This article is from the source 'guardian' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.theguardian.com/world/2016/nov/30/croatia-anti-abortion-lobby-new-ways-get-message-across
The article has changed 7 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 0 | Version 1 |
|---|---|
| Croatia's anti-abortion lobby finds new ways to spread its message Croatia's anti-abortion lobby finds new ways to spread its message | |
| (about 1 hour later) | |
| Search the internet in Croatia for abortion clinics and the top result on Google appears, at first glance, to be a website offering information to women about the procedure. | Search the internet in Croatia for abortion clinics and the top result on Google appears, at first glance, to be a website offering information to women about the procedure. |
| But klinikazapobacaje.com is in reality part of a nation-wide campaign aimed at discouraging women from terminating their pregnancies. | But klinikazapobacaje.com is in reality part of a nation-wide campaign aimed at discouraging women from terminating their pregnancies. |
| Women who abort, the website claims, risk depression, sexual dysfunction, cancer, drug addiction and suicidal thoughts. | Women who abort, the website claims, risk depression, sexual dysfunction, cancer, drug addiction and suicidal thoughts. |
| One of the phone numbers it lists is for Meri Bilic, a woman who works at the Bethlehem Centre for Unborn Life, one of five facilities across Croatia offering refuge to pregnant women driven by family or financial circumstances to consider a termination. In exchange for keeping the foetus, the centres offer free board and lodging for a year. | One of the phone numbers it lists is for Meri Bilic, a woman who works at the Bethlehem Centre for Unborn Life, one of five facilities across Croatia offering refuge to pregnant women driven by family or financial circumstances to consider a termination. In exchange for keeping the foetus, the centres offer free board and lodging for a year. |
| Bilic and the Bethlehem centres are part of a growing movement to end abortion in predominantly Catholic Croatia, where a right to termination has been enshrined in law for decades but increasingly difficult for women to access. | Bilic and the Bethlehem centres are part of a growing movement to end abortion in predominantly Catholic Croatia, where a right to termination has been enshrined in law for decades but increasingly difficult for women to access. |
| The newest member of the European Union, Croatia has one of the lowest rates of abortion in Europe, falling dramatically since the country broke away from Yugoslavia in the 1990s, during a war that reawakened a sense of national identity rooted for many Croatians in their Catholic faith. | The newest member of the European Union, Croatia has one of the lowest rates of abortion in Europe, falling dramatically since the country broke away from Yugoslavia in the 1990s, during a war that reawakened a sense of national identity rooted for many Croatians in their Catholic faith. |
| A recent investigation suggests the official figures do not tell the whole story. | A recent investigation suggests the official figures do not tell the whole story. |
| Fearing stigma and blocked by a large number of doctors who refuse to perform abortions in public hospitals on grounds of faith, many Croatian women are forced to have unregistered terminations in private clinics. | Fearing stigma and blocked by a large number of doctors who refuse to perform abortions in public hospitals on grounds of faith, many Croatian women are forced to have unregistered terminations in private clinics. |
| Pregnant women who seek help due to family or financial problems are often directed by the state to Catholic-run shelters, which in Bethlehem’s case can include mix warnings of damnation with promises of salvation. | Pregnant women who seek help due to family or financial problems are often directed by the state to Catholic-run shelters, which in Bethlehem’s case can include mix warnings of damnation with promises of salvation. |
| With the rise to power in 2016 of a conservative government, the legal right to choose abortion is now under direct threat, echoing developments in Poland in October where only mass protests halted parliament from instituting a near-total ban on the procedure. | With the rise to power in 2016 of a conservative government, the legal right to choose abortion is now under direct threat, echoing developments in Poland in October where only mass protests halted parliament from instituting a near-total ban on the procedure. |
| It has parallels, too, with moves in the former Yugoslav republic of Macedonia to restrict abortion, and in Kosovo where social stigma is fuelling illegal terminations. | It has parallels, too, with moves in the former Yugoslav republic of Macedonia to restrict abortion, and in Kosovo where social stigma is fuelling illegal terminations. |
| “The position of women in society is … under threat [and] becoming the space where an ideological battle is being fought for the profile of Croatian society,” said Croatian sociologist Valerija Barada. | “The position of women in society is … under threat [and] becoming the space where an ideological battle is being fought for the profile of Croatian society,” said Croatian sociologist Valerija Barada. |
| In 1980, according to the World Health Organisation, there were 701 abortions per 1,000 live births in Croatia, then part of a socialist Yugoslav federation where abortion rates were generally high. | In 1980, according to the World Health Organisation, there were 701 abortions per 1,000 live births in Croatia, then part of a socialist Yugoslav federation where abortion rates were generally high. |
| The figure began falling rapidly with the outbreak of war in 1991 when Croatia declared independence, and by 2014 had dropped to 76 per 1,000 live births, the lowest rate in the Balkan region compared with 156 in Albania, 168 in Montenegro, 195 in Slovenia, 201 in Macedonia, 259 in Serbia, 401 in Romania and 416 in Bulgaria. | The figure began falling rapidly with the outbreak of war in 1991 when Croatia declared independence, and by 2014 had dropped to 76 per 1,000 live births, the lowest rate in the Balkan region compared with 156 in Albania, 168 in Montenegro, 195 in Slovenia, 201 in Macedonia, 259 in Serbia, 401 in Romania and 416 in Bulgaria. |
| A general fall in eastern Europe is partly explained by the more widespread use of effective contraception. But in Croatia there are other reasons too, rooted in a rise in “traditional values”. | A general fall in eastern Europe is partly explained by the more widespread use of effective contraception. But in Croatia there are other reasons too, rooted in a rise in “traditional values”. |
| Today, abortions in Croatia are allowed at public hospitals and one private clinic in the capital, Zagreb. But of 375 doctors certified to carry out the procedure, just over half refuse to do so on the basis of a 2003 law that introduced the right to conscientious objection, according to a 2014 report by the ombudsperson for gender equality. | Today, abortions in Croatia are allowed at public hospitals and one private clinic in the capital, Zagreb. But of 375 doctors certified to carry out the procedure, just over half refuse to do so on the basis of a 2003 law that introduced the right to conscientious objection, according to a 2014 report by the ombudsperson for gender equality. |
| Critics say the right to object is poorly regulated, leaving some areas of the country with barely any doctors prepared to carry out abortions. | Critics say the right to object is poorly regulated, leaving some areas of the country with barely any doctors prepared to carry out abortions. |
| The story of Sani, who asked for her surname not be used, is not unusual. When she fell pregnant in 2011 aged 18, the public hospital in Split told her none of its doctors performed abortions. So Sani called her gynaecologist. “She told me she’s bringing babies onto the earth, not killing them,” Sani said. | The story of Sani, who asked for her surname not be used, is not unusual. When she fell pregnant in 2011 aged 18, the public hospital in Split told her none of its doctors performed abortions. So Sani called her gynaecologist. “She told me she’s bringing babies onto the earth, not killing them,” Sani said. |
| Finally, Sani told her boyfriend’s parents, who arranged an abortion with a doctor in a private clinic. On Sani’s medical record, the termination is recorded as a miscarriage. She paid €340, more than twice the official average in public hospitals. | Finally, Sani told her boyfriend’s parents, who arranged an abortion with a doctor in a private clinic. On Sani’s medical record, the termination is recorded as a miscarriage. She paid €340, more than twice the official average in public hospitals. |
| “Hidden abortions” like Sani’s almost certainly account for the fact that while the number of legal abortions has fallen rapidly, the proportion of terminations registered as occurring for medical reasons has more than doubled from 21% to 48% between 1998 and 2014, according to state statistics. | “Hidden abortions” like Sani’s almost certainly account for the fact that while the number of legal abortions has fallen rapidly, the proportion of terminations registered as occurring for medical reasons has more than doubled from 21% to 48% between 1998 and 2014, according to state statistics. |
| This shift tallies with a broader shift in public discourse, in which women who terminate a pregnancy are vilified. | This shift tallies with a broader shift in public discourse, in which women who terminate a pregnancy are vilified. |
| In May, up to 10,000 people took part in a rally in Zagreb called March for Life, proclaiming the sanctity of the family. At the head of the march was the conservative movement’s most prominent leader, Željka Markić. Next to her was Sanja Orešković, the wife of the then prime minister Tihomir Orešković. | In May, up to 10,000 people took part in a rally in Zagreb called March for Life, proclaiming the sanctity of the family. At the head of the march was the conservative movement’s most prominent leader, Željka Markić. Next to her was Sanja Orešković, the wife of the then prime minister Tihomir Orešković. |
| “Every reasonable person will choose life over death, and everything else is just nonsense and fear,” Orešković told reporters. | “Every reasonable person will choose life over death, and everything else is just nonsense and fear,” Orešković told reporters. |
| It was the first march of its kind in Croatia, and a sign of the times. | It was the first march of its kind in Croatia, and a sign of the times. |
| In October, the Catholic anti-abortion activist group 40 Days for Life published on Facebook a call to prayer outside a hospital in the eastern town of Vukovar, where they had learned a woman was due to have an abortion there the next day. | In October, the Catholic anti-abortion activist group 40 Days for Life published on Facebook a call to prayer outside a hospital in the eastern town of Vukovar, where they had learned a woman was due to have an abortion there the next day. |
| The hospital ordered an internal investigation and the state attorney’s office ordered its own inquiry amid uproar among rights groups over how confidential medical details were leaked. | The hospital ordered an internal investigation and the state attorney’s office ordered its own inquiry amid uproar among rights groups over how confidential medical details were leaked. |
| Fighting ‘violence and lies’ | Fighting ‘violence and lies’ |
| Catholic clergyman Pater Marko Glogović opened the first Bethlehem house in 2010 in the town of Karlovac. The organisation now offers accommodation for 19 women and their children for up to a year. | Catholic clergyman Pater Marko Glogović opened the first Bethlehem house in 2010 in the town of Karlovac. The organisation now offers accommodation for 19 women and their children for up to a year. |
| Glogović said Karlovac centre had housed 70 pregnant women since opening, on condition they go through with the pregnancy. It has received more than €300,000 from unspecified donors over the past three years, according to financial reports filed at the ministry of finance. | Glogović said Karlovac centre had housed 70 pregnant women since opening, on condition they go through with the pregnancy. It has received more than €300,000 from unspecified donors over the past three years, according to financial reports filed at the ministry of finance. |
| The separation of religious principles from the state … is extremely important, but it’s not happening in this case | The separation of religious principles from the state … is extremely important, but it’s not happening in this case |
| “In general we are always full, but since mothers sometimes stay only a short time, we can always take in new ones,” Glogović. | “In general we are always full, but since mothers sometimes stay only a short time, we can always take in new ones,” Glogović. |
| He added that he had nothing to do with the abortion clinic website, but supported its intentions. “I did not encourage or create, nor am I the editor of this site, but I certainly give them my blessing as they are a symbol of the David versus Goliath fight against lies and violence towards women and children,” he said. | He added that he had nothing to do with the abortion clinic website, but supported its intentions. “I did not encourage or create, nor am I the editor of this site, but I certainly give them my blessing as they are a symbol of the David versus Goliath fight against lies and violence towards women and children,” he said. |
| Silvija Stanić, who runs an organisation called Step by Step which offers counselling and psychological support to young pregnant women, said she did not have any direct experience with Bethlehem but had reservations about their message. | Silvija Stanić, who runs an organisation called Step by Step which offers counselling and psychological support to young pregnant women, said she did not have any direct experience with Bethlehem but had reservations about their message. |
| “What I have heard about Bethlehem is that it’s a house for women to give birth in. If the alternative to sleeping under a bridge is an institution where she has a roof over her head, of course it is a rescue. But I wonder, at what price? | “What I have heard about Bethlehem is that it’s a house for women to give birth in. If the alternative to sleeping under a bridge is an institution where she has a roof over her head, of course it is a rescue. But I wonder, at what price? |
| “The separation of religious principles from the state … is extremely important, but it’s not happening in this case. This is experimentation with a person’s life,” Stanić said. | “The separation of religious principles from the state … is extremely important, but it’s not happening in this case. This is experimentation with a person’s life,” Stanić said. |
| Nevertheless, Bethlehem says it regularly receives referrals from the authorities. “Doctors and nurses will let us know if a girl needs help,” said Blaženka Bakula, the head of the Bethlehem house in Zagreb. The house she runs, she added, has “wonderful cooperation” with the Centre for Social Welfare, the main state welfare body. | Nevertheless, Bethlehem says it regularly receives referrals from the authorities. “Doctors and nurses will let us know if a girl needs help,” said Blaženka Bakula, the head of the Bethlehem house in Zagreb. The house she runs, she added, has “wonderful cooperation” with the Centre for Social Welfare, the main state welfare body. |
| The ministry of social policy and youth declined to comment. | The ministry of social policy and youth declined to comment. |
| The authorities have so far rejected criminal complaints about the abortion clinic website. In response to a complaint by the ombudsperson for gender equality, Višnja Ljubičić, the interior ministry said in early 2016 that it had found no criminal wrongdoing. | The authorities have so far rejected criminal complaints about the abortion clinic website. In response to a complaint by the ombudsperson for gender equality, Višnja Ljubičić, the interior ministry said in early 2016 that it had found no criminal wrongdoing. |
| Masenjka Bacic is a freelance print and broadcast journalist from Split. This article was produced as part of the Balkan Fellowship for Journalistic Excellence, supported by the ERSTE Foundation and Open Society Foundations, in cooperation with the Balkan Investigative Reporting Network. | Masenjka Bacic is a freelance print and broadcast journalist from Split. This article was produced as part of the Balkan Fellowship for Journalistic Excellence, supported by the ERSTE Foundation and Open Society Foundations, in cooperation with the Balkan Investigative Reporting Network. |