This article is from the source 'guardian' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2016/dec/06/oakland-fire-ghost-ship-transgender-victims-them-are-us-too
The article has changed 6 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 0 | Version 1 |
|---|---|
| For trans women killed by Oakland fire, struggle for respect continues in death | |
| (35 minutes later) | |
| Instead of grieving for her friends, Scout Wolfcave has spent the last two days phoning news reporters and begging them not to disrespect the transgender women who died by calling them “men” in their reports and refusing to use their proper names. | Instead of grieving for her friends, Scout Wolfcave has spent the last two days phoning news reporters and begging them not to disrespect the transgender women who died by calling them “men” in their reports and refusing to use their proper names. |
| Feral Pines, Cash Askew and Em B were victims of the devastating fire on Friday night at an Oakland warehouse, known as the Ghost Ship, where at least 36 people died, many of them young artists, musicians and activists. | Feral Pines, Cash Askew and Em B were victims of the devastating fire on Friday night at an Oakland warehouse, known as the Ghost Ship, where at least 36 people died, many of them young artists, musicians and activists. |
| In death, you can’t defend yourself anymore, so it falls on your friends to do it for you | In death, you can’t defend yourself anymore, so it falls on your friends to do it for you |
| The tragedy has sent shockwaves through the Bay Area underground music scene, but has been particularly painful for the tight-knit communities of trans people, who already face disproportionate levels of violence and discrimination and often flock to Oakland in search of safer spaces to live and make art. | The tragedy has sent shockwaves through the Bay Area underground music scene, but has been particularly painful for the tight-knit communities of trans people, who already face disproportionate levels of violence and discrimination and often flock to Oakland in search of safer spaces to live and make art. |
| Wolfcave, an Oregon-based trans woman and close friend of Pines, said that when the police and the media incorrectly use “he” pronouns for the women and refer to them by the names on their legal documents, it is deeply hurtful to the trans community. | Wolfcave, an Oregon-based trans woman and close friend of Pines, said that when the police and the media incorrectly use “he” pronouns for the women and refer to them by the names on their legal documents, it is deeply hurtful to the trans community. |
| “We fight hard enough every single day to be seen as our authentic selves and to be treated with respect,” said Wolfcave, 34, in an interview at a San Francisco bar on Monday night. “In death, you can’t defend yourself anymore, so it falls on your friends to do it for you.” | “We fight hard enough every single day to be seen as our authentic selves and to be treated with respect,” said Wolfcave, 34, in an interview at a San Francisco bar on Monday night. “In death, you can’t defend yourself anymore, so it falls on your friends to do it for you.” |
| Wolfcave, who recently founded an initiative called the Trans Assistance Project, said she was eager to shift the focus toward the lives and accomplishments of the women, who were well-known in local arts scenes and were role models to many trans women. | Wolfcave, who recently founded an initiative called the Trans Assistance Project, said she was eager to shift the focus toward the lives and accomplishments of the women, who were well-known in local arts scenes and were role models to many trans women. |
| Wolfcave said she considered Pines, 29, a sister, and that the two were roommates in Bloomington, Indiana. Pines recently relocated to Oakland where she found a “queer family” and community of trans artists and friends. | Wolfcave said she considered Pines, 29, a sister, and that the two were roommates in Bloomington, Indiana. Pines recently relocated to Oakland where she found a “queer family” and community of trans artists and friends. |
| In Indiana, Wolfcave said, she and Pines struggled to access basic health care or find steady employment. “Trans people move to the west coast where we can actually live as fully actualized human beings.” | In Indiana, Wolfcave said, she and Pines struggled to access basic health care or find steady employment. “Trans people move to the west coast where we can actually live as fully actualized human beings.” |
| After moving to California, Pines planned to get her legal identification formally changed to her correct name – a process that can be challenging and expensive, even in a liberal state. | After moving to California, Pines planned to get her legal identification formally changed to her correct name – a process that can be challenging and expensive, even in a liberal state. |
| Wolfcave’s Trans Assistance Project – which she formed after Donald Trump was elected – was going to help Pines get the necessary funds to complete the process. | Wolfcave’s Trans Assistance Project – which she formed after Donald Trump was elected – was going to help Pines get the necessary funds to complete the process. |
| ID changes can be a critical step for trans people, she said: “It’s really empowering and important that they have documents that match who they are.” | ID changes can be a critical step for trans people, she said: “It’s really empowering and important that they have documents that match who they are.” |
| Having proper identification can also be critical in life and death situations, ensuring police can correctly identify trans people. | Having proper identification can also be critical in life and death situations, ensuring police can correctly identify trans people. |
| “She was happier than she had ever been in her whole life,” Wolfcave said, recounting the last time she hung out with Pines in her new Oakland home. “I had never seen her more full of light and possibility.” | “She was happier than she had ever been in her whole life,” Wolfcave said, recounting the last time she hung out with Pines in her new Oakland home. “I had never seen her more full of light and possibility.” |
| The last time they saw each other, Pines talked to Wolfcave about her dreams of traveling and making new music and said she was eager to start an “all trans-girl rave collective”. | The last time they saw each other, Pines talked to Wolfcave about her dreams of traveling and making new music and said she was eager to start an “all trans-girl rave collective”. |
| Despite the intense mistreatment trans women face, particularly in a state like Indiana, Pines was never afraid to be herself and fight back against transphobia, her friends said, recounting her catchphrase “blow up the sun”. | Despite the intense mistreatment trans women face, particularly in a state like Indiana, Pines was never afraid to be herself and fight back against transphobia, her friends said, recounting her catchphrase “blow up the sun”. |
| “She loved to take anyone to task for their bad politics,” Pines’ longtime friend Max Tamola said. “She was larger than life in the most beautiful way.” | “She loved to take anyone to task for their bad politics,” Pines’ longtime friend Max Tamola said. “She was larger than life in the most beautiful way.” |
| Wolfcave added: “Feral was that nerd that knocked the bully out.” | Wolfcave added: “Feral was that nerd that knocked the bully out.” |
| Another victim, Askew, was widely respected for her goth duo band Them Are Us Too and had recently begun making music with Pines. | Another victim, Askew, was widely respected for her goth duo band Them Are Us Too and had recently begun making music with Pines. |
| Oakland curator Tiare Ribeaux said she met Askew when the musician was only 19 years old, and was in awe of her talent. “I was blown away by her genius.” | Oakland curator Tiare Ribeaux said she met Askew when the musician was only 19 years old, and was in awe of her talent. “I was blown away by her genius.” |
| Describing Askew as a “powerful voice for the queer and transgender community”, Ribeaux said the 22-year-old helped pave the way for other trans and gender-nonconforming people to express themselves in art and their lives. “She was really honest and courageous.” | Describing Askew as a “powerful voice for the queer and transgender community”, Ribeaux said the 22-year-old helped pave the way for other trans and gender-nonconforming people to express themselves in art and their lives. “She was really honest and courageous.” |
| Em B, 33, was a poet and barista who moved in 2015 from southern California to Oakland where she found a more accepting community, her father Jack Bohlka, said. | Em B, 33, was a poet and barista who moved in 2015 from southern California to Oakland where she found a more accepting community, her father Jack Bohlka, said. |
| “She was feeling at home,” he said through tears, recounting how she recently told him, “Dad, at last I feel at peace.” | “She was feeling at home,” he said through tears, recounting how she recently told him, “Dad, at last I feel at peace.” |
| Bohlka said he was devastated to think that trans people, who had already endured so much violence and harassment, would have to face tragedy in an arts space meant to be a place where they could gather and feel welcome. | Bohlka said he was devastated to think that trans people, who had already endured so much violence and harassment, would have to face tragedy in an arts space meant to be a place where they could gather and feel welcome. |
| “It’s so fucking horrible that the trans community has to go to places like that that are not physically safe, even if they feel safe with one another.” | “It’s so fucking horrible that the trans community has to go to places like that that are not physically safe, even if they feel safe with one another.” |
| His daughter was interested in moving to New York City and becoming a teacher, he added. “She was always a champion for people who were on the margins.” | His daughter was interested in moving to New York City and becoming a teacher, he added. “She was always a champion for people who were on the margins.” |
| Some queer friends in mourning noted that grieving and trauma are nothing new for trans women, a population that experiences high rates of assault, violence and suicide. | Some queer friends in mourning noted that grieving and trauma are nothing new for trans women, a population that experiences high rates of assault, violence and suicide. |
| Wolfcave said: “Trans women are always having to hold each other in grief.” | Wolfcave said: “Trans women are always having to hold each other in grief.” |