This article is from the source 'guardian' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.

You can find the current article at its original source at https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2016/nov/29/donald-tusk-turns-on-tories-in-row-over-rights-of-eu-citizens-in-uk

The article has changed 9 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.

Version 1 Version 2
Donald Tusk turns on Tories in row over rights of EU citizens in UK Donald Tusk blames British voters for expats' EU uncertainty Donald Tusk blames British voters for expats' EU uncertainty
(about 2 hours later)
Donald Tusk has accused dozens of Conservative MPs of making an argument that “has nothing to do with reality” in an astonishing row over the rights of EU citizens living in the UK and British people living overseas. Donald Tusk has appeared to blame the UK electorate for causing “anxiety and uncertainty” for millions of British and EU citizens living abroad, in an extraordinary letter that immediately embroiled him in a row with Conservative MPs.
The president of the European council responded to a letter sent by 80 British parliamentarians in which they warned that the European commission was making it harder to end the “anxiety and uncertainty” for citizens by refusing to discuss a reciprocal agreement over the issue. The president of the European council wrote to a group of 80 mainly Tory MPs arguing that EU politicians could not be blamed for the impact of the Brexit vote and saying the real cause of the problems was the referendum result on 23 June.
Tusk hit back with a public letter in which he said the uncertainty had instead been caused by the decision of the British people to vote for Brexit and that the best way to dispel the fears was for Theresa May to trigger article 50 earlier than March next year. He accused the British parliamentarians of making an argument that “has nothing to do with reality” after they claimed in a letter that the lead EU negotiator for Brexit, Michel Barnier, was “worryingly indifferent to securing reciprocal rights for our and your resident citizens”.
He said: “In your letter you state that the European commission, and in particular [Michel] Barnier, are attempting to prevent negotiations, thereby creating ‘anxiety and uncertainty for the UK and EU citizens living in one another’s territories’. Tusk hit back in a letter he published on Twitter by pointing to the decision of the British public to back Brexit as the cause of uncertainty, and said the problem could be solved by Theresa May triggering article 50 as soon as possible.
“It is a very interesting argument, the only problem being that it had nothing to do with reality. Would you not agree that the only source of anxiety and uncertainty is rather the decision on Brexit? And that the only way to dispel the fears and doubts of all citizens concerned is the quickest possible start of the negotiations based on article 50 of the treaty?” “In your letter you state that the European commission, and in particular [Michel] Barnier, are attempting to prevent negotiations, thereby creating ‘anxiety and uncertainty for the UK and EU citizens living in one another’s territories’,” he said.
“It is a very interesting argument; the only problem being that it had nothing to do with reality. Would you not agree that the only source of anxiety and uncertainty is rather the decision on Brexit? And that the only way to dispel the fears and doubts of all citizens concerned is the quickest possible start of the negotiations based on article 50 of the treaty?”
The letter, organised by the Tory MPs Michael Tomlinson and Steve Baker, and signed by MPs including Michael Gove and Iain Duncan Smith, suggested that the issue of reciprocal rights was too important to wait until article 50 was triggered.
“[Barnier’s] attempts to prevent negotiations taking place on this issue between the democratically elected governments of EU member states are making it harder to achieve what is in everyone’s interest: ending the anxiety and uncertainty for UK and EU citizens living in one another’s territories,” it said.
My reply to the UK MPs on the status of EU citizens in the UK and UK citizens living and working in Europe: https://t.co/NR0KC80j3k pic.twitter.com/lBRQfv7rr5My reply to the UK MPs on the status of EU citizens in the UK and UK citizens living and working in Europe: https://t.co/NR0KC80j3k pic.twitter.com/lBRQfv7rr5
Tusk’s letter was addressed to UK parliamentarians but also specifically to Michael Tomlinson MP after he hit out at the German chancellor, Angela Merkel, accusing her of having “quit the moral high ground”. Tusk said the EU “stands ready” to negotiate Britain’s exit from the EU, including reciprocal rights, but could only do so once the process formally began. “Let me reiterate, however, that the decision about triggering article 50 belongs only to the UK, which we fully respect,” he said.
The Conservative MP’s attack was in response to reports suggesting Merkel would not guarantee reciprocal rights for UK citizens living in Germany until formal Brexit negotiations had begun, and had told May as much during a bilateral meeting. His letter came after Tomlinson hit out at the German chancellor, Angela Merkel, accusing her of having “quit the moral high ground” over the issue.
Tomlinson accused her of having “entered the fray with the implication that human beings will be traded tit for tat in a political playground”. The Conservative MP’s attack was in response to reports suggesting Merkel would not guarantee reciprocal rights for UK citizens living in Germany until formal Brexit negotiations had begun, and that she had told May as much during a bilateral meeting.
“I read with dismay the article on Politico that Angela Merkel, in common with Commissioner Michel Barnier, refused to engage in a civilised way on reciprocal rights and failed to give assurances that UK citizens living in Europe would remain entitled to live and work there,” said Tomlinson, who is deputy chair of the European Research Group (ERG) of MPs. Tomlinson accused Merkel of having “entered the fray with the implication that human beings will be traded ‘tit for tat’ in a political playground”.
In a letter to Tusk, Tomlinson attacked Barnier, the chief EU negotiator, for “obstructing member state negotiations on reciprocal rights”, accusing him of being “worryingly indifferent” to the “anxiety and uncertainty” of citizens in each territory. “I read with dismay the article on Politico that Angela Merkel, in common with Michel Barnier, refused to engage in a civilised way on reciprocal rights and failed to give assurances that UK citizens living in Europe would remain entitled to live and work there,” said Tomlinson, who is the deputy chair of the European research group of MPs.
He said agreeing reciprocal rights was the only “just and humane thing to do”, arguing that people were not “bargaining chips” or “cards to be traded”.Steve Baker, chair of the ERG, said: “Michel Barnier’s intransigence is inhumane. It is only compounded by the petulance of his recent tweet. He should apologise and immediately agree in principle the continuation of reciprocal rights for resident UK and EU citizens.” The former environment secretary Owen Paterson also criticised the German leader, suggesting that other countries were willing to try to reach an early deal. “Angela Merkel is wrong to be intransigent. She must act now to reassure millions of UK and EU resident citizens,” he said.
The Tory MP Julian Knight tweeted: “So I can now tell the worried EU citizens who do come to my surgery on this issue that it is the EU which is holding them to ransom.” Reacting to Tusk’s letter, the former work and pensions secretary Iain Duncan Smith said: “EU politicians should stop playing politics with people’s lives. They should agree to end the speculation and take away the anxiety that people feel about their futures. The EU yet again puts systems above people.”
Baker said: “The EU is doing the wrong thing, being defensive. It is on the back foot through sheer dogmatism, and now in the wrong.”
Tomlinson sent Tusk a direct message on Twitter saying his “response to my letter is disappointing and wrongheaded. He is putting EU process above and beyond human beings”.
The Tory MP Julian Knight said: “So I can now tell the worried EU citizens who do come to my surgery on this issue that it is the EU which is holding them to ransom.”
The row comes after the prime minister of Malta said Britain might not be in a position to trigger article 50 to begin leaving the EU by the government’s deadline of the end of March 2017.
Joseph Muscat, whose country takes over the EU’s rotating presidency in January, said he would not be surprised if legal proceedings resulted in the divorce between the UK and the EU being delayed.
Next week, the UK supreme court will hear a government appeal against a high court ruling that parliament must be consulted before article 50 can be invoked.
Muscat also said European leaders were “not bluffing” when they insisted that Britain would not retain the single market access it currently has if UK politicians also wanted to curb immigration, adding that the European parliament could veto any deal.