This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-34897585
The article has changed 3 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 0 | Version 1 |
|---|---|
| Pacific islands want a bigger share of fishing income | Pacific islands want a bigger share of fishing income |
| (about 2 hours later) | |
| As huge schools of tuna cut swiftly across the Western Pacific on a migration course that spans thousands of kilometres, they cluster by size. | As huge schools of tuna cut swiftly across the Western Pacific on a migration course that spans thousands of kilometres, they cluster by size. |
| Massive adult yellowfins swim together, while juveniles group separately and swim with adult skipjack of a similar size. | Massive adult yellowfins swim together, while juveniles group separately and swim with adult skipjack of a similar size. |
| Schooling confuses predators and makes it less likely that any single fish will fall victim to one. And bigger numbers mean more eyes are on the lookout for a meal. | Schooling confuses predators and makes it less likely that any single fish will fall victim to one. And bigger numbers mean more eyes are on the lookout for a meal. |
| Fishing is the best economic hope for the tiny island states that dot this part of the Pacific. And much like the fish they pull from the ocean, they've learned the benefits of swimming together. | Fishing is the best economic hope for the tiny island states that dot this part of the Pacific. And much like the fish they pull from the ocean, they've learned the benefits of swimming together. |
| The bulk of the fishing in the Pacific is sold by treaty to other countries, with the host nation collecting an access fee for each day of fishing. | The bulk of the fishing in the Pacific is sold by treaty to other countries, with the host nation collecting an access fee for each day of fishing. |
| Since the Pacific island nations started negotiating as a bloc five years ago, they've found themselves in a much better position. | Since the Pacific island nations started negotiating as a bloc five years ago, they've found themselves in a much better position. |
| Effectively, eight Pacific countries including Kiribati, formed a cartel, banding together to wield their market power to negotiate a better deal, and it's working. | |
| Their revenues from fishing rights have increased from $100m (£65m) to $430m over the past five years, according to the Pacific Islands Forum Fisheries Agency. | Their revenues from fishing rights have increased from $100m (£65m) to $430m over the past five years, according to the Pacific Islands Forum Fisheries Agency. |
| So how can these tiny states, mere specks on a map of the vast Pacific, wield this kind of market power? | So how can these tiny states, mere specks on a map of the vast Pacific, wield this kind of market power? |
| Sprawling economic areas | Sprawling economic areas |
| In truth, they're not as small as they seem. | In truth, they're not as small as they seem. |
| Every nation's exclusive economic zone spreads roughly 370 kilometres (230 miles) from its shores in every direction. So a country of widely-scattered, tiny atolls can have massive fishing grounds, even if it doesn't have much land. | Every nation's exclusive economic zone spreads roughly 370 kilometres (230 miles) from its shores in every direction. So a country of widely-scattered, tiny atolls can have massive fishing grounds, even if it doesn't have much land. |
| Kiribati's land area is only 810 sq km, roughly equal to the city of New York or about half the size of Greater London, but its exclusive economic zone is bigger than India (about 3.5 million sq km). | Kiribati's land area is only 810 sq km, roughly equal to the city of New York or about half the size of Greater London, but its exclusive economic zone is bigger than India (about 3.5 million sq km). |
| Together, the small island states control so much ocean that they've enacted a rule forcing their customers to choose between their waters and the open ocean. Most opt for the former. | Together, the small island states control so much ocean that they've enacted a rule forcing their customers to choose between their waters and the open ocean. Most opt for the former. |
| But controlling enough of the resources is no guarantee of an effective cartel. Cartels take a considerable amount of political will and discipline. | But controlling enough of the resources is no guarantee of an effective cartel. Cartels take a considerable amount of political will and discipline. |
| Members of the most famous one, Opec, often break ranks, and there's some evidence of discord here, too. | Members of the most famous one, Opec, often break ranks, and there's some evidence of discord here, too. |
| "Certainly we encounter more and more where it becomes more difficult to operate as a bloc. The easy wins have been won already," says Wez Norris, the deputy director-general of the Pacific Islands Forum Fisheries Agency. | "Certainly we encounter more and more where it becomes more difficult to operate as a bloc. The easy wins have been won already," says Wez Norris, the deputy director-general of the Pacific Islands Forum Fisheries Agency. |
| Looking for better deal | Looking for better deal |
| Last year, Kiribati largely opted out of a regional $90m deal with the US. | Last year, Kiribati largely opted out of a regional $90m deal with the US. |
| The deal gave the US 8,300 fishing days in the Pacific - fishing rights are now sold by the day. But Kiribati stunned many of its Pacific neighbours by contributing just 300 days to it. The country had been expected to offer several thousand days to the deal. | The deal gave the US 8,300 fishing days in the Pacific - fishing rights are now sold by the day. But Kiribati stunned many of its Pacific neighbours by contributing just 300 days to it. The country had been expected to offer several thousand days to the deal. |
| Kiribati's President Anote Tong says there's a practical element to it. | Kiribati's President Anote Tong says there's a practical element to it. |
| In previous years, they ran out of fishing days allowed under the treaty, and had to buy some from one country in order to give it to another. | In previous years, they ran out of fishing days allowed under the treaty, and had to buy some from one country in order to give it to another. |
| But Kiribati might also be looking for a better deal. | But Kiribati might also be looking for a better deal. |
| "All we're saying is we would reduce our contribution of vessel days to the US treaty. If the US boats want to fish in our waters, they can buy direct from us," he says. | "All we're saying is we would reduce our contribution of vessel days to the US treaty. If the US boats want to fish in our waters, they can buy direct from us," he says. |
| Regardless of whether cartels stick together, national competition and consumer watchdogs take a dim view of them, because they usually jack up prices. | Regardless of whether cartels stick together, national competition and consumer watchdogs take a dim view of them, because they usually jack up prices. |
| Trade commissions or consumer bodies might step in, for example, if supermarket chains or petrol retailers were jointly setting prices or conspiring to drive rivals out of business. | Trade commissions or consumer bodies might step in, for example, if supermarket chains or petrol retailers were jointly setting prices or conspiring to drive rivals out of business. |
| Of course, there's no watchdog that can stop co-operation between governments. | Of course, there's no watchdog that can stop co-operation between governments. |
| But the small Pacific states can scarcely be accused of predatory trade practices given how much fishing wealth flows out of the region. | But the small Pacific states can scarcely be accused of predatory trade practices given how much fishing wealth flows out of the region. |
| Money in processing | Money in processing |
| The real money is not in selling the raw materials, it is in processing. | The real money is not in selling the raw materials, it is in processing. |
| Some years, Kiribati will keep only 5% of the wealth from its fish, although the average is closer to 10%. | Some years, Kiribati will keep only 5% of the wealth from its fish, although the average is closer to 10%. |
| President Anote Tong says if every fish caught in the country's waters was processed domestically, the country's gross domestic product would double or triple many times over. | President Anote Tong says if every fish caught in the country's waters was processed domestically, the country's gross domestic product would double or triple many times over. |
| "All the fish is now being taken to Bangkok. Imagine all the jobs it's creating over there, but not here," he says. | "All the fish is now being taken to Bangkok. Imagine all the jobs it's creating over there, but not here," he says. |
| "So our objective is, and I think it's fair, that we want the processing. We want greater participation in the industry. Not just be the source of the raw material." | "So our objective is, and I think it's fair, that we want the processing. We want greater participation in the industry. Not just be the source of the raw material." |
| Kiribati is doing something about it. | Kiribati is doing something about it. |
| Every Wednesday, longline fishing boats glide across the startling blue lagoon waters and dock at Tarawa, the main island. | Every Wednesday, longline fishing boats glide across the startling blue lagoon waters and dock at Tarawa, the main island. |
| Workers haul massive yellowfin and bigeye tuna from below the deck, throw them over their shoulders and march up a flight of stairs before lifting them onto the docks. Then, they're loaded into massive ice-filled tubs, and taken down the dock to a processing plant. | Workers haul massive yellowfin and bigeye tuna from below the deck, throw them over their shoulders and march up a flight of stairs before lifting them onto the docks. Then, they're loaded into massive ice-filled tubs, and taken down the dock to a processing plant. |
| This facility, run by Kiribati Fish Limited, employs 200 people, in addition to 100 who work on the boats. That's no small achievement in a country where unemployment tops 30%. | This facility, run by Kiribati Fish Limited, employs 200 people, in addition to 100 who work on the boats. That's no small achievement in a country where unemployment tops 30%. |
| Still, it faces massive challenges. | Still, it faces massive challenges. |
| Remote location hurdles | Remote location hurdles |
| The same geography that gives these states such large fishing grounds ensures that they're smaller than their competitors and a long way from the markets they serve. | The same geography that gives these states such large fishing grounds ensures that they're smaller than their competitors and a long way from the markets they serve. |
| "There's more cost on labour and more cost on freight because the location is very far from the market," says Riakaina Teiwaki, who's the firm's assistant general manager. | "There's more cost on labour and more cost on freight because the location is very far from the market," says Riakaina Teiwaki, who's the firm's assistant general manager. |
| "This makes the product more expensive." | "This makes the product more expensive." |
| Fish processing plants in the Pacific have a patchy record. But Mr Norris of the Pacific Islands Forum Fisheries Agency is optimistic that there's a future in them. | Fish processing plants in the Pacific have a patchy record. But Mr Norris of the Pacific Islands Forum Fisheries Agency is optimistic that there's a future in them. |
| There have been "a number of failed ventures in the region over the past 30 years." he says. "It's just a matter of learning from mistakes of the past and applying proper scrutiny." | There have been "a number of failed ventures in the region over the past 30 years." he says. "It's just a matter of learning from mistakes of the past and applying proper scrutiny." |
| And Kiribati desperately needs the money. | And Kiribati desperately needs the money. |
| The low-lying atolls that make up this country are among the world's most vulnerable to climate change, and President Tong says this is perhaps the only way for Kiribati to build its resilience. | The low-lying atolls that make up this country are among the world's most vulnerable to climate change, and President Tong says this is perhaps the only way for Kiribati to build its resilience. |