This article is from the source 'guardian' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2018/jan/30/leaked-brexit-memo-labour-choice-poorer
The article has changed 4 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 0 | Version 1 |
|---|---|
| This leaked Brexit memo means Labour must make a choice | This leaked Brexit memo means Labour must make a choice |
| (about 5 hours later) | |
| Analysis showing any Brexit will leave Britain poorer should push Labour MPs – and voters – to a decisive stand over Europe | Analysis showing any Brexit will leave Britain poorer should push Labour MPs – and voters – to a decisive stand over Europe |
| Tue 30 Jan 2018 11.56 GMT | Tue 30 Jan 2018 11.56 GMT |
| Last modified on Tue 30 Jan 2018 16.46 GMT | |
| Share on Facebook | Share on Facebook |
| Share on Twitter | Share on Twitter |
| Share via Email | Share via Email |
| View more sharing options | View more sharing options |
| Share on LinkedIn | Share on LinkedIn |
| Share on Pinterest | Share on Pinterest |
| Share on Google+ | Share on Google+ |
| Share on WhatsApp | Share on WhatsApp |
| Share on Messenger | Share on Messenger |
| Close | Close |
| Brexit is going to be godawful. | Brexit is going to be godawful. |
| Granted, the leaked draft of the analysis prepared for cabinet ministers didn’t quite use those words, but that was the general gist. Under every scenario considered for leaving the EU, Britain would be worse off, with any Brexit bonus from new trade deals hopelessly dwarfed by the losses. It hasn’t been published, a Department for Exiting the European Union source helpfully explained, “because it’s embarrassing”. Well, quite. | Granted, the leaked draft of the analysis prepared for cabinet ministers didn’t quite use those words, but that was the general gist. Under every scenario considered for leaving the EU, Britain would be worse off, with any Brexit bonus from new trade deals hopelessly dwarfed by the losses. It hasn’t been published, a Department for Exiting the European Union source helpfully explained, “because it’s embarrassing”. Well, quite. |
| Easier just to hide behind Theresa May, saying as little as possible about Brexit and hoping voters blame the Tories | Easier just to hide behind Theresa May, saying as little as possible about Brexit and hoping voters blame the Tories |
| It may be wrong, obviously. It could be as wrong as the forecasts George Osborne produced before the referendum, suggesting we’d all fall into a pit of fire shortly after voting to get out, and it will be just as roundly ignored by leave voters now. Economists, what do they know? It’s remainers who will take it to heart, because everyone likes news that seemingly proves they were right all along. | It may be wrong, obviously. It could be as wrong as the forecasts George Osborne produced before the referendum, suggesting we’d all fall into a pit of fire shortly after voting to get out, and it will be just as roundly ignored by leave voters now. Economists, what do they know? It’s remainers who will take it to heart, because everyone likes news that seemingly proves they were right all along. |
| But if it’s preaching to the converted, uniquely in the Labour party it is also preaching to potential converters; to those millions of members and voters who were never comfortable with Jeremy Corbyn’s (and perhaps more importantly John McDonnell’s) instinctively Eurosceptic stance on Brexit and are getting more not less anxious as the cliff edge draws nearer. What the memo suggests is that any future Labour government now risks exchanging one form of self-imposed, avoidable austerity for another; that it just may not have the money to make good on its promises. | But if it’s preaching to the converted, uniquely in the Labour party it is also preaching to potential converters; to those millions of members and voters who were never comfortable with Jeremy Corbyn’s (and perhaps more importantly John McDonnell’s) instinctively Eurosceptic stance on Brexit and are getting more not less anxious as the cliff edge draws nearer. What the memo suggests is that any future Labour government now risks exchanging one form of self-imposed, avoidable austerity for another; that it just may not have the money to make good on its promises. |
| The memo will undoubtedly bring existing differences in the cabinet to an explosive head. But the majority of Labour voters, members and MPs who backed remain also have a choice to make. If the forecasts are anything like right, they know what it would do to people who are barely coping now. They get that pain will be disproportionately felt in places – the northeast, parts of the Midlands – that haven’t yet recovered from the last shock. They accepted Corbyn’s insistence on leaving both the single market and the customs union either because they believed “Lexit” – Labour leave – arguments about how austerity couldn’t possibly be unravelled otherwise (briskly challenged in Heidi Alexander and Alison McGovern’s new collection of essays) or because they were pragmatists who understood that was how you built a winning Labour coalition in places such as Sunderland and Hartlepool. | The memo will undoubtedly bring existing differences in the cabinet to an explosive head. But the majority of Labour voters, members and MPs who backed remain also have a choice to make. If the forecasts are anything like right, they know what it would do to people who are barely coping now. They get that pain will be disproportionately felt in places – the northeast, parts of the Midlands – that haven’t yet recovered from the last shock. They accepted Corbyn’s insistence on leaving both the single market and the customs union either because they believed “Lexit” – Labour leave – arguments about how austerity couldn’t possibly be unravelled otherwise (briskly challenged in Heidi Alexander and Alison McGovern’s new collection of essays) or because they were pragmatists who understood that was how you built a winning Labour coalition in places such as Sunderland and Hartlepool. |
| Only now they’ve seen the polling suggesting Labour leavers might be wobbling a bit; that voters now back a referendum on the final deal, the baby step Corbyn could perhaps most easily be nudged towards. They desperately want to believe it. The tyranny of hope is kicking in. | Only now they’ve seen the polling suggesting Labour leavers might be wobbling a bit; that voters now back a referendum on the final deal, the baby step Corbyn could perhaps most easily be nudged towards. They desperately want to believe it. The tyranny of hope is kicking in. |
| Now each doom-laden Brexit story grates more than the last. What’s wrong with Labour? Is it just going to stand by and let people suffer? What’s the point of “empowering the membership” but ignoring their views on something life-changing? Talk of a “jobs-first Brexit” – or as it’s otherwise known, a “jobs-first avoidable recession” – is barely more convincing than Downing Street’s argument that its preferred alternative, the one where we magically achieve a deal that isn’t on offer and that nobody can explain, wasn’t in the memo. | Now each doom-laden Brexit story grates more than the last. What’s wrong with Labour? Is it just going to stand by and let people suffer? What’s the point of “empowering the membership” but ignoring their views on something life-changing? Talk of a “jobs-first Brexit” – or as it’s otherwise known, a “jobs-first avoidable recession” – is barely more convincing than Downing Street’s argument that its preferred alternative, the one where we magically achieve a deal that isn’t on offer and that nobody can explain, wasn’t in the memo. |
| Most remainers still vastly underestimate how hard even a partial U-turn would be; how betrayed Labour leavers would feel, how fast anti-immigration feeling could surge again. The only real path back is convincing those who backed leave out of desperation, because they wanted things to change and people to listen, that Labour has better answers. And even assuming Corbyn could break through to a demographic that’s never really trusted him, that’s the work of years not months. Easier just to hide behind Theresa May, saying as little as possible about Brexit and hoping voters blame the Tories for everything that goes wrong. | Most remainers still vastly underestimate how hard even a partial U-turn would be; how betrayed Labour leavers would feel, how fast anti-immigration feeling could surge again. The only real path back is convincing those who backed leave out of desperation, because they wanted things to change and people to listen, that Labour has better answers. And even assuming Corbyn could break through to a demographic that’s never really trusted him, that’s the work of years not months. Easier just to hide behind Theresa May, saying as little as possible about Brexit and hoping voters blame the Tories for everything that goes wrong. |
| But that’s not leadership. It’s not a strategy. It’s barely even a tactic, since at this rate May’s government could fall before a final deal is done. If this is really a government in waiting, it’s time to make some choices. | But that’s not leadership. It’s not a strategy. It’s barely even a tactic, since at this rate May’s government could fall before a final deal is done. If this is really a government in waiting, it’s time to make some choices. |
| • Gaby Hinsliff is a Guardian columnist | • Gaby Hinsliff is a Guardian columnist |
| Labour | Labour |
| First thoughts | First thoughts |
| Brexit | Brexit |
| European Union | European Union |
| Foreign policy | Foreign policy |
| Economic growth (GDP) | Economic growth (GDP) |
| Jeremy Corbyn | Jeremy Corbyn |
| comment | comment |
| Share on Facebook | Share on Facebook |
| Share on Twitter | Share on Twitter |
| Share via Email | Share via Email |
| Share on LinkedIn | Share on LinkedIn |
| Share on Pinterest | Share on Pinterest |
| Share on Google+ | Share on Google+ |
| Share on WhatsApp | Share on WhatsApp |
| Share on Messenger | Share on Messenger |
| Reuse this content | Reuse this content |