This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-35242523
The article has changed 2 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
Previous version
1
Next version
Version 0 | Version 1 |
---|---|
Mein Kampf hits stores in tense Germany | Mein Kampf hits stores in tense Germany |
(about 17 hours later) | |
It's one of the most talked about publications of the year. It's not a new book. And it's not even a well-written book. But Mein Kampf, by Adolf Hitler, which hits German bookshops for the first time in 70 years on Friday, is certainly attracting attention. | It's one of the most talked about publications of the year. It's not a new book. And it's not even a well-written book. But Mein Kampf, by Adolf Hitler, which hits German bookshops for the first time in 70 years on Friday, is certainly attracting attention. |
Hitler's anti-Semitic tirade is seen as the forerunner to the Holocaust. But that is also why historians want it republished. | Hitler's anti-Semitic tirade is seen as the forerunner to the Holocaust. But that is also why historians want it republished. |
Hitler wrote it mostly while in prison in the mid-1920s, and academics say it helps explain the Nazis' crazed ideology when they came to power less than a decade later. | Hitler wrote it mostly while in prison in the mid-1920s, and academics say it helps explain the Nazis' crazed ideology when they came to power less than a decade later. |
As such, they say, it's a crucial academic text. Not pleasant reading, but essential to understanding the Holocaust and Hitler's brutal rule. | As such, they say, it's a crucial academic text. Not pleasant reading, but essential to understanding the Holocaust and Hitler's brutal rule. |
Surprisingly, some Jewish groups have also supported this edition. | Surprisingly, some Jewish groups have also supported this edition. |
This is an annotated, critical version, with thousands of academic notes. | This is an annotated, critical version, with thousands of academic notes. |
And without this republication, the only hard copies available in Germany would be the pre-1945 Nazi editions, still found in second-hand bookshops or online. Those are certainly not critical. | And without this republication, the only hard copies available in Germany would be the pre-1945 Nazi editions, still found in second-hand bookshops or online. Those are certainly not critical. |
The idea is that republishing Mein Kampf will help undermine it. | The idea is that republishing Mein Kampf will help undermine it. |
Until now, the copyright has been in the hands of the Bavarian government. But because 70 years have now passed since the the death of the author - in this case, Adolf Hitler - that copyright has expired. | Until now, the copyright has been in the hands of the Bavarian government. But because 70 years have now passed since the the death of the author - in this case, Adolf Hitler - that copyright has expired. |
Ban counter-productive | Ban counter-productive |
Germany could ban it. After all, the swastika and other Nazi symbols are outlawed here, under incitement-to-violence laws. | Germany could ban it. After all, the swastika and other Nazi symbols are outlawed here, under incitement-to-violence laws. |
Germans see that not as an infringement of free speech, but as a way of guaranteeing it, by not allowing fascist groups to intimidate minorities. | Germans see that not as an infringement of free speech, but as a way of guaranteeing it, by not allowing fascist groups to intimidate minorities. |
But the problem with banning Mein Kampf is that this could simply increase its power. | But the problem with banning Mein Kampf is that this could simply increase its power. |
It would fuel the neo-Nazi propaganda that claims that modern Germany stamps out dissent from far-right groups. | It would fuel the neo-Nazi propaganda that claims that modern Germany stamps out dissent from far-right groups. |
There is also a feeling that outlawing the book would simply add to its mystique. Much better to destroy the myth, is the hope. | There is also a feeling that outlawing the book would simply add to its mystique. Much better to destroy the myth, is the hope. |
Actually reading it, rather than regarding the book as dangerous and seductive, takes away any power from a text that is clearly nothing more than an incoherent and badly written rant. | Actually reading it, rather than regarding the book as dangerous and seductive, takes away any power from a text that is clearly nothing more than an incoherent and badly written rant. |
So, using incitement laws, Germany's authorities have decided to restrict publication: an annotated, academic edition will be allowed - but not other uncritical editions. | So, using incitement laws, Germany's authorities have decided to restrict publication: an annotated, academic edition will be allowed - but not other uncritical editions. |
But Germans are still distinctly uncomfortable with the idea that they might suddenly start seeing the Fuehrer's face adorning shop windows, not to mention the moral issue of making a profit out of an anti-Semitic text written by Hitler. | But Germans are still distinctly uncomfortable with the idea that they might suddenly start seeing the Fuehrer's face adorning shop windows, not to mention the moral issue of making a profit out of an anti-Semitic text written by Hitler. |
That is why some bookshops have said they will not stock the book. And they are certainly not displaying it. | That is why some bookshops have said they will not stock the book. And they are certainly not displaying it. |
The biggest bookshop in Berlin, Dussmann, told us that they have one copy available on shelves in the history section. | The biggest bookshop in Berlin, Dussmann, told us that they have one copy available on shelves in the history section. |
But the store will not advertise it in any way. And more copies will only be available on order. | But the store will not advertise it in any way. And more copies will only be available on order. |
Clearly any short-term business opportunity that might come from the media buzz would be more than undermined by the bad press a bookshop would get if sales were boosted thanks to Hitler. | Clearly any short-term business opportunity that might come from the media buzz would be more than undermined by the bad press a bookshop would get if sales were boosted thanks to Hitler. |
Changing attitudes | Changing attitudes |
But over the past few years, attitudes towards Hitler have changed. | But over the past few years, attitudes towards Hitler have changed. |
I remember the media furore 10 years ago when Swiss-born actor Bruno Ganz played Hitler in the film Downfall. | |
There were nationwide debates about whether audiences would sympathise with Hitler as he met his end in the bunker. | There were nationwide debates about whether audiences would sympathise with Hitler as he met his end in the bunker. |
Last Autumn, it was a comedy about Hitler that went straight to the top of the box office chart. There were the same debates. | Last Autumn, it was a comedy about Hitler that went straight to the top of the box office chart. There were the same debates. |
But this time round, they felt more like debates the media was having with itself, rather than anything people were actually talking about. | But this time round, they felt more like debates the media was having with itself, rather than anything people were actually talking about. |
Possibly, that is because over the past decade there have been plenty of comedies showing Hitler as ridiculous. | Possibly, that is because over the past decade there have been plenty of comedies showing Hitler as ridiculous. |
And for many young Germans, whose grandparents may have been born after Hitler died, the idea that they are guilty seems odd. | And for many young Germans, whose grandparents may have been born after Hitler died, the idea that they are guilty seems odd. |
Mein Kampf: | Mein Kampf: |
But Nazi guilt still very much informs German political culture today - even in the current refugee crisis. | But Nazi guilt still very much informs German political culture today - even in the current refugee crisis. |
After 1945, Germany's constitution was set up as a reaction against Hitler's brutal treatment of political opponents. | After 1945, Germany's constitution was set up as a reaction against Hitler's brutal treatment of political opponents. |
Which is why Article 16a stipulates that anyone fleeing political oppression has a right to asylum in Germany. | Which is why Article 16a stipulates that anyone fleeing political oppression has a right to asylum in Germany. |
Closing the door to refugees, Chancellor Angela Merkel has argued, would mean changing the country's constitution. | Closing the door to refugees, Chancellor Angela Merkel has argued, would mean changing the country's constitution. |
The shadow of the Nazis is also why the current debate over the sexual harassment of more than 100 women in Cologne on New Year's Eve is particularly difficult. | The shadow of the Nazis is also why the current debate over the sexual harassment of more than 100 women in Cologne on New Year's Eve is particularly difficult. |
The attackers appeared to be of Arabic or North African origin. | The attackers appeared to be of Arabic or North African origin. |
For far-right extremists, this is an ideal opportunity to enflame xenophobia using an old Nazi trope: the pure German woman abused by the "foreigner." | For far-right extremists, this is an ideal opportunity to enflame xenophobia using an old Nazi trope: the pure German woman abused by the "foreigner." |
In the 1930s, for Nazis, it was the Jew. Today, for neo-Nazis, that "foreigner" is the Muslim. | In the 1930s, for Nazis, it was the Jew. Today, for neo-Nazis, that "foreigner" is the Muslim. |
Hitler's book may be back in the mainstream. But Germans are determined to make sure that his ideas never are. | Hitler's book may be back in the mainstream. But Germans are determined to make sure that his ideas never are. |
Previous version
1
Next version