This article is from the source 'nytimes' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.nytimes.com/2016/05/04/world/middleeast/damascus-aleppo-syria-qanda.html
The article has changed 5 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 2 | Version 3 |
|---|---|
| A Strange, Sad, Surprising Reality of Syria at War | A Strange, Sad, Surprising Reality of Syria at War |
| (about 11 hours later) | |
| Declan Walsh, the Cairo bureau chief for The New York Times, recently visited Damascus, the war-weary Syrian capital, and the government-controlled part of the divided city of Aleppo. Below, he answers selected readers’ questions about his reporting trip to Syria, life in the devastated parts of the country and how Syrians view their prospects. | |
| Is there any semblance of normal life in Aleppo, or is it on complete lockdown? Do you see office workers commuting every morning, vendors selling street food, etc.? Or is it more of a ghost town? | Is there any semblance of normal life in Aleppo, or is it on complete lockdown? Do you see office workers commuting every morning, vendors selling street food, etc.? Or is it more of a ghost town? |
| MICHAEL SANDER | MICHAEL SANDER |
| One of the most striking things about Aleppo is how much of the city appears to be functioning relatively normally. Much of the periphery has been reduced to rubble. But in the city center, the sidewalks bustle, traffic flows, restaurants are busy and students pour from universities and schools. | One of the most striking things about Aleppo is how much of the city appears to be functioning relatively normally. Much of the periphery has been reduced to rubble. But in the city center, the sidewalks bustle, traffic flows, restaurants are busy and students pour from universities and schools. |
| The strange part is that the backdrop to the daily bustle is a cacophony of booms. I regularly heard explosions from falling shells or, from the other side of the front line, the sound of Russian jets bombing rebel-held areas. Many of the residents I met said they just filter those noises out: After four years of war, they had learned to ignore them, despite the risks. | The strange part is that the backdrop to the daily bustle is a cacophony of booms. I regularly heard explosions from falling shells or, from the other side of the front line, the sound of Russian jets bombing rebel-held areas. Many of the residents I met said they just filter those noises out: After four years of war, they had learned to ignore them, despite the risks. |
| I’m always surprised to read how normal life can be in war zones — the fact that there even is an upscale restaurant to eat in amazes me. This also means it might not take that long to make Aleppo livable again. From what you have seen, how much of a challenge will reconstruction eventually be? | I’m always surprised to read how normal life can be in war zones — the fact that there even is an upscale restaurant to eat in amazes me. This also means it might not take that long to make Aleppo livable again. From what you have seen, how much of a challenge will reconstruction eventually be? |
| MARKUS WAGNER, Vienna | MARKUS WAGNER, Vienna |
| Reconstruction, when it finally happens, will be a daunting challenge. Huge swaths of Aleppo have been reduced to rubble, and the basic municipal infrastructure — water, electricity, sewage — has been badly compromised, too. | Reconstruction, when it finally happens, will be a daunting challenge. Huge swaths of Aleppo have been reduced to rubble, and the basic municipal infrastructure — water, electricity, sewage — has been badly compromised, too. |
| For now, residents are getting by with jury-rigged systems: a network of private diesel generators, and some emergency solutions put in place by aid groups. But those makeshift systems are highly vulnerable to the fighting. | For now, residents are getting by with jury-rigged systems: a network of private diesel generators, and some emergency solutions put in place by aid groups. But those makeshift systems are highly vulnerable to the fighting. |
| Still, the city’s industrialists remain doggedly bullish. At the Aleppo Chamber of Commerce last Thursday, two businessmen told me of their ambitious plans to rebuild. But outside, we heard about a dozen explosions during our hourlong interview. That was bizarre. | Still, the city’s industrialists remain doggedly bullish. At the Aleppo Chamber of Commerce last Thursday, two businessmen told me of their ambitious plans to rebuild. But outside, we heard about a dozen explosions during our hourlong interview. That was bizarre. |
| What is the status of rebuilding in Aleppo? Have the souk merchants been able to replenish their supplies and regain clientele? | What is the status of rebuilding in Aleppo? Have the souk merchants been able to replenish their supplies and regain clientele? |
| RICK HAUSER | RICK HAUSER |
| The front line runs right through the old souk, which has been partly destroyed by combat. I got to visit one small part of it, where I interviewed Rose Abu Jaffar, the former zookeeper. To talk safely, we had to drive quickly through a maze of narrow and empty streets until we got to the little bunker where she and a couple of other government fighters were posted. | The front line runs right through the old souk, which has been partly destroyed by combat. I got to visit one small part of it, where I interviewed Rose Abu Jaffar, the former zookeeper. To talk safely, we had to drive quickly through a maze of narrow and empty streets until we got to the little bunker where she and a couple of other government fighters were posted. |
| So what has become of the shop owners? Many have transplanted their businesses to safer parts of the city where a sort of sidewalk souk has popped up: a long line of stalls outside a row of apartment buildings and shops. Aleppo has lots of broad, French-style boulevards wide enough to accommodate the new stores. But this souk is much smaller than the original. | So what has become of the shop owners? Many have transplanted their businesses to safer parts of the city where a sort of sidewalk souk has popped up: a long line of stalls outside a row of apartment buildings and shops. Aleppo has lots of broad, French-style boulevards wide enough to accommodate the new stores. But this souk is much smaller than the original. |
| Is the average citizen more pro- or anti-Assad? | Is the average citizen more pro- or anti-Assad? |
| ALDEN LOFQUIST | ALDEN LOFQUIST |
| From the immigration hall, where I crossed into Syria from Lebanon, to the most remote desert outposts, I saw posters of President Assad. It got me thinking about whether that profusion of imagery represents strength or weakness. It’s hard to tell. | From the immigration hall, where I crossed into Syria from Lebanon, to the most remote desert outposts, I saw posters of President Assad. It got me thinking about whether that profusion of imagery represents strength or weakness. It’s hard to tell. |
| As in most war zones, it’s very difficult to gauge public opinion because people fear the consequences of speaking their mind, or of even discussing politics openly. In Syria, it’s all the more difficult because the country is geographically fragmented, divided among rebels, Islamic State militants and government forces. | As in most war zones, it’s very difficult to gauge public opinion because people fear the consequences of speaking their mind, or of even discussing politics openly. In Syria, it’s all the more difficult because the country is geographically fragmented, divided among rebels, Islamic State militants and government forces. |
| Still, there were some indicators of Mr. Assad’s popularity. I met people from minority communities, particularly Armenian Syrians, who were unabashed supporters of his rule. But I also heard from a disillusioned military officer, a Sunni Muslim from a different part of the country, who quietly asserted that it was time for President Assad to go. | Still, there were some indicators of Mr. Assad’s popularity. I met people from minority communities, particularly Armenian Syrians, who were unabashed supporters of his rule. But I also heard from a disillusioned military officer, a Sunni Muslim from a different part of the country, who quietly asserted that it was time for President Assad to go. |
| “We have lost more than enough,” he said. He did not want to be identified, for obvious reasons. | “We have lost more than enough,” he said. He did not want to be identified, for obvious reasons. |
| The situation in Aleppo is very dangerous, so how did you and The Times make the decision to go? What precautions did you take? Did you travel with a government and/or rebel minder? | The situation in Aleppo is very dangerous, so how did you and The Times make the decision to go? What precautions did you take? Did you travel with a government and/or rebel minder? |
| LUKE JOHNSON, Washington, D.C. | LUKE JOHNSON, Washington, D.C. |
| The New York Times has detailed security procedures for reporting from countries like Syria. Before leaving Damascus for Aleppo, I sent an outline of my trip to editors in New York and a security manager in Europe, with details about how I was traveling, with whom, and where we would stay. I carried a flak jacket and first-aid kit, and was in regular contact with a Times security officer via a messaging service. | The New York Times has detailed security procedures for reporting from countries like Syria. Before leaving Damascus for Aleppo, I sent an outline of my trip to editors in New York and a security manager in Europe, with details about how I was traveling, with whom, and where we would stay. I carried a flak jacket and first-aid kit, and was in regular contact with a Times security officer via a messaging service. |
| After a discussion, we figured the risks were manageable: The road into Aleppo, although it had been under attack a month ago, was now open to regular traffic. International aid officials advised that it was possible to work there, with precautions. | After a discussion, we figured the risks were manageable: The road into Aleppo, although it had been under attack a month ago, was now open to regular traffic. International aid officials advised that it was possible to work there, with precautions. |
| Still, such plans are inevitably provisional, and on the ground the best security often involves taking advice from local residents. That is how it worked in Aleppo when, on my second day of reporting, the area where we were staying came under intense rebel shelling. | Still, such plans are inevitably provisional, and on the ground the best security often involves taking advice from local residents. That is how it worked in Aleppo when, on my second day of reporting, the area where we were staying came under intense rebel shelling. |
| I traveled with an interpreter and a Syrian Information Ministry minder: a courteous man with a few charming idiosyncrasies. An ardent fan of British culture, he had learned English, in part, from TV series like “Blackadder,” “Fawlty Towers” and even the children’s cartoon “Danger Mouse.” When his mobile phone rang, it played the BBC World Service theme. But he had never actually been to Britain. | I traveled with an interpreter and a Syrian Information Ministry minder: a courteous man with a few charming idiosyncrasies. An ardent fan of British culture, he had learned English, in part, from TV series like “Blackadder,” “Fawlty Towers” and even the children’s cartoon “Danger Mouse.” When his mobile phone rang, it played the BBC World Service theme. But he had never actually been to Britain. |
| Still, there was little ambiguity about his role: to translate as necessary, but also to keep tabs on where I went, whom I met and what I photographed. In Aleppo, our team picked up a second minder, from the local information ministry, so I sometimes conducted interviews with at least three other people — not ideal, but unavoidable. | Still, there was little ambiguity about his role: to translate as necessary, but also to keep tabs on where I went, whom I met and what I photographed. In Aleppo, our team picked up a second minder, from the local information ministry, so I sometimes conducted interviews with at least three other people — not ideal, but unavoidable. |
| People say Syrians should stay in their country and fight to keep it rather than leaving for other countries. How realistic is it for ordinary people to stay there and fight back? | People say Syrians should stay in their country and fight to keep it rather than leaving for other countries. How realistic is it for ordinary people to stay there and fight back? |
| ANN D. HOANG, San Francisco | ANN D. HOANG, San Francisco |
| Just a couple of days in Damascus offered an eye-opening perspective on the plight of displaced Syrians. | Just a couple of days in Damascus offered an eye-opening perspective on the plight of displaced Syrians. |
| So many people had been displaced once, twice or even three times in the course of this long war. Their homes had been destroyed, or lay behind the rebel lines. I could see why so many had sent family members — sons, daughters, cousins — on the dangerous journey to Europe. | So many people had been displaced once, twice or even three times in the course of this long war. Their homes had been destroyed, or lay behind the rebel lines. I could see why so many had sent family members — sons, daughters, cousins — on the dangerous journey to Europe. |
| Young men face the possibility of conscription into the Army, and being sent to the front lines, if they remain in Syria. If they leave, they can send their families a remittance from abroad — even $100 a month can go a long way. | Young men face the possibility of conscription into the Army, and being sent to the front lines, if they remain in Syria. If they leave, they can send their families a remittance from abroad — even $100 a month can go a long way. |
| Few of the people I spoke to appeared to have any appetite for a fight. The war now involves a number of foreign forces, including Russia, Iran, the United States and Saudi Arabia. It has become impossibly complicated. I didn’t ask them if they wanted to fight, but if I had, I imagine their response would have been: Fight whom? And for what? | Few of the people I spoke to appeared to have any appetite for a fight. The war now involves a number of foreign forces, including Russia, Iran, the United States and Saudi Arabia. It has become impossibly complicated. I didn’t ask them if they wanted to fight, but if I had, I imagine their response would have been: Fight whom? And for what? |