This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-africa-42012629
The article has changed 3 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
Version 1 | Version 2 |
---|---|
What is the extent of China's influence in Zimbabwe? | What is the extent of China's influence in Zimbabwe? |
(about 9 hours later) | |
A trip to Beijing by Zimbabwe's military chief was a "normal military exchange", China's foreign ministry said after the army seized power in Harare. How deep are relations between China and Zimbabwe really? | A trip to Beijing by Zimbabwe's military chief was a "normal military exchange", China's foreign ministry said after the army seized power in Harare. How deep are relations between China and Zimbabwe really? |
The news that General Constantino Chiwenga had visited China only a few days before the military takeover in Zimbabwe was a coincidence that did not go unnoticed. | The news that General Constantino Chiwenga had visited China only a few days before the military takeover in Zimbabwe was a coincidence that did not go unnoticed. |
There was also speculation after China said it was closely watching developments, but stopped short of condemning President Mugabe's apparent removal from power. | There was also speculation after China said it was closely watching developments, but stopped short of condemning President Mugabe's apparent removal from power. |
China is Zimbabwe's fourth largest trading partner and its largest source of investment - with stakes worth many billions of pounds in everything from agriculture to construction. | |
Zimbabwe is the dependent partner - with China providing the largest market for its exports and much needed support to its fragile economy. | |
China's relations with Zimbabwe are deep, starting during the Rhodesian Bush War. | China's relations with Zimbabwe are deep, starting during the Rhodesian Bush War. |
Robert Mugabe failed in 1979 to get Soviet backing, so turned to China, which provided his guerrilla fighters with weapons and training. | Robert Mugabe failed in 1979 to get Soviet backing, so turned to China, which provided his guerrilla fighters with weapons and training. |
Both countries formally established diplomatic relations at Zimbabwean independence in 1980 and Robert Mugabe visited Beijing as prime minister the following year. | Both countries formally established diplomatic relations at Zimbabwean independence in 1980 and Robert Mugabe visited Beijing as prime minister the following year. |
He has been a regular visitor since. | He has been a regular visitor since. |
For years, Zimbabwe's officials have tried to play off China against the West, advocating the country's "Look East" strategy, particularly following the introduction of EU sanctions in 2002. | For years, Zimbabwe's officials have tried to play off China against the West, advocating the country's "Look East" strategy, particularly following the introduction of EU sanctions in 2002. |
Indeed, a decade ago, Mr Mugabe told a packed rally at the Chinese-built national sports stadium in Harare: 'We have turned east, where the sun rises, and given our back to the west, where the sun sets." | Indeed, a decade ago, Mr Mugabe told a packed rally at the Chinese-built national sports stadium in Harare: 'We have turned east, where the sun rises, and given our back to the west, where the sun sets." |
China's military engagement also deepened during Zimbabwe's "Look East" era. | China's military engagement also deepened during Zimbabwe's "Look East" era. |
Significant purchases were made, including Hongdu JL-8 jet aircraft, JF-17 Thunder fighter aircraft, vehicles, radar and weapons. | Significant purchases were made, including Hongdu JL-8 jet aircraft, JF-17 Thunder fighter aircraft, vehicles, radar and weapons. |
However, following a controversy about a shipment of arms in 2008, Beijing decided to list Zimbabwe for "limited level" military trading. | However, following a controversy about a shipment of arms in 2008, Beijing decided to list Zimbabwe for "limited level" military trading. |
Despite Zimbabwe's efforts, the "Look East" strategy did not bring the investment flood hoped for and a decade later, in August 2015, Mr Mugabe openly asked for Western re-engagement in his "state of the nation" address. | Despite Zimbabwe's efforts, the "Look East" strategy did not bring the investment flood hoped for and a decade later, in August 2015, Mr Mugabe openly asked for Western re-engagement in his "state of the nation" address. |
Now, the reality is that increasingly Chinese and Western interests - particularly those of the UK - have become aligned. | Now, the reality is that increasingly Chinese and Western interests - particularly those of the UK - have become aligned. |
Not far from each other in the outer suburbs of Harare, two of the biggest embassies in Zimbabwe are the British and the Chinese. | Not far from each other in the outer suburbs of Harare, two of the biggest embassies in Zimbabwe are the British and the Chinese. |
As other embassies scaled down or closed, Beijing's expanded. | As other embassies scaled down or closed, Beijing's expanded. |
Whereas British diplomats were well connected with business, civil society and opposition figures, the Chinese invested in "technical support" of the party of government Zanu-PF, including state security and the presidency. | Whereas British diplomats were well connected with business, civil society and opposition figures, the Chinese invested in "technical support" of the party of government Zanu-PF, including state security and the presidency. |
When it came to Zanu-PF politics and factionalism, Chinese diplomats were well connected and insightful and, like their Western colleagues, concerned about stability, a better investment climate and adherence to the rule of law. | When it came to Zanu-PF politics and factionalism, Chinese diplomats were well connected and insightful and, like their Western colleagues, concerned about stability, a better investment climate and adherence to the rule of law. |
President Xi Jinping visited Zimbabwe in 2015 and President Mugabe visited Beijing in January 2017. | President Xi Jinping visited Zimbabwe in 2015 and President Mugabe visited Beijing in January 2017. |
In public, the Chinese leader said his country is willing to encourage capable companies to invest in Zimbabwe. | In public, the Chinese leader said his country is willing to encourage capable companies to invest in Zimbabwe. |
But in private, the message was that there would be no more loans until Zimbabwe stabilised its economy. | But in private, the message was that there would be no more loans until Zimbabwe stabilised its economy. |
In 2016 trade between the two countries amounted to $1.1bn (£0.8bn), with China the biggest buyer of Zimbabwean tobacco and also importing cotton and various minerals. | |
In return Zimbabwe imported electronics, clothing and other finished products. | |
Chinese state construction firms have also been active, building infrastructure including Zimbabwe's $100m (£75m) National Defence College. | |
And last year China agreed to finance a new 650-seat parliament in Harare. | |
But Chinese diplomats and many businesses are waiting for better days in Zimbabwe. | |
Some companies have found the investment climate challenging - being burned on diamonds, for example - and have looked for alternative markets. | |
A couple of weeks ago I was in China, attending a meeting on China-Africa relations and Zimbabwe was not mentioned once. | A couple of weeks ago I was in China, attending a meeting on China-Africa relations and Zimbabwe was not mentioned once. |
Unlike Ethiopia, Sudan, or Angola that are strategic partners, or big markets like Nigeria, Kenya and South Africa, Zimbabwe is far from being Beijing's new priority. | Unlike Ethiopia, Sudan, or Angola that are strategic partners, or big markets like Nigeria, Kenya and South Africa, Zimbabwe is far from being Beijing's new priority. |
So, Beijing's interest is in a better investment climate in Zimbabwe. | So, Beijing's interest is in a better investment climate in Zimbabwe. |
A clear transitional arrangement resulting in elections for a legitimate government in Harare is as much in Beijing's interest as London's. | A clear transitional arrangement resulting in elections for a legitimate government in Harare is as much in Beijing's interest as London's. |
The "Look East" and the "Re-engagement with the West" strategies have not brought about the confidence and investment that Zimbabwe needs. | The "Look East" and the "Re-engagement with the West" strategies have not brought about the confidence and investment that Zimbabwe needs. |
What Zimbabwe requires is stable and accountable government - then investors from Asia, America and Europe will seriously consider that Zimbabwe has an investment future. | What Zimbabwe requires is stable and accountable government - then investors from Asia, America and Europe will seriously consider that Zimbabwe has an investment future. |
This was the message that Mr Mugabe received in Beijing in January. | This was the message that Mr Mugabe received in Beijing in January. |
And the one which Zimbabwe's military chief also was given last week. | And the one which Zimbabwe's military chief also was given last week. |
About this piece | About this piece |
This analysis piece was commissioned by the BBC from an expert working for an outside organisation. | This analysis piece was commissioned by the BBC from an expert working for an outside organisation. |
Dr Alex Vines OBE is Head of Africa Programme, Chatham House, and a Senior Lecturer at Coventry University. | Dr Alex Vines OBE is Head of Africa Programme, Chatham House, and a Senior Lecturer at Coventry University. |
Chatham House, the Royal Institute of International Affairs, describes itself as an independent policy institute helping to build a sustainably secure, prosperous and just world. | Chatham House, the Royal Institute of International Affairs, describes itself as an independent policy institute helping to build a sustainably secure, prosperous and just world. |
Edited by Duncan Walker | Edited by Duncan Walker |