This article is from the source 'guardian' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.theguardian.com/politics/2015/nov/04/corbyn-v-cameron-at-pmqs-tax-credits-round-two-who-won
The article has changed 4 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 2 | Version 3 |
|---|---|
| Corbyn v Cameron at PMQs: tax credits round two, who won? | Corbyn v Cameron at PMQs: tax credits round two, who won? |
| (35 minutes later) | |
| Key points | Key points |
| Jeremy Corbyn has tackled David Cameron on tax credits for the second week in a row. The Labour leader also used three of his six questions to ask the prime minister about the NHS, which he said was facing problems of underfunding and neglect. | Jeremy Corbyn has tackled David Cameron on tax credits for the second week in a row. The Labour leader also used three of his six questions to ask the prime minister about the NHS, which he said was facing problems of underfunding and neglect. |
| Snap verdict | Snap verdict |
| It was a scrappy, inconclusive PMQs. Cameron mocked Corbyn for returning to the tax credit question that worked so well for him last week, but there can be merit in persistence. Although Cameron had better answers than he did last week, Corbyn made his point effectively. He was probably less successful with his questions on the NHS, but Cameron’s attempts to shift the subject were not edifying either, and neither side can claim a win. The high-minded, policy-focused tone, however, seems to be slipping. | It was a scrappy, inconclusive PMQs. Cameron mocked Corbyn for returning to the tax credit question that worked so well for him last week, but there can be merit in persistence. Although Cameron had better answers than he did last week, Corbyn made his point effectively. He was probably less successful with his questions on the NHS, but Cameron’s attempts to shift the subject were not edifying either, and neither side can claim a win. The high-minded, policy-focused tone, however, seems to be slipping. |
| This sounded like an old-fashioned, Cameron-Miliband session, and the PM can no longer hide the scorn he clearly feels for Corbyn. Letting it show, however, is not necessarily a good idea. | This sounded like an old-fashioned, Cameron-Miliband session, and the PM can no longer hide the scorn he clearly feels for Corbyn. Letting it show, however, is not necessarily a good idea. |
| Best lines | Best lines |
| Cameron taunted Corbyn over the leftwing credentials of his team: | Cameron taunted Corbyn over the leftwing credentials of his team: |
| His media adviser is a Stalinist, his new policy adviser is a Trotskyist, and his economic adviser is a communist. If he’s trying to move the Labour party to the left, I’d give him full Marx. | |
| Corbyn chided Cameron on his tone over tax credits: | Corbyn chided Cameron on his tone over tax credits: |
| This isn’t about entertainment. This is not funny for people who are desperately worried about what’s going to happen next April. | This isn’t about entertainment. This is not funny for people who are desperately worried about what’s going to happen next April. |
| More on PMQs | More on PMQs |
| Cameron rejects Corbyn’s concerns over looming NHS ‘winter crisis’ | Cameron rejects Corbyn’s concerns over looming NHS ‘winter crisis’ |