This article is from the source 'guardian' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.

You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2016/jun/20/brexit-cheap-labour-britain-wages-eu-trade-unions

The article has changed 2 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.

Version 0 Version 1
A Brexit won’t stop cheap labour coming to Britain A Brexit won’t stop cheap labour coming to Britain
(2 months later)
The Unite union is fighting all the way for a remain vote and for British workers to build their future in unity with workers in the rest of Europe. But I refuse to lecture or to patronise those working people who take a different view. After all, who can be surprised that in so many industrial areas, voting for the status quo is not a popular option?The Unite union is fighting all the way for a remain vote and for British workers to build their future in unity with workers in the rest of Europe. But I refuse to lecture or to patronise those working people who take a different view. After all, who can be surprised that in so many industrial areas, voting for the status quo is not a popular option?
Related: Len McCluskey says EU migration was an 'experiment' at UK workers' expense
I am just asking all those people, including many Unite members, to reflect on their concerns, and whether they would be best addressed by staying in Europe or by voting for Brexit.I am just asking all those people, including many Unite members, to reflect on their concerns, and whether they would be best addressed by staying in Europe or by voting for Brexit.
Some pundits and commentators, like explorers returning from a visit to the deep unknown, are stunned to find that immigration has become an issue among Labour voters. I am not in the least surprised. In the past 10 years there has been a gigantic experiment at the expense of ordinary workers. Countries with vast historical differences in wage rates and living standards have been brought together in a common labour market. The result has been sustained pressure on living standards and a systematic attempt to hold down wages and cut the costs of social provision for working people.Some pundits and commentators, like explorers returning from a visit to the deep unknown, are stunned to find that immigration has become an issue among Labour voters. I am not in the least surprised. In the past 10 years there has been a gigantic experiment at the expense of ordinary workers. Countries with vast historical differences in wage rates and living standards have been brought together in a common labour market. The result has been sustained pressure on living standards and a systematic attempt to hold down wages and cut the costs of social provision for working people.
That is why, for trade unions, control of the labour supply in an industry or across society has always been the core of our mission, to ensure that workers get a fair share of the wealth they create.That is why, for trade unions, control of the labour supply in an industry or across society has always been the core of our mission, to ensure that workers get a fair share of the wealth they create.
Related: The Guardian view on the EU referendum: keep connected and inclusive, not angry and isolated | Editorial
But pulling up the drawbridge against the rest of Europe is the wrong answer. The right answer is the same one we used when migrants from Ireland were vilified in the last century; when Jewish immigrants were targeted a century ago; and when Asian and African-Caribbean workers were attacked in the 1950s, 60s and beyond. That is, strong trade unions delivering the rate for the job, whoever you are and wherever you come from.But pulling up the drawbridge against the rest of Europe is the wrong answer. The right answer is the same one we used when migrants from Ireland were vilified in the last century; when Jewish immigrants were targeted a century ago; and when Asian and African-Caribbean workers were attacked in the 1950s, 60s and beyond. That is, strong trade unions delivering the rate for the job, whoever you are and wherever you come from.
Leaving the EU will not stop the supply of cheap labour to Britain. Those who profit from wage-cutting found a way to import cheap labour without the EU in the past, and will do so again. The idea that leaving the EU is a shortcut to social justice is a cruel con-trick by the right wing of the Tory party.Leaving the EU will not stop the supply of cheap labour to Britain. Those who profit from wage-cutting found a way to import cheap labour without the EU in the past, and will do so again. The idea that leaving the EU is a shortcut to social justice is a cruel con-trick by the right wing of the Tory party.
Some argue that such workers’ rights as we have secured did not come as a gift from Brussels, but were the result of union campaigning. That is true – but surely they can best be defended and extended by working in unity across borders, rather than each isolated in our own country, turning our back on trade unions abroad.Some argue that such workers’ rights as we have secured did not come as a gift from Brussels, but were the result of union campaigning. That is true – but surely they can best be defended and extended by working in unity across borders, rather than each isolated in our own country, turning our back on trade unions abroad.
And what of jobs? I have been in enough multinational boardrooms fighting for the future of our factories to know that raising this issue is not scaremongering. When the big investment decisions are made, particularly in manufacturing, Britain will be heading to the back of the queue if we stand outside the European market. A Brexit will immediately cast a long shadow over factories across the country – whether owned abroad or run from UK boardrooms.And what of jobs? I have been in enough multinational boardrooms fighting for the future of our factories to know that raising this issue is not scaremongering. When the big investment decisions are made, particularly in manufacturing, Britain will be heading to the back of the queue if we stand outside the European market. A Brexit will immediately cast a long shadow over factories across the country – whether owned abroad or run from UK boardrooms.
Would British industry survive? Probably, in the long run, although cavalier Brexit economists seem quite happy to wave goodbye to manufacturing altogether. Brexit is playing Russian roulette with our industrial base. We’d be walking out of the EU and into the arms of those who think Margaret Thatcher didn’t go far enough. Brexit may or may not prompt an early election but it will certainly lead to an early shift to the right – a shift no trade unionist, or anyone who cares about our communities, can afford.Would British industry survive? Probably, in the long run, although cavalier Brexit economists seem quite happy to wave goodbye to manufacturing altogether. Brexit is playing Russian roulette with our industrial base. We’d be walking out of the EU and into the arms of those who think Margaret Thatcher didn’t go far enough. Brexit may or may not prompt an early election but it will certainly lead to an early shift to the right – a shift no trade unionist, or anyone who cares about our communities, can afford.
I am not a partisan of Project Fear – I’ve been in Project Hope’s corner all my life. It is because of my confidence in the values and the initiative of working people that my appeal is on the basis of hope. This hope rests on our internationalism, and our commitment to democracy and social justice.I am not a partisan of Project Fear – I’ve been in Project Hope’s corner all my life. It is because of my confidence in the values and the initiative of working people that my appeal is on the basis of hope. This hope rests on our internationalism, and our commitment to democracy and social justice.
For sure, the EU as it stands is not the EU that it can and will be if we work together. But as our friends in Europe fight against the politics of fear and division stalking their streets, a UK vote for remain will help stem the rise of the reactionary right.For sure, the EU as it stands is not the EU that it can and will be if we work together. But as our friends in Europe fight against the politics of fear and division stalking their streets, a UK vote for remain will help stem the rise of the reactionary right.