing app operated in London by the US firm Uber does not break the law, the High Court has found. |
| The court had been asked to decide whether the company's smartphones were considered meters, which are outlawed for private hire vehicles. | The court had been asked to decide whether the company's smartphones were considered meters, which are outlawed for private hire vehicles. |
| The phones use GPS and external servers to calculate the cost of a journey. | The phones use GPS and external servers to calculate the cost of a journey. |
| Transport for London said taking the case to court had been "in the public interest". | Transport for London said taking the case to court had been "in the public interest". |
| The app-based company allows users to order cars via their smartphones, which often arrive within minutes and can cost a fraction of the price of a black cab. | The app-based company allows users to order cars via their smartphones, which often arrive within minutes and can cost a fraction of the price of a black cab. |
| Mr Justice Ouseley declared that taximeters do not operate in the same way as the app as they do not depend on GPS signals or include the app's other new-tech characteristics to calculate fares. | Mr Justice Ouseley declared that taximeters do not operate in the same way as the app as they do not depend on GPS signals or include the app's other new-tech characteristics to calculate fares. |
| 'Emphatic' call | 'Emphatic' call |
| TfL and Uber had both argued at a one-day hearing earlier in October that the app was not a meter, and both organisations greeted the decision as a victory. | TfL and Uber had both argued at a one-day hearing earlier in October that the app was not a meter, and both organisations greeted the decision as a victory. |
| An Uber spokesman said: "This was not a marginal call; it is quite emphatic. In fact, it is contemptuous of the case brought before it. | An Uber spokesman said: "This was not a marginal call; it is quite emphatic. In fact, it is contemptuous of the case brought before it. |
| "Uber will continue going about our business and making sure customers have choice." | "Uber will continue going about our business and making sure customers have choice." |
| Transport for London also welcomed the ruling, saying there had been "significant public interest in establishing legal certainty in the matter". | Transport for London also welcomed the ruling, saying there had been "significant public interest in establishing legal certainty in the matter". |
| The Licensed Taxi Drivers' Association (LTDA), which represents many of the 25,000 licensed taxi drivers in London, asked the judge to rule it was a meter and ban its use. | The Licensed Taxi Drivers' Association (LTDA), which represents many of the 25,000 licensed taxi drivers in London, asked the judge to rule it was a meter and ban its use. |
| LTDA chairman Richard Massett said: "We certainly are going to an appeal. | |
| "It's a fact that the smart phone acts in exactly the same way as a taximeter. It calculates the fare by means of time taken and distance covered - and it's doing exactly the same job. | |
| "Private hire legislation specifically precludes private hire from using a meter - and that's exactly what it is." | |
| The Licensed Private Hire Car Association (LPHCA) backed the LTDA and said the app was "an attempt to circumvent the statutory prohibition" on minicabs using meters. | The Licensed Private Hire Car Association (LPHCA) backed the LTDA and said the app was "an attempt to circumvent the statutory prohibition" on minicabs using meters. |
| Analysis from BBC London transport correspondent Tom Edwards | Analysis from BBC London transport correspondent Tom Edwards |
| This is not the end of this story - I think it is only the beginning. | This is not the end of this story - I think it is only the beginning. |
| As well as probable legal challenges to the High Court taximeter ruling, there are big changes to regulation being proposed by the mayor. | As well as probable legal challenges to the High Court taximeter ruling, there are big changes to regulation being proposed by the mayor. |
| Among those are a five-minute wait between booking a taxi via an app and the pick-up - and a ban on apps showing which cars are immediately available. That would seriously curtail how Uber currently operates. | Among those are a five-minute wait between booking a taxi via an app and the pick-up - and a ban on apps showing which cars are immediately available. That would seriously curtail how Uber currently operates. |
| A huge lobbying battle is now under way. Expect more protests from black cab drivers. | A huge lobbying battle is now under way. Expect more protests from black cab drivers. |
| The policy-makers are scrambling to keep up with this new technology - it has tied them in knots. | The policy-makers are scrambling to keep up with this new technology - it has tied them in knots. |
| There are also differing political opinions on the Uber app - the business secretary said in July he and the government welcomed "disruptive technology" - and that clashes with what the mayor is trying to achieve with his private-hire proposals. | There are also differing political opinions on the Uber app - the business secretary said in July he and the government welcomed "disruptive technology" - and that clashes with what the mayor is trying to achieve with his private-hire proposals. |
| 'Huge challenges' | 'Huge challenges' |
| Black cab drivers argue that the app poses a risk to public safety and customers being overcharged, with no opportunity to challenge fares before the money is automatically taken out of their bank accounts. | Black cab drivers argue that the app poses a risk to public safety and customers being overcharged, with no opportunity to challenge fares before the money is automatically taken out of their bank accounts. |
| A spokesman for London Mayor Boris Johnson said: "The mayor is a strong supporter of new technology and he recognises that innovation is embraced by Londoners." | A spokesman for London Mayor Boris Johnson said: "The mayor is a strong supporter of new technology and he recognises that innovation is embraced by Londoners." |
| However, he acknowledged "huge challenges" for the taxi and private hire trades, and "legitimate concerns" over vehicle emissions and congestion. | However, he acknowledged "huge challenges" for the taxi and private hire trades, and "legitimate concerns" over vehicle emissions and congestion. |
| He pointed out that TfL was carrying out a consultation on how to regulate the industry. | He pointed out that TfL was carrying out a consultation on how to regulate the industry. |
| BBC London transport correspondent Tom Edwards predicted that the LTDA would appeal against the decision, but that the future of the dispute would move from the courts to lobbying on new regulations. | BBC London transport correspondent Tom Edwards predicted that the LTDA would appeal against the decision, but that the future of the dispute would move from the courts to lobbying on new regulations. |