This article is from the source 'guardian' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/live/2016/nov/04/how-do-you-stay-happy-in-winter-join-our-live-look-at-the-week
The article has changed 5 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 1 | Version 2 |
|---|---|
| Do you know about these obscure household chores? Join our live look at the week | Do you know about these obscure household chores? Join our live look at the week |
| (35 minutes later) | |
| 3.29pm GMT | |
| 15:29 | |
| Everyone's a comedian – even social workers ... | |
| Norman Miller | |
| With the Guardian tracking social workers Debbie Greaves and Jim McGrath on a stand-up tour based on their often difficult day jobs, plus Jo Brand’s TV series Damned offering plentiful moments to wince on Channel 4, social work and its dealings with troubled folk are in the comedy spotlight. | |
| But is it important that those creating this sort of comedy have personal experience at the sharp end? (Brand worked for many years in psychiatric nursing.) Can any decent writer wring comic gold from a difficult subject through imagination and a bit of research alone – or is that the route to an offensive comedy pig’s ear? | |
| 3.20pm GMT | |
| 15:20 | |
| In response to our colleague Martin Belam below the line a reader shares their commendation ... | |
| Martin, I would just like to commend you on the sterling piece of hard hitting investigative journalism you did on the travails of Dave the Earthworm | |
| Who is Dave the earthworm? | |
| Sad news folks – that should have been who was Dave the earthworm ... | |
| 3.07pm GMT | 3.07pm GMT |
| 15:07 | 15:07 |
| On the subject of homework ... | On the subject of homework ... |
| As an educator with 39 plus years of experience I would say the amount of homework assigned in the uk,is excessive. Way to much no need for,it. Just as the constant testing and exams are over the top. One never has time to,teach. As the saying goes, weighing the baby all the time leaves no time for feeding | As an educator with 39 plus years of experience I would say the amount of homework assigned in the uk,is excessive. Way to much no need for,it. Just as the constant testing and exams are over the top. One never has time to,teach. As the saying goes, weighing the baby all the time leaves no time for feeding |
| Only homework at primary school should be learning spellings and times tables. 5 days a week is long enough to teach. | Only homework at primary school should be learning spellings and times tables. 5 days a week is long enough to teach. |
| What make me laugh sometimes is how forgetful people around my age are, 29, some of them seem to think their little one is getting more homework than they did but I member at 6/7 get spelling lists to memories 20 to 30 words, maths worksheets to do, 2 or 3 books a week to read those little one sentence a page books and then at secondary school homework was pretty much unending. If I can do it with no long term effects and as a person who is hard of hearing and has speech difficulties, I'm sure my friends perfectly healthy kids will cope just fine. | What make me laugh sometimes is how forgetful people around my age are, 29, some of them seem to think their little one is getting more homework than they did but I member at 6/7 get spelling lists to memories 20 to 30 words, maths worksheets to do, 2 or 3 books a week to read those little one sentence a page books and then at secondary school homework was pretty much unending. If I can do it with no long term effects and as a person who is hard of hearing and has speech difficulties, I'm sure my friends perfectly healthy kids will cope just fine. |
| 2.50pm GMT | 2.50pm GMT |
| 14:50 | 14:50 |
| The 10 household chores you need only do once a year | The 10 household chores you need only do once a year |
| Tim Dowling | Tim Dowling |
| Earlier in the week I wrote a piece about the Good Housekeeping Institute’s claim that there are 10 household chores you need only do once a year. They made it sound as if they were cutting us all some slack, but there were chores on their list I simply hadn’t heard of - who wipes down their lightbulbs? It turns out my lightbulbs are pretty dirty, but I was happier not knowing. | Earlier in the week I wrote a piece about the Good Housekeeping Institute’s claim that there are 10 household chores you need only do once a year. They made it sound as if they were cutting us all some slack, but there were chores on their list I simply hadn’t heard of - who wipes down their lightbulbs? It turns out my lightbulbs are pretty dirty, but I was happier not knowing. |
| Given the comments, it seemed a lot of people felt the same way - that if you can get away with not doing a chore for a whole year, then it can probably wait another year, or ten. Just last night I went to see a stand-up who quoted one of her ex-husband’s frequent criticisms - “I’ve never seen you wash a door,” he said. Before that, the idea had never occurred to her. | Given the comments, it seemed a lot of people felt the same way - that if you can get away with not doing a chore for a whole year, then it can probably wait another year, or ten. Just last night I went to see a stand-up who quoted one of her ex-husband’s frequent criticisms - “I’ve never seen you wash a door,” he said. Before that, the idea had never occurred to her. |
| What household chores have you escaped through sheer ignorance of their existence? Come and spoil it for the rest of us. | What household chores have you escaped through sheer ignorance of their existence? Come and spoil it for the rest of us. |
| 2.05pm GMT | 2.05pm GMT |
| 14:05 | 14:05 |
| Are parents right to rebel over homework? | Are parents right to rebel over homework? |
| Martin Belam | Martin Belam |
| Parents in Spain are protesting over the level of homework that is set for their children. A 2012 found that Spanish 15-year-olds have 6.5 hours of homework a week, nearly one-and-a-half hours more a week than the average. And children from the ages of three to six in the country are apparently doing half an hour’s homework every day. Parents are being given letters to send to schools by a campaign group, urging headteachers not to set homework. | Parents in Spain are protesting over the level of homework that is set for their children. A 2012 found that Spanish 15-year-olds have 6.5 hours of homework a week, nearly one-and-a-half hours more a week than the average. And children from the ages of three to six in the country are apparently doing half an hour’s homework every day. Parents are being given letters to send to schools by a campaign group, urging headteachers not to set homework. |
| It is a touchy subject for parents. I don’t remember having any homework until I was in secondary school, but my seven year old daughter has a “homework menu” which she can choose to do some things from each half-term. She’s also expected to do reading at home nearly every night. It isn’t over-burdensome, but it does sometimes take a chunk out of our weekend when we could be doing things that are perhaps a bit more fun for all the family. | It is a touchy subject for parents. I don’t remember having any homework until I was in secondary school, but my seven year old daughter has a “homework menu” which she can choose to do some things from each half-term. She’s also expected to do reading at home nearly every night. It isn’t over-burdensome, but it does sometimes take a chunk out of our weekend when we could be doing things that are perhaps a bit more fun for all the family. |
| We asked readers from around the world what they thought of the amount of homework given to their children. Craig in Romania told us “My son often stays up until midnight finishing off homework” and Zainab from London said “My son is constantly stressed about work and no longer sees learning as fun.” | We asked readers from around the world what they thought of the amount of homework given to their children. Craig in Romania told us “My son often stays up until midnight finishing off homework” and Zainab from London said “My son is constantly stressed about work and no longer sees learning as fun.” |
| What do you think? Do children get too much homework? Does it impact on family life too much? Or should kids just knuckle down and get on with it? | What do you think? Do children get too much homework? Does it impact on family life too much? Or should kids just knuckle down and get on with it? |
| Updated | Updated |
| at 2.08pm GMT | at 2.08pm GMT |
| 1.46pm GMT | 1.46pm GMT |
| 13:46 | 13:46 |
| Caelainn Barr | Caelainn Barr |
| On polls, here’s something from data journalist Caelainn Barr. | On polls, here’s something from data journalist Caelainn Barr. |
| Donald Trump has been gaining ground in the polls since the announcement by the FBI that it has discovered new emails that may relate to Hillary Clinton’s use of a private server during her time as secretary of state. | Donald Trump has been gaining ground in the polls since the announcement by the FBI that it has discovered new emails that may relate to Hillary Clinton’s use of a private server during her time as secretary of state. |
| One of the problems with many of the polls we’ve seen this week is the margin of error, or by how many points the polls could be wrong. In most cases this has been greater than the lead taken by either candidate. | One of the problems with many of the polls we’ve seen this week is the margin of error, or by how many points the polls could be wrong. In most cases this has been greater than the lead taken by either candidate. |
| As Trump and Clinton make their final campaign push in key swing states what now ultimately matters is who goes out and votes next Tuesday and the narrowing polls could help boost turnout. | As Trump and Clinton make their final campaign push in key swing states what now ultimately matters is who goes out and votes next Tuesday and the narrowing polls could help boost turnout. |
| Updated | Updated |
| at 1.47pm GMT | at 1.47pm GMT |
| 1.30pm GMT | 1.30pm GMT |
| 13:30 | 13:30 |
| Are you worried about the US election? | Are you worried about the US election? |
| James Walsh | James Walsh |
| But how about something that could make make a lot of people very unhappy? Here’s James Walsh on the US election. | But how about something that could make make a lot of people very unhappy? Here’s James Walsh on the US election. |
| It’s been one of the most controversial US elections ever. After a seemingly endless campaign, pockmarked with moments of unprecedented outrage and farce, decision day is nearly upon us. Barring a repeat of the 2000 election, when the Florida election recount delayed things somewhat, by this time next week either Donald Trump or Hillary Clinton* will be in the White House. | It’s been one of the most controversial US elections ever. After a seemingly endless campaign, pockmarked with moments of unprecedented outrage and farce, decision day is nearly upon us. Barring a repeat of the 2000 election, when the Florida election recount delayed things somewhat, by this time next week either Donald Trump or Hillary Clinton* will be in the White House. |
| A quick glance at our busy comments threads will reveal there’s been a lot of anxiety about this election, both from our US readers and those watching nervously from afar. | A quick glance at our busy comments threads will reveal there’s been a lot of anxiety about this election, both from our US readers and those watching nervously from afar. |
| Have you been worrying about the US election? Take part in our poll and discuss your own personal heebie jeebies in the comments below. | Have you been worrying about the US election? Take part in our poll and discuss your own personal heebie jeebies in the comments below. |
| *For those of you about to ask “but what about Gary Johnson?”, let me point you in the direction of this Simpsons clip. | *For those of you about to ask “but what about Gary Johnson?”, let me point you in the direction of this Simpsons clip. |
| **Like polls? Here’s another. | **Like polls? Here’s another. |
| 1.28pm GMT | 1.28pm GMT |
| 13:28 | 13:28 |
| Picture of the day? | Picture of the day? |
| Talking of staying happy, this young panda featured in the latest of our pictures of the day roundups might make you smile ... | Talking of staying happy, this young panda featured in the latest of our pictures of the day roundups might make you smile ... |
| Updated | Updated |
| at 1.28pm GMT | at 1.28pm GMT |
| 1.13pm GMT | 1.13pm GMT |
| 13:13 | 13:13 |
| A couple more of your comments so far – how do you stay happy? | A couple more of your comments so far – how do you stay happy? |
| The drink. | The drink. |
| It will be dusk/dark here by 4.30pm and being a 'night owl' I love it, and actually feel more awake in the dark evenings. My husband is the opposite, which makes for problems sometimes in winter when he accuses me of being crepuscular, verging on the nocturnal. However, I once visited the Lofotens (beautiful) and the continual half light did eventually become a little depressing, so I can see how this could be a medical issue and a serious problem for some people. | It will be dusk/dark here by 4.30pm and being a 'night owl' I love it, and actually feel more awake in the dark evenings. My husband is the opposite, which makes for problems sometimes in winter when he accuses me of being crepuscular, verging on the nocturnal. However, I once visited the Lofotens (beautiful) and the continual half light did eventually become a little depressing, so I can see how this could be a medical issue and a serious problem for some people. |
| I force myself to get outdoors. Where possible I walk in some woods. The British climate is designed to be spent in the woods. Anyone who hasn't figured that out yet hasn't been born. | I force myself to get outdoors. Where possible I walk in some woods. The British climate is designed to be spent in the woods. Anyone who hasn't figured that out yet hasn't been born. |
| Updated | Updated |
| at 1.14pm GMT | at 1.14pm GMT |
| 12.39pm GMT | 12.39pm GMT |
| 12:39 | 12:39 |
| In an earlier discussion on winter and SAD in the Gardens section, there was a tremendous comment from Cryptic Mirror that you might consider putting ATL here with the others. | In an earlier discussion on winter and SAD in the Gardens section, there was a tremendous comment from Cryptic Mirror that you might consider putting ATL here with the others. |
| Good spot, Tenthred ... here it is | Good spot, Tenthred ... here it is |
| I've bought one of those miracle-gro aero-gradens, and the light from it helps combat my SAD as well as giving me fresh flowers -nothing fancy, just calendulas- in the winter. It does really help and I completely recommend it to anyone who has SAD. It is a light-box and mini-garden all in one. | I've bought one of those miracle-gro aero-gradens, and the light from it helps combat my SAD as well as giving me fresh flowers -nothing fancy, just calendulas- in the winter. It does really help and I completely recommend it to anyone who has SAD. It is a light-box and mini-garden all in one. |
| 12.12pm GMT | 12.12pm GMT |
| 12:12 | 12:12 |
| Conversation of the week – how do you stay happy in winter? | Conversation of the week – how do you stay happy in winter? |
| Guardian readers | Guardian readers |
| Several writers lit up our pages this week with a celebration of what they were calling “one of the great impalpable joys of life”. But what happens when we don’t get enough light? One answer seems to be seasonal affective disorder, and readers had an interesting discussion beneath this piece looking at therapy lamps that aim to halt it. | Several writers lit up our pages this week with a celebration of what they were calling “one of the great impalpable joys of life”. But what happens when we don’t get enough light? One answer seems to be seasonal affective disorder, and readers had an interesting discussion beneath this piece looking at therapy lamps that aim to halt it. |
| ‘Winters have made me ill since I was a small child’ | ‘Winters have made me ill since I was a small child’ |
| Winters have made me ill since I was a small child. I am fine in other countries that have clear days with bright sunlight, just shorter hours of it, but the endless grey halflight of the UK is unbearable. | Winters have made me ill since I was a small child. I am fine in other countries that have clear days with bright sunlight, just shorter hours of it, but the endless grey halflight of the UK is unbearable. |
| I have been using one of these sunrise alarms clocks for over a decade, through most of which I had such long working hours I had to survive on 4/5 hours sleep. Even when you are exhausted these lamps work, waking you up gradually rather than jolting you awake with loud noise. | I have been using one of these sunrise alarms clocks for over a decade, through most of which I had such long working hours I had to survive on 4/5 hours sleep. Even when you are exhausted these lamps work, waking you up gradually rather than jolting you awake with loud noise. |
| I also have a SAD desk lamp at my office. It has transformed winters for me. Arriving at work in the dark, leaving in the dark and sitting away from natural light would previously make me feel more and more run down, even when going out to get some quick natural light at lunchtime and making the most of opportunities to get out in sunshine at weekends (few and far between!). I cannot recommend these lamps enough to anybody who struggles with the incessant greyness of the UK. | I also have a SAD desk lamp at my office. It has transformed winters for me. Arriving at work in the dark, leaving in the dark and sitting away from natural light would previously make me feel more and more run down, even when going out to get some quick natural light at lunchtime and making the most of opportunities to get out in sunshine at weekends (few and far between!). I cannot recommend these lamps enough to anybody who struggles with the incessant greyness of the UK. |
| ‘Using a light box is a good way to go’ | ‘Using a light box is a good way to go’ |
| A large study in the Netherlands found that sunlight hours correlated to levels of Brain-Derived Neurotrophic Factor (BDNF) - low in winter high in summer - which is very important to neurogenesis and found to be low in many mental illness. So it seems using a light box is a good way to go. | A large study in the Netherlands found that sunlight hours correlated to levels of Brain-Derived Neurotrophic Factor (BDNF) - low in winter high in summer - which is very important to neurogenesis and found to be low in many mental illness. So it seems using a light box is a good way to go. |
| https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3487856/ | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3487856/ |
| ‘Even better if combined with a bit of light exercise’ | ‘Even better if combined with a bit of light exercise’ |
| I have a 'LitePod' standing on my desk next to my computer while I do a morning check of emails etc. Light therapy works best in the early morning. Works for me. I also get out in natural daylight as much as I can, even better if combined with a bit of light exercise sweeping up leaves in the garden. Then I'm lucky enough to have a garden that I can go out in to and a large greenhouse that I can sit in the end of having a cuppa (with the door open so that I get direct sunlight in to the eyes). Low sunlight levels during the winter also coincide with cold air and wet roads or I'd indulge more in the equally beneficial "RAM" treatment (Riding A Motorcycle). | I have a 'LitePod' standing on my desk next to my computer while I do a morning check of emails etc. Light therapy works best in the early morning. Works for me. I also get out in natural daylight as much as I can, even better if combined with a bit of light exercise sweeping up leaves in the garden. Then I'm lucky enough to have a garden that I can go out in to and a large greenhouse that I can sit in the end of having a cuppa (with the door open so that I get direct sunlight in to the eyes). Low sunlight levels during the winter also coincide with cold air and wet roads or I'd indulge more in the equally beneficial "RAM" treatment (Riding A Motorcycle). |
| What do you think? | What do you think? |
| 11.57am GMT | 11.57am GMT |
| 11:57 | 11:57 |
| Welcome to our social | Welcome to our social |
| Sarah Marsh | Sarah Marsh |
| Hello all, and welcome to our weekly social, where we discuss the best of the week in terms of news and comment with our readers. We have a lot of interesting reading lined up for you today to trigger debate. Tell us if there are any topics that you’re keen to talk about by tweeting @GuardianOpinion or emailing sarah.marsh@theguardian.com | Hello all, and welcome to our weekly social, where we discuss the best of the week in terms of news and comment with our readers. We have a lot of interesting reading lined up for you today to trigger debate. Tell us if there are any topics that you’re keen to talk about by tweeting @GuardianOpinion or emailing sarah.marsh@theguardian.com |
| Anyway, let’s get started. We will be here from 12pm-4.30pm (GMT). | Anyway, let’s get started. We will be here from 12pm-4.30pm (GMT). |
| Updated | Updated |
| at 12.00pm GMT | at 12.00pm GMT |