This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.

You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-hampshire-34898799

The article has changed 2 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.

Version 0 Version 1
Children's social services staff 'altered report' Children's social services staff 'altered report'
(about 3 hours later)
Social services staff involved in deciding whether five children should remain in care altered a report about their parents, a judge has said.Social services staff involved in deciding whether five children should remain in care altered a report about their parents, a judge has said.
The family court in Portsmouth was told a social worker and manager altered an assessment to create a "wholly negative" picture of a couple who were trying to get their children back.The family court in Portsmouth was told a social worker and manager altered an assessment to create a "wholly negative" picture of a couple who were trying to get their children back.
Judge Mark Horton said a worker had also lied under oath.Judge Mark Horton said a worker had also lied under oath.
But he ruled the children, aged three to 16, should stay in foster care. The council said it was "considering its position".
The judge ruled the children, aged three to 16, should stay in foster care.
Judge Horton said there had been an attempted "cover-up" by Hampshire County Council social worker Sarah Walker Smart and her manager, Kim Goode.Judge Horton said there had been an attempted "cover-up" by Hampshire County Council social worker Sarah Walker Smart and her manager, Kim Goode.
He said an assessment of the parents containing "positives and negatives" was changed, with the effect of improving the case for removing the children.He said an assessment of the parents containing "positives and negatives" was changed, with the effect of improving the case for removing the children.
'Hollow apology''Hollow apology'
He told the court: "It is exceptional to find a case in which there has been deliberate and calculated alteration of a report prepared by one social worker in order to make that assessment seem less favourable, by another social worker and the team manager."He told the court: "It is exceptional to find a case in which there has been deliberate and calculated alteration of a report prepared by one social worker in order to make that assessment seem less favourable, by another social worker and the team manager."
He said the original report had been withheld and the "parties to the alterations" tried to cover up its existence.He said the original report had been withheld and the "parties to the alterations" tried to cover up its existence.
Ms Walker Smart, who was subsequently promoted to team manager, "lied twice to me on oath", he said.Ms Walker Smart, who was subsequently promoted to team manager, "lied twice to me on oath", he said.
Ms Goode, now district manager for the Isle of Wight, "initiated the wholesale alteration of the original report and who attempted to keep the truth from the parties and me".Ms Goode, now district manager for the Isle of Wight, "initiated the wholesale alteration of the original report and who attempted to keep the truth from the parties and me".
Judge Horton said Ms Goode's manager, Lisa Humphreys, made a "hollow apology" during evidence and "failed to accept any personal responsibility" for what had happened.Judge Horton said Ms Goode's manager, Lisa Humphreys, made a "hollow apology" during evidence and "failed to accept any personal responsibility" for what had happened.
She had since become assistant director of children's social care at Lambeth Borough Council.She had since become assistant director of children's social care at Lambeth Borough Council.
Despite his criticisms, the judge approved the long-term fostering plans put forward by the council.Despite his criticisms, the judge approved the long-term fostering plans put forward by the council.
BBC has contacted Hampshire County Council for a comment. Hampshire County Council said it was considering its position and it believed some aspects of the court's criticism were "not quite correct".
A spokeswoman said: "We do accept that there were deficiencies in some of the social worker practice in this case and subsequent action was taken, including the termination of one social worker's employment with the county council. We are satisfied that at no stage did any of the named officers deliberately mislead the courts."
"We are very pleased that the outcome of the court case was consistent with the local authority's original application to the court - to safeguard very vulnerable children who were at risk of suffering significant harm as a result of neglect."