This article is from the source 'guardian' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.

You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.theguardian.com/business/2016/jan/14/argos-sales-threaten-home-retail-profits-homebase-sainsburys

The article has changed 5 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.

Version 2 Version 3
Argos sales threaten Home Retail profits Argos sales threaten Home Retail profits
(about 4 hours later)
Home Retail Group’s boss, John Walden, has insisted the company does not need a takeover despite warning that poor sales at its Argos chain would hit profits. The boss of Home Retail Group has insisted the company does not need a takeover despite warning yesterday that poor sales at its Argos chain would hit profits.
The group, which was the target of a £1bn approach from Sainsbury’s, revealed a 2.2% fall in sales at established Argos stores in the 18 weeks to 2 January. Analysts had forecast a 0.3% rise. The group, which is in the sights of Sainsburys and received a £1bn approach from the grocer in November, said like-for-like sales – which exclude gains from new store space – had tumbled 2.2% in the 18 weeks to 2 January. City analysts had forecast a 0.3% rise.
A 10% rise in online sales in December failed to offset a 13% slump at the Argos store chain, as sales of games consoles, large kitchen appliances and jewellery declined. Online sales rose 10% in December – but that wasn’t enough to make up for a 13% slump at the High street store chain. Sales of games consoles, large kitchen appliances and jewellery were all down.
Related: Thousands of Argos jobs at risk if Sainsbury's deal is struckRelated: Thousands of Argos jobs at risk if Sainsbury's deal is struck
Profit margins also fell by more than 2 percentage points, with Argos selling more items at a discount as a result of the rising popularity of the Black Friday promotional period. Profit margins were also down – by more than 2 percentage points – with Argos selling more items at a discount as a result of Black Friday.
The group’s DIY chain Homebase, which is to be sold to Australia’s Wesfarmers for £340m in a deal announced late on Wednesday, reported a 5% rise in sales at established stores, bolstered by purchases of kitchen and bathroom products. As a result, Home Retail said profits for the group would now be about £92m, about 10% below the average forecast.
Home Retail said profits for the group would now be about £92m, the lowest end of analysts’ expectations and about 10% below the average forecast. Walden also made clear that Argos had seen the strongest performance at its concessions, most of which are in Homebase stores, and that these may be closed within 18 months under the terms of the deal with Wesfarmers. The warning is the second downgrade for Home Retail in less than three months. The company said in October that it was not sure if its investment in delivery vans and advertising ahead of Black Fridaywould pay off.
Despite the poor performance, Walden insisted Argos was a “strong business”. He added: “The capabilities we are building are going to play into the digital future. We are not feeling we would be a weaker business [if Homebase is sold] but a stronger business with an improved balance sheet.” The group’s DIY chain Homebase, which is to be sold to Australia’s Wesfarmers for £340m in a deal announced late on Wednesday, reported a 5% rise in sales at established stores, bolstered by purchases of kitchen and bathroom goods.
He said the sale of Homebase would give the group cash to invest in updating Argos’ stores and delivery systems. “We don’t need a tie-up,” he said. “We feel we good about what we are building and know what we are becoming is of value.” Chief executive John Walden said that despite the poor performance, Argos was a “strong business”.
“The capabilities we are building are going to play into the digital future. We are not feeling we would be a weaker business [if Homebase is sold] but a stronger business with an improved balance sheet,” he said.
The American said the sale of Homebase would give the group cash to invest in updating Argos’ stores and delivery systems. “We don’t need a tie-up,” he said. “We feel good about what we are building and know what we are becoming is of value.”
He said Argos had proved that the idea of concessions in other stores worked and that it would be able to find alternative partners if Homebase, or Sainsbury’s, pushed it out.He said Argos had proved that the idea of concessions in other stores worked and that it would be able to find alternative partners if Homebase, or Sainsbury’s, pushed it out.
Walden added that Argos had outperformed rivals in the markets it traded in and insisted its systems had coped well with a huge surge in sales on Black Friday – when sales were up 41% on last year. Tony Shiret, an analyst at Haitong Research, said the rationale for Sainsbury’s buying Argos “should theoretically have been damaged by the trading results”. He suggested that the supermarket’s shareholders would want a low price to compensate for the risk of a deal.
But Tony Shiret, an analyst at Haitong Research, said the longer-term economic rationale for the Sainsbury’s buy-out of Argos “should theoretically have been damaged by the trading results” and that the supermarket’s shareholders were likely to want to pay a low price to compensate for the risk of a deal. David Jeary, an analyst at Canaccord Genuity, said: “We believe today’s trading update [from Home Retail] makes a bid from Sainsbury’s less rather than more likely.”
Sainsbury’s management team made clear on Wednesday that they would not overpay for Home Retail and Jeary said any share-based offer from the supermarket may not be attractive as it would expose the Argos-owner’s investors to the highly competitive grocery market.
“For Home Retail shareholders its a choice between the devil you know or the deep blue sea,” Jeary said.
Sainsbury’s has until 2 February to return with a new bid for Home Retail but has made clear it is only interested in the Argos chain.Sainsbury’s has until 2 February to return with a new bid for Home Retail but has made clear it is only interested in the Argos chain.
The likelihood of the company making a new offer had appeared to increase on Wednesday night when Home Retail announced it was in advanced talks on the sale of Homebase to Wesfarmers. Analysts said it was difficult to assess the potential effect of the sale of Homebase on the price Sainsbury’s might have to pay to win over Home Retail shareholders.
The supermarket is expected to have to pay at least 160p a share, or £1.3bn, while some shareholders have indicated they would not accept less than 200p.
The sale of Homebase makes Home Retail potentially more attractive, as Sainsbury’s has made clear it is not interested in the DIY chain and the sale of the chain’s leases would help reduce the group’s net debt from £1.5bn to just £13m.
But the probable loss of Homebase also reduces the prospects for profits at Argos by as much as £20m because of the likely closure of nearly 100 concessions within Homebase stores and it would eventually have sole responsibility for head office and operational costs that were shared between the two businesses.
Shiret said the most important aspect of Argos for Sainsbury’s would be the potential value of the cost savings it could realise through the merger.