This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-africa-40365245
The article has changed 6 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
Version 4 | Version 5 |
---|---|
South Africa court allows secret Zuma no-confidence vote | South Africa court allows secret Zuma no-confidence vote |
(about 17 hours later) | |
South Africa's highest court has ruled that a vote of no-confidence against President Jacob Zuma can be held in secret. | South Africa's highest court has ruled that a vote of no-confidence against President Jacob Zuma can be held in secret. |
The constitutional court said that the Speaker of parliament had the right to order such a move. She had previously stated she did not have the power. | The constitutional court said that the Speaker of parliament had the right to order such a move. She had previously stated she did not have the power. |
Opposition parties believe that under a secret ballot, MPs from Mr Zuma's ANC party would vote against him. | Opposition parties believe that under a secret ballot, MPs from Mr Zuma's ANC party would vote against him. |
He has survived several previous votes of no-confidence. | He has survived several previous votes of no-confidence. |
Mr Zuma has been under constant pressure over everything from corruption allegations to a controversial cabinet reshuffle that saw his widely respected finance minister, Pravin Gordhan fired. | |
Delivering his verdict, Chief Justice Mogoeng Mogoeng said that under South Africa's separation of powers, it was up to the Speaker of parliament to decide how the vote was conducted. | |
The Speaker, Baleka Mbete, is a top ANC official and had argued that the rules of parliament did not allow for a secret ballot. She is yet to say if she will order such a vote. | The Speaker, Baleka Mbete, is a top ANC official and had argued that the rules of parliament did not allow for a secret ballot. She is yet to say if she will order such a vote. |
Mr Zuma said the ruling was unfair, telling parliament "you are trying to get a majority you don't have by saying 'secret ballot'". | Mr Zuma said the ruling was unfair, telling parliament "you are trying to get a majority you don't have by saying 'secret ballot'". |
Zuma likely to survive, by Milton Nkosi, BBC News, Johannesburg | Zuma likely to survive, by Milton Nkosi, BBC News, Johannesburg |
This decision certainly puts more pressure on President Zuma. But it does not seal his fate. | This decision certainly puts more pressure on President Zuma. But it does not seal his fate. |
The ball is back in Baleka Mbete's court. As the Speaker of the national assembly, she has been President Zuma's protector-in-chief in parliament. | The ball is back in Baleka Mbete's court. As the Speaker of the national assembly, she has been President Zuma's protector-in-chief in parliament. |
A secret ballot is now very likely. The judges effectively told her to hold one and we know from her court submission that she was "not against" it. | A secret ballot is now very likely. The judges effectively told her to hold one and we know from her court submission that she was "not against" it. |
But it is still highly unlikely that ANC MPs will vote President Zuma out of power by supporting a vote of no-confidence, particularly one brought by the opposition. | But it is still highly unlikely that ANC MPs will vote President Zuma out of power by supporting a vote of no-confidence, particularly one brought by the opposition. |
They will use their majority to keep him in office. Mr Zuma's fate, however, will be sealed back at the ranch, when the ANC meets in December to vote in a new presidential candidate. They might just reject his preferred candidate for the 2019 election. | They will use their majority to keep him in office. Mr Zuma's fate, however, will be sealed back at the ranch, when the ANC meets in December to vote in a new presidential candidate. They might just reject his preferred candidate for the 2019 election. |
Responding to the ruling, the ANC said it would defeat the motion to remove Mr Zuma, which the opposition Democratic Alliance said presented an opportunity to oust a "toxic" president. | Responding to the ruling, the ANC said it would defeat the motion to remove Mr Zuma, which the opposition Democratic Alliance said presented an opportunity to oust a "toxic" president. |
A new date for a motion of no-confidence now has to be set. | A new date for a motion of no-confidence now has to be set. |
On top of the confidence votes, President Zuma has lost a number of prominent court cases against him, including one which ended with him being ordered to pay back a portion of state funds used to refurbish his private home in Nkandla. | On top of the confidence votes, President Zuma has lost a number of prominent court cases against him, including one which ended with him being ordered to pay back a portion of state funds used to refurbish his private home in Nkandla. |
But it was the reshuffle that proved particularly damaging, with Mr Zuma facing calls from within his own party to resign. | But it was the reshuffle that proved particularly damaging, with Mr Zuma facing calls from within his own party to resign. |