This article is from the source 'guardian' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2017/oct/13/brexit-wrangle-over-citizens-rights-is-nonsense-says-juncker
The article has changed 7 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 4 | Version 5 |
|---|---|
| 'Now they have to pay': Juncker says UK stance on Brexit bill untenable | 'Now they have to pay': Juncker says UK stance on Brexit bill untenable |
| (1 day later) | |
| EU chief builds pressure on May, comparing UK to friend who orders drinks at bar then leaves without paying | |
| Daniel Boffey in Brussels | |
| Fri 13 Oct 2017 15.51 BST | |
| First published on Fri 13 Oct 2017 11.35 BST | |
| Share on Facebook | |
| Share on Twitter | |
| Share via Email | |
| View more sharing options | |
| Share on LinkedIn | |
| Share on Pinterest | |
| Share on Google+ | |
| Share on WhatsApp | |
| Share on Messenger | |
| Close | |
| Jean-Claude Juncker has upped the pressure on Theresa May over Britain’s Brexit divorce bill, acknowledging Europe’s debt of gratitude to the country “during the war, after the war, before the war”, but insisting: “Now they have to pay.” | Jean-Claude Juncker has upped the pressure on Theresa May over Britain’s Brexit divorce bill, acknowledging Europe’s debt of gratitude to the country “during the war, after the war, before the war”, but insisting: “Now they have to pay.” |
| With EU leaders meeting for a summit next week, the European commission president used a speech in Luxembourg to express his frustration at the British government’s failure so far to commit to honouring its financial obligations to the bloc on leaving it. | With EU leaders meeting for a summit next week, the European commission president used a speech in Luxembourg to express his frustration at the British government’s failure so far to commit to honouring its financial obligations to the bloc on leaving it. |
| The Brexit secretary, David Davis, insisted on Thursday at the end of the fifth round of negotiations that the UK would only spell out what aspects of the past commitments it was willing to meet once talks were opened on the future trading relationship. As a consequence, the EU’s chief negotiator, Michel Barnier, claimed the talks were in a “very disturbing state of deadlock”. | The Brexit secretary, David Davis, insisted on Thursday at the end of the fifth round of negotiations that the UK would only spell out what aspects of the past commitments it was willing to meet once talks were opened on the future trading relationship. As a consequence, the EU’s chief negotiator, Michel Barnier, claimed the talks were in a “very disturbing state of deadlock”. |
| Juncker told students at Luxembourg University that the British position was untenable. “We cannot find, for the time being, a real compromise as far as the remaining financial commitments of the UK are concerned,” he said. | Juncker told students at Luxembourg University that the British position was untenable. “We cannot find, for the time being, a real compromise as far as the remaining financial commitments of the UK are concerned,” he said. |
| “As we cannot do this, we will not be able to say during the European council in October that now we can move to the second phase of the negotiations, which means the shaping of the British-European future. Things have to [be] done. One has to deliver. | “As we cannot do this, we will not be able to say during the European council in October that now we can move to the second phase of the negotiations, which means the shaping of the British-European future. Things have to [be] done. One has to deliver. |
| “If you are sitting in the bar and you are ordering 28 beers and then suddenly some of your colleagues [are leaving without] paying, that is not feasible. They have to pay. They have to pay.” | “If you are sitting in the bar and you are ordering 28 beers and then suddenly some of your colleagues [are leaving without] paying, that is not feasible. They have to pay. They have to pay.” |
| To laughter in the audience, Juncker added: “Not in an impossible way. I am not in a revenge way. I am not hating the British. We Europeans have to be grateful for so many things Britain has brought to Europe. During the war, before the war, after the war. Everywhere and every time. But now they have to pay.” | To laughter in the audience, Juncker added: “Not in an impossible way. I am not in a revenge way. I am not hating the British. We Europeans have to be grateful for so many things Britain has brought to Europe. During the war, before the war, after the war. Everywhere and every time. But now they have to pay.” |
| Estimates on the size of the divorce bill have varied from about €60bn to €100bn (£54bn to £90bn). | Estimates on the size of the divorce bill have varied from about €60bn to €100bn (£54bn to £90bn). |
| Juncker also dismissed the negotiations over citizens’ rights as a “nonsense”, claiming he could not understand why the British had not guaranteed from the start that everything would remain the same for European nationals – “or ‘foreigners’, as they are saying in London” – after the UK leaves the EU. | Juncker also dismissed the negotiations over citizens’ rights as a “nonsense”, claiming he could not understand why the British had not guaranteed from the start that everything would remain the same for European nationals – “or ‘foreigners’, as they are saying in London” – after the UK leaves the EU. |
| Citizens’ rights is the aspect of the negotiation upon which the two parties are closest to a deal, but differences remain on a number of aspects, including the so-called right of family reunification, which would allow EU nationals to avoid having to meet an income threshold, as British citizens do, when they are seeking to bring a non-EU spouse to the UK. | Citizens’ rights is the aspect of the negotiation upon which the two parties are closest to a deal, but differences remain on a number of aspects, including the so-called right of family reunification, which would allow EU nationals to avoid having to meet an income threshold, as British citizens do, when they are seeking to bring a non-EU spouse to the UK. |
| “Brexit is a serious issue,” Juncker said. “It came unexpected but not totally unexpected. Now we have to deal with the results and first to be impressed by the numerous disadvantages that Brexit – Brexit meaning Brexit – is entailing for the British. They are discovering, as we are, day after day, new problems. That is the reason why this process will take longer than initially thought.” | “Brexit is a serious issue,” Juncker said. “It came unexpected but not totally unexpected. Now we have to deal with the results and first to be impressed by the numerous disadvantages that Brexit – Brexit meaning Brexit – is entailing for the British. They are discovering, as we are, day after day, new problems. That is the reason why this process will take longer than initially thought.” |
| Juncker continued: “We had the idea that we would clear all the questions related to the divorce, but it’s not possible. Citizens’ rights, yes, we are making progress. I don’t even understand this problem. Why not say, easily, with common sense – which is not a political category, as we know – that things will stay as they are? The Europeans – ‘foreigners’, as they are saying in London – they are there in the island, and so many British friends are here. Let them here, let them there. Why are we discussing nonsense like that?” | Juncker continued: “We had the idea that we would clear all the questions related to the divorce, but it’s not possible. Citizens’ rights, yes, we are making progress. I don’t even understand this problem. Why not say, easily, with common sense – which is not a political category, as we know – that things will stay as they are? The Europeans – ‘foreigners’, as they are saying in London – they are there in the island, and so many British friends are here. Let them here, let them there. Why are we discussing nonsense like that?” |
| The European council summit next week is expected to see the EU’s leaders conclude that talks about any future trading relationship with Britain will have to be delayed because of a lack of progress on the issues of citizens’ rights, the Irish border and the divorce bill. | The European council summit next week is expected to see the EU’s leaders conclude that talks about any future trading relationship with Britain will have to be delayed because of a lack of progress on the issues of citizens’ rights, the Irish border and the divorce bill. |
| A document leaked on Thursday suggests that the European council president, Donald Tusk, will, however, invite the 27 EU member states to start working among themselves on their vision of the transition period and the future relationship, in the hope that sufficient progress on the opening issues can be made by a summit in December. | A document leaked on Thursday suggests that the European council president, Donald Tusk, will, however, invite the 27 EU member states to start working among themselves on their vision of the transition period and the future relationship, in the hope that sufficient progress on the opening issues can be made by a summit in December. |
| One EU source said the move was both “prudent planning” and an attempt to push the UK to build on Theresa May’s pledge in her speech in Florence to pay its way, including the provision of €20bn to ensure no member state loses out in the two years after Brexit. | One EU source said the move was both “prudent planning” and an attempt to push the UK to build on Theresa May’s pledge in her speech in Florence to pay its way, including the provision of €20bn to ensure no member state loses out in the two years after Brexit. |
| During a wide-ranging speech, Juncker also attempted to play down suggestions that his recent state of the union address was an attempt to turn the EU into a single political entity. | During a wide-ranging speech, Juncker also attempted to play down suggestions that his recent state of the union address was an attempt to turn the EU into a single political entity. |
| “I don’t believe a European citizen would really like to see the creation of a united states of Europe similar to what they have in the USA,” he said. “I’m not in favour of a united states of Europe, but I am in favour of further integration.” | “I don’t believe a European citizen would really like to see the creation of a united states of Europe similar to what they have in the USA,” he said. “I’m not in favour of a united states of Europe, but I am in favour of further integration.” |
| Brexit | |
| Jean-Claude Juncker | |
| European commission | |
| Foreign policy | |
| European Union | |
| Europe | |
| news | |
| Share on Facebook | |
| Share on Twitter | |
| Share via Email | |
| Share on LinkedIn | |
| Share on Pinterest | |
| Share on Google+ | |
| Share on WhatsApp | |
| Share on Messenger | |
| Reuse this content |