This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-42870299
The article has changed 2 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
Previous version
1
Next version
Version 0 | Version 1 |
---|---|
Irish abortion referendum: Debate rages after vote announced | Irish abortion referendum: Debate rages after vote announced |
(about 5 hours later) | |
The Republic of Ireland's decision to hold a referendum in May on whether to reform the country's near-total ban on abortion has triggered strong reaction. | |
Voters will be asked whether they want to keep the constitutional restrictions or scrap them, allowing MPs to legislate on the sensitive issue. | |
PM Leo Varadkar urged all sides to be respectful in the run-up to the poll. | |
Abortion is now allowed when a woman's life is at risk - not in cases of fatal foetal abnormality, rape or incest. | |
After Monday's announcement, Children's Minister Katherine Zappone said: "As an independent woman sitting at the cabinet table, I believe we have reached a significant moment and I am full of emotion at this time. | |
"As we continue our preparation for a referendum, it is my firm hope we will have a respectful debate based on the facts. I hope we will live together in an Ireland someday soon where abortion is safe, legal and rare." | "As we continue our preparation for a referendum, it is my firm hope we will have a respectful debate based on the facts. I hope we will live together in an Ireland someday soon where abortion is safe, legal and rare." |
The May vote will decide whether to repeal a constitutional amendment that effectively bans terminations. | The May vote will decide whether to repeal a constitutional amendment that effectively bans terminations. |
The ballot will not be on specific terms of any new law, but on whether to retain or repeal article 40.3.3 of the constitution, known as the Eighth Amendment. | The ballot will not be on specific terms of any new law, but on whether to retain or repeal article 40.3.3 of the constitution, known as the Eighth Amendment. |
Speaking on RTÉ's Morning Ireland on Tuesday, Minister for Health Simon Harris said: "Whether the Eighth Amendment is in our Constitution, or indeed not in our Constitution, abortion is a reality for Irish women. | Speaking on RTÉ's Morning Ireland on Tuesday, Minister for Health Simon Harris said: "Whether the Eighth Amendment is in our Constitution, or indeed not in our Constitution, abortion is a reality for Irish women. |
"I cannot close my eyes and block my ears to the fact that 3,265 of our citizens travelled to the UK in 2016 from every county in Ireland. | "I cannot close my eyes and block my ears to the fact that 3,265 of our citizens travelled to the UK in 2016 from every county in Ireland. |
"I cannot stand over a situation where the abortion pill is illegally accessed in this country and women, perhaps in the privacy of their own bedroom, in a lonely isolated place, [are] taking a pill without any medical supervision." | "I cannot stand over a situation where the abortion pill is illegally accessed in this country and women, perhaps in the privacy of their own bedroom, in a lonely isolated place, [are] taking a pill without any medical supervision." |
Using the hashtags #repealthe8th or #savethe8th, people have welcomed or condemned the decision. | Using the hashtags #repealthe8th or #savethe8th, people have welcomed or condemned the decision. |
Ailbhe Smyth, who has campaigned to have the amendment repealed, welcomed it with open arms. | Ailbhe Smyth, who has campaigned to have the amendment repealed, welcomed it with open arms. |
Many others did too: | Many others did too: |
Some Twitter users point out that in the meantime, the flow of women travelling to England for abortions will continue: | Some Twitter users point out that in the meantime, the flow of women travelling to England for abortions will continue: |
#savethe8th | #savethe8th |
The Eighth Amendment, which was approved by a 1983 referendum, "acknowledges the right to life of the unborn" - meaning the lives of the woman and her unborn child are seen as equal. | |
Those on the anti-abortion side of the debate defend the unborn baby's rights to be taken into account. | Those on the anti-abortion side of the debate defend the unborn baby's rights to be taken into account. |
Some users argue that, once the constitutional protection of the amendment is gone, it will be hard to get back. | Some users argue that, once the constitutional protection of the amendment is gone, it will be hard to get back. |
Michael O'Dowd, spokesman for a new organisation, Disability Voices for Life and who has a son with Down's syndrome, says the amendment could mean a drop in the number of babies with the condition born in Ireland. | Michael O'Dowd, spokesman for a new organisation, Disability Voices for Life and who has a son with Down's syndrome, says the amendment could mean a drop in the number of babies with the condition born in Ireland. |
"People whose disabilities are detected before birth are effectively being wiped out by abortion," he told the Irish Times. | "People whose disabilities are detected before birth are effectively being wiped out by abortion," he told the Irish Times. |
"Ninety per cent of babies diagnosed with Down syndrome in Britain are aborted. In Denmark, 98% of children like my son are aborted, with Iceland now reporting a close to 100% abortion rate for babies with Down syndrome." | "Ninety per cent of babies diagnosed with Down syndrome in Britain are aborted. In Denmark, 98% of children like my son are aborted, with Iceland now reporting a close to 100% abortion rate for babies with Down syndrome." |
But barrister Paul Anthony McDermott says the term "repeal and replace" is a simple one that hides "a certain amount of legal complexity". | But barrister Paul Anthony McDermott says the term "repeal and replace" is a simple one that hides "a certain amount of legal complexity". |
He says the constitution as a whole prohibits abortion and that the proposed replacement clause does not provide immunity for a new abortion law. | He says the constitution as a whole prohibits abortion and that the proposed replacement clause does not provide immunity for a new abortion law. |
This means, that any citizen can still challenge the law if it is passed and say it is unconstitutional, he told RTÉ. | This means, that any citizen can still challenge the law if it is passed and say it is unconstitutional, he told RTÉ. |
Previous version
1
Next version