This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-suffolk-34921715
The article has changed 4 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
Version 2 | Version 3 |
---|---|
Former MP Tim Yeo loses Sunday Times cash claim libel bid | Former MP Tim Yeo loses Sunday Times cash claim libel bid |
(35 minutes later) | |
Former Conservative MP Tim Yeo has lost his libel case against The Sunday Times over a "cash for advocacy" claim. | Former Conservative MP Tim Yeo has lost his libel case against The Sunday Times over a "cash for advocacy" claim. |
Tim Yeo, South Suffolk MP from 1983 to 2015, claimed his reputation had been "trashed" by three articles in 2013. | |
The newspaper alleged he breached parliamentary codes of conduct by telling reporters he could promote business concerns in return for cash, the High Court heard. | The newspaper alleged he breached parliamentary codes of conduct by telling reporters he could promote business concerns in return for cash, the High Court heard. |
It suggested Mr Yeo, 70, would approach ministers for a daily fee of £7,000. | It suggested Mr Yeo, 70, would approach ministers for a daily fee of £7,000. |
Representing Mr Yeo at a week-long trial, Desmond Browne QC said his client was quite unjustifiably tarred with the same brush as another MP who had been exposed a week before. | |
But in Wednesday's High Court ruling, Judge Mr Justice Warby said he found some of Mr Yeo's evidence "utterly implausible" and, overall, he did not present "convincingly". | |
Martin Ivens, editor of The Sunday Times, said the decision was "a victory for investigative journalism". | |
He added: "It vindicates the role of the press in exposing the clandestine advocacy by MPs for undisclosed interests." | |
Undercover journalists | |
The articles had stemmed from a lunch Mr Yeo had had with two undercover journalists who posed as representatives of a solar energy concern in the Far East. | The articles had stemmed from a lunch Mr Yeo had had with two undercover journalists who posed as representatives of a solar energy concern in the Far East. |
They alleged that Mr Yeo - then chairman of the Energy and Climate Change Select Committee - was prepared to, and had offered to, act as a paid parliamentary advocate who would push for new laws to benefit the business of a client. | |
They also contained comment to the effect that he had shown willing to abuse his position to further his own financial and business interests. | They also contained comment to the effect that he had shown willing to abuse his position to further his own financial and business interests. |
Tim Yeo's parliamentary career | |
Mr Browne said the Sunday Times acted in numerous respects "with a singular lack of responsibility both at the journalistic and the editorial level". | |
He added: "Mr Yeo was the unfortunate victim of that irresponsibility. | |
"He says that in his last years of service as an MP, his reputation was trashed." | |
'Evidence was untrue' | |
Dismissing the case, Mr Justice Warby said he was unable to accept Mr Yeo's evidence that he was unable to remember an email which mentioned a "generous remuneration package". | |
"I can think of none who convincingly claim to have no interest in money, yet end up with an annual income in excess of £200,000," the judge said. | |
"I do not consider that Mr Yeo is such a person. In my judgment this evidence was untrue. | |
"I am not persuaded that it was honest either." | |
More on this and other Suffolk stories | |
Times Newspapers Ltd said the articles were true, fair comment and responsible journalism on matters of public interest. | Times Newspapers Ltd said the articles were true, fair comment and responsible journalism on matters of public interest. |
Gavin Millar QC, for Times Newspapers, said: "The day after the lunch the claimant, a very experienced parliamentarian, admitted that he had been aware at the meeting that it was being proposed that he undertake lobbying activities which were incompatible with his public office." | Gavin Millar QC, for Times Newspapers, said: "The day after the lunch the claimant, a very experienced parliamentarian, admitted that he had been aware at the meeting that it was being proposed that he undertake lobbying activities which were incompatible with his public office." |
According to the newspaper, Mr Yeo has agreed to pay its legal fees of £411,000. |