This article is from the source 'guardian' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at https://www.theguardian.com/world/2018/feb/04/bbc-journalist-rebecca-henschke-papua-tweets-hurt-soldiers-feelings
The article has changed 4 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 0 | Version 1 |
|---|---|
| BBC journalist ordered out of Papua over tweets that 'hurt soldiers' feelings' | BBC journalist ordered out of Papua over tweets that 'hurt soldiers' feelings' |
| (5 days later) | |
| A BBC journalist reporting on a health and malnutrition crisis in Indonesia’s easternmost area of Papua has been forced to leave the province after the military said tweets she sent during her trip had “hurt soldiers’ feelings”. | A BBC journalist reporting on a health and malnutrition crisis in Indonesia’s easternmost area of Papua has been forced to leave the province after the military said tweets she sent during her trip had “hurt soldiers’ feelings”. |
| Rebecca Henschke, the BBC’s Indonesia editor, had tweeted a photo of supplies on her personal Twitter account, adding: “This is the aid coming in for severely malnourished children in Papua – instant noodles, super sweet soft drinks and biscuits.” | Rebecca Henschke, the BBC’s Indonesia editor, had tweeted a photo of supplies on her personal Twitter account, adding: “This is the aid coming in for severely malnourished children in Papua – instant noodles, super sweet soft drinks and biscuits.” |
| Indonesia’s military said the post about the type of food being sent to the district of Asmat had “hurt the feelings of TNI [Indonesian military] personnel” involved in relief efforts. | Indonesia’s military said the post about the type of food being sent to the district of Asmat had “hurt the feelings of TNI [Indonesian military] personnel” involved in relief efforts. |
| Papua is one of Indonesia’s poorest areas and the president, Joko Widodo, has pledged to speed up its development and ease media restrictions in the area, the site of a simmering secessionist movement. | Papua is one of Indonesia’s poorest areas and the president, Joko Widodo, has pledged to speed up its development and ease media restrictions in the area, the site of a simmering secessionist movement. |
| But while investment has risen and efforts made to address some human rights concerns, activists say foreign journalists continue to be blocked or face obstacles when trying to report. | But while investment has risen and efforts made to address some human rights concerns, activists say foreign journalists continue to be blocked or face obstacles when trying to report. |
| Papua military spokesman Colonel Muhammad Aidi said: “[The food and drink] that she took the picture of at the speedboat pier are not donations or aid. It was merchandise from merchants that was incidentally there.” Aidi also described two other tweets as misleading. | Papua military spokesman Colonel Muhammad Aidi said: “[The food and drink] that she took the picture of at the speedboat pier are not donations or aid. It was merchandise from merchants that was incidentally there.” Aidi also described two other tweets as misleading. |
| Henschke, a Jakarta-based Australian citizen, later took down the photograph and tweeted: “Adding important NOTE: Other sources say this is NOT aid but normal supplies. Huge relief effort underway here.” | Henschke, a Jakarta-based Australian citizen, later took down the photograph and tweeted: “Adding important NOTE: Other sources say this is NOT aid but normal supplies. Huge relief effort underway here.” |
| Indonesia has deployed additional military personnel to help in Asmat, where at least 61 infants are reported to have died from malnutrition and diseases such as measles. | Indonesia has deployed additional military personnel to help in Asmat, where at least 61 infants are reported to have died from malnutrition and diseases such as measles. |
| Henschke had asked to be allowed to continue covering the story during questioning by security forces over her tweets on Friday, but was escorted to the city of Timika and held by immigration, the military statement said. | Henschke had asked to be allowed to continue covering the story during questioning by security forces over her tweets on Friday, but was escorted to the city of Timika and held by immigration, the military statement said. |
| Henschke declined to comment, but a BBC spokesperson said via email: “A BBC team on a deployment to Papua province has now returned to Jakarta. They had the necessary documentation and the authorities were aware of their visit. The BBC respects local laws wherever it operates.” | Henschke declined to comment, but a BBC spokesperson said via email: “A BBC team on a deployment to Papua province has now returned to Jakarta. They had the necessary documentation and the authorities were aware of their visit. The BBC respects local laws wherever it operates.” |
| Many Papuans, who are predominantly Christian and a minority in Muslim-majority Indonesia, criticise Jakarta for neglecting Papua and instead being too focused on the densely populated island of Java. | Many Papuans, who are predominantly Christian and a minority in Muslim-majority Indonesia, criticise Jakarta for neglecting Papua and instead being too focused on the densely populated island of Java. |
| Catholic priest and rights activist John Jonga blamed the crisis on a lack of vaccinations and a switch from more nutritious tubers to rice as a staple food. Some people are also reported to be increasingly relying on instant food or energy drinks. | Catholic priest and rights activist John Jonga blamed the crisis on a lack of vaccinations and a switch from more nutritious tubers to rice as a staple food. Some people are also reported to be increasingly relying on instant food or energy drinks. |
| Andreas Harsono of Human Rights Watch said Henschke’s treatment showed pledges to open up Papua had not materialised. “She had her travel permit – the only Indonesian area where foreign journalists need to get a permit to visit – and still got intimidation for a single tweet,” Harsono said. | Andreas Harsono of Human Rights Watch said Henschke’s treatment showed pledges to open up Papua had not materialised. “She had her travel permit – the only Indonesian area where foreign journalists need to get a permit to visit – and still got intimidation for a single tweet,” Harsono said. |
| A presidential spokesman did not immediately respond to a request for comment. | A presidential spokesman did not immediately respond to a request for comment. |