This article is from the source 'guardian' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.

You can find the current article at its original source at https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/live/2016/jun/27/hillary-clinton-elizabeth-warren-donald-trump-ohio

The article has changed 23 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.

Version 4 Version 5
Warren warns Americans: Trump 'will crush you into the dirt' – campaign live Warren warns Americans: Trump 'will crush you into the dirt' – campaign live
(35 minutes later)
5.49pm BST
17:49
This is confusing. Trump spokesperson Katrina Pierson defends her boss’s handling of the Brexit vote by alluding to criticism of Clinton’s handling of the Benghazi incident:
Trump spox @KatrinaPierson: "Perhaps Mr. Trump could have blamed Brexit on a video that never existed" pic.twitter.com/QDjPoUPTz2
B R E X I TENGH A I LAZ O DI https://t.co/k7rHHjLiRg
Updated
at 5.50pm BST
5.47pm BST
17:47
Trump will travel to Ohio after all.
After coming in for criticism for making no visits to the Buckeye State since March, Trump will participate in an upcoming rally in St Clairsville, a 95% white blue-collar town with more in common with West Virginia across the river than the Ohio metropolises to the west.
Trump will be up against the spectacle this morning in Cincinnati of Hillary Clinton and Elizabeth Warren onstage together.
Trump announces his first trip to Ohio since the March primary pic.twitter.com/WrbTOgVUJf
5.38pm BST
17:38
The Supreme Court has vacated a conviction on corruption charges of former Virginia governor Bob McDonnell, who was originally found guilty of taking $175,000 in cash and gifts – a Ferrarri loaner, for example, and payment towards a daughter’s wedding – from a businessmen, in return, a jury decided, for McDonnell’s arranging access to officials. The businessman was hocking a dietary supplement.
McDonnell’s lawyers argued there was no quid-pro-quo and that the governor’s actions did not violate federal bribery statutes. The court found that the conviction hinged on instructions to a jury that were too broad.
The case raises questions about what kinds of gifts, exactly, a politician may accept, and what constitutes a favor in return. It appears more politicians may be about to get Ferrari rides:
In today's McDonnell ruling, a donor can legally give unlimited $$ to a candidate as a personal gift if no "official act" involved
Good news for Hillary! https://t.co/F2rEBxpOgK
5.27pm BST
17:27
Dole joins Twitter
The 1996 Republican nominee is up and tweeting:
I'm proof that it's never too late to join Twitter. #myfirstTweet
5.20pm BST
17:20
Democrats accuse Benghazi committee Republicans of 'grave abuses'
The House select committee on Benghazi, led by dogged truth seeker Trey Gowdy, a Republican from South Carolina, earlier this month had to postpone the release of a summary report on its investigation into Hillary Clinton’s role in the disaster and the contents of her email.
The Democrats on the committee are out with their side today. They accuse the Republicans on the committee of “grave abuses” including concealing exculpatory evidence:
Republicans excluded Democrats from interviews, concealed exculpatory evidence, withheld interview transcripts, leaked inaccurate information, issued unilateral subpoenas, sent armed Marshals to the home of a cooperative witness, and even conducted political fundraising by exploiting the deaths of four Americans. In one of the most serious abuses, Chairman Gowdy personally and publicly accused Secretary Clinton of compromising a highly classified intelligence source. Although the Intelligence Community quickly debunked his claim, Chairman Gowdy has yet to apologize to Secretary Clinton for his slanderous accusation.
Read further:
Latest abuse of authority by House Republicans is ridiculous & a desperate distraction from a failed investigation https://t.co/8j4yZ0zifp
5.05pm BST5.05pm BST
17:0517:05
Mike Huckabee, the former Arkansas governor, used the Survivor song Eye of the Tiger without permission at a rally he held for Kim Davis, the Kentucky clerk who refused to issue same-sex couples marriage licenses.Mike Huckabee, the former Arkansas governor, used the Survivor song Eye of the Tiger without permission at a rally he held for Kim Davis, the Kentucky clerk who refused to issue same-sex couples marriage licenses.
Huckabee got sued and had to pay out $25,000 in a settlement, CNN reports.Huckabee got sued and had to pay out $25,000 in a settlement, CNN reports.
(h/t @bencjacobs)(h/t @bencjacobs)
4.59pm BST4.59pm BST
16:5916:59
Clinton: abortion ruling 'is a reminder of how much is at stake'Clinton: abortion ruling 'is a reminder of how much is at stake'
In a 5-3 ruling, the Supreme Court has prevented Texas from enforcing a restrictive anti-abortion law that would have closed all but nine abortion clinics in the state.In a 5-3 ruling, the Supreme Court has prevented Texas from enforcing a restrictive anti-abortion law that would have closed all but nine abortion clinics in the state.
“The Supreme Court’s decision in Whole Woman’s Health v. Hellerstedt is a victory for women across America,” Clinton said in a statement:“The Supreme Court’s decision in Whole Woman’s Health v. Hellerstedt is a victory for women across America,” Clinton said in a statement:
By striking down politically motivated restrictions that made it nearly impossible for Texans to exercise their full reproductive rights, the Court upheld every woman’s right to safe, legal abortion, no matter where she lives.By striking down politically motivated restrictions that made it nearly impossible for Texans to exercise their full reproductive rights, the Court upheld every woman’s right to safe, legal abortion, no matter where she lives.
The statement drew a contrast with Trump:The statement drew a contrast with Trump:
Donald Trump has said women should be punished for having abortions. He also pledged to defund Planned Parenthood and appoint Supreme Court justices who would overturn Roe v. Wade.Donald Trump has said women should be punished for having abortions. He also pledged to defund Planned Parenthood and appoint Supreme Court justices who would overturn Roe v. Wade.
Today’s decision is a reminder of how much is at stake in this election.Today’s decision is a reminder of how much is at stake in this election.
The Trump campaign has yet to issue a statement on the ruling.The Trump campaign has yet to issue a statement on the ruling.
4.35pm BST4.35pm BST
16:3516:35
A high concentration of political gravity in one hug:A high concentration of political gravity in one hug:
Hillary Clinton and Elizabeth Warren, working their first joint rope line, share a quick hug before Warren heads out pic.twitter.com/YxmSL8kahfHillary Clinton and Elizabeth Warren, working their first joint rope line, share a quick hug before Warren heads out pic.twitter.com/YxmSL8kahf
4.30pm BST4.30pm BST
16:3016:30
Brown to make rebuttal to Clinton-WarrenBrown to make rebuttal to Clinton-Warren
You’ve heard Clinton and Warren make their argument. Now listen to the other side, from the mouth of... brief US senator Scott Brown.You’ve heard Clinton and Warren make their argument. Now listen to the other side, from the mouth of... brief US senator Scott Brown.
The Republican national committee has scheduled a conference call with media this afternoon with Brown, who won a special election to the senate in 2010 before losing to Warren for senate in Massachusetts (2012) and then losing to Jeanne Shaheen for senate in New Hampshire (2014).The Republican national committee has scheduled a conference call with media this afternoon with Brown, who won a special election to the senate in 2010 before losing to Warren for senate in Massachusetts (2012) and then losing to Jeanne Shaheen for senate in New Hampshire (2014).
We’ll listen to Brown and let you know what he says.We’ll listen to Brown and let you know what he says.
4.26pm BST4.26pm BST
16:2616:26
Clinton says Trump tried to turn Brexit into 'an infomercial'Clinton says Trump tried to turn Brexit into 'an infomercial'
Clinton delivers a sustained criticism of Trump as conclusion to her speech:Clinton delivers a sustained criticism of Trump as conclusion to her speech:
“I have this old fashioned idea. If you’re running for president, you should say what you want to do and how you will get it done,” she says.“I have this old fashioned idea. If you’re running for president, you should say what you want to do and how you will get it done,” she says.
Ask yourself what are Donald Trump’s plans? Well, best I can tell, he has no credible strategy for creating jobs... he says he’s for our workers. But Trump’s own products are made in countries that are not called America.”Ask yourself what are Donald Trump’s plans? Well, best I can tell, he has no credible strategy for creating jobs... he says he’s for our workers. But Trump’s own products are made in countries that are not called America.”
This time she names Trump suits, furniture and barware, all manufactured overseas. That’s not “America First”, she says.This time she names Trump suits, furniture and barware, all manufactured overseas. That’s not “America First”, she says.
Then Clinton runs down a list of ways she says Trump is wrong, from “playing coy” with white supremacists to mocking people with disabilities, favoring banning Muslims, abolishing gun-free zones at schools, defaulting on the national debt, rolling back marriage equality...Then Clinton runs down a list of ways she says Trump is wrong, from “playing coy” with white supremacists to mocking people with disabilities, favoring banning Muslims, abolishing gun-free zones at schools, defaulting on the national debt, rolling back marriage equality...
I could go on and on.. Whose reaction to the horrific mass shoting in Orlando was to publicly congratulate himself... and on Friday [after Brexit announcement], he crowed from his golf course about how the disruption could end up creating higher profits for that golf course, even though within 24 hours Americans lost [tens of billions] from their 401Ks.I could go on and on.. Whose reaction to the horrific mass shoting in Orlando was to publicly congratulate himself... and on Friday [after Brexit announcement], he crowed from his golf course about how the disruption could end up creating higher profits for that golf course, even though within 24 hours Americans lost [tens of billions] from their 401Ks.
“He tried to turn a glogal economic challenge into an infomercial,” Clinton says. “Imagine him being in charge.. imagine him trying to figure out what to do in case of an emergency”.“He tried to turn a glogal economic challenge into an infomercial,” Clinton says. “Imagine him being in charge.. imagine him trying to figure out what to do in case of an emergency”.
4.15pm BST4.15pm BST
16:1516:15
Clinton is describing the America of tomorrow that she envisions, under her presidency. It will have the most competitive auto-parts industry in the world, every home will have high-speed broadband Internet and the USA will be the clean-energy superpower of the 21st century.Clinton is describing the America of tomorrow that she envisions, under her presidency. It will have the most competitive auto-parts industry in the world, every home will have high-speed broadband Internet and the USA will be the clean-energy superpower of the 21st century.
She’s coughing a bit. She continues:She’s coughing a bit. She continues:
“Cincinnati is already one of the biggest cities in the country to run 100% on clean energy. Congratulations!... I hope you don’t mind if I go around across the country and say if you can do it in Cincinnati you can do it anywhere!”“Cincinnati is already one of the biggest cities in the country to run 100% on clean energy. Congratulations!... I hope you don’t mind if I go around across the country and say if you can do it in Cincinnati you can do it anywhere!”
Clinton deploys the “Woman card” line:Clinton deploys the “Woman card” line:
If fighting for families is playing the woman card, deal me in”.If fighting for families is playing the woman card, deal me in”.
People chant along and there’s lots of clapping and a “Hillary! Hillary!” chant breaks out.People chant along and there’s lots of clapping and a “Hillary! Hillary!” chant breaks out.
4.09pm BST4.09pm BST
16:0916:09
4.08pm BST4.08pm BST
16:0816:08
Clinton promise: 'not raise' taxes on middle class; 'raise taxes' on wealthyClinton promise: 'not raise' taxes on middle class; 'raise taxes' on wealthy
Clinton: “I got into this race because I wanted to even the odds for people who have the odds stacked against them...”Clinton: “I got into this race because I wanted to even the odds for people who have the odds stacked against them...”
We’ve got to go big and we’ve got to go bold. We need to take the frustration, the fear, the anxiety and yes the anger... we’ve got to work together.We’ve got to go big and we’ve got to go bold. We need to take the frustration, the fear, the anxiety and yes the anger... we’ve got to work together.
Let’s set five ambition goals for the economy, Clinton says, lapsing into the economic policy program she’s laid out elsewhere: 1/ jobs and infrastructure spending; 2/ debt-free college & college debt relief 3/ profit-sharing & less outsourcing 4/ tax Wall Street & Buffett rule 5/ family leave & health careLet’s set five ambition goals for the economy, Clinton says, lapsing into the economic policy program she’s laid out elsewhere: 1/ jobs and infrastructure spending; 2/ debt-free college & college debt relief 3/ profit-sharing & less outsourcing 4/ tax Wall Street & Buffett rule 5/ family leave & health care
Then Clinton makes a classic campaign-trail tax pledge, notable for the political comfort she feels at drawing such a line. She promises to tax the rich and not to tax the middle class:Then Clinton makes a classic campaign-trail tax pledge, notable for the political comfort she feels at drawing such a line. She promises to tax the rich and not to tax the middle class:
I’ve made a pledge: I will not raise taxes on the middle class, but we are going to raise taxes on corporations and the wealthy.”I’ve made a pledge: I will not raise taxes on the middle class, but we are going to raise taxes on corporations and the wealthy.”
3.59pm BST3.59pm BST
15:5915:59
Clinton: Warren speaks for 'every American who is frustrated'Clinton: Warren speaks for 'every American who is frustrated'
Clinton, perhaps targeting the kind of frustrated blue collar voter whose support for Trump has been apparent, calls Warren a premier defender of the disenfranchised:Clinton, perhaps targeting the kind of frustrated blue collar voter whose support for Trump has been apparent, calls Warren a premier defender of the disenfranchised:
Some of the best TV since Elizabeth came to the senate is actually on CSPAN.... She is speaking for every American who is frustrated and fed up. She is speaking for all of us. And we thank her for that.Some of the best TV since Elizabeth came to the senate is actually on CSPAN.... She is speaking for every American who is frustrated and fed up. She is speaking for all of us. And we thank her for that.
Clinton also expressed admiration for Warren’s ability to attack Trump:Clinton also expressed admiration for Warren’s ability to attack Trump:
And I must say. I do just love to see how she gets under Donald Trump’s thin skin. As Elizabeth made clear, Donald Trump proves every day, he’s not in it for the American people, he’s only in it for himself. And Elizabeth reminds us of that.. because... she exposes him for what he is. Temperamentally unfit and totally unqualified to be president of the United States.And I must say. I do just love to see how she gets under Donald Trump’s thin skin. As Elizabeth made clear, Donald Trump proves every day, he’s not in it for the American people, he’s only in it for himself. And Elizabeth reminds us of that.. because... she exposes him for what he is. Temperamentally unfit and totally unqualified to be president of the United States.
3.54pm BST
15:54
“Elizabeth and I came of age around the same time,” Clinton says.
Warren appears to have left the stage. Clearing the way for the candidate.
Clinton says “no one works harder to make sure Wall Street never, never wrecks Main Street again...” She talks about Warren’s consumer financial protection bureau. “It has already returned over $10.8bn to 25m Americans who have been hurt by illegal financial practices,” Clinton says.
“We need to make sure that basic bargain is alive and well in 2016. Elizabeth is leading the fight to liberate millions of Americans from the burden of student debt and to make sure Washington never again profits off our students.”
3.51pm BST
15:51
Warren leads the crowd in a “Hillary! Hillary!” cheer.
Donald Trump cheats his workers and wants to abolish the minimum wage. HIllary Clinton believes no one should work full time and live in poverty and that means raising the minimum wage.. Hillary fights for us!
Donald Trump calls African Americans thugs, Muslims terrorists, Latinos criminals and rapists and women bimbos. Hillary Clinton believes racism .. and bigotry have no place in our country. She fights for us and we will fight for Hillary Clinton.
The crowd is into it.
Thank you Cincinnati! Clinton says. That’s a tough speech to follow.
3.48pm BST
15:48
Warren: Trump 'will crush you into the dirt'
Warren with a sharp attack on Trump:
Donald Trump says “we’ll make America great again.”
“It’s stamped on front of his goofy hat. You want to see goofy? Look at him in that hat.” [Trump has taken to referring to Warren as ‘goofy Elizabeth Warren”.]
When Donald Trump says great, I think, great for who, exactly?... For families that don’t fly to Scotland for golf? ... He means make it even greater for rich guys like Donald Trump... great for the guys... great for the guys who always want more...
Watch out because he will crush you into the dirt to get whatever he wants. That’s who he is.
Then she repeats her “small, insecure moneygrubber” line about Trump and the crowd really cheers.
What kind of a man? A nasty man who will never become president of the United States. Because Hillary Clinton will be the next president of the United States.... She knows how to beat a thin-skinned bully who is driven by greed and hate. She knows you beat a bully not by tucking tail and but by standing ground and fighting back.
Warren says Clinton has been hit by “one right-wing attack or another for 25 years, but she has never backed down. She doesn’t whine, she doesn’t run to Twitter to call her enemies fat pigs or dummies. No...” she remembers the people who need her most.
Hillary has brains. She has guts. She has thick skin and steady hands. But most of all, she has a good heart. And that’s what AMerica needs. And that’s why I’m with her.
3.41pm BST
15:41
“Hillary Clinton is a granddaughter of a factory worker who’s going to make it all the way to the White House,” Warren says. It’s an applause line.
Clinton is standing next to Warren as Warren speaks. Clinton is nodding attentively as Warren talks about “fat tax breaks for CEO bonuses”.
3.39pm BST
15:39
Here’s Warren and Clinton in Cincinnati.
They’re
both wearing Democratic blue (
Clinton appears to be more in purple, many photos above to review).
Warren is calling for protecting and expanding social security. She’s talking about her biography and professional background.
Updated
at 4.36pm BST
3.33pm BST
15:33
Here’s a live video stream of the Clinton-Warren event in Cincinnati, which is scheduled to start soon:
3.32pm BST
15:32
We’re trialling our first Guardian US politics Snapchat update from the Hillary Clinton and Elizabeth Warren event today.
Sabrina Saddiqui is recording live in Ohio. She’s behind the scenes at the event, speaking to the crowd and commenting on the speeches.
Follow her and watch the event by adding guardian_us as a friend on Snapchat, or scan the code. Send us a message and let us know how we’re doing.
3.27pm BST
15:27
Democratic unity shaping up more quickly than in 2008 – poll
Bernie Sanders supporters may not include many “party-unity-my-ass” types, in the model of the Hillary Clinton Pumas, who, in 2008, resisted backing Barack Obama after he beat her to the nomination.
The 81% of Sanders backers who now say they’re with her, in a new Washington Post-ABC poll, “is a higher number than in any poll of 2008 Clinton backers who rallied to Obama”, writes the Washington Post’s Aaron Blake. “The high that year was 74%, in October”.
Sanders has done a bit to rally his followers, if not behind Clinton then at least against Donald Trump, whom Sanders has repeatedly said must be defeated at all costs. The Clinton camp would say there’s a lot more to be done.
81% of Sanders backers say they'll vote Clinton. Much quicker Dem rallying effect than '08. https://t.co/RvFtAXLCwg pic.twitter.com/TQdOoRylyE
A second poll backs up the WaPo/ ABC finding:
45% of Sanders backers now have a positive view of Cilnton vs. 33% with negative view, per NBC/WSJ poll https://t.co/hxEFIxOgA2
3.16pm BST
15:16
Look who’s tweeting.
Donald Trump usually refers to Elizabeth Warren as “Pocahontas”, in reference to the senator’s disputed Native American background. But this morning he’s behaving: Warren now “lied on heritage”.
Crooked Hillary is wheeling out one of the least productive senators in the U.S. Senate, goofy Elizabeth Warren, who lied on heritage.
Trump is telegraphing discontent with the media this morning, in what seems to be a bit of a bender of focus on the forces Trump perceives to be arrayed against him, namely pollsters and the media.
On Sunday night, Trump tweeted negatively about a new ABC / Washington Post poll finding that nearly two-thirds of Americans think he is unqualified to be president. He called the poll “dirty” and a “disgrace”.
Trump has been grappling with seriously bad polling numbers for a couple weeks now, and the struggle has been something to watch from the outside. At first he used the word “phony” to describe the polls, then he said “I haven’t started yet”, and now it’s “dirty” and “disgrace” with a side helping of a media conspiracy against him:
The media is unrelenting. They will only go with and report a story in a negative light. I called Brexit (Hillary was wrong), watch November
Trump pays special tribute to CNN, which last week hired the campaign manager Trump fired. Somehow Trump knows what’s on CNN, though he does not watch it:
.@CNN is all negative when it comes to me. I don't watch it anymore.
1.44pm BST
13:44
Hello and welcome to our live-wire coverage of the 2016 race for the White House. Senator Elizabeth Warren will join Hillary Clinton for their first joint campaign event today in Cincinnati, Ohio, a key toss-up state Clinton has been visiting regularly since sewing up the Democratic nomination.
Donald Trump has not visited the state since March. “Trump has now visited Scotland more than Ohio since becoming the Republican party’s presumptive nominee,” local WCPO Cincinnati observed on Monday morning. Perhaps Trump figures he can get all the Buckeye fuel he needs out of next month’s convention in Cleveland.
Trump is not entirely neglecting a traditional swing-state campaigning strategy, however. His team announced an event on Tuesday outside Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, a state the Clinton camp has expressed confidence about keeping in the Democratic column even as a pro-Clinton Super Pac makes eight-figure ad buys there. If Trump’s strategy is “you never know”, Clinton’s is “you can never be too sure”.
Speaking of swing states: a CBS News/YouGov poll of four swing states out this morning finds Clinton and Trump basically tied in Colorado and North Carolina, and Clinton a bit ahead in Florida and Wisconsin. Here’s the breakdown:
Clinton ahead in Wisconsin; tight races in Colorado, Florida and North Carolina https://t.co/EcQOpF3OU0 pic.twitter.com/XKsulypZMQ
The Clinton campaign is out with a new ad hitting Trump for his Scotland golf course do on Friday as the world awoke to news that Britain had voted to leave the EU. “In a volatile world, the last thing we need isa volatile president,” the narrator intones.
At the weekend, Trump campaign manager (is that his title these days?) Paul Manafort teased some news to come: “This week we will be making some major announcements about people that are taking over and major positions in our national campaign and state campaigns,” he said.
Clinton walked briefly in the Pride march in New York City on Sunday. As Clinton passed the corner of Christopher Street and Bleecker, the Guardian’s Nicole Puglise wrote, an announcer asked the crowd to “make some noise if you’re voting for Secretary Clinton”. Attendees shouted and whooped.
Barack Obama is suddenly quite popular, his approval rating continuing to climb. It would help Clinton if he can keep this up:
Poll: 56% approve of President Obama pic.twitter.com/54yR1gULd1
The same poll found that almost two-thirds of Americans think Trump is unqualified to be president while 61% think Clinton is qualified. Trump did not say the poll was “skewed”, but he did call it a “dirty” and a “disgrace”:
The "dirty" poll done by @ABC @washingtonpost is a disgrace. Even they admit that many more Democrats were polled. Other polls were good.
McConnell mum on Trump ‘qualified’ question
“Our primary voters have made their decision ... there’s a lot of work to be done”.
Thanks for reading and please join us in the comments.