This article is from the source 'guardian' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.

You can find the current article at its original source at https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/live/2017/aug/16/nick-xenophon-rejects-one-nation-abc-restrictions-but-pushes-small-media-tax-breaks-politics-live

The article has changed 18 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.

Version 11 Version 12
One Nation media deal cannot be delivered, Greens and Xenophon say – question time live Labor steps up attack over Barnaby Joyce's citizenship – question time live
(35 minutes later)
6.15am BST
06:15
6.14am BST
06:14
Labor loses the suspension of standing orders. Question time is over.
6.09am BST
06:09
The house votes to gag Joel Fitzgibbon. Now the house votes on the suspension of standing orders.
6.08am BST
06:08
6.06am BST
06:06
The house votes to gag Burke and then Labor agriculture shadow Joel Fitzgibbon has a go. Pyne then moves to gag Fitzgibbon.
6.03am BST
06:03
6.02am BST
06:02
6.01am BST
06:01
5.54am BST
05:54
Labor’s Tony Burke moves to suspend standing orders. The motion:
Notes:a) On Monday, this house unanimously asked the high court to determine whether the deputy prime minister is constitutionally qualified to be a member of parliament;
b) On Tuesday, the deputy prime minister admitted he had been a citizen of a foreign power right up until the weekend;
c) Former minister Matt Canavan has resigned from cabinet and will not vote in the Senate until the high court resolves doubts about his constitutional qualifications to be a member of parliament;
d) Yesterday, the foreign minister refused to accept that the conservative New Zealand internal affairs minister was telling the truth; and
e) This morning, on Sky News, the foreign minister refused to answer whether she could now work with a future New Zealand government; and
2. Therefore, calls on the prime minister:
a) To stop trashing Australia’s international relations in order to distract from the crisis the government is facing;
b) Rule out accepting the vote of the deputy prime minister while his constitutional qualifications are in doubt; and
c) Direct the deputy prime minister to immediately resign from cabinet.
Pyne has moved to gag Burke so the division is in progress.
Updated
at 6.04am BST
5.49am BST
05:49
Tanya Plibersek to Julie Bishop: In her travels, the foreign minister has made it clear she has constructive meeting with the president of Iran, the presidents of Russia and the Philippines. How can the foreign minister bring credibility and professionalism to her job if we are meant to believe she will work with Iran, Russia and the Philippines, but maybe not New Zealand?
Bishop sets into TPlibs.
This is a question from a member of parliament who called Ariel Sharon a war criminal and called Israel a rogue state. She has no credibility whatsoever because she thinks Africa is a country, not once, not twice, but three times she called Africa a country. What is the capital of Africa again? Mr Speaker, the fact is the New Zealand Labour leader has now distanced herself from the Australian Labor party.
Five Labor MPs have been thrown out so far, including Plibersek.
Updated
at 5.56am BST
5.46am BST
05:46
Foreign Minister Julie Bishop #QT #seriousStinkeye @gabriellechan @GuardianAus #politicslive pic.twitter.com/20DOvuH1Ze
This will be our frontline weapon when we invade New Zealand in the next stage of Operation Jandal
Updated
at 5.47am BST
5.44am BST
05:44
Labor’s Tony Burke to Malcolm Turnbull: My question is to the prime minister, going to the extraordinary theories the government is advancing as to why Labor is to blame. Which is Labor’s fault? That the leader of the house moved a motion to refer the deputy prime minister to the high court? That the deputy admitted yesterday he was a citizen of a foreign power? Or is it Labor’s fault the deputy prime minister’s father was born in New Zealand in 1924?
Pyne says the standing orders are very clear about the responsibilities of the prime minister and they do not go to the failures of the Labor party.
Speaker Smith agrees.
Updated
at 5.53am BST
5.38am BST5.38am BST
05:3805:38
Mark Dreyfus to Julie Bishop: Yesterday, the Foreign Minister refused to accept the conservative internal affairs minister of New Zealand was telling the truth when he said it was media inquiries that prompted the response to Deputy Prime Minister’s citizenship. On what basis did the Foreign Minister call the internal affairs minister of New Zealand a liar? Mark Dreyfus to Julie Bishop: Yesterday, the foreign minister refused to accept the conservative internal affairs minister of New Zealand was telling the truth when he said it was media inquiries that prompted the response to the deputy prime minister’s citizenship. On what basis did the foreign minister call the internal affairs minister of New Zealand a liar?
Julie Bishop:Julie Bishop:
The questions from the Fairfax media, in fact, do not give rise to an obligation on the part of in New Zealand government to answer it. But as Senator well knew, as her chief of staff well knew, it was raising questions in the parliament that put an obligation on the New Zealand government to act. The questions from the Fairfax media, in fact, do not give rise to an obligation on the part of the New Zealand government to answer it. But as Senator [Wong] well knew, as her chief of staff well knew, it was raising questions in the parliament that put an obligation on the New Zealand government to act.
Updated
at 5.49am BST
5.36am BST5.36am BST
05:3605:36
Tom McIlroy at Fairfax has the most extraordinary story. He reports:Tom McIlroy at Fairfax has the most extraordinary story. He reports:
The Trump administration has listed Pauline Hanson’s One Nation Party as a threat to religious freedom in a new report released in Washington. The Trump administration has listed Pauline Hanson’s One Nation party as a threat to religious freedom in a new report released in Washington.
Secretary of State Rex Tillerson released the annual assessment of religious persecution and intolerance on Wednesday, using a chapter on Australia to highlight Senator Hanson’s 2016 maiden speech to the Senate in which she claimed the country was “in danger of being swamped by Muslims”.Secretary of State Rex Tillerson released the annual assessment of religious persecution and intolerance on Wednesday, using a chapter on Australia to highlight Senator Hanson’s 2016 maiden speech to the Senate in which she claimed the country was “in danger of being swamped by Muslims”.
Updated
at 5.45am BST
5.34am BST5.34am BST
05:3405:34
Oh that Bowers...Oh that Bowers...
Deputy PM Barnaby Joyce grits his teeth through another #qt @gabriellechan @GuardianAus #politicslive pic.twitter.com/HlfxhT9lYpDeputy PM Barnaby Joyce grits his teeth through another #qt @gabriellechan @GuardianAus #politicslive pic.twitter.com/HlfxhT9lYp
5.33am BST5.33am BST
05:3305:33
Greens MP Adam Bandt asks a question which starts with congrats to the Yarra council on moving citizenship ceremonies.Greens MP Adam Bandt asks a question which starts with congrats to the Yarra council on moving citizenship ceremonies.
Bandt to former environment minister Greg Hunt for Josh Frydenberg who is away: During a recent debate about coal, climate change and the Great Barrier Reef in this chamber, one of your backbenchers, and I quote from Hansard, said, “There is nothing wrong with the reef, I live on the reef”. Will you condemn it or is it your official position? Is it why you are happy to bankroll the Adani coalmine, using the drug dealer’s defence: if we do not give other countries our product, someone else will? And with Adani under investigation for siphoning money into offshore tax havens, why are you leaving a questionable minister in charge? Bandt to the PM who flicks it to the former environment minister Greg Hunt, for Josh Frydenberg who is away: During a recent debate about coal, climate change and the Great Barrier Reef in this chamber, one of your backbenchers, and I quote from Hansard, said, “There is nothing wrong with the reef, I live on the reef”. Will you condemn it or is it your official position? Is it why you are happy to bankroll the Adani coalmine, using the drug dealer’s defence: if we do not give other countries our product, someone else will? And with Adani under investigation for siphoning money into offshore tax havens, why are you leaving a questionable minister in charge?
Greg Hunt says the government is the best manager of the reef in the entire universe. (Or thereabouts.)Greg Hunt says the government is the best manager of the reef in the entire universe. (Or thereabouts.)
We inherited five major dredge disposal projects on the reef and we ended them all. We banned capital dredge disposal in the Great Barrier Reef, which had been a practice for over 100 years, right through the Greens’ partnership with the ALP ... they are environmental frauds.We inherited five major dredge disposal projects on the reef and we ended them all. We banned capital dredge disposal in the Great Barrier Reef, which had been a practice for over 100 years, right through the Greens’ partnership with the ALP ... they are environmental frauds.
UpdatedUpdated
at 5.37am BST at 6.05am BST
5.27am BST5.27am BST
05:2705:27
Labor’s Tony Burke bowls up a piss-take question to Julie Bishop: Would the minister for foreign affairs please tell the house some more about the evil, treacherous conspiracy she has exposed in this house time and again?Labor’s Tony Burke bowls up a piss-take question to Julie Bishop: Would the minister for foreign affairs please tell the house some more about the evil, treacherous conspiracy she has exposed in this house time and again?
Bishop walks to the dispatch box with a face like stone.Bishop walks to the dispatch box with a face like stone.
The hubris of the Australian Labor party on this issue is extraordinary. Apparently, the Labor party believes that they are above the law. There is one rule for the Labor party and one rule for the rest of Australia. Craig Thomson was allowed to sit in this parliament when he was in clear breach of the law. The leader of the opposition condones the lawlessness of his unions. The Labor party have breached the most fundamental international principle and they laugh about it?The hubris of the Australian Labor party on this issue is extraordinary. Apparently, the Labor party believes that they are above the law. There is one rule for the Labor party and one rule for the rest of Australia. Craig Thomson was allowed to sit in this parliament when he was in clear breach of the law. The leader of the opposition condones the lawlessness of his unions. The Labor party have breached the most fundamental international principle and they laugh about it?
UpdatedUpdated
at 5.32am BSTat 5.32am BST
5.21am BST
05:21
And with the second government question to foreign affairs minister Julie Bishop we are back to foreign conspiracies.
As the New Zealand media are reporting, the New Zealand government is under no obligation to answer questions from the Australian media, but as soon as the questions were put on notice in the New Zealand parliament, the New Zealand government had an obligation, a legal obligation, to answer. So the Australian Labor party set up the New Zealand government. As Prime Minister Bill English said, these are serious issues.
Updated
at 5.26am BST
5.19am BST
05:19
Shorten to Turnbull: Why then did the government refer the deputy prime minister to the high court?
The PM says he has answered the question on more than one occasion.
Updated
at 5.20am BST
5.15am BST
05:15
Shorten to Turnbull: Can the prime minister guarantee to the house that he is leading a majority government that meets all of the requirements of the Constitution?
Yes.
Updated
at 5.19am BST
5.15am BST
05:15
Bill Shorten jokes that he thought he was in Yarra council, drawing heckles from the government benches. His answer is more nuanced, weaving a careful way through the issues and constituencies.
There is no doubt, even before the prime minister spoke, that Australia Day is a most important national day. It does commemorate the first British penal colony established in Australia. And it also, I believe, is a source of great celebration for Australians right up to the current day. But it does also acknowledge, as the prime minister said, that for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples, the 26th can speak of dispossession and sorrow. It also needs to recognise, I believe, that before the British settlement there were 65,000 years of continuous occupation by the world’s oldest continuing culture, in our country. Now, I do not support changing the date of Australia Day.
It is a day of citizenship ceremonies, of looking to the future, of celebrating all our cultures and faiths and traditions. And the member for Barton [Linda Burney], for example, has spoken most eloquently about this.
Reconciliation is more about changing hearts and minds than it is about moving public holidays. But, of course, if we look at national days important in the history of this country, there is March 1,1901, when the Australian parliament, the Australian nation, came into being, when our old friend the Constitution came into being. And there is, of course, another potential national public holiday, which has not yet been gazetted. And that will be when we finally have an Australian head of state.
Updated
at 5.19am BST
5.12am BST
05:12
Labor frontbencher Anthony Albanese yells,
prime minister responds to Yarra Council!
5.11am BST
05:11
Labor MP.
What crock of shite #qt delayed for this crap.#auspol Do a Min statement
5.11am BST
05:11
Malcolm Turnbull asks to make a statement on indulgence about Australia Day following the Melbourne council’s decision (the city of Yarra) to stop holding citizenship ceremonies on January 26.
We recognise that the history of European settlement in Australia has been complex and tragic for Indigenous Australians. We recognise the complexities and the challenges of our history. But on Australia Day, we recognise the greatness of our achievement as Australians.
We recognise the remarkable nation we have become. We recognise and honour our first Australians and our newest migrant citizens. We bring all that together in a day that is uniquely and proudly Australian and that is why, Mr Speaker, my government and every government before me, in this house, has urged Australians to celebrate Australia Day.
Updated
at 5.14am BST
5.06am BST
05:06
We have a condolence motion on Liberal senator Brian Gibson.
Then on to questions.
5.02am BST
05:02
What meme is that?
4.55am BST
04:55
Question time coming up.