This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-us-canada-40651502
The article has changed 14 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 11 | Version 12 |
|---|---|
| Trump and Putin had another, undisclosed conversation at G20 | Trump and Putin had another, undisclosed conversation at G20 |
| (35 minutes later) | |
| US President Donald Trump and Russian counterpart Vladimir Putin had another, previously undisclosed conversation at this month's G20, the White House has confirmed. | US President Donald Trump and Russian counterpart Vladimir Putin had another, previously undisclosed conversation at this month's G20, the White House has confirmed. |
| They spoke towards the end of a formal dinner but the White House has not revealed what was discussed. | They spoke towards the end of a formal dinner but the White House has not revealed what was discussed. |
| President Trump has condemned media revelations of the talks as "sick". | President Trump has condemned media revelations of the talks as "sick". |
| The two leaders' relationship is under scrutiny amid allegations of Russian interference in the US election. | The two leaders' relationship is under scrutiny amid allegations of Russian interference in the US election. |
| US intelligence agencies believe Moscow tried to tip the election in Mr Trump's favour, something denied by Russia. Mr Trump has rejected allegations of any collusion. | US intelligence agencies believe Moscow tried to tip the election in Mr Trump's favour, something denied by Russia. Mr Trump has rejected allegations of any collusion. |
| The extra conversation happened during a private meal of heads of state at the G20 summit in Hamburg earlier in the month. | The extra conversation happened during a private meal of heads of state at the G20 summit in Hamburg earlier in the month. |
| The Kremlin said at the time that the two leaders had had "an opportunity to continue their discussion during the dinner" but the extent of the meeting was not known. | The Kremlin said at the time that the two leaders had had "an opportunity to continue their discussion during the dinner" but the extent of the meeting was not known. |
| Mr Trump left his seat and headed to Mr Putin, who had been sitting next to Mr Trump's wife, Melania, US media said. The US president was alone with Mr Putin, apart from the attendance of the Russian president's official interpreter. | Mr Trump left his seat and headed to Mr Putin, who had been sitting next to Mr Trump's wife, Melania, US media said. The US president was alone with Mr Putin, apart from the attendance of the Russian president's official interpreter. |
| Mr Trump had been seated next to Japanese PM Shinzo Abe's wife, so the US interpreter at the dinner spoke Japanese, not Russian. No media were in attendance. | Mr Trump had been seated next to Japanese PM Shinzo Abe's wife, so the US interpreter at the dinner spoke Japanese, not Russian. No media were in attendance. |
| Analysis: Uncomfortable questions raised | Analysis: Uncomfortable questions raised |
| Jonathan Marcus, BBC News defence and diplomatic correspondent | Jonathan Marcus, BBC News defence and diplomatic correspondent |
| Given the poor state of relations between Washington and Moscow and the controversy surrounding Russia's efforts to interfere with the US presidential campaign, each and every encounter between Mr Putin and Mr Trump is bound to be carefully scrutinised. | Given the poor state of relations between Washington and Moscow and the controversy surrounding Russia's efforts to interfere with the US presidential campaign, each and every encounter between Mr Putin and Mr Trump is bound to be carefully scrutinised. |
| Thus the apparently impromptu discussion between the two men at the G20 dinner inevitably raises many questions. What was President Trump seeking to do in approaching the Russian president? Were matters of substance discussed? If so, why was no formal note taken? And why did the US president have to rely upon a Russian official for translation? | Thus the apparently impromptu discussion between the two men at the G20 dinner inevitably raises many questions. What was President Trump seeking to do in approaching the Russian president? Were matters of substance discussed? If so, why was no formal note taken? And why did the US president have to rely upon a Russian official for translation? |
| This is all highly unusual, especially at a time when relations between the two countries are laden with so many problems. | This is all highly unusual, especially at a time when relations between the two countries are laden with so many problems. |
| Mr Trump also appeared unaware of another dimension - the message that his tete-a-tete would send to other leaders in the room, who must have watched the US president's gambit with some unease. | Mr Trump also appeared unaware of another dimension - the message that his tete-a-tete would send to other leaders in the room, who must have watched the US president's gambit with some unease. |
| The length of the talks has been disputed. | The length of the talks has been disputed. |
| Ian Bremmer, president of the US-based Eurasia Group, who first reported them in a newsletter to clients, said: "Donald Trump got up from the table and sat down with Putin for about an hour. It was very animated and very friendly." | Ian Bremmer, president of the US-based Eurasia Group, who first reported them in a newsletter to clients, said: "Donald Trump got up from the table and sat down with Putin for about an hour. It was very animated and very friendly." |
| No-one else was nearby, so the topics of discussion were not known, he said. | No-one else was nearby, so the topics of discussion were not known, he said. |
| Mr Bremmer had not been at the dinner but said details were given to him by unnamed attendees who, he said, were "flummoxed, confused and startled" by the turn of events. | Mr Bremmer had not been at the dinner but said details were given to him by unnamed attendees who, he said, were "flummoxed, confused and startled" by the turn of events. |
| "At summit meetings you have little 'pull-asides' between heads of state to discuss business all the time - a one-hour pull-aside is highly unusual in any context," he told the BBC. | |
| "A one-hour pull-aside between Putin and Trump where only the Kremlin translator is there, where we don't know what's discussed, given the uniqueness of the US-Russia relationship... makes the [US] president, surprisingly and disturbingly, not credible." | |
| In a statement, a senior White House official said there was no "second meeting", just a brief conversation after dinner. | In a statement, a senior White House official said there was no "second meeting", just a brief conversation after dinner. |
| The official said: "The insinuation that the White House has tried to 'hide' a second meeting is false, malicious and absurd. It is not merely perfectly normal, it is part of a president's duties, to interact with world leaders." | The official said: "The insinuation that the White House has tried to 'hide' a second meeting is false, malicious and absurd. It is not merely perfectly normal, it is part of a president's duties, to interact with world leaders." |
| National Security Council spokesman Michael Anton said: "A conversation over dessert should not be characterised as a meeting." | |
| Mr Trump later said on Twitter: "Fake News story of secret dinner with Putin is 'sick.' All G20 leaders, and spouses, were invited by the Chancellor of Germany. Press knew!" | Mr Trump later said on Twitter: "Fake News story of secret dinner with Putin is 'sick.' All G20 leaders, and spouses, were invited by the Chancellor of Germany. Press knew!" |
| The dinner and its attendees have always been known. Only the Trump-Putin discussion had not been reported before. | The dinner and its attendees have always been known. Only the Trump-Putin discussion had not been reported before. |
| Trump and Putin: Comparing the men | Trump and Putin: Comparing the men |
| At the earlier, formal meeting, their first face-to-face encounter, Mr Trump said he had repeatedly pressed Mr Putin about the allegations of interference in the US vote. | At the earlier, formal meeting, their first face-to-face encounter, Mr Trump said he had repeatedly pressed Mr Putin about the allegations of interference in the US vote. |
| "I said, 'Did you do it?' He said, 'No, I did not, absolutely not.' I then asked him a second time, in a totally different way. He said, 'Absolutely not.'" | "I said, 'Did you do it?' He said, 'No, I did not, absolutely not.' I then asked him a second time, in a totally different way. He said, 'Absolutely not.'" |
| There are congressional investigations, and one by a special counsel, into the allegations of Russian interference in the US election and possible collusion with the Trump team. | There are congressional investigations, and one by a special counsel, into the allegations of Russian interference in the US election and possible collusion with the Trump team. |
| On Tuesday, the Senate intelligence committee said it wanted to interview Mr Trump's son, Donald Jr, and other members of the Trump team, over a meeting they had with a Russian lawyer in June last year. | On Tuesday, the Senate intelligence committee said it wanted to interview Mr Trump's son, Donald Jr, and other members of the Trump team, over a meeting they had with a Russian lawyer in June last year. |
| Mr Trump Jr said he had attended the meeting with Natalia Veselnitskaya as he was promised damaging material on Hillary Clinton, but it did not materialise. | Mr Trump Jr said he had attended the meeting with Natalia Veselnitskaya as he was promised damaging material on Hillary Clinton, but it did not materialise. |
| On Wednesday, Ms Veselnitskaya told Russia's RT television channel she would be willing to testify before the Senate on the matter. | On Wednesday, Ms Veselnitskaya told Russia's RT television channel she would be willing to testify before the Senate on the matter. |
| Trump at six months | Trump at six months |
| Meanwhile, the White House said Mr Trump would nominate former Utah governor Jon Huntsman as ambassador to Russia, a key post for a president who promised to improve relations with Moscow. | Meanwhile, the White House said Mr Trump would nominate former Utah governor Jon Huntsman as ambassador to Russia, a key post for a president who promised to improve relations with Moscow. |
| Mr Huntsman, who served as ambassador to China and Singapore, needs to have his name confirmed by the Senate. | Mr Huntsman, who served as ambassador to China and Singapore, needs to have his name confirmed by the Senate. |
| The suspicions over Russian interference are likely to play a significant factor in his confirmation process, correspondents say. | The suspicions over Russian interference are likely to play a significant factor in his confirmation process, correspondents say. |