This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It will not be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://news.bbc.co.uk/go/rss/-/1/hi/health/7422418.stm
The article has changed 3 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 1 | Version 2 |
|---|---|
| Heart failure guidance 'ignored' | Heart failure guidance 'ignored' |
| (40 minutes later) | |
| Many GPs, and even some hospital specialists, are failing to follow guidelines for managing heart failure, a Europe-wide survey suggests. | Many GPs, and even some hospital specialists, are failing to follow guidelines for managing heart failure, a Europe-wide survey suggests. |
| British GPs frequently did not use recommended tests or drugs, which the researchers said could be unsafe. | British GPs frequently did not use recommended tests or drugs, which the researchers said could be unsafe. |
| The European Heart Journal report said the results were "very worrying". | The European Heart Journal report said the results were "very worrying". |
| However, one specialist GP disputed whether the survey answers were clear evidence of poor practice among family doctors in the UK. | However, one specialist GP disputed whether the survey answers were clear evidence of poor practice among family doctors in the UK. |
| I find these figures very worrying as guidelines are the only source of information which gives management advice in a complete and unbiased way Professor Willem RemmeStudy author | I find these figures very worrying as guidelines are the only source of information which gives management advice in a complete and unbiased way Professor Willem RemmeStudy author |
| Heart failure is a common disease of old age, with approximately 67,000 new cases diagnosed in the UK every year. | Heart failure is a common disease of old age, with approximately 67,000 new cases diagnosed in the UK every year. |
| The study found that while 94% of UK hospital cardiologists would use an echocardiograph test, 69% of GPs said that they could make the diagnosis on symptoms and other signs alone. | The study found that while 94% of UK hospital cardiologists would use an echocardiograph test, 69% of GPs said that they could make the diagnosis on symptoms and other signs alone. |
| Only half the GPs who answered the survey said they often needed other tests to confirm the diagnosis, the team led by the Sticares Cardiovascular Research Foundation in the Netherlands reported. | Only half the GPs who answered the survey said they often needed other tests to confirm the diagnosis, the team led by the Sticares Cardiovascular Research Foundation in the Netherlands reported. |
| Only a quarter of GPs said they could get echocardiography tests for their patients within a month - compared to three quarters of French primary care doctors, 90% in Germany, and 51% in Italy. | Only a quarter of GPs said they could get echocardiography tests for their patients within a month - compared to three quarters of French primary care doctors, 90% in Germany, and 51% in Italy. |
| Drug mistakes | Drug mistakes |
| Having made their diagnosis, just over a third of UK GPs opted for a treatment using ACE inhibitors, with well over half appearing to choose diuretic drugs alone, a practice described as "unsafe" by the study authors. | Having made their diagnosis, just over a third of UK GPs opted for a treatment using ACE inhibitors, with well over half appearing to choose diuretic drugs alone, a practice described as "unsafe" by the study authors. |
| No-one is going to turn around and say that heart failure care in the UK is perfect, but I don't think that we are performing that badly Dr Terry McCormackPrimary Care Cardiovascular Society | No-one is going to turn around and say that heart failure care in the UK is perfect, but I don't think that we are performing that badly Dr Terry McCormackPrimary Care Cardiovascular Society |
| However, Dr Terry McCormack, a Yorkshire GP and chairman of the UK Primary Care Cardiovascular Society, said that European guidelines did not exactly match those in the UK, and there were reasonable arguments for using diuretics as a first step while awaiting test results. | |
| "No-one is going to turn around and say that heart failure care in the UK is perfect, but I don't think that we are performing that badly. | "No-one is going to turn around and say that heart failure care in the UK is perfect, but I don't think that we are performing that badly. |
| "We are pretty good for getting echocardiagrams, and pretty good for the use of ACE inhibitors and beta blockers." | "We are pretty good for getting echocardiagrams, and pretty good for the use of ACE inhibitors and beta blockers." |
| Among the specialists, ACE inhibitors were more commonly prescribed, with 85% of UK cardiologists saying they used them in at least nine out of 10 patients, well above the European average. | |
| Professor Willem Remme, who led the study, said that many doctors were aware that the guidelines existed, but had not read them, or chose not to follow them. | Professor Willem Remme, who led the study, said that many doctors were aware that the guidelines existed, but had not read them, or chose not to follow them. |
| "I find these figures very worrying as guidelines are the only source of information which gives management advice in a complete and unbiased way, based on data from controlled studies or real expert opinion." | "I find these figures very worrying as guidelines are the only source of information which gives management advice in a complete and unbiased way, based on data from controlled studies or real expert opinion." |
| Professor Peter Weissberg, medical director for the British Heart Foundation, said: "The main message from this study is that heart failure patients get better treatment if they are managed by a specialist." |