This article is from the source 'guardian' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2017/nov/06/mps-senators-declare-citizenship-status-malcolm-turnbull
The article has changed 11 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 7 | Version 8 |
|---|---|
| MPs and senators will be forced to declare citizenship status, Malcolm Turnbull says | MPs and senators will be forced to declare citizenship status, Malcolm Turnbull says |
| (2 months later) | |
| All MPs and senators will have to lodge declarations and produce evidence that they were not foreign citizens at the time of nomination in a new disclosure measure announced by Malcolm Turnbull to staunch the disruption of the government caused by the citizenship eligibility crisis. | All MPs and senators will have to lodge declarations and produce evidence that they were not foreign citizens at the time of nomination in a new disclosure measure announced by Malcolm Turnbull to staunch the disruption of the government caused by the citizenship eligibility crisis. |
| Unveiling the plan in Canberra on Monday, Turnbull acknowledged the public’s “legitimate concern” that there is a lack of transparency over whether parliamentarians retain foreign citizenship, but said the cabinet had opted for this transparency measure instead of an audit. | Unveiling the plan in Canberra on Monday, Turnbull acknowledged the public’s “legitimate concern” that there is a lack of transparency over whether parliamentarians retain foreign citizenship, but said the cabinet had opted for this transparency measure instead of an audit. |
| Current and future MPs and senators will be required to state the place and date of birth of themselves and their parents, and details of renunciation of foreign citizenship within 21 days of resolutions to be passed by the Senate and House of Representatives or 21 days of being sworn in. | Current and future MPs and senators will be required to state the place and date of birth of themselves and their parents, and details of renunciation of foreign citizenship within 21 days of resolutions to be passed by the Senate and House of Representatives or 21 days of being sworn in. |
| Turnbull said the system was not an audit because “there is no auditor” and stressed that only the high court could determine if a member of parliament were ineligible. | Turnbull said the system was not an audit because “there is no auditor” and stressed that only the high court could determine if a member of parliament were ineligible. |
| The system mirrors parliamentarians’ disclosure of pecuniary interests, including public release of their statements. | The system mirrors parliamentarians’ disclosure of pecuniary interests, including public release of their statements. |
| Turnbull warned incorrect or false statements would be “a serious breach of [parliamentary] privilege”. He declined to nominate any specific penalty but said political consequences alone would be “very dramatic” and noted parliament could impose further penalties. | Turnbull warned incorrect or false statements would be “a serious breach of [parliamentary] privilege”. He declined to nominate any specific penalty but said political consequences alone would be “very dramatic” and noted parliament could impose further penalties. |
| MPs and senators will have to answer if they were citizens at the time of the nomination and declaration “to the best of their knowledge and belief”, although the high court has found that knowledge is not required to be in breach of section 44 of the constitution, which prohibits foreign citizens from sitting in parliament. | MPs and senators will have to answer if they were citizens at the time of the nomination and declaration “to the best of their knowledge and belief”, although the high court has found that knowledge is not required to be in breach of section 44 of the constitution, which prohibits foreign citizens from sitting in parliament. |
| Turnbull said there was “no question” that the high court’s decision in the citizenship seven case would result in “complex cases” where more parliamentarians may be found to be ineligible. | Turnbull said there was “no question” that the high court’s decision in the citizenship seven case would result in “complex cases” where more parliamentarians may be found to be ineligible. |
| Turnbull said every MP and senator had a continuing “personal obligation to ensure that they are in compliance with the constitution” and the declaration process would bring that obligation “squarely to the front of their mind”. | Turnbull said every MP and senator had a continuing “personal obligation to ensure that they are in compliance with the constitution” and the declaration process would bring that obligation “squarely to the front of their mind”. |
| He suggested the disclosures might prompt some parliamentarians to resign if they discovered facts which suggested they were not eligible, or the parliament could refer them to the high court. | He suggested the disclosures might prompt some parliamentarians to resign if they discovered facts which suggested they were not eligible, or the parliament could refer them to the high court. |
| He stopped short of promising all people who were foreign citizens at the time of nomination would be referred, noting that in some instances, such as Iranian citizenship, the foreign country can refuse renunciation. | He stopped short of promising all people who were foreign citizens at the time of nomination would be referred, noting that in some instances, such as Iranian citizenship, the foreign country can refuse renunciation. |
| “But given the severity and ... the strict literal interpretation of the court’s decision ... if people are foreign citizens, unless there is a proviso of the kind described, then they should not be sitting in the parliament.” | “But given the severity and ... the strict literal interpretation of the court’s decision ... if people are foreign citizens, unless there is a proviso of the kind described, then they should not be sitting in the parliament.” |
| Turnbull said he had received advice from the federal director of the Liberal party that all its MPs and senators believed they were in compliance with the constitution. | Turnbull said he had received advice from the federal director of the Liberal party that all its MPs and senators believed they were in compliance with the constitution. |
| Turnbull’s plan is similar to Labor’s call for “universal disclosure”, which it first suggested on Friday. | Turnbull’s plan is similar to Labor’s call for “universal disclosure”, which it first suggested on Friday. |
| Turnbull said he wanted the Senate to consider a resolution in the next sitting week, starting 13 November. The House of Representatives next sits on 27 November. If the resolutions passed immediately, declarations would be due in early and mid December. | Turnbull said he wanted the Senate to consider a resolution in the next sitting week, starting 13 November. The House of Representatives next sits on 27 November. If the resolutions passed immediately, declarations would be due in early and mid December. |
| At a doorstop interview, Shorten accused Turnbull of a “dramatic about-face”, suggesting he had sneered at Labor’s proposal before proposing something similar. | At a doorstop interview, Shorten accused Turnbull of a “dramatic about-face”, suggesting he had sneered at Labor’s proposal before proposing something similar. |
| Shorten said he would be constructive and meet the prime minister to discuss the proposal, but warned it had to be “fair dinkum” and not “whitewash” instances of parliamentarians sitting while ineligible. | Shorten said he would be constructive and meet the prime minister to discuss the proposal, but warned it had to be “fair dinkum” and not “whitewash” instances of parliamentarians sitting while ineligible. |
| “I will do nothing which stops the high court from arbitrating on matters should the emerging fact situations of parliamentarians require referral to the high court,” he said. | “I will do nothing which stops the high court from arbitrating on matters should the emerging fact situations of parliamentarians require referral to the high court,” he said. |
| The Greens leader, Richard Di Natale, told Sky News the proposal was “full of holes” and amounted to “kicking the can down the road”. | The Greens leader, Richard Di Natale, told Sky News the proposal was “full of holes” and amounted to “kicking the can down the road”. |
| “It does nothing to end the uncertainty – it is absolutely crystal clear that when we get to the end of this process, questions will remain over a number of members of parliament,” he said. | “It does nothing to end the uncertainty – it is absolutely crystal clear that when we get to the end of this process, questions will remain over a number of members of parliament,” he said. |
| Di Natale argued that much of the information is already in the public domain and noted parliamentarians wouldn’t be asked about their grandparents’ place of birth, despite the fact that could confer citizenship by descent. | Di Natale argued that much of the information is already in the public domain and noted parliamentarians wouldn’t be asked about their grandparents’ place of birth, despite the fact that could confer citizenship by descent. |
| He said the penalties were “like being hit with a bit of wet lettuce”. | He said the penalties were “like being hit with a bit of wet lettuce”. |
| “There are people who don’t comply with the register of interests all the time: they do it late ... they’re serial offenders and there’s hardly any sanction.” | “There are people who don’t comply with the register of interests all the time: they do it late ... they’re serial offenders and there’s hardly any sanction.” |
| Earlier Di Natale reiterated the Greens calls for two parliamentary committees to examine eligibility and “to stop any MP being paid who is found to be a dual citizen from the moment of the high court decision”. | Earlier Di Natale reiterated the Greens calls for two parliamentary committees to examine eligibility and “to stop any MP being paid who is found to be a dual citizen from the moment of the high court decision”. |
| Eric Abetz, one of the Coalition backbenchers calling for an audit or similar, welcomed the announcement, saying he was “confident it would go a long way to ensure parliament is seen to have integrity”. | Eric Abetz, one of the Coalition backbenchers calling for an audit or similar, welcomed the announcement, saying he was “confident it would go a long way to ensure parliament is seen to have integrity”. |
| On Monday the Australian Electoral Commission ran recounts to fill the vacancies created by the high court finding that Malcolm Roberts, Larissa Waters, Fiona Nash and Scott Ludlam were ineligible to sit in the Senate. | On Monday the Australian Electoral Commission ran recounts to fill the vacancies created by the high court finding that Malcolm Roberts, Larissa Waters, Fiona Nash and Scott Ludlam were ineligible to sit in the Senate. |
| The recount is understood to have returned One Nation’s Fraser Anning, Green Andrew Bartlett, Liberal Hollie Hughes and Green Jordon Steele-John, who will be confirmed as the new senators by the high court on Friday and sworn in on Monday week. | The recount is understood to have returned One Nation’s Fraser Anning, Green Andrew Bartlett, Liberal Hollie Hughes and Green Jordon Steele-John, who will be confirmed as the new senators by the high court on Friday and sworn in on Monday week. |
| Australian citizenship | Australian citizenship |
| Malcolm Turnbull | Malcolm Turnbull |
| Australian politics | Australian politics |
| Coalition | Coalition |
| Liberal party | Liberal party |
| Labor party | Labor party |
| Bill Shorten | |
| news | news |
| Share on Facebook | Share on Facebook |
| Share on Twitter | Share on Twitter |
| Share via Email | Share via Email |
| Share on LinkedIn | Share on LinkedIn |
| Share on Pinterest | Share on Pinterest |
| Share on Google+ | Share on Google+ |
| Share on WhatsApp | Share on WhatsApp |
| Share on Messenger | Share on Messenger |
| Reuse this content | Reuse this content |