This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-wales-politics-35443832
The article has changed 2 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
Previous version
1
Next version
Version 0 | Version 1 |
---|---|
Warning draft Wales devolution bill 'problematic' | Warning draft Wales devolution bill 'problematic' |
(about 11 hours later) | |
Plans to give the Welsh government extra powers are "problematic", open to legal challenge, and will cause even greater uncertainty in Cardiff Bay, a constitutional expert has warned. | Plans to give the Welsh government extra powers are "problematic", open to legal challenge, and will cause even greater uncertainty in Cardiff Bay, a constitutional expert has warned. |
The draft Wales Bill offers more say over energy, transport and elections. | The draft Wales Bill offers more say over energy, transport and elections. |
But Prof Richard Wyn Jones of Cardiff University said there were still uncertainties which could lead to court battles between Wales and Westminster. | But Prof Richard Wyn Jones of Cardiff University said there were still uncertainties which could lead to court battles between Wales and Westminster. |
He warned against "legislating in haste" for another failed settlement. | He warned against "legislating in haste" for another failed settlement. |
Prof Jones is one of the authors of a report assessing the UK government's devolution plans, to be published by Cardiff University and University College London on Monday. | Prof Jones is one of the authors of a report assessing the UK government's devolution plans, to be published by Cardiff University and University College London on Monday. |
In 2015, the same team warned proposals for a so-called "reserved powers" model of devolution for Wales were unlikely to be workable. | In 2015, the same team warned proposals for a so-called "reserved powers" model of devolution for Wales were unlikely to be workable. |
Reserved powers is a change in approach to devolution, by which responsibility is assumed to be devolved in all matters except those specified as staying at Westminster. | Reserved powers is a change in approach to devolution, by which responsibility is assumed to be devolved in all matters except those specified as staying at Westminster. |
There have been complaints the list of powers kept back by the UK government is too long, but Welsh Secretary Stephen Crabb has already said he is open to changes. | There have been complaints the list of powers kept back by the UK government is too long, but Welsh Secretary Stephen Crabb has already said he is open to changes. |
Speaking to BBC Radio Wales' Sunday Supplement programme, Prof Jones said there were "some really big changes from the White Paper to the draft legislation". | Speaking to BBC Radio Wales' Sunday Supplement programme, Prof Jones said there were "some really big changes from the White Paper to the draft legislation". |
"We think that these add to the problems and further undermine the aims associated with the reserved powers model which is to make things clearer, more robust and more stable. | "We think that these add to the problems and further undermine the aims associated with the reserved powers model which is to make things clearer, more robust and more stable. |
"It creates lots of uncertainty and arguably lots of scope for Supreme Court challenges - we've had three of those of course since 2011. | "It creates lots of uncertainty and arguably lots of scope for Supreme Court challenges - we've had three of those of course since 2011. |
Prof Jones said Wales "craved stability" but claimed the draft bill failed to deliver it. | Prof Jones said Wales "craved stability" but claimed the draft bill failed to deliver it. |
"It would actually be good not to talk about the constitution for a few years but that's not going to happen if there's real uncertainty about the powers of the assembly. | "It would actually be good not to talk about the constitution for a few years but that's not going to happen if there's real uncertainty about the powers of the assembly. |
"The idea of legislating in haste to establish another dispensation which we know will also fail seems like a waste of everybody's time." | "The idea of legislating in haste to establish another dispensation which we know will also fail seems like a waste of everybody's time." |
Welsh Conservatives leader Andrew RT Davies said: "This is our opportunity to get devolution right and takes us towards a lasting settlement." |
Previous version
1
Next version