This article is from the source 'guardian' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.

You can find the current article at its original source at https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/live/2016/oct/04/commonwealth-bank-boss-appears-before-parliamentary-committee-live

The article has changed 8 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.

Version 3 Version 4
Bank hearings: nobody fired for denying life insurance payouts, Commonwealth boss says – live Banking inquiry: nobody fired for denying life insurance payouts, Commonwealth boss says – live
(35 minutes later)
6.14am BST
06:14
Matt Keogh has asked about the $2.8m of Ian Narev’s pay based on performance. Commonwealth Bank and other companies are under fire for paying executives extra for things that should be core business like customer satisfaction.
Ian Narev explains that his pay is set by the board and shareholders.
It’s performance based remuneration - nowhere should it be described as a bonus.
Narev rattles off consumer surveys that show its customers are happy with the bank. He said he took a hit on pay because the bank’s response to financial advice controversies was “not good enough”.
6.06am BST
06:06
Labor MP Matt Keogh starts his questioning by disclosing that he still has his Dollarmite account.
He then asks why Ian Narev has not taken the Ethics Centre banking and finance oath despite the chief executives of the other three big banks signing on. The guts of the oath are:
Narev replied:
I agree completely with the content.
The sole reason I haven’t [sworn the oath] to date is ... my view is that the day I took the job I signed up for that, I made that commitment to all our stakeholders.
5.58am BST
05:58
And we’re back.
Liberal MP, Julia Banks, is asking about CBA’s risk assessment, and whether it has an alert system where two or more consumer complaints or a report of wrongdoing by a whistleblower will trigger an alert for the chief executive and other senior executives.
Ian Narev says there is no system where two complaints trigger an alert, and says given the size of the bank it would be “unworkable”.
Narev explains the process it does have:
I’ve lost count of the number of times I’ve emphasised escalation.
[In senior executive meetings] We have a specific agenda item for complaints, where we specifically consider patterns in complaints.
The newly created customer advocate inside the bank will provide a further alert, Narev said. He adds he can’t guarantee it would have sped up the time to alert executives of problems such as the definition of heart attacks being used to deny payouts.
Chief risk officer, David Cohen, adds that there is a whistleblower hotline.
Updated
at 6.03am BST
5.46am BST
05:46
Labor’s Pat Conroy is trying to discover just how big the Commonwealth Bank’s returns on home loans and credit cards are.
Chief executive Ian Narev replied:
We don’t disclose the returns on equity by individual products. In highly competitive markets, you don’t want these individual aspects of product profitability disclosed to your competitors.
Narev said home loans are just over half the bank’s balance sheet and gives general figures for the performance of the bank: in 2007 the bank’s return on equity was 22.1% and in 2016 it’s 16.5%.
Chairman David Coleman reads the rules on refusing to answer a question and notes the committee can determine it still requires an answer which can be provided in private.
Narev said he has the “highest respect” for the committee’s ability to ask for information.
We will engage in the way we should engage with the committee, with requests that come through the chair.
Conroy labels the committee “a farce” when he’s cut off for lack of time, and the hearing goes to a 10 minute break.
Updated
at 5.51am BST
5.30am BST5.30am BST
05:3005:30
No employment terminations over denying life insurance claims: NarevNo employment terminations over denying life insurance claims: Narev
Labor’s Pat Conroy has asked about whether there have been any disciplinary consequences for CommInsure claims officers for rejecting insurance claims from terminally ill people or refusal to pay out on life insurance.Labor’s Pat Conroy has asked about whether there have been any disciplinary consequences for CommInsure claims officers for rejecting insurance claims from terminally ill people or refusal to pay out on life insurance.
Ian Narev replied there have been disciplinary outcomes, but no terminations of employment.Ian Narev replied there have been disciplinary outcomes, but no terminations of employment.
There are certainly individuals where we know enough about them that they’ve had some consequences related to remuneration but at this stage we have not had individuals terminated because of this because we’ve not seen the need to do that.There are certainly individuals where we know enough about them that they’ve had some consequences related to remuneration but at this stage we have not had individuals terminated because of this because we’ve not seen the need to do that.
Narev said the bank had to “finish the work and make sure the consequences are dealt with as part of that”. After reviews are completed, independent committees within the bank will decide on disciplinary action.Narev said the bank had to “finish the work and make sure the consequences are dealt with as part of that”. After reviews are completed, independent committees within the bank will decide on disciplinary action.
We’re committed to an environment where if people are accountable, they will be held accountable.We’re committed to an environment where if people are accountable, they will be held accountable.
UpdatedUpdated
at 5.34am BSTat 5.34am BST
5.19am BST5.19am BST
05:1905:19
Labor MP, Pat Conroy, has asked about an ABC report that CommInsure ignored the findings of police and the coroner to refuse a payout for a woman who died of an accidental prescription drug overdose because it decided she had taken her own life.Labor MP, Pat Conroy, has asked about an ABC report that CommInsure ignored the findings of police and the coroner to refuse a payout for a woman who died of an accidental prescription drug overdose because it decided she had taken her own life.
Ian Narev said it hadn’t been established that the claims officer had wilfully ignored the coroner’s finding.Ian Narev said it hadn’t been established that the claims officer had wilfully ignored the coroner’s finding.
They made a conclusion that was mistaken.They made a conclusion that was mistaken.
It was not a customer-friendly process.It was not a customer-friendly process.
UpdatedUpdated
at 5.23am BSTat 5.23am BST
5.14am BST5.14am BST
05:1405:14
Liberal MP Craig Kelly and chief risk officer, David Cohen, have been going back and forth over the interest rates businesses pay on loans.Liberal MP Craig Kelly and chief risk officer, David Cohen, have been going back and forth over the interest rates businesses pay on loans.
Cohen explains the bank has repriced risk so it’s not as simple as saying that defaults have gone down since the global financial crisis so rates should have dropped more.Cohen explains the bank has repriced risk so it’s not as simple as saying that defaults have gone down since the global financial crisis so rates should have dropped more.
During the GFC the banks got it wrong, we weren’t pricing for risk appropriately.During the GFC the banks got it wrong, we weren’t pricing for risk appropriately.
The reason [the margin on loans] is higher is the risk we have learned to price for. Around 40% of new businesses fail in the first couple of years. That risk was not priced appropriately previously.The reason [the margin on loans] is higher is the risk we have learned to price for. Around 40% of new businesses fail in the first couple of years. That risk was not priced appropriately previously.
UpdatedUpdated
at 5.16am BSTat 5.16am BST
5.09am BST5.09am BST
05:0905:09
Labor wants more time to question CBA chief Ian NarevLabor wants more time to question CBA chief Ian Narev
Labor’s Matt Thistlethwaite has concluded questioning but rattles off several topics he didn’t get round to, including the review of Commonwealth Bank financial advice and Future of Financial Advice reforms.Labor’s Matt Thistlethwaite has concluded questioning but rattles off several topics he didn’t get round to, including the review of Commonwealth Bank financial advice and Future of Financial Advice reforms.
Are you willing to come back? I simply don’t have enough time: I have two days worth of questions to ask on behalf of the Australian people.Are you willing to come back? I simply don’t have enough time: I have two days worth of questions to ask on behalf of the Australian people.
Ian Narev, replies that he has appeared as requested and he is happy to leave the issue of whether a further hearing is required to the chairman, Liberal David Coleman.Ian Narev, replies that he has appeared as requested and he is happy to leave the issue of whether a further hearing is required to the chairman, Liberal David Coleman.
Liberal MP Craig Kelly is now asking about defaults on debt and has established there have been fewer since 2010. It’s a set up for a question about why business lending interest rates haven’t dropped more if default rates are low.Liberal MP Craig Kelly is now asking about defaults on debt and has established there have been fewer since 2010. It’s a set up for a question about why business lending interest rates haven’t dropped more if default rates are low.
Narev said the bank needs to take a “through the cycle view” to consider that default rates might rise again in future.Narev said the bank needs to take a “through the cycle view” to consider that default rates might rise again in future.
UpdatedUpdated
at 5.12am BSTat 5.12am BST
5.01am BST5.01am BST
05:0105:01
Matt Thistlethwaite has asked about performance targets and league tables of the financial performance of CBA branches.Matt Thistlethwaite has asked about performance targets and league tables of the financial performance of CBA branches.
Ian Narev replies that financial results are “an input” into assessing branch performance, but they are more dependent on the overall performance of the economy.Ian Narev replies that financial results are “an input” into assessing branch performance, but they are more dependent on the overall performance of the economy.
Asked if individuals would be performance managed as a result of financial results, Narev replied:Asked if individuals would be performance managed as a result of financial results, Narev replied:
There’s no direct link between a branch performing above level X or below level Y and any consequence at the branch or individual level.”There’s no direct link between a branch performing above level X or below level Y and any consequence at the branch or individual level.”
4.55am BST4.55am BST
04:5504:55
Labor’s Matt Thistlethwaite has asked about the Commonwealth Bank’s insurance division and why it took CommInsure’s former chief medical officer, Dr Benjamin Koh, blowing the whistle to discover allegations that doctors were asked to change their assessments to deny claims.Labor’s Matt Thistlethwaite has asked about the Commonwealth Bank’s insurance division and why it took CommInsure’s former chief medical officer, Dr Benjamin Koh, blowing the whistle to discover allegations that doctors were asked to change their assessments to deny claims.
Narev said the bank has a “very, very different view from the former chief medical officer about the substantive issues of assessment of claims”.Narev said the bank has a “very, very different view from the former chief medical officer about the substantive issues of assessment of claims”.
Chief risk officer, David Cohen, said Koh’s claims were being investigated by the chief risk officer and chief legal officer when Koh went to Four Corners with the claims.Chief risk officer, David Cohen, said Koh’s claims were being investigated by the chief risk officer and chief legal officer when Koh went to Four Corners with the claims.
UpdatedUpdated
at 5.04am BSTat 5.04am BST
4.46am BST4.46am BST
04:4604:46
Gareth HutchensGareth Hutchens
As Ian Narev faces questions about his bank’s financial planning scandal, the Reserve Bank has kept the official cash rate unchanged at 1.5%.As Ian Narev faces questions about his bank’s financial planning scandal, the Reserve Bank has kept the official cash rate unchanged at 1.5%.
The new RBA governor, Phil Lowe, says inflation remains “quite low” and he expects it to remain low for some time.The new RBA governor, Phil Lowe, says inflation remains “quite low” and he expects it to remain low for some time.
He’s listed the reasons:He’s listed the reasons:
UpdatedUpdated
at 4.52am BSTat 4.52am BST
4.45am BST
04:45
Narev gives an update on the financial advice review program, which has looked at 10 years of complaints. He said the review found 800 cases of poor advice out of hundreds of thousands who had received advice in that time.
The figure is just 10% of the people who applied to have their advice reviewed, Narev said, correcting Labor’s Matt Thistlethwaite who construed the figure as 10% of all consumers receiving poor advice.
Updated
at 4.50am BST
4.41am BST
04:41
The chairman of the committee has raised the concept of a one-stop banking tribunal to allow consumers to pursue redress in an environment more simple than a court as Liberal MP Warren Entsch has called for.
Ian Narev said the Commonwealth Bank is “very open” to discussions about the tribunal.
We’re for any work that can be done that allows customers to be heard.
Narev said he wanted such a body to be cost-efficient and the architecture to be very clear. He accepted that the “industry would have a role in funding it” and said introduction of a new tribunal would need to clarify what happens to existing avenues for redress.
Updated
at 4.48am BST
4.33am BST
04:33
The third topic is interest rates. Chairman David Coleman has asked why Commonwealth Bank doesn’t offer interest rates that track the increases and decreases of changes in the official cash rate.
Ian Narev replies:
The Reserve Bank cash rate is an important benchmark but a large number of funding costs exist irrespective of that benchmark. If we were to provide such a product, we would need to take into account all potential factors on the costs of funds.
He gives as an example new regulations in the US which come into effect next week and which he says will “materially change” the amount and price of short term borrowing.
Coleman foreshadows the committee may recommend banks be forced to provide interest rates that track the official rate, which would prevent banks refusing to pass on rate cuts.
Updated
at 4.44am BST
4.24am BST
04:24
The second question from chairman, David Coleman, is about financial advice.
Ian Narev concedes: “We did not act with the requisite speed … on financial advice matters.”
The Commonwealth Bank chief executive said the bank had already paid out $52m in the first round of remediation for poor financial advice, and has made a further $11m of payouts.
4.22am BST
04:22
The first question is about CommInsure. Narev said that after criticism of the definition of heart attacks being used to deny customers payouts, 17 customers received a payout using a fairer definition applied retrospectively.
4.18am BST
04:18
Narev predicts more cases of poor customer outcomes and compensation
The only two witnesses at the committee table are Commonwealth Bank chief executive, Ian Narev, and chief risk officer, David Cohen.
Narev has delivered an opening statement that the bank comes to the hearings in the “spirit of openness”.
The chief executive said banking regulation is about balancing “strength and fairness”. “You cannot have a prosperous economy unless banks are strong,” he warned.
Narev said banks have to balance the demands of borrowers and businesses who want cheap credit, depositors who want higher returns, and returns for shareholders.
He foreshadows that the two main concerns of the committee will be bank profitability and “the unequal power between banks and their customers”.
I have personally met with customers we have let down ... I have said before how sorry we are for the pain we’ve caused them, and I say so again today.
Narev paints problems as arising from a combination of human error and defective processes and promises to make changes to the root causes of problems.
As we do this work I expect there will be cases of more poor customer outcomes. And there will undoubtedly be more announcements of compensation due to customers, which will include some significant monetary amounts ...
Critics will paint these as signs of ongoing problems, actually they’re signs of how serious we are about fairness.
Updated
at 4.36am BST
4.01am BST
04:01
The committee hearing has just kicked off, for those who’d like to watch along a live stream is available. Chairman David Coleman has just rattled off the committee’s terms of references and is going through house rules now.
Updated
at 4.35am BST
3.56am BST
03:56
The director of policy and campaigns at the Consumer Action Law Centre, Denise Boyd, has told ABC24 the committee hearings are unlikely to make calls for a royal commission go away but “if the CEOs of the big banks … are being asked some searching questions about their policies and practices, within their businesses, that’s got to be a good thing for all Australians”.
Boyd said she wants the committee to examine credit cards because half of the Consumer Action Law Centre’s clients face credit card debts of more than $10,000
There are really high interest rates that apply for those when interest rates in Australia are at record lows so we’d like to know how the banks justify charging those high rates.
There is a duty of care. Everybody has got their own personal responsibility but for a bunch of reasons, people do fall into difficult circumstances and by the time they have racked up … more than $10,000 worth of debt, that is a long way back.
3.46am BST
03:46
Before the action kicks off at 2pm AEDT, you’ll want to know who is on the house committee on economics. It consists of six government MPs, three from Labor and Greens MP Adam Bandt. Its chair is the Liberal Party’s David Coleman, the deputy chair is Labor’s Matt Thistlethwaite.
One government MP on the committee, Craig Kelly, is an outspoken critic of excessive credit card late fees which he has labelled a “plain rip-off”. Kelly has also expressed support for a proposal from MP Warren Entsch calling for bank victims to be compensated by a special tribunal rather than set up a royal commission that can’t grant compensation.
The other MPs on the committee are: Liberals Julia Banks, Scott Buchholz and Trevor Evans; The Nationals’ Kevin Hogan; and Labor’s Pat Conroy and Matt Keogh.
I’ll bring you a list of Commonwealth Bank witnesses when we have it.
Updated
at 4.33am BST
3.32am BST
03:32
Hello and welcome to our live blog on the first day of parliamentary committee hearings into the big four banks. Tuesday’s hearing will focus on the Commonwealth Bank, followed by ANZ on Wednesday and then NAB and Westpac on Thursday.
In August, Malcolm Turnbull announced the new review mechanism in response to Labor pressure for a royal commission into banks. The House of Representatives Standing Committee on Economics will hear from the big four at least once a year.
Its terms of reference include questioning the banks on their decisions about whether to pass on interest rate cuts, as well as how they plan to enhance consumer protections. That will be where Labor wants the main action, as it’s a juicy opportunity to raise allegations of rate rigging and claims insurers systematically delayed payouts to sick and dying customers.
Opposition frontbencher Matt Thistlethwaite, deputy chair of the committee, has indicated he will ask about industry scandals, credit card interest rates and commissions that encourage staff to push customers into products that may not be right for them.
After calling for a bank royal commission in April, Labor has indicated it will continue to push for a fuller inquiry. The government points to the new accountability mechanism and powers for the Australian Securities and Investment Commission as sufficient to regulate the banks.
Let’s see whether Commonwealth Bank chief executive, Ian Narev, and other executives can convince the committee the industry is well-regulated or whether the hearings add to calls for a royal commission.
Comments for the live blog are open – so please contribute your take on proceedings below. You can contact me on Twitter @Paul_Karp.
Updated
at 4.32am BST