This article is from the source 'guardian' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/live/2016/feb/09/labor-maintains-pressure-over-stuart-roberts-china-trip-politics-live
The article has changed 18 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 1 | Version 2 |
|---|---|
| Labor maintains pressure over Stuart Robert's China trip – politics live | Labor maintains pressure over Stuart Robert's China trip – politics live |
| (35 minutes later) | |
| 10.13pm GMT | |
| 22:13 | |
| Senate estimates are underway now. The Human Rights Commission is up early. As my colleague Shalailah Medhora reports, a new sex discrimination commissioner is on the way. | |
| Attorney general says sex discrimination commissioner will be announced this week, filling vacancy left by @LizBroderick in Sept #estimates | |
| Cabinet confirmed decision of who will become the next sex discrimination commissioner yesterday, Brandis said #estimates | |
| Updated | |
| at 10.14pm GMT | |
| 10.06pm GMT | |
| 22:06 | |
| Having given you a taste of Paul’s thoughts, I’ll just add one (considerably less than perfectly formed thought) about Turnbull and Indigenous affairs. It is inevitable that Turnbull’s approach will be compared to and contrasted with his predecessor, Tony Abbott. | |
| Readers will remember Abbott prided himself on putting Indigenous affairs at the heart of decision making (leaving aside, briefly, the millions of dollars he cut from programs in that process). While his efforts may have looked meagre to many people spectating from the sidelines, the focus nonetheless caused Abbott grief internally, with conservatives both within the Coalition and with commentators like Andrew Bolt. The teensy tiny hedged activism cost him something. | |
| If we project that thought to Turnbull, who of course has his own trouble with conservatives on a range of fronts, you can start to see the some of the delicacy for Turnbull associated with defining his own terms of engagement. | |
| Updated | |
| at 10.08pm GMT | |
| 9.54pm GMT | |
| 21:54 | |
| Good morning Mike Bowers, who is down at the reconciliation event. | |
| Paul Daley has written a typically terrific piece this morning about closing the gap. Given several prominent Indigenous leaders are out and about this morning calling on Malcolm Turnbull to define the terms of his relationship with Indigenous people – a couple of interesting observations from Paul here. | |
| Malcolm Turnbull, who has shown no sign that the shameful crisis in Indigenous wellbeing is a priority for his government (tick tax reform, tick border control and immigration, but what about the blackfellas?) has, however, done two things right during his brief tenure. | |
| The first was that he did not succumb to pressure to reappoint Mal - Mr Intervention – Brough to the Indigenous Affairs portfolio. Brough, possessed of the paternalism of the old mission manager and the unquestioning strong arm of the bullying drill sergeant, was loathed during the Howard government era by all but a few select Indigenous leaders as an arrogant and destructive blow-hard who used the portfolio for little but furtherance of his deluded leadership ambitions. | |
| Turnbull stuck with journeyman Nigel Scullion instead. | |
| Turnbull’s second, small positive initiative, was to make his first low-key formal contact with an Aboriginal community at La Perouse in Sydney, rather than through a PR-driven Abbott era carnival-style sweep through a “real” remote community in northern Australia trailed by a largely unquestioning, ill-informed, media pack. This reflected the (encouraging) realisation of Turnbull – or that of someone in his office – that three-quarters of first Australians do not live in the bush, and that the developing world-poverty, appalling life expectancies and other associated Closing the Gap indicators of Indigenous Australians that can be linked back to invasion in 1788 and dispossession, are right under the noses of non-Indigenous city people. | |
| That’s it for Turnbull so far. So let’s watch his response to the latest appalling indicators on Wednesday to see if he offers a response beyond the algorithmic, beyond the bipartisan smokescreen that might assuage non-Indigenous guilt and reassure a horrified global community that the Australian commonwealth is at least vigilant when it comes to the appalling plight of its indigenes. | |
| You can read Paul’s column here. | |
| 9.41pm GMT | 9.41pm GMT |
| 21:41 | 21:41 |
| The shadow attorney-general Mark Dreyfus has surfaced now in the Sky News studios. He’s asked whether it is possible that the Chinese officials just misinterpreted Stuart Robert’s appearance at a contract signing. | The shadow attorney-general Mark Dreyfus has surfaced now in the Sky News studios. He’s asked whether it is possible that the Chinese officials just misinterpreted Stuart Robert’s appearance at a contract signing. |
| Dreyfus doesn’t think so. | Dreyfus doesn’t think so. |
| He (Robert) has misused his public office. I think that is absolutely clear. I don’t accept for a moment he went in a private capacity. The only proper approach was not to be there at all. | He (Robert) has misused his public office. I think that is absolutely clear. I don’t accept for a moment he went in a private capacity. The only proper approach was not to be there at all. |
| Q: Does it warrant sacking? | Q: Does it warrant sacking? |
| It’s a clear breach of ministerial standards. Mr Turnbull needs to show some leadership. | It’s a clear breach of ministerial standards. Mr Turnbull needs to show some leadership. |
| Q: You are stopping short then of calling for him to be sacked? | Q: You are stopping short then of calling for him to be sacked? |
| It’s the clearest possible breach of ministerial standards. We need a full [explanatory] statement [of the conduct] and that’s what should happen today. | It’s the clearest possible breach of ministerial standards. We need a full [explanatory] statement [of the conduct] and that’s what should happen today. |
| 9.33pm GMT | 9.33pm GMT |
| 21:33 | 21:33 |
| As far as I am aware, Robert has made no public statements since the story of his 2014 travels surfaced yesterday in the Herald Sun, but a copy of his letter to the prime minister yesterday has been circulated. I’ll transcribe it here so you are across the contents. | As far as I am aware, Robert has made no public statements since the story of his 2014 travels surfaced yesterday in the Herald Sun, but a copy of his letter to the prime minister yesterday has been circulated. I’ll transcribe it here so you are across the contents. |
| Dear Malcolm, | Dear Malcolm, |
| As you are aware certain questions have arisen publicly regarding a visit I undertook overseas in a personal capacity in 2014. I am confident that I have not acted inappropriately but I am cognisant of the high standards expected of all ministers and I write to ask you to seek advice from the secretary of the department of prime minister and cabinet on these matters. I will, of course, fully assist the secretary. | As you are aware certain questions have arisen publicly regarding a visit I undertook overseas in a personal capacity in 2014. I am confident that I have not acted inappropriately but I am cognisant of the high standards expected of all ministers and I write to ask you to seek advice from the secretary of the department of prime minister and cabinet on these matters. I will, of course, fully assist the secretary. |
| Yours sincerely, | Yours sincerely, |
| Stuart Robert | Stuart Robert |
| 9.27pm GMT | 9.27pm GMT |
| 21:27 | 21:27 |
| Daniel Hurst | Daniel Hurst |
| Morning, just a quick overnight report on Stuart Robert. In Senate estimates some senators sought to find out how the Department of the Prime Minister and Cabinet would handle the investigation into the possible breach of ministerial standards. | Morning, just a quick overnight report on Stuart Robert. In Senate estimates some senators sought to find out how the Department of the Prime Minister and Cabinet would handle the investigation into the possible breach of ministerial standards. |
| Alas, most of the questions went unanswered on the basis the prime minister had only just put in the request that afternoon. Labor’s deputy Senate leader, Stephen Conroy, wanted to know if Robert would be interviewed personally and whether the full transcript of his controversial speech at the mining celebration in Beijing would be released publicly. The PM&C deputy secretary, Elizabeth Kelly, told the committee she was yet to talk to the newly appointed secretary, Martin Parkinson, about the way in which he wanted to proceed: “I don’t think there is a usual process. The secretary’s advice is sought, the secretary then determines the appropriate way to inform himself.” | Alas, most of the questions went unanswered on the basis the prime minister had only just put in the request that afternoon. Labor’s deputy Senate leader, Stephen Conroy, wanted to know if Robert would be interviewed personally and whether the full transcript of his controversial speech at the mining celebration in Beijing would be released publicly. The PM&C deputy secretary, Elizabeth Kelly, told the committee she was yet to talk to the newly appointed secretary, Martin Parkinson, about the way in which he wanted to proceed: “I don’t think there is a usual process. The secretary’s advice is sought, the secretary then determines the appropriate way to inform himself.” |
| Kelly confirmed Robert’s request for personal leave from 15 to 22 August 2014 had been approved by the former prime minister, Tony Abbott. (The mining event that he said he attended in a “private capacity” occurred on 18 August 2014.) As for the claim that Robert bestowed a medal on behalf of the prime minister, Kelly said she was unaware of the existence of such a medal: “I’m not familiar with such a thing.” | Kelly confirmed Robert’s request for personal leave from 15 to 22 August 2014 had been approved by the former prime minister, Tony Abbott. (The mining event that he said he attended in a “private capacity” occurred on 18 August 2014.) As for the claim that Robert bestowed a medal on behalf of the prime minister, Kelly said she was unaware of the existence of such a medal: “I’m not familiar with such a thing.” |
| 9.22pm GMT | 9.22pm GMT |
| 21:22 | 21:22 |
| I’ll come back to some necessary bits and pieces about Stuart Robert but first, an update on the other major themes of this morning. | I’ll come back to some necessary bits and pieces about Stuart Robert but first, an update on the other major themes of this morning. |
| My neighbour, the West Australian’s political editor, Andrew Probyn, helpfully reminds us about a privatisation proposal we’d all almost forgotten about: a proposal that Medicare, pharmaceutical and aged-care benefits be delivered in the future by the private sector. (From memory, this idea first appeared in Tony Abbott’s commission of audit report.) | My neighbour, the West Australian’s political editor, Andrew Probyn, helpfully reminds us about a privatisation proposal we’d all almost forgotten about: a proposal that Medicare, pharmaceutical and aged-care benefits be delivered in the future by the private sector. (From memory, this idea first appeared in Tony Abbott’s commission of audit report.) |
| Andrew reports this morning “that planning for the ambitious but politically risky outsourcing of government payments is well-advanced, with a view to making it a key feature of treasurer Scott Morrison’s first budget in May.” | Andrew reports this morning “that planning for the ambitious but politically risky outsourcing of government payments is well-advanced, with a view to making it a key feature of treasurer Scott Morrison’s first budget in May.” |
| Shorten’s nostrils flared happily at the mere mention of the word Medicare this morning. He’s declared if the prime minister wants to have an election on Medicare, then B-I-O-B. (Bring it on, baby.) | Shorten’s nostrils flared happily at the mere mention of the word Medicare this morning. He’s declared if the prime minister wants to have an election on Medicare, then B-I-O-B. (Bring it on, baby.) |
| With the “closing the gap” statement to parliament due this week, my colleague Bridie Jabour has a curtain raiser. | With the “closing the gap” statement to parliament due this week, my colleague Bridie Jabour has a curtain raiser. |
| The latest State of Reconciliation in Australia report finds that thirty per cent of the general Australian community socialise with Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people, and while support for reconciliation is increasing, the government needs a more focused policy approach. While government intentions for Indigenous Australians were sound, there was only a “piecemeal” approach in policy. | The latest State of Reconciliation in Australia report finds that thirty per cent of the general Australian community socialise with Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people, and while support for reconciliation is increasing, the government needs a more focused policy approach. While government intentions for Indigenous Australians were sound, there was only a “piecemeal” approach in policy. |
| There is a breakfast on this morning in the parliament to mark the release of this report. Indigenous leaders have already hit the airwaves to call on the new prime minister to engage on Indigenous affairs. | There is a breakfast on this morning in the parliament to mark the release of this report. Indigenous leaders have already hit the airwaves to call on the new prime minister to engage on Indigenous affairs. |
| 9.02pm GMT | 9.02pm GMT |
| 21:02 | 21:02 |
| Good morning good people and welcome to Tuesday. | Good morning good people and welcome to Tuesday. |
| The prime minister has barely had time to clear the rowing machine and mop his brow before Labor is unloading on every open microphone about Turnbull’s (insert your adjective of choice) human services minister, Stuart Robert. | The prime minister has barely had time to clear the rowing machine and mop his brow before Labor is unloading on every open microphone about Turnbull’s (insert your adjective of choice) human services minister, Stuart Robert. |
| Readers with me yesterday will know Robert is in the soup courtesy of a trip he took to China with a mining mate and generous donor to the Liberal party in order to witness a commercial agreement. The prime minister has asked his departmental head to report to him about whether the trip constitutes a breach of the ministerial code, which forbids ministers acting as “a consultant or adviser to any company, business, or other interests, whether paid or unpaid, or provide assistance to any such body, except as may be appropriate in their official capacity as minister.” | Readers with me yesterday will know Robert is in the soup courtesy of a trip he took to China with a mining mate and generous donor to the Liberal party in order to witness a commercial agreement. The prime minister has asked his departmental head to report to him about whether the trip constitutes a breach of the ministerial code, which forbids ministers acting as “a consultant or adviser to any company, business, or other interests, whether paid or unpaid, or provide assistance to any such body, except as may be appropriate in their official capacity as minister.” |
| As we launch this morning Bill Shorten is on Radio National and the shadow attorney general, Mark Dreyfus, is down at the House doors declaring Robert has questions to answer. Adding to the story, the Australian Financial Review is also reporting this morning the minister “met with a senior Chinese minister to discuss Chinese investment in Australia” while on the trip, which Robert has thus far characterised as a self-funded private holiday. | As we launch this morning Bill Shorten is on Radio National and the shadow attorney general, Mark Dreyfus, is down at the House doors declaring Robert has questions to answer. Adding to the story, the Australian Financial Review is also reporting this morning the minister “met with a senior Chinese minister to discuss Chinese investment in Australia” while on the trip, which Robert has thus far characterised as a self-funded private holiday. |
| Shorten spoke to reporters before entering the ABC studios, noting “the Stuart Robert scandal is going to become a test of Malcolm Turnbull” – before adding that the prime minister “has lost more ministers than he’s released tax policies.” (You see what he did there, right?) | Shorten spoke to reporters before entering the ABC studios, noting “the Stuart Robert scandal is going to become a test of Malcolm Turnbull” – before adding that the prime minister “has lost more ministers than he’s released tax policies.” (You see what he did there, right?) |
| Once seated in the ABC studio, Shorten noted to his host Fran Kelly “the signs aren’t promising for one of Malcolm Turnbull’s ministers. There’s a lot of explanation required. The opposition is not satisfied that we know all the facts and we will not rest until we do.” | Once seated in the ABC studio, Shorten noted to his host Fran Kelly “the signs aren’t promising for one of Malcolm Turnbull’s ministers. There’s a lot of explanation required. The opposition is not satisfied that we know all the facts and we will not rest until we do.” |
| That gives you an opening picture for the day. Let’s sail forth into this bracing headwind and the million other things I’ve not yet told you about. You can sail forth in the thread, which is now open for your jolly business. You can also reach the Marvellous Mikearoo and I on the twits. He’s @mpbowers and @murpharoo | That gives you an opening picture for the day. Let’s sail forth into this bracing headwind and the million other things I’ve not yet told you about. You can sail forth in the thread, which is now open for your jolly business. You can also reach the Marvellous Mikearoo and I on the twits. He’s @mpbowers and @murpharoo |
| Pop on your life jackets. Here comes Tuesday. | Pop on your life jackets. Here comes Tuesday. |
| Updated | Updated |
| at 9.29pm GMT | at 9.29pm GMT |