This article is from the source 'guardian' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at https://www.theguardian.com/inequality/2017/aug/15/the-help-never-lasts-why-has-mexicos-education-revolution-failed
The article has changed 5 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 1 | Version 2 |
|---|---|
| 'The help never lasts': why has Mexico's education revolution failed? | 'The help never lasts': why has Mexico's education revolution failed? |
| (25 days later) | |
| It’s almost four in the afternoon, and a quarter of the fifth-grade pupils at Ángel Albino Corzo primary school in Buena Vista haven’t eaten all day. The children are fidgety and distracted as their teacher explains decimals on the white board. | It’s almost four in the afternoon, and a quarter of the fifth-grade pupils at Ángel Albino Corzo primary school in Buena Vista haven’t eaten all day. The children are fidgety and distracted as their teacher explains decimals on the white board. |
| They are counting down the minutes until break time, when they will be given a small portion of beans with tortillas – for some, the only meal they will eat today (Mexico’s schooling is split into two distinct shifts; these children study from 1.30-6pm). | They are counting down the minutes until break time, when they will be given a small portion of beans with tortillas – for some, the only meal they will eat today (Mexico’s schooling is split into two distinct shifts; these children study from 1.30-6pm). |
| “How can they learn if they’ve not eaten and we haven’t got the right tools?” their teacher, Juan Carlos, asks later. He would like to use interactive online worksheets, but the computer lab is closed and there’s no internet. “There’s only so much we can do.” | “How can they learn if they’ve not eaten and we haven’t got the right tools?” their teacher, Juan Carlos, asks later. He would like to use interactive online worksheets, but the computer lab is closed and there’s no internet. “There’s only so much we can do.” |
| Buena Vista is a bleak hillside community constructed on industrial wasteland in the sprawling State of Mexico, which wraps around the capital, Mexico City. Crime rates are so high here that in winter months, the school closes early as many children walk home alone. Police do not patrol the neighbourhood. | Buena Vista is a bleak hillside community constructed on industrial wasteland in the sprawling State of Mexico, which wraps around the capital, Mexico City. Crime rates are so high here that in winter months, the school closes early as many children walk home alone. Police do not patrol the neighbourhood. |
| Attendance at the school is dismal, and drop-out rates are high. Ten of the fifth grade’s 35 enrolled pupils are absent today. Only three of the original class still attend. “We don’t know what happens to them, they just stop coming,” Carlos says. | Attendance at the school is dismal, and drop-out rates are high. Ten of the fifth grade’s 35 enrolled pupils are absent today. Only three of the original class still attend. “We don’t know what happens to them, they just stop coming,” Carlos says. |
| His fellow teacher, Angelica Rivera, is worried about 14-year-old Pablo, who dropped out of sixth grade two months ago. Pablo was already three years behind but had been doing better until his brother was murdered, at which point he spiralled into drugs and depression. “I pleaded with him to come back and finish school, but he’s working now,” Rivera says. Children who leave here able to read and write are considered a success. | His fellow teacher, Angelica Rivera, is worried about 14-year-old Pablo, who dropped out of sixth grade two months ago. Pablo was already three years behind but had been doing better until his brother was murdered, at which point he spiralled into drugs and depression. “I pleaded with him to come back and finish school, but he’s working now,” Rivera says. Children who leave here able to read and write are considered a success. |
| Education was meant to be Mexican president Enrique Peña Nieto’s flagship policy. In the year after his election in 2012, he announced ambitious reforms to clean-up corruption in the Mexican teachers union (SNTE), improve teaching standards, and create a fairer education model fit for the 21st century. | Education was meant to be Mexican president Enrique Peña Nieto’s flagship policy. In the year after his election in 2012, he announced ambitious reforms to clean-up corruption in the Mexican teachers union (SNTE), improve teaching standards, and create a fairer education model fit for the 21st century. |
| How will the government fund more teachers and technology if it’s still spending millions of dollars on corrupt posts? | How will the government fund more teachers and technology if it’s still spending millions of dollars on corrupt posts? |
| The government introduced mandatory testing for all teachers, promising from then on promotions and salaries would depend on performance, not favours. The first-ever education census revealed tens of thousands of salaries were being paid illegally to union workers, administrators and even dead, retired and “ghost” teachers. | The government introduced mandatory testing for all teachers, promising from then on promotions and salaries would depend on performance, not favours. The first-ever education census revealed tens of thousands of salaries were being paid illegally to union workers, administrators and even dead, retired and “ghost” teachers. |
| But while some progress has been made, millions of dollars are still being misspent. Teachers’ salaries continue to be paid to people who never enter a classroom, according to federal payroll figures being analysed by the Mexico Evalúa watchdog and Monterrey Institute of Technology and Higher Education. This is illegal but, according to lead investigator Marco Fernandez, no one has been sanctioned. | But while some progress has been made, millions of dollars are still being misspent. Teachers’ salaries continue to be paid to people who never enter a classroom, according to federal payroll figures being analysed by the Mexico Evalúa watchdog and Monterrey Institute of Technology and Higher Education. This is illegal but, according to lead investigator Marco Fernandez, no one has been sanctioned. |
| “The new education model needs money to succeed,” Fernandez says. “How will the government fund more teachers and technology if it’s still spending millions of dollars on corrupt posts, and failing to punish those responsible? | “The new education model needs money to succeed,” Fernandez says. “How will the government fund more teachers and technology if it’s still spending millions of dollars on corrupt posts, and failing to punish those responsible? |
| ‘Quality doesn’t matter’ | ‘Quality doesn’t matter’ |
| Mexico ranks last in education among the 35 Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD) countries. Mexican children leave school with the worst literacy, maths and science skills, with around half failing to meet the most basic standards. The poorest children in Vietnam outperform the most privileged in Mexico. | Mexico ranks last in education among the 35 Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD) countries. Mexican children leave school with the worst literacy, maths and science skills, with around half failing to meet the most basic standards. The poorest children in Vietnam outperform the most privileged in Mexico. |
| “No matter how rich or poor you are in Mexico, your education is bad or very bad. Jobs are given based on connections not merit, so quality doesn’t matter,” says Alexandra Zapata, education specialist from the thinktank Mexican Institute for Competitiveness (Imco). | “No matter how rich or poor you are in Mexico, your education is bad or very bad. Jobs are given based on connections not merit, so quality doesn’t matter,” says Alexandra Zapata, education specialist from the thinktank Mexican Institute for Competitiveness (Imco). |
| Like others before him, Peña Nieto put computers and information technology at the heart of his education revolution. Rivera’s class in Buena Vista was one of those selected to benefit from this highly publicised programme of gifting laptops and tablets to fifth-and sixth-graders. Rivera spent six months studying evenings for an online diploma to improve her digital teaching skills. | Like others before him, Peña Nieto put computers and information technology at the heart of his education revolution. Rivera’s class in Buena Vista was one of those selected to benefit from this highly publicised programme of gifting laptops and tablets to fifth-and sixth-graders. Rivera spent six months studying evenings for an online diploma to improve her digital teaching skills. |
| But around two thirds of the tablets no longer work, and the repair budget has been cut. Some parents simply sold them. In total, a million devices were handed out in six states before the scheme ended; its impact has not been measured. | But around two thirds of the tablets no longer work, and the repair budget has been cut. Some parents simply sold them. In total, a million devices were handed out in six states before the scheme ended; its impact has not been measured. |
| Another eye-catching policy, announced earlier this year, is to have English-speaking teachers in every school within a decade, and for all children to be bilingual in Spanish and English within 20 years. | Another eye-catching policy, announced earlier this year, is to have English-speaking teachers in every school within a decade, and for all children to be bilingual in Spanish and English within 20 years. |
| Yet Mexico’s teachers are hardly equipped to educate those who already speak a different language: 1.3 million schoolchildren around the country use indigenous dialects as their first – and sometimes only – language. Only 60% of the 55,000 teachers who do speak an indigenous language are in classrooms where students speak the same one. | Yet Mexico’s teachers are hardly equipped to educate those who already speak a different language: 1.3 million schoolchildren around the country use indigenous dialects as their first – and sometimes only – language. Only 60% of the 55,000 teachers who do speak an indigenous language are in classrooms where students speak the same one. |
| “Racism has always featured in education policy, and this one fails to recognise that this is a multilingual country where all children have equal rights,” says researcher Ivania de la Cruz Orozco, from the Centre for Research and Teaching of Economics (Cide). | “Racism has always featured in education policy, and this one fails to recognise that this is a multilingual country where all children have equal rights,” says researcher Ivania de la Cruz Orozco, from the Centre for Research and Teaching of Economics (Cide). |
| “Education doesn’t exist in a bubble,” Orozco says. “Mexico’s indigenous children do not go to university because of the social and economic conditions they live in. It’s not because they don’t want to go.” | “Education doesn’t exist in a bubble,” Orozco says. “Mexico’s indigenous children do not go to university because of the social and economic conditions they live in. It’s not because they don’t want to go.” |
| Children in indigenous schools have the lowest achievement levels, with more than 80% falling below the basic level needed to progress. One in four indigenous 15-year-olds cannot read or write – four times the general illiteracy rate. Poverty within indigenous communities is rising. | Children in indigenous schools have the lowest achievement levels, with more than 80% falling below the basic level needed to progress. One in four indigenous 15-year-olds cannot read or write – four times the general illiteracy rate. Poverty within indigenous communities is rising. |
| According to Patricio Solís, a leading inequalities expert at the College of Mexico, education is a double-edged sword. “It can be a vehicle for social mobility or, like in Mexico, it can reflect and reproduce inequalities.” | According to Patricio Solís, a leading inequalities expert at the College of Mexico, education is a double-edged sword. “It can be a vehicle for social mobility or, like in Mexico, it can reflect and reproduce inequalities.” |
| There’s no denying we have a quality problem and an inequality problem. Both are very serious | There’s no denying we have a quality problem and an inequality problem. Both are very serious |
| For Solís, the education system could compensate for a child’s unequal start by offering summer schools in the most marginalised communities and incentives so the best teachers work in the most needy schools. Instead, it does the opposite. | For Solís, the education system could compensate for a child’s unequal start by offering summer schools in the most marginalised communities and incentives so the best teachers work in the most needy schools. Instead, it does the opposite. |
| “Our system is designed to reproduce inequalities rather than compensate for them. The children with the most needs get the worst services, like tele-secondary schools [a distance learning model where a reduced number of teachers rely on video and audio materials to teach the curriculum]. I’ve seen no evidence that the situation is improving,” Solís says. | “Our system is designed to reproduce inequalities rather than compensate for them. The children with the most needs get the worst services, like tele-secondary schools [a distance learning model where a reduced number of teachers rely on video and audio materials to teach the curriculum]. I’ve seen no evidence that the situation is improving,” Solís says. |
| Mexico is currently the OECD’s second most unequal country, after newcomer Chile. School dropout rates, absences and grade repetition are all much worse within its poorer communities. | Mexico is currently the OECD’s second most unequal country, after newcomer Chile. School dropout rates, absences and grade repetition are all much worse within its poorer communities. |
| “Where people live in the poorest conditions, the education always arrives last and is the poorest in every aspect – funding, materials, preparation of teachers – which means inequality is perpetuated,” says Sylvia Schmelkes, outgoing director of the National Institute for the Evaluation of Education. | “Where people live in the poorest conditions, the education always arrives last and is the poorest in every aspect – funding, materials, preparation of teachers – which means inequality is perpetuated,” says Sylvia Schmelkes, outgoing director of the National Institute for the Evaluation of Education. |
| “There’s no denying we have a quality problem and an inequality problem. Both are very serious.” | “There’s no denying we have a quality problem and an inequality problem. Both are very serious.” |
| Teachers feel demonised | Teachers feel demonised |
| As Peña Nieto enters his final year in office, the future of his “flagship” education reform programme looks bleak. While the education minister, a close ally of the president, insists the government remains committed to its education agenda, and a spokeswoman says that “all the priority programmes that support this educational transformation are sufficiently funded”, the numbers are revealing. | As Peña Nieto enters his final year in office, the future of his “flagship” education reform programme looks bleak. While the education minister, a close ally of the president, insists the government remains committed to its education agenda, and a spokeswoman says that “all the priority programmes that support this educational transformation are sufficiently funded”, the numbers are revealing. |
| The education budget was slashed by 11.4% this year to £12bn – the lowest since 2011 – as the economy reels from US president Donald Trump’s threats to build a border wall and rip up trade agreements. | The education budget was slashed by 11.4% this year to £12bn – the lowest since 2011 – as the economy reels from US president Donald Trump’s threats to build a border wall and rip up trade agreements. |
| The textbook budget has been cut by a third; teacher training and equality programmes reduced by 40% each; and funds to get children digitally connected have been cut completely. | The textbook budget has been cut by a third; teacher training and equality programmes reduced by 40% each; and funds to get children digitally connected have been cut completely. |
| Many teachers feel demonised thanks to the monumental dispute between the government and their union – but in Buena Vista, at least, they’re trying their best under desperately difficult circumstances. | Many teachers feel demonised thanks to the monumental dispute between the government and their union – but in Buena Vista, at least, they’re trying their best under desperately difficult circumstances. |
| Rivera buys and downloads interactive worksheets on to her personal laptop and projects them on to the whiteboard to try and inspire her class. A high school volunteer is trying to fix the broken desktops but there’s no IT teacher, so the computer lab is largely defunct. | Rivera buys and downloads interactive worksheets on to her personal laptop and projects them on to the whiteboard to try and inspire her class. A high school volunteer is trying to fix the broken desktops but there’s no IT teacher, so the computer lab is largely defunct. |
| It’s not just technology deficits the teachers have to cope with. The school didn’t receive enough textbooks to go round this year, so children must work in groups or from photocopies. | It’s not just technology deficits the teachers have to cope with. The school didn’t receive enough textbooks to go round this year, so children must work in groups or from photocopies. |
| The local government did, however, donate some reading books – including an unreadable, fine-print version of Gulliver’s Travels. “What child would read this?” asks Rivera, flicking through the pictureless book. “But it means some politician somewhere can say he helped the school.” | The local government did, however, donate some reading books – including an unreadable, fine-print version of Gulliver’s Travels. “What child would read this?” asks Rivera, flicking through the pictureless book. “But it means some politician somewhere can say he helped the school.” |
| When the break-time bell finally rings at 4.30pm, the children bolt towards the dining room – all except Julia, a twinkly-eyed sixth-grader who loiters outside, playing with a ratty looking dog. She only had a glass of milk for breakfast and doesn’t have the five pesos (20p) to pay for lunch. Rivera hands her a coin, and Julia runs in, smiling. | When the break-time bell finally rings at 4.30pm, the children bolt towards the dining room – all except Julia, a twinkly-eyed sixth-grader who loiters outside, playing with a ratty looking dog. She only had a glass of milk for breakfast and doesn’t have the five pesos (20p) to pay for lunch. Rivera hands her a coin, and Julia runs in, smiling. |
| “We’re bang in the middle of the poverty belt,” says the school’s headteacher Norma Jimenez, sitting at her office desk next to an imposing Mexican flag. “There is no doctor, no dentist, no water, no police in this community – this is marginalisation.” | “We’re bang in the middle of the poverty belt,” says the school’s headteacher Norma Jimenez, sitting at her office desk next to an imposing Mexican flag. “There is no doctor, no dentist, no water, no police in this community – this is marginalisation.” |
| Straight-talking Jimenez is zealous about the potential of education. “Every time there’s a new programme, we get excited and I send my teachers on courses. But then it disappears and we get disillusioned. It’s like boom and bust. | Straight-talking Jimenez is zealous about the potential of education. “Every time there’s a new programme, we get excited and I send my teachers on courses. But then it disappears and we get disillusioned. It’s like boom and bust. |
| “We could do so much good here, have a real impact,” she adds. “But there’s no assessment of need. The help never lasts.” | “We could do so much good here, have a real impact,” she adds. “But there’s no assessment of need. The help never lasts.” |
| Share your experience of education inequality, wherever you live, by emailing inequality.project@theguardian.com | Share your experience of education inequality, wherever you live, by emailing inequality.project@theguardian.com |
| Follow the Guardian’s Inequality Project on Twitter here. | Follow the Guardian’s Inequality Project on Twitter here. |