This article is from the source 'guardian' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.

You can find the current article at its original source at https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2018/mar/28/north-carolina-ends-shackling-of-inmates-during-childbirth

The article has changed 3 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.

Version 0 Version 1
North Carolina ends shackling of inmates during childbirth North Carolina ends shackling of inmates during childbirth
(34 minutes later)
Pregnant inmates will no longer give birth in shackles in North Carolina after a change in the state’s prison rules.Pregnant inmates will no longer give birth in shackles in North Carolina after a change in the state’s prison rules.
Prisons director Kenneth Lassiter announced a new policy Monday that will remove wrist restraints once an inmate is in labor unless she poses an immediate risk of escape or is a clear threat to herself or others. The use of leg or waist restraints will now also be prevented. Prisons director Kenneth Lassiter has announced a new policy that will remove wrist restraints once an inmate is in labor unless she poses an immediate risk of escape or is a clear threat to herself or others. The use of leg or waist restraints will now also be stopped.
North Carolina joins 18 other states where legislation prohibits or restricts such shackling, although many of those laws are not properly implemented according to the American Civil Liberties Union. Of the 200,000 women in US prisons or jails each year, 6%, or 12,000, are pregnant when they are incarcerated, the ACLU reported.North Carolina joins 18 other states where legislation prohibits or restricts such shackling, although many of those laws are not properly implemented according to the American Civil Liberties Union. Of the 200,000 women in US prisons or jails each year, 6%, or 12,000, are pregnant when they are incarcerated, the ACLU reported.
Eight states have no laws or policies on the subject at all, essentially giving prisons the option to handcuff an inmate while she’s having her baby and also use other restraints earlier in the labor. Other states have some restrictive policies but no laws protecting the mother from being shackled in childbirth.Eight states have no laws or policies on the subject at all, essentially giving prisons the option to handcuff an inmate while she’s having her baby and also use other restraints earlier in the labor. Other states have some restrictive policies but no laws protecting the mother from being shackled in childbirth.
Dr Carolyn Sufrin, an OB-GYN at Johns Hopkins School of Medicine, welcomed North Carolina’s decision but added that “passing laws and changing policy is only one step – there needs to be training and accountability and oversight to make sure that it doesn’t actually happen”. Dr Carolyn Sufrin, an OB-GYN at Johns Hopkins school of medicine, welcomed North Carolina’s decision but said: “Passing laws and changing policy is only one steps– there needs to be training and accountability and oversight to make sure that it doesn’t actually happen.”
Sufrin has delivered the babies of several women who were incarcerated, but only one who was in chains. She described it as a “deeply troubling experience”, adding “I felt like I was not providing good care to that patient. I worried about what I would do if the baby’s shoulder got stuck in the birth canal or if the mother needed an emergency c-section. I wondered how she would be able to hold the baby after it was born.” Sufrin has delivered the babies of several imprisoned women, but only one who was in chains. She described it as a “deeply troubling experience”. She said: “I felt like I was not providing good care to that patient. I worried about what I would do if the baby’s shoulder got stuck in the birth canal or if the mother needed an emergency c-section. I wondered how she would be able to hold the baby after it was born.”
The continued use of shackles has repeatedly been criticized by human rights organizations and health professionals. The American Medical Association has described it as “a barbaric practice that needlessly inflicts excruciating pain and humiliation”. The practice contravenes the United Nations Convention against Torture. The continued use of shackles has repeatedly been criticized by human rights organizations and health professionals. The American Medical Association has described it as “a barbaric practice that needlessly inflicts excruciating pain and humiliation”. The practice contravenes the United Nations convention against torture.
There are health risks too, according to the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists, including:There are health risks too, according to the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists, including:
Increased duration and painfulness of labor. Women who are shackled to a hospital bed cannot walk or change position (which can shorten and ease labor).Increased duration and painfulness of labor. Women who are shackled to a hospital bed cannot walk or change position (which can shorten and ease labor).
Possible delays if emergency operations are needed.Possible delays if emergency operations are needed.
Increased risk of postpartum hemorrhaging.Increased risk of postpartum hemorrhaging.
Many of these pregnancies are already high risk because incarcerated women often lack prenatal care, have poor nutrition, experience of domestic violence, mental illness and drug or alcohol abuse. Many of these pregnancies are already high risk. Incarcerated women often lack adequate pre-natal care and are at greater exposure to poor nutrition, domestic violence, mental illness, and drug or alcohol abuse.
“I am unaware of any cases of women or girls in labor attempting to escape. If I did – I would suggest that they are superhuman. Corrections officials often use this crazy scenario as a justification for chaining women prisoners during childbirth – but it simply doesn’t hold water,” Amy Fettig, deputy director of the ACLU national prison project, told the Guardian. Amy Fettig, the deputy director of the ACLU national prison project, told the Guardian: “I am unaware of any cases of women or girls in labor attempting to escape. If I did, I would suggest that they are superhuman. Corrections officials often use this crazy scenario as a justification for chaining women prisoners during childbirth – but it simply doesn’t hold water.”
Shawanna Nelson is one prisoner whose experience in Arkansas has helped to shift the debate in recent years. When she arrived to the hospital in 2003 with her legs shackled together, she had already been in labor for 12 hours. After childbirth, shackles caused her to soil the bed sheets as she was unable to reach a bathroom in time. Shawanna Nelson’s experience in Arkansas has helped to shift the debate in recent years. When she arrived to the hospital in 2003 with her legs shackled together, she had already been in labor for 12 hours. After childbirth, shackles caused her to soil the bed sheets as she was unable to reach a bathroom in time.
North Carolina’s change in policy came after repeated criticism from advocacy groups such as SisterSong, which campaigns for reproductive rights for women of color.North Carolina’s change in policy came after repeated criticism from advocacy groups such as SisterSong, which campaigns for reproductive rights for women of color.
SisterSong lobbied the department after it received reports that two prisoners had been shackled during childbirth in the state in recent months, despite medical staff asking that the shackles be removed.SisterSong lobbied the department after it received reports that two prisoners had been shackled during childbirth in the state in recent months, despite medical staff asking that the shackles be removed.
Omisade Burney Scott, director of strategic partnerships and advocacy for SisterSong, said: “I don’t know many pregnant women who try to escape the hospital when they’re in the throes of labor.”Omisade Burney Scott, director of strategic partnerships and advocacy for SisterSong, said: “I don’t know many pregnant women who try to escape the hospital when they’re in the throes of labor.”
The Associated Press contributed to this report.The Associated Press contributed to this report.
For more information on this subject, full state-by-state report cards were published here in 2010 by the National Women’s Law Center and the Rebecca Project for Human Rights. For more information on this subject, full state-by-state report cards were published here in 2010 by the National Women’s Law Center and the Rebecca Project for Human Rights
US prisonsUS prisons
North CarolinaNorth Carolina
PregnancyPregnancy
newsnews
Share on FacebookShare on Facebook
Share on TwitterShare on Twitter
Share via EmailShare via Email
Share on LinkedInShare on LinkedIn
Share on PinterestShare on Pinterest
Share on Google+Share on Google+
Share on WhatsAppShare on WhatsApp
Share on MessengerShare on Messenger
Reuse this contentReuse this content