This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-wales-politics-42343250
The article has changed 3 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 1 | Version 2 |
|---|---|
| UKIP AM Gareth Bennett barred over 'hateful' remarks | UKIP AM Gareth Bennett barred over 'hateful' remarks |
| (35 minutes later) | |
| UKIP AM Gareth Bennett has been barred from speaking in Senedd debates in 2018 following a speech about transgender rights. | |
| Mr Bennett refused to apologise for saying society could implode if there was too much "deviation from the norm". | |
| Presiding Officer Elin Jones said on Wednesday some of the comments were "particularly hateful". | Presiding Officer Elin Jones said on Wednesday some of the comments were "particularly hateful". |
| Ms Jones wants the AM to say sorry before he can contribute again, but he said he had no intention of doing so. | |
| In a debate on Tuesday, Mr Bennett told the assembly: "There is only so much deviation from the norm that any society can take before that society completely implodes. | In a debate on Tuesday, Mr Bennett told the assembly: "There is only so much deviation from the norm that any society can take before that society completely implodes. |
| "If we carry on down this road of appeasing the nuttiest elements of the transgender movement," he said, "then what we will face as a society, within a very short space of time, is total implosion." | "If we carry on down this road of appeasing the nuttiest elements of the transgender movement," he said, "then what we will face as a society, within a very short space of time, is total implosion." |
| He was speaking about a UK government proposal to make the process of changing legal gender easier. | He was speaking about a UK government proposal to make the process of changing legal gender easier. |
| After Labour AM Joyce Watson raised a point of order on Wednesday objecting to Mr Bennett's remarks, Ms Jones said: "Some of the comments were particularly hateful to the transgender community." | |
| "This chamber is not a platform to demean citizens of Wales. Everyone deserves our respect and our understanding." | "This chamber is not a platform to demean citizens of Wales. Everyone deserves our respect and our understanding." |
| The presiding officer asked Mr Bennett to withdraw his comments and apologise. He refused. | The presiding officer asked Mr Bennett to withdraw his comments and apologise. He refused. |
| UKIP Wales leader Neil Hamilton then intervened, saying it was a "point of argument and debate" and the remarks were related to a bill on gender recognition in the House of Commons. | UKIP Wales leader Neil Hamilton then intervened, saying it was a "point of argument and debate" and the remarks were related to a bill on gender recognition in the House of Commons. |
| "If we cannot in this chamber debate the matters which are contained in a bill that is proposed to be introduced in the House of Commons, I think that's a very serious diminution of the democratic rights of the Welsh people," Mr Hamilton said. | "If we cannot in this chamber debate the matters which are contained in a bill that is proposed to be introduced in the House of Commons, I think that's a very serious diminution of the democratic rights of the Welsh people," Mr Hamilton said. |
| Ms Jones said the South Wales Central AM "will not be called in this chamber in 2018" until he apologises and withdraws his comment. | |
| Mr Bennett then left the chamber. Mr Hamilton attempted to make a further point of order, but Ms Jones dismissed the protest and went on to the next item. | Mr Bennett then left the chamber. Mr Hamilton attempted to make a further point of order, but Ms Jones dismissed the protest and went on to the next item. |
| Ms Jones had singled out Mr Bennett's "deviation from the norm" comment for particular criticism. | |
| 'Collapse' | 'Collapse' |
| Speaking to BBC Wales later on Wednesday Mr Bennett stood his ground - saying he had no intention of apologising for the remarks. | Speaking to BBC Wales later on Wednesday Mr Bennett stood his ground - saying he had no intention of apologising for the remarks. |
| "I do not see that they are in anyway unparliamentarily," he said. | "I do not see that they are in anyway unparliamentarily," he said. |
| "It would be a move towards a collapse of free speech if I was to apologise for them." | "It would be a move towards a collapse of free speech if I was to apologise for them." |
| Mr Bennett said UKIP AMs were unclear on which assembly rule was used to gag him: "As far as we were aware all that could happen is that I could be withdrawn or excluded from proceedings for one day." | Mr Bennett said UKIP AMs were unclear on which assembly rule was used to gag him: "As far as we were aware all that could happen is that I could be withdrawn or excluded from proceedings for one day." |
| Among those critical of Mr Bennett was Plaid Cymru AM Sian Gwenllian, who said the comments were "shameful". | |
| "Members of minority groups have an unquestionable right to be treated equally, regardless of their gender identity, sexual orientation, colour of their skin, religion, disability or anything else", she said. | |
| Andrew White, director of LGBT rights group Stonewall Cymru, said: 'It is disappointing that UKIP's Gareth Bennett has singled out trans people as somehow less deserving of human rights than others." | |
| UKIP Wales leader Neil Hamilton said he had a "frank exchange of views with the presiding officer" on Wednesday afternoon, with a further meeting planned over the recess. | |
| "UKIP is a minority whose rights need to be protected as well," he added. | "UKIP is a minority whose rights need to be protected as well," he added. |
| "We were elected to confront the Cardiff Bay consensus and political correctness and will continue to do so." | |