This article is from the source 'guardian' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2017/jun/26/bob-brown-endorses-action-lee-rhiannon-greens-turmoil
The article has changed 6 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 3 | Version 4 |
|---|---|
| Bob Brown endorses action against Lee Rhiannon as Greens turmoil deepens | Bob Brown endorses action against Lee Rhiannon as Greens turmoil deepens |
| (7 months later) | |
| Former leader says the party rules allow for Rhiannon’s expulsion from the party room, and even removal of her membership of the Greens | |
| Gabrielle Chan | |
| Mon 26 Jun 2017 02.24 BST | |
| First published on Sun 25 Jun 2017 22.37 BST | |
| Share on Facebook | |
| Share on Twitter | |
| Share via Email | |
| View more sharing options | |
| Share on LinkedIn | |
| Share on Pinterest | |
| Share on Google+ | |
| Share on WhatsApp | |
| Share on Messenger | |
| Close | |
| The Greens party elder Bob Brown has described a formal complaint against Lee Rhiannon, signed by her nine party colleagues, as unprecedented but “warranted”. | The Greens party elder Bob Brown has described a formal complaint against Lee Rhiannon, signed by her nine party colleagues, as unprecedented but “warranted”. |
| Brown, who was the first national leader of the Australian Greens, confirmed the matter could lead to Rhiannon’s expulsion from the party room and even the party itself. The complaint followed her involvement in producing a leaflet urging people to lobby to block the Coalition’s Gonski 2.0 school funding package before the party had settled a position on it. | Brown, who was the first national leader of the Australian Greens, confirmed the matter could lead to Rhiannon’s expulsion from the party room and even the party itself. The complaint followed her involvement in producing a leaflet urging people to lobby to block the Coalition’s Gonski 2.0 school funding package before the party had settled a position on it. |
| Brown was closely involved in writing the rules governing the party room and said the party organisation also had the option of removing her membership. | Brown was closely involved in writing the rules governing the party room and said the party organisation also had the option of removing her membership. |
| “[The complaint] is unprecedented but warranted,” Brown told Guardian Australia. “You can’t have a party leader and spokesman working hard to get a good outcome while another person in the party room with shadow ministry functions is out undermining. | “[The complaint] is unprecedented but warranted,” Brown told Guardian Australia. “You can’t have a party leader and spokesman working hard to get a good outcome while another person in the party room with shadow ministry functions is out undermining. |
| Lee is a specialist in party-room rancour | Lee is a specialist in party-room rancour |
| “I wouldn’t be advising on what the party room should do. They are closer to the issue, but we put this rule in as a reasonable backstop to very bad behaviour. | “I wouldn’t be advising on what the party room should do. They are closer to the issue, but we put this rule in as a reasonable backstop to very bad behaviour. |
| “It is really up to party, but I am pleased there is an option there for dealing with Lee.” | “It is really up to party, but I am pleased there is an option there for dealing with Lee.” |
| A phone hook-up between Greens MPs on Monday ended with no formal resolution but will reconvene later in the week. | A phone hook-up between Greens MPs on Monday ended with no formal resolution but will reconvene later in the week. |
| “No formal resolutions have come out of today’s meeting,” a Greens statement said. | “No formal resolutions have come out of today’s meeting,” a Greens statement said. |
| Brown has long opposed Rhiannon’s Senate candidacy. He accused her of not hitting a chord with voters at the last election and introducing factionalism into the NSW Greens. | Brown has long opposed Rhiannon’s Senate candidacy. He accused her of not hitting a chord with voters at the last election and introducing factionalism into the NSW Greens. |
| Rhiannon’s party-room colleagues took action against her after a bruising outcome to the school funding debate. The government had only two pathways to pass the bill, via the Greens or the crossbench, after Labor blocked the bill. | Rhiannon’s party-room colleagues took action against her after a bruising outcome to the school funding debate. The government had only two pathways to pass the bill, via the Greens or the crossbench, after Labor blocked the bill. |
| The Greens leader, Richard Di Natale, and the education spokeswoman, Sarah Hanson-Young, negotiated for $5bn in extra funding, a mechanism to ensure more money came from the states and an independent funding body but at the last minute the Coalition won the required votes from the crossbench. | The Greens leader, Richard Di Natale, and the education spokeswoman, Sarah Hanson-Young, negotiated for $5bn in extra funding, a mechanism to ensure more money came from the states and an independent funding body but at the last minute the Coalition won the required votes from the crossbench. |
| Rhiannon’s colleagues allege she was working against their efforts to improve the bill, in tandem with the Australian Education Union, which had threatened to campaign against the Greens if they supported the bill. | Rhiannon’s colleagues allege she was working against their efforts to improve the bill, in tandem with the Australian Education Union, which had threatened to campaign against the Greens if they supported the bill. |
| Rhiannon has said she had always been faithful to Greens policy and process but opposed the Coalition’s schools package because it favoured private schools. | Rhiannon has said she had always been faithful to Greens policy and process but opposed the Coalition’s schools package because it favoured private schools. |
| She described the leaflets as a good local initiative that highlighted the negative impact the Turnbull funding plan on local public schools, and said nothing she had done had affected the negotiations. | She described the leaflets as a good local initiative that highlighted the negative impact the Turnbull funding plan on local public schools, and said nothing she had done had affected the negotiations. |
| “Producing such materials are a regular feature of Greens campaigns,” Rhiannon said. “These leaflets urged people to lobby all senators to oppose the bill. I was proud to stand with branches of the Australian Education Union, particularly as the Turnbull school funding plan favoured private schools.” | “Producing such materials are a regular feature of Greens campaigns,” Rhiannon said. “These leaflets urged people to lobby all senators to oppose the bill. I was proud to stand with branches of the Australian Education Union, particularly as the Turnbull school funding plan favoured private schools.” |
| After Brown’s criticism, a NSW splinter group called Left Renewal, which is linked to Rhiannon, put a statement on Facebook defending the senator. | After Brown’s criticism, a NSW splinter group called Left Renewal, which is linked to Rhiannon, put a statement on Facebook defending the senator. |
| The group described the party-room complaint as cruel and called for it to be retracted, describing it as an attack on the membership of the NSW Greens. The group also criticised Hanson-Young and Di Natale’s behaviour in the school funding debate. | The group described the party-room complaint as cruel and called for it to be retracted, describing it as an attack on the membership of the NSW Greens. The group also criticised Hanson-Young and Di Natale’s behaviour in the school funding debate. |
| “Left Renewal are astounded at the willingness of Sarah Hanson-Young and Richard Di Natale to negotiate with the Liberals on this bill, and to waver on Greens principles so far as to fail to rule out any cuts to public schools,” the statement said. | “Left Renewal are astounded at the willingness of Sarah Hanson-Young and Richard Di Natale to negotiate with the Liberals on this bill, and to waver on Greens principles so far as to fail to rule out any cuts to public schools,” the statement said. |
| “This has cost the Greens the trust and support of unionists, teachers and public education activists across the country: trust built so strongly by years of fantastic work from the late John Kaye and from Lee Rhiannon before she had the education portfolio stripped from her by party room. | “This has cost the Greens the trust and support of unionists, teachers and public education activists across the country: trust built so strongly by years of fantastic work from the late John Kaye and from Lee Rhiannon before she had the education portfolio stripped from her by party room. |
| “We are disappointed in the party room’s eagerness to cruelly and publicly undermine NSW’s Greens senator for simply taking the position of her party, and a policy the Greens took to an election, into parliament.” | “We are disappointed in the party room’s eagerness to cruelly and publicly undermine NSW’s Greens senator for simply taking the position of her party, and a policy the Greens took to an election, into parliament.” |
| If Rhiannon was expelled from the party room the Greens would lose one of their 10 votes, although she would probably continue to vote with her colleagues on most issues. | If Rhiannon was expelled from the party room the Greens would lose one of their 10 votes, although she would probably continue to vote with her colleagues on most issues. |
| Brown said under the rules members could expel a fellow MP from the party room if he or she was behaving in a way that was inimical to the party. It would then be up to party machinery whether to take membership away as well. | Brown said under the rules members could expel a fellow MP from the party room if he or she was behaving in a way that was inimical to the party. It would then be up to party machinery whether to take membership away as well. |
| “The Greens is a voluntary party and they don’t want to be involved in rancour, but Lee is a specialist in party-room rancour,” Brown said. | “The Greens is a voluntary party and they don’t want to be involved in rancour, but Lee is a specialist in party-room rancour,” Brown said. |
| “This is going to keep happening. NSW Greens voters will have had enough of this. The education shadow [Hanson-Young] got $5bn out of a conservative government for schools. | “This is going to keep happening. NSW Greens voters will have had enough of this. The education shadow [Hanson-Young] got $5bn out of a conservative government for schools. |
| “I can’t fathom it, ultimately it comes down to a more doctrinaire position which overcomes political good sense. As an individual, you have a right to speak out, but you can’t do it secretly behind the backs of your colleagues.” | “I can’t fathom it, ultimately it comes down to a more doctrinaire position which overcomes political good sense. As an individual, you have a right to speak out, but you can’t do it secretly behind the backs of your colleagues.” |
| As the parliament begins a long parliamentary recess until 8 August, the Greens party room will hold a special meeting to discuss the issue after the signed complaint to the National Council was returned to the party room to deal with as they saw fit. | As the parliament begins a long parliamentary recess until 8 August, the Greens party room will hold a special meeting to discuss the issue after the signed complaint to the National Council was returned to the party room to deal with as they saw fit. |
| Rhiannon faces a preselection battle within months to determine whether she will serve six more years as a NSW Greens senator. | Rhiannon faces a preselection battle within months to determine whether she will serve six more years as a NSW Greens senator. |
| “If she was an honourable MP, she would remove herself from Greens and allow a new Greens member to fill her space,” Brown said. | “If she was an honourable MP, she would remove herself from Greens and allow a new Greens member to fill her space,” Brown said. |
| “It is up to the NSW Greens whether they re-endorse her, but in the last two elections thousands of people ceased to vote Greens. If she wins preselection, she is very likely to lose election.” | “It is up to the NSW Greens whether they re-endorse her, but in the last two elections thousands of people ceased to vote Greens. If she wins preselection, she is very likely to lose election.” |
| Australian Greens | |
| Bob Brown | |
| Australian politics | |
| Gonski reforms | |
| Australian education | |
| Lee Rhiannon | |
| news | |
| Share on Facebook | |
| Share on Twitter | |
| Share via Email | |
| Share on LinkedIn | |
| Share on Pinterest | |
| Share on Google+ | |
| Share on WhatsApp | |
| Share on Messenger | |
| Reuse this content |