This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It will not be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://news.bbc.co.uk/go/rss/-/1/hi/england/tees/7330303.stm
The article has changed 5 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 3 | Version 4 |
|---|---|
| Man cleared in suicide rape case | Man cleared in suicide rape case |
| (10 minutes later) | |
| A man accused of raping a woman who later killed herself on a beach has had the case against him dropped. | A man accused of raping a woman who later killed herself on a beach has had the case against him dropped. |
| Kim Corner, 34, of Billingham, Teesside, was found dead with a bottle of vodka and tablets at Seaton Carew. | Kim Corner, 34, of Billingham, Teesside, was found dead with a bottle of vodka and tablets at Seaton Carew. |
| Michael Nicholson, 39, from Berkley Court, Billingham, was formally cleared of rape at Teesside Crown Court on Friday after no evidence was submitted. | Michael Nicholson, 39, from Berkley Court, Billingham, was formally cleared of rape at Teesside Crown Court on Friday after no evidence was submitted. |
| Police had considered a manslaughter charge to try to prove the alleged sex attack led Ms Corner to take her life. | Police had considered a manslaughter charge to try to prove the alleged sex attack led Ms Corner to take her life. |
| As he left court, Mr Nicholson said: "I've been through hell. I don't want to say any more right now." | As he left court, Mr Nicholson said: "I've been through hell. I don't want to say any more right now." |
| Ms Corner's body was discovered on the beach at Seaton Carew, near Hartlepool, close to the water's edge on 27 October, 2007. | Ms Corner's body was discovered on the beach at Seaton Carew, near Hartlepool, close to the water's edge on 27 October, 2007. |
| She was found clutching a photograph of her eight-year-old daughter and her mobile phone. A bottle of vodka was also nearby on the sands. | She was found clutching a photograph of her eight-year-old daughter and her mobile phone. A bottle of vodka was also nearby on the sands. |
| Five days before her suicide, she complained to police that her partner Mr Nicholson had raped and sexually assaulted her. | Five days before her suicide, she complained to police that her partner Mr Nicholson had raped and sexually assaulted her. |
| Michael Nicholson said he had been "through hell" | |
| He was charged and appeared in court before she took her own life. | He was charged and appeared in court before she took her own life. |
| Adrian Waterman QC, prosecuting, said Ms Corner had made allegations of domestic abuse in the past against Mr Nicholson, but never made any formal complaints. | Adrian Waterman QC, prosecuting, said Ms Corner had made allegations of domestic abuse in the past against Mr Nicholson, but never made any formal complaints. |
| In the hours before she alleged she was raped, while she was drunk in a pub, she was heard by several witnesses to say she was going to get her "revenge" on Mr Nicholson, the court heard. | In the hours before she alleged she was raped, while she was drunk in a pub, she was heard by several witnesses to say she was going to get her "revenge" on Mr Nicholson, the court heard. |
| One witness claimed the word "rape" was used, Mr Waterman told the court. | One witness claimed the word "rape" was used, Mr Waterman told the court. |
| He said: "The difficulty is that tragically, she is not here to answer the inevitable questions that the evidence raises, or to say one way or the other whether she did or did not use the word 'rape'." | He said: "The difficulty is that tragically, she is not here to answer the inevitable questions that the evidence raises, or to say one way or the other whether she did or did not use the word 'rape'." |
| 'Realistic prospect' | |
| Mr Waterman said Ms Corner had a history of self-harming and had tried to kill herself before. | Mr Waterman said Ms Corner had a history of self-harming and had tried to kill herself before. |
| Her depression worsened after she started her relationship with the defendant, he said. | Her depression worsened after she started her relationship with the defendant, he said. |
| "Nonetheless, her suicide raised for the Crown the question whether Michael Nicholson was criminally responsible for it," he said. | "Nonetheless, her suicide raised for the Crown the question whether Michael Nicholson was criminally responsible for it," he said. |
| A forensic psychiatrist was consulted who said if the rape allegation could be proved, there was a "realistic prospect" of proving a manslaughter charge. | A forensic psychiatrist was consulted who said if the rape allegation could be proved, there was a "realistic prospect" of proving a manslaughter charge. |
| But the Crown Prosecution Service decided it could not prove the allegations and did not submit any evidence. | But the Crown Prosecution Service decided it could not prove the allegations and did not submit any evidence. |
| Mr Nicholson was formally cleared of the charge against him. | Mr Nicholson was formally cleared of the charge against him. |
| A Cleveland Police spokeswoman said: "Following a lengthy investigation of the case and discussions involving both the police and CPS, the CPS has decided not to proceed with the case." | A Cleveland Police spokeswoman said: "Following a lengthy investigation of the case and discussions involving both the police and CPS, the CPS has decided not to proceed with the case." |