This article is from the source 'guardian' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.theguardian.com/world/2017/aug/22/toppling-nelson-risks-importing-us-anger
The article has changed 5 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 1 | Version 2 |
|---|---|
| Toppling Nelson risks importing US anger | Toppling Nelson risks importing US anger |
| (17 days later) | |
| Afua Hirsch (Why not topple Nelson?, 22 August) has the argument back to front when she says the purpose of statues to “figures like Nelson” is to energise “white supremacist groups”. On the contrary, it is those agitating to remove such statues who are trying to import into the UK the US “frenzied debate”, in the hope of stirring up conflict and hostility, even though our “white supremacist groups” are insignificant at present, thanks to what she calls our “inertia, arrogance and intellectual laziness”. Her anger would be better directed at current discrimination, not at absurd historical claims such as the suggestion that “the brutalisation of black slaves made Britain the global power it then was”. Sure, it played a part, and should be commemorated – but so should Nelson.Alan BaileyLondon | Afua Hirsch (Why not topple Nelson?, 22 August) has the argument back to front when she says the purpose of statues to “figures like Nelson” is to energise “white supremacist groups”. On the contrary, it is those agitating to remove such statues who are trying to import into the UK the US “frenzied debate”, in the hope of stirring up conflict and hostility, even though our “white supremacist groups” are insignificant at present, thanks to what she calls our “inertia, arrogance and intellectual laziness”. Her anger would be better directed at current discrimination, not at absurd historical claims such as the suggestion that “the brutalisation of black slaves made Britain the global power it then was”. Sure, it played a part, and should be commemorated – but so should Nelson.Alan BaileyLondon |
| • Afua Hirsch is right that consideration should be given to how appropriate memorials to Britain’s imperial past now are. That is not about rewriting history, but gaining a better understanding of exactly what empire actually meant. At the same time she is right that the “subjects” of that empire are almost forgotten from history when it comes to memorials, let alone statues. For example, London still lacks a public reminder of the work of William Cuffay, the black tailor and son of a slave who was the leader of London Chartism in 1848 and found himself transported to Tasmania for fighting for the right to vote.Keith FlettLondon | • Afua Hirsch is right that consideration should be given to how appropriate memorials to Britain’s imperial past now are. That is not about rewriting history, but gaining a better understanding of exactly what empire actually meant. At the same time she is right that the “subjects” of that empire are almost forgotten from history when it comes to memorials, let alone statues. For example, London still lacks a public reminder of the work of William Cuffay, the black tailor and son of a slave who was the leader of London Chartism in 1848 and found himself transported to Tasmania for fighting for the right to vote.Keith FlettLondon |
| • We’ve already toppled our Nelson statue. On 8 March 1966, persons unknown blew up Nelson’s Pillar in the middle of Dublin. The man may not have been much missed but the pillar was. For a few pence, you could climb to the top of it and fire down gooseberries (or spit) at people below. We’ve still got his head though and that can be seen in Dublin’s city library in Pearse Street. Entry free.Mary Russell Oxford | • We’ve already toppled our Nelson statue. On 8 March 1966, persons unknown blew up Nelson’s Pillar in the middle of Dublin. The man may not have been much missed but the pillar was. For a few pence, you could climb to the top of it and fire down gooseberries (or spit) at people below. We’ve still got his head though and that can be seen in Dublin’s city library in Pearse Street. Entry free.Mary Russell Oxford |
| • Join the debate – email guardian.letters@theguardian.com | • Join the debate – email guardian.letters@theguardian.com |
| • Read more Guardian letters – click here to visit gu.com/letters | • Read more Guardian letters – click here to visit gu.com/letters |