This article is from the source 'guardian' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at https://www.theguardian.com/world/2017/oct/12/is-targeting-of-isis-member-sally-jones-legally-justified
The article has changed 5 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 3 | Version 4 |
|---|---|
| Is the targeting of Isis member Sally Jones legally justified? | Is the targeting of Isis member Sally Jones legally justified? |
| (25 days later) | |
| The targeting of Sally Jones, who is believed to have died in a CIA drone strike in Syria, fits neatly into a framework of legal justifications prepared by the government for such premeditated killings. | The targeting of Sally Jones, who is believed to have died in a CIA drone strike in Syria, fits neatly into a framework of legal justifications prepared by the government for such premeditated killings. |
| Specific advance evidence of a terror plot threatening UK interests is not legally necessary before launching pre-emptive drone strikes against suspects overseas, the attorney general, Jeremy Wright QC, explained earlier this year. | Specific advance evidence of a terror plot threatening UK interests is not legally necessary before launching pre-emptive drone strikes against suspects overseas, the attorney general, Jeremy Wright QC, explained earlier this year. |
| The surge in improvised jihadi attacks this summer inspired by Islamic State videos that are broadcast across the internet is likely to have heightened the security services’ interest in Jones and the danger she posed. | The surge in improvised jihadi attacks this summer inspired by Islamic State videos that are broadcast across the internet is likely to have heightened the security services’ interest in Jones and the danger she posed. |
| Nicknamed “the white widow” after her husband, Junaid Hussain, was killed in a 2015 US drone strike, she was an active Isis recruiter and propagandist who urged her followers to carry out attacks in the UK. | Nicknamed “the white widow” after her husband, Junaid Hussain, was killed in a 2015 US drone strike, she was an active Isis recruiter and propagandist who urged her followers to carry out attacks in the UK. |
| Her killing raises more acutely the question of whether the UK is operating a kill-list of priority targets. The reported death of her 12-year-old son, Jojo, alongside her also raises concerns about the legality of the attack because he would be classified as a non-combatant. | Her killing raises more acutely the question of whether the UK is operating a kill-list of priority targets. The reported death of her 12-year-old son, Jojo, alongside her also raises concerns about the legality of the attack because he would be classified as a non-combatant. |
| The latest drone strike was carried out by the CIA using US military hardware, but the closeness of US-UK cooperation in previous Predator drone attacks in Syria make any denial of advance knowledge by British officials implausible. | The latest drone strike was carried out by the CIA using US military hardware, but the closeness of US-UK cooperation in previous Predator drone attacks in Syria make any denial of advance knowledge by British officials implausible. |
| British drone pilots operate Reaper and Predator drones out of RAF Waddington in Lincolnshire and Creech US air force base in Nevada. The US and UK have also shared intelligence in past Syria drone strikes. | British drone pilots operate Reaper and Predator drones out of RAF Waddington in Lincolnshire and Creech US air force base in Nevada. The US and UK have also shared intelligence in past Syria drone strikes. |
| The first drone strikes against British Isis militants Reyaad Khan, Ruhul Amin and Junaid Hussain were carried out by both US and RAF drones. | The first drone strikes against British Isis militants Reyaad Khan, Ruhul Amin and Junaid Hussain were carried out by both US and RAF drones. |
| The killing of Mohammed Emwazi, the Isis executioner known as Jihadi John, later that year was a joint operation. David Cameron, the then prime minister, said Britain had been working “hand in glove, round the clock” with the US to track down and target Emwazi. | The killing of Mohammed Emwazi, the Isis executioner known as Jihadi John, later that year was a joint operation. David Cameron, the then prime minister, said Britain had been working “hand in glove, round the clock” with the US to track down and target Emwazi. |
| Anticipating that there would be future drone killings of UK citizens in Syria, the attorney general gave a speech in January that set out the legal justification for such attacks. One of the key requirements for exercising self-defence under international law, he said, is that the threat must be imminent. | Anticipating that there would be future drone killings of UK citizens in Syria, the attorney general gave a speech in January that set out the legal justification for such attacks. One of the key requirements for exercising self-defence under international law, he said, is that the threat must be imminent. |
| Wright denied that the threshold for self-defence was being watered down, but he told the International Institute for Strategic Studies: “In a world where a small number of committed plotters may be seeking to inspire, enable and direct attacks around the world, and indeed have a proven track record of doing so, we will not always know where and when an attack will take place, or the precise nature of the attack. | Wright denied that the threshold for self-defence was being watered down, but he told the International Institute for Strategic Studies: “In a world where a small number of committed plotters may be seeking to inspire, enable and direct attacks around the world, and indeed have a proven track record of doing so, we will not always know where and when an attack will take place, or the precise nature of the attack. |
| “But where the evidence supports an assessment that an attack is imminent it cannot be right that a state is prevented from meeting its first duty of protecting its citizens without nailing down the specific target and timing of an attack. Apart from anything else, our enemies will not always have fixed plans. They are often opportunists.” | “But where the evidence supports an assessment that an attack is imminent it cannot be right that a state is prevented from meeting its first duty of protecting its citizens without nailing down the specific target and timing of an attack. Apart from anything else, our enemies will not always have fixed plans. They are often opportunists.” |
| The government has advanced two separate justifications for carrying out drone strikes in Syria: as part of the UN-sanctioned collective coalition defending Iraq; and as self-defence of Britain in the face of imminent threats of attack by Isis and the supporters it inspires online. | The government has advanced two separate justifications for carrying out drone strikes in Syria: as part of the UN-sanctioned collective coalition defending Iraq; and as self-defence of Britain in the face of imminent threats of attack by Isis and the supporters it inspires online. |
| The organisation Rights Watch UK is challenging the government’s refusal to reveal the precise legal advice justifying the targeted killings of British jihadis abroad in the UK courts. | The organisation Rights Watch UK is challenging the government’s refusal to reveal the precise legal advice justifying the targeted killings of British jihadis abroad in the UK courts. |
| Before a hearing in July, Yasmine Ahmed, the executive director of Rights Watch, said such drone strikes were “a sweeping expansion of the circumstances in which the government claims they can lawfully use force overseas”. | Before a hearing in July, Yasmine Ahmed, the executive director of Rights Watch, said such drone strikes were “a sweeping expansion of the circumstances in which the government claims they can lawfully use force overseas”. |
| “By shielding their legal justification from public view the government are depriving parliament and the public of the opportunity to have informed debate about where and when its government can engage in the premeditated killings of individuals, including British nationals abroad,” she said. | “By shielding their legal justification from public view the government are depriving parliament and the public of the opportunity to have informed debate about where and when its government can engage in the premeditated killings of individuals, including British nationals abroad,” she said. |
| Judgment is awaited in the case. Daniel Carey, a solicitor at the law firm Deighton Pierce Glynn who is involved in the legal challenge, said on Thursday: “The self-defence basis [of the legal justification] opens up the possibility of kill-lists, formal or informal. | Judgment is awaited in the case. Daniel Carey, a solicitor at the law firm Deighton Pierce Glynn who is involved in the legal challenge, said on Thursday: “The self-defence basis [of the legal justification] opens up the possibility of kill-lists, formal or informal. |
| “The question of legality is most starkly thrown up by the death of her [Sally Jones’s] child, if he was killed. The big issue is the requirement under international humanitarian law that any threat should be imminent.” The attorney general’s interpretation of that issue, he said, was controversial. | “The question of legality is most starkly thrown up by the death of her [Sally Jones’s] child, if he was killed. The big issue is the requirement under international humanitarian law that any threat should be imminent.” The attorney general’s interpretation of that issue, he said, was controversial. |
| “If the UK is getting the US to do its dirty work, that does not absolve [ministers] from responsibility for it.” | “If the UK is getting the US to do its dirty work, that does not absolve [ministers] from responsibility for it.” |
| Drones (military) | Drones (military) |
| Islamic State | Islamic State |
| Foreign policy | Foreign policy |
| analysis | analysis |
| Share on Facebook | Share on Facebook |
| Share on Twitter | Share on Twitter |
| Share via Email | Share via Email |
| Share on LinkedIn | Share on LinkedIn |
| Share on Pinterest | Share on Pinterest |
| Share on Google+ | Share on Google+ |
| Share on WhatsApp | Share on WhatsApp |
| Share on Messenger | Share on Messenger |
| Reuse this content | Reuse this content |