This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-essex-43155309
The article has changed 2 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
Previous version
1
Next version
Version 0 | Version 1 |
---|---|
Desk-fall Essex Police detective 'exaggerated' injury | Desk-fall Essex Police detective 'exaggerated' injury |
(about 17 hours later) | |
A former detective who "grossly" exaggerated her injury after falling in a police station prank has won damages. | A former detective who "grossly" exaggerated her injury after falling in a police station prank has won damages. |
Rebecca Jenkins, 33, was at Grays police station in 2012 when she slipped after a fellow officer put her phone in a ceiling void. | Rebecca Jenkins, 33, was at Grays police station in 2012 when she slipped after a fellow officer put her phone in a ceiling void. |
Miss Jenkins said the fall caused long-term pain and restriction of movement. | Miss Jenkins said the fall caused long-term pain and restriction of movement. |
She sued Essex Police for £500,000 but the Central London County Court judge said she had not been "candid" in evidence and awarded her £10,825. | She sued Essex Police for £500,000 but the Central London County Court judge said she had not been "candid" in evidence and awarded her £10,825. |
The court heard Sgt Alan Blakesley hid her phone in an attempt to "boost team morale" and watched her clamber up to retrieve it when it rang. | The court heard Sgt Alan Blakesley hid her phone in an attempt to "boost team morale" and watched her clamber up to retrieve it when it rang. |
But Miss Jenkins slipped during her descent, banging her left knee on her desk, said Judge Charles Freeland QC. | But Miss Jenkins slipped during her descent, banging her left knee on her desk, said Judge Charles Freeland QC. |
Miss Jenkins, of Wickford, Essex, was formally dismissed by Essex Police in October. She had returned to work after the accident but never returned after going "off sick" in 2014. | Miss Jenkins, of Wickford, Essex, was formally dismissed by Essex Police in October. She had returned to work after the accident but never returned after going "off sick" in 2014. |
She was seeking over £500,000 from Essex Police, alleging they bore legal responsibility for Sgt Blakesley's "foolhardy" act. | She was seeking over £500,000 from Essex Police, alleging they bore legal responsibility for Sgt Blakesley's "foolhardy" act. |
Miss Jenkins was captured by covert video surveillance which showed her going about her daily life, crouching down to look at shoes in a shop whilst out shopping in high heels in 2016, the court had previously heard. | Miss Jenkins was captured by covert video surveillance which showed her going about her daily life, crouching down to look at shoes in a shop whilst out shopping in high heels in 2016, the court had previously heard. |
Judge Freeland said: "She has grossly exaggerated her symptoms and has not made a reliable witness. | Judge Freeland said: "She has grossly exaggerated her symptoms and has not made a reliable witness. |
"She chose to leave the police force when she was fit for all except confrontational duties. | "She chose to leave the police force when she was fit for all except confrontational duties. |
"I conclude that she now functions extremely well and has exaggerated her symptoms." | "I conclude that she now functions extremely well and has exaggerated her symptoms." |
Judge Freeland said Miss Jenkins had probably recovered from her physical symptoms within two years of the accident. | Judge Freeland said Miss Jenkins had probably recovered from her physical symptoms within two years of the accident. |
He said there was no evidence that Miss Jenkins had been "targeted" for pranks, nor was there a culture of pranking at the police station. | |
The court heard that Miss Jenkins earlier rejected a £50,000 pre-trial offer to settle her claim. | The court heard that Miss Jenkins earlier rejected a £50,000 pre-trial offer to settle her claim. |
Previous version
1
Next version