This article is from the source 'guardian' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2017/oct/23/the-guardian-view-on-gene-therapy-money-well-spent
The article has changed 4 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 2 | Version 3 |
|---|---|
| The Guardian view on gene therapy: money well spent | The Guardian view on gene therapy: money well spent |
| (1 day later) | |
| The NHS is to fund a very expensive treatment for a very rare but terrible childhood disorder that leaves babies condemned to life in a sterile bubble. This is a triumph for medical science but it should also provoke some deep and careful thought. The treatment in question, strimvelis, qualifies as the second most expensive drug ever put on the market (the only one more expensive was withdrawn due to lack of demand). A single dose costs nearly £500,000 plus VAT, and can only be administered in Milan, where the preparation is made. On the other hand, that one dose is literally life-saving, and as far as we now know, is the only treatment the disorder will ever need. At the rate that the National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (Nice), is prepared to pay for treatments of rare diseases – £100,000 a year of good life – this represents good value. The calculation may seem heartless, but it is unavoidable. Money spent on one patient is unavailable for all others. Someone, somehow, must decide who benefits. | The NHS is to fund a very expensive treatment for a very rare but terrible childhood disorder that leaves babies condemned to life in a sterile bubble. This is a triumph for medical science but it should also provoke some deep and careful thought. The treatment in question, strimvelis, qualifies as the second most expensive drug ever put on the market (the only one more expensive was withdrawn due to lack of demand). A single dose costs nearly £500,000 plus VAT, and can only be administered in Milan, where the preparation is made. On the other hand, that one dose is literally life-saving, and as far as we now know, is the only treatment the disorder will ever need. At the rate that the National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (Nice), is prepared to pay for treatments of rare diseases – £100,000 a year of good life – this represents good value. The calculation may seem heartless, but it is unavoidable. Money spent on one patient is unavailable for all others. Someone, somehow, must decide who benefits. |
| Looked at purely as a medical advance, this is great. The babies born with this syndrome have two defective copies of a gene essential to the functioning of white blood cells. They are therefore unable to defend themselves against infection and unless kept in wholly sterile surroundings will die of a variety of horrible diseases and developmental disorders before they reach school age. Until now the only treatment was with a stem cell transplant, which was only effective in about three quarters of the cases, and relied on finding matched donors, who are rare. The new treatment removes defective stem cells and replaces their genes with properly functioning versions before returning these to the patients. Once these are incorporated into the bone marrow, they produce healthy white blood cells and the immune system functions as it should. This is how genetic medicine is supposed to work, but has not done reliably until now. | Looked at purely as a medical advance, this is great. The babies born with this syndrome have two defective copies of a gene essential to the functioning of white blood cells. They are therefore unable to defend themselves against infection and unless kept in wholly sterile surroundings will die of a variety of horrible diseases and developmental disorders before they reach school age. Until now the only treatment was with a stem cell transplant, which was only effective in about three quarters of the cases, and relied on finding matched donors, who are rare. The new treatment removes defective stem cells and replaces their genes with properly functioning versions before returning these to the patients. Once these are incorporated into the bone marrow, they produce healthy white blood cells and the immune system functions as it should. This is how genetic medicine is supposed to work, but has not done reliably until now. |
| The decision to make the treatment available is clearly correct. But it is also irrelevant to the deeper and more urgent problems of the NHS, which are not caused by a shortage of miracle cures for rare and dramatic diseases. It is the common ills that almost all flesh is heir to that cost most when you add them up. Sorting out social care, making things work away from the headlines: those are the measures that will relieve the most suffering, but compared with medical miracles, political ones are harder. | The decision to make the treatment available is clearly correct. But it is also irrelevant to the deeper and more urgent problems of the NHS, which are not caused by a shortage of miracle cures for rare and dramatic diseases. It is the common ills that almost all flesh is heir to that cost most when you add them up. Sorting out social care, making things work away from the headlines: those are the measures that will relieve the most suffering, but compared with medical miracles, political ones are harder. |
| Medical research | Medical research |
| Opinion | Opinion |
| Stem cells | Stem cells |
| Genetics | Genetics |
| Biology | Biology |
| NHS | NHS |
| Health | Health |
| editorials | editorials |
| Share on Facebook | Share on Facebook |
| Share on Twitter | Share on Twitter |
| Share via Email | Share via Email |
| Share on LinkedIn | Share on LinkedIn |
| Share on Pinterest | Share on Pinterest |
| Share on Google+ | Share on Google+ |
| Share on WhatsApp | Share on WhatsApp |
| Share on Messenger | Share on Messenger |
| Reuse this content | Reuse this content |