This article is from the source 'guardian' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.theguardian.com/world/2016/mar/24/brazil-president-dilma-rousseff-defiant-resignation-interview
The article has changed 11 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 5 | Version 6 |
|---|---|
| Dilma Rousseff defiant amid calls for resignation over corruption scandal | Dilma Rousseff defiant amid calls for resignation over corruption scandal |
| (about 13 hours later) | |
| A defiant Dilma Rousseff has insisted that there is no legal justification for her impeachment and warned that any attempt to remove her from power illegally would leave lasting scars on Brazilian democracy. | A defiant Dilma Rousseff has insisted that there is no legal justification for her impeachment and warned that any attempt to remove her from power illegally would leave lasting scars on Brazilian democracy. |
| In a 90-minute interview with six foreign media organizations in Planalto, the presidential palace, Rousseff stated that “peace would reign” in Brazil by the start of this year’s Olympic Games, due to take place in Rio de Janeiro in August. | In a 90-minute interview with six foreign media organizations in Planalto, the presidential palace, Rousseff stated that “peace would reign” in Brazil by the start of this year’s Olympic Games, due to take place in Rio de Janeiro in August. |
| Thousands of Brazilians later took to the streets in Sao Paulo in support of the embattled president. They followed huge anti-government protests that have shaken the country in recent weeks as revelations over the country’s worst-ever corruption scandal add momentum to an impeachment process that began in December. | Thousands of Brazilians later took to the streets in Sao Paulo in support of the embattled president. They followed huge anti-government protests that have shaken the country in recent weeks as revelations over the country’s worst-ever corruption scandal add momentum to an impeachment process that began in December. |
| The president’s attempt to appoint her predecessor, Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva, to cabinet last week – in what critics argue is a move to shield him from prosecution – added to widespread public outrage at politicians’ impunity and prompted calls for Rousseff’s resignation. | The president’s attempt to appoint her predecessor, Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva, to cabinet last week – in what critics argue is a move to shield him from prosecution – added to widespread public outrage at politicians’ impunity and prompted calls for Rousseff’s resignation. |
| “Why do they want me to resign? Because I am a weak woman? I’m not,” she said, arguing that her political rivals wanted her to stand down “to avoid the difficulty of removing – unduly, illegally and criminally – a legitimately elected president from power”. | “Why do they want me to resign? Because I am a weak woman? I’m not,” she said, arguing that her political rivals wanted her to stand down “to avoid the difficulty of removing – unduly, illegally and criminally – a legitimately elected president from power”. |
| Pushed as to why it was necessary for Lula to become a minister, rather than serve as an adviser, Rousseff said he had repeatedly turned down her requests to join her government, but now that the crisis had deepened he was doing it as a service for Brazil. | Pushed as to why it was necessary for Lula to become a minister, rather than serve as an adviser, Rousseff said he had repeatedly turned down her requests to join her government, but now that the crisis had deepened he was doing it as a service for Brazil. |
| “I became his cabinet chief in 2005 in the middle of the mensalão [cash-for-votes scandal],” she said. “I know I helped him then, and I know he can help me now.” | “I became his cabinet chief in 2005 in the middle of the mensalão [cash-for-votes scandal],” she said. “I know I helped him then, and I know he can help me now.” |
| The impeachment process currently in congress accuses Rousseff of using illegal accounting manoeuvres to balance her government’s books, but she insists that the legal basis for the accusation is extremely weak. | The impeachment process currently in congress accuses Rousseff of using illegal accounting manoeuvres to balance her government’s books, but she insists that the legal basis for the accusation is extremely weak. |
| Rousseff has proved herself a fighter. As a leftwing guerrilla during the dictatorship era, she was imprisoned and reportedly tortured. | Rousseff has proved herself a fighter. As a leftwing guerrilla during the dictatorship era, she was imprisoned and reportedly tortured. |
| Rousseff noted that every president since the time of Getúlio Vargas (who ruled from 1930 to 1945) have had impeachment processes launched against them. She also noted that the man who initiated the case against her, Eduardo Cunha, the speaker of the lower house of congress, has been charged with corruption. | Rousseff noted that every president since the time of Getúlio Vargas (who ruled from 1930 to 1945) have had impeachment processes launched against them. She also noted that the man who initiated the case against her, Eduardo Cunha, the speaker of the lower house of congress, has been charged with corruption. |
| In the president’s opinion, the opposition failed to accept their narrow defeat in the 2014 election and since then have pursued a strategy of “the worse, the better”, by sabotaging her legislative agenda and sinking the country. | In the president’s opinion, the opposition failed to accept their narrow defeat in the 2014 election and since then have pursued a strategy of “the worse, the better”, by sabotaging her legislative agenda and sinking the country. |
| As for the demonstrations, Rousseff stressed that she was in favour of street protests, because she came from “a generation in which if you opened your mouth you could go to jail”. | As for the demonstrations, Rousseff stressed that she was in favour of street protests, because she came from “a generation in which if you opened your mouth you could go to jail”. |
| But she pointed out that those who have taken to the streets against her government represent less than 2% of Brazil’s entire population, and criticised the “fascist methods” used by some of her opponents. | But she pointed out that those who have taken to the streets against her government represent less than 2% of Brazil’s entire population, and criticised the “fascist methods” used by some of her opponents. |
| “We have never seen such intolerance in Brazil,” she said. “We are not an intolerant people.” | “We have never seen such intolerance in Brazil,” she said. “We are not an intolerant people.” |
| Related: Brazil’s judiciary is in danger of turning the clock back on democracy | Eliane Brum | Related: Brazil’s judiciary is in danger of turning the clock back on democracy | Eliane Brum |
| The past month has been one of the worst in a spectacularly rough second term for the president, who was re-elected in 2014 in one of the closest campaigns in Brazil’s political history. | The past month has been one of the worst in a spectacularly rough second term for the president, who was re-elected in 2014 in one of the closest campaigns in Brazil’s political history. |
| Despite a clear mandate, she has had to deal with a hostile congress, an unreliable coalition partner and a corruption investigation that has moved ever closer to the highest level of her Workers Party. | Despite a clear mandate, she has had to deal with a hostile congress, an unreliable coalition partner and a corruption investigation that has moved ever closer to the highest level of her Workers Party. |
| Rousseff believes that any attempt to remove her from power without legal justification would represent a “coup”. | Rousseff believes that any attempt to remove her from power without legal justification would represent a “coup”. |
| “I am not comparing the coup here to the military coups of the past, but it would be a breaking of the democratic order of Brazil.” | “I am not comparing the coup here to the military coups of the past, but it would be a breaking of the democratic order of Brazil.” |
| Such a move, she said, “will have consequences. Maybe not immediately, but it will leave a deep scar on Brazilians’ political life.” | Such a move, she said, “will have consequences. Maybe not immediately, but it will leave a deep scar on Brazilians’ political life.” |
| For more than a year, there has been a steady drip drip of grim news for Rousseff: the economy is in the midst of its biggest decline in a century, ratings agencies have downgraded Brazil’s sovereign debt to junk status and unemployment is rising. | For more than a year, there has been a steady drip drip of grim news for Rousseff: the economy is in the midst of its biggest decline in a century, ratings agencies have downgraded Brazil’s sovereign debt to junk status and unemployment is rising. |
| Meanwhile, the president’s popularity has crashed, the finance minister resigned, and the corruption scandal has paralysed Petrobras – the biggest company in the country – and led to the jailing of the head of the leading construction firm, Odebrecht. | Meanwhile, the president’s popularity has crashed, the finance minister resigned, and the corruption scandal has paralysed Petrobras – the biggest company in the country – and led to the jailing of the head of the leading construction firm, Odebrecht. |
| Personally and politically, however, the biggest crisis for Dilma has been that sparked by a prosecution investigation into alleged wrongdoing by her predecessor and mentor, Da Silva. | Personally and politically, however, the biggest crisis for Dilma has been that sparked by a prosecution investigation into alleged wrongdoing by her predecessor and mentor, Da Silva. |
| The former president – universally known as Lula – was detained for questioning and his home and other properties searched earlier this month. Soon after, Rousseff invited him into her cabinet, thereby taking jurisdiction away from the lower court judges who had approved the warrants for the search and interrogation. | The former president – universally known as Lula – was detained for questioning and his home and other properties searched earlier this month. Soon after, Rousseff invited him into her cabinet, thereby taking jurisdiction away from the lower court judges who had approved the warrants for the search and interrogation. |
| Asked by the Guardian about her decision to appoint Lula, a move that is currently suspended awaiting a final supreme court decision, Rousseff was unrepentant. | Asked by the Guardian about her decision to appoint Lula, a move that is currently suspended awaiting a final supreme court decision, Rousseff was unrepentant. |
| “Lula is not just a talented negotiator, he also understands all of Brazil’s problems,” she said, insisting that the idea that he has been appointed to avoid scrutiny did not make sense. | “Lula is not just a talented negotiator, he also understands all of Brazil’s problems,” she said, insisting that the idea that he has been appointed to avoid scrutiny did not make sense. |
| “A cabinet minister is not immune from investigation, he faces investigation by the supreme court,” she said. “Is the supreme court not good enough to investigate Lula?” | “A cabinet minister is not immune from investigation, he faces investigation by the supreme court,” she said. “Is the supreme court not good enough to investigate Lula?” |
| Last week, Sergio Moro, the lead judge in Operation Lava-jato, a two-year investigation into corruption at the state-run oil company, Petrobras, released secretly recorded phone calls made by Lula. | Last week, Sergio Moro, the lead judge in Operation Lava-jato, a two-year investigation into corruption at the state-run oil company, Petrobras, released secretly recorded phone calls made by Lula. |
| They included a conversation with Dilma in which she told him she has an instrument of investiture ready for him “in case it is necessary”. Although ambiguous, this was interpreted by her opponents (and some supporters) as proof that the two were colluding to help the former president avoid prosecution. | They included a conversation with Dilma in which she told him she has an instrument of investiture ready for him “in case it is necessary”. Although ambiguous, this was interpreted by her opponents (and some supporters) as proof that the two were colluding to help the former president avoid prosecution. |
| Calm and seemingly upbeat throughout the interview, the only time Rousseff expressed irritation was when she recalled Moro’s leak of the phone tap. | Calm and seemingly upbeat throughout the interview, the only time Rousseff expressed irritation was when she recalled Moro’s leak of the phone tap. |
| “Violating privacy breaks democracy because it breaks the right of every citizen to a private life,” she said, banging the table. | “Violating privacy breaks democracy because it breaks the right of every citizen to a private life,” she said, banging the table. |
| Accepting that she had been recorded by accident, Rousseff argued that the correct action for the judge to have done would have been to pass the tape to the supreme court, not the media. | Accepting that she had been recorded by accident, Rousseff argued that the correct action for the judge to have done would have been to pass the tape to the supreme court, not the media. |
| In a veiled criticism of Moro, the president said, “a judge must be impartial. A judge cannot rule with political passions.” | In a veiled criticism of Moro, the president said, “a judge must be impartial. A judge cannot rule with political passions.” |
| Despite having been on the board of Petrobras and a minister of mines and energy, Rousseff has consistently denied knowing anything about the massive corruption scheme that took place at the company. | Despite having been on the board of Petrobras and a minister of mines and energy, Rousseff has consistently denied knowing anything about the massive corruption scheme that took place at the company. |
| During the interview she insisted that there was a big difference between a company’s board of directors and its executives, adding that none of her fellow directors had known about the corruption. She also pointed out the anti-corruption measures that she had instigated during her government, including the law which allows suspects to offer plea-bargain testimony, a development which has significantly facilitated investigators. | During the interview she insisted that there was a big difference between a company’s board of directors and its executives, adding that none of her fellow directors had known about the corruption. She also pointed out the anti-corruption measures that she had instigated during her government, including the law which allows suspects to offer plea-bargain testimony, a development which has significantly facilitated investigators. |
| As well as the impeachment process, Rousseff also faces investigation by Brazil’s supreme electoral court over allegations that her 2014 election campaign received financing from the Petrobras scandal. | As well as the impeachment process, Rousseff also faces investigation by Brazil’s supreme electoral court over allegations that her 2014 election campaign received financing from the Petrobras scandal. |
| But the president categorically denied that her campaign benefited from any illegal donations and said she was not worried about the contents of the plea-bargaining testimony of her election guru, João Santana. | But the president categorically denied that her campaign benefited from any illegal donations and said she was not worried about the contents of the plea-bargaining testimony of her election guru, João Santana. |
| The president said that she was sleeping well and insisted that Brazil’s current political crisis was not getting her down. | The president said that she was sleeping well and insisted that Brazil’s current political crisis was not getting her down. |
| “I think you only get depressed when you feel guilty about something,” she said. “I have never used my powers to favour people whom I shouldn’t have favoured.” |