This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/newsbeat-43554424
The article has changed 2 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
Previous version
1
Next version
Version 0 | Version 1 |
---|---|
Are adverts deliberately being racist? | Are adverts deliberately being racist? |
(about 9 hours later) | |
Several big brands have been labelled "racist" recently after releasing adverts which have backfired. | Several big brands have been labelled "racist" recently after releasing adverts which have backfired. |
H&M apologised in January for showing a black child modelling a hoodie which had "coolest monkey in the jungle" on the front, following a huge backlash. | H&M apologised in January for showing a black child modelling a hoodie which had "coolest monkey in the jungle" on the front, following a huge backlash. |
Dove soap said sorry a few months earlier for releasing a series of images that appeared to show a black woman turning into a white person. | |
And Chance the Rapper has labelled an advert for Heineken's low calorie beer "terribly racist" - claiming that brands are "purposely putting out noticeably racist ads so they can get more views". | And Chance the Rapper has labelled an advert for Heineken's low calorie beer "terribly racist" - claiming that brands are "purposely putting out noticeably racist ads so they can get more views". |
But is there any truth in his claim? | But is there any truth in his claim? |
Paul MacKenzie-Cummins, managing director of Clearly PR Marketing and Communications, thinks some brands are using race to grab people's attention. | Paul MacKenzie-Cummins, managing director of Clearly PR Marketing and Communications, thinks some brands are using race to grab people's attention. |
"They're clever people, those who work in ad agencies. They're very skilled and have huge budgets and are under increasing pressure to raise the profile of their client's brand. | "They're clever people, those who work in ad agencies. They're very skilled and have huge budgets and are under increasing pressure to raise the profile of their client's brand. |
"It's an ultra-competitive market and the retail space has never been as competitive as what it is now. They need to do something to get their voices seen and heard." | "It's an ultra-competitive market and the retail space has never been as competitive as what it is now. They need to do something to get their voices seen and heard." |
Paul, who worked in advertising for 11 years, thinks the approach will ultimately damage a brand's reputation. | Paul, who worked in advertising for 11 years, thinks the approach will ultimately damage a brand's reputation. |
"To a degree Chance is kind of right in the sense that it's deliberately being provocative and it's trying to get the headlines - and it's working in that respect. That's the key word - respect. That's what it comes back down to. | "To a degree Chance is kind of right in the sense that it's deliberately being provocative and it's trying to get the headlines - and it's working in that respect. That's the key word - respect. That's what it comes back down to. |
"And this ultimately is going to be much more damaging for brands than what they actually realise." | "And this ultimately is going to be much more damaging for brands than what they actually realise." |
The UK's advertising watchdog, the Advertising Standards Authority (ASA), has received 2396 racism complaints since 2013 about 956 different ads. | The UK's advertising watchdog, the Advertising Standards Authority (ASA), has received 2396 racism complaints since 2013 about 956 different ads. |
Of those, 12 cases were formally investigated and 10 of those had the complaint upheld. | Of those, 12 cases were formally investigated and 10 of those had the complaint upheld. |
The ASA has the power to ban adverts it thinks breaches its standards. | The ASA has the power to ban adverts it thinks breaches its standards. |
One of its most recent cases was a complaint against Paddy Power for an advert featuring boxer Floyd Mayweather Jr, which encouraged readers to "always bet on black". | One of its most recent cases was a complaint against Paddy Power for an advert featuring boxer Floyd Mayweather Jr, which encouraged readers to "always bet on black". |
It banned the advert because it was "likely to cause serious offence on the grounds of race", and told the bookies not to make the same mistake again. | It banned the advert because it was "likely to cause serious offence on the grounds of race", and told the bookies not to make the same mistake again. |
Kubi Springer is the founder of global branding agency She Builds Brands and has worked with the likes of L'Oreal and the Mobo Awards. | Kubi Springer is the founder of global branding agency She Builds Brands and has worked with the likes of L'Oreal and the Mobo Awards. |
She says that despite adverts being looked at by lots of people before they make it to the public, a "lack of diversity" in advertising agencies means things can be missed. | She says that despite adverts being looked at by lots of people before they make it to the public, a "lack of diversity" in advertising agencies means things can be missed. |
"I wouldn't go as far as to say [brands are making] innocent mistakes, but also wouldn't go as far as Chance the Rapper and say they are being deliberately racist. | "I wouldn't go as far as to say [brands are making] innocent mistakes, but also wouldn't go as far as Chance the Rapper and say they are being deliberately racist. |
"You need people at management and senior manager level that are diverse - and that's both ethnicity, as well as the LGBT community, as well as women who will say 'Actually this might offend a particular demographic and maybe you should think about this again'." | "You need people at management and senior manager level that are diverse - and that's both ethnicity, as well as the LGBT community, as well as women who will say 'Actually this might offend a particular demographic and maybe you should think about this again'." |
A 2017 survey by the Institute of Practitioners in Advertising found that 12.9% of employees in the ad industry were from a black or ethnic minority background. | A 2017 survey by the Institute of Practitioners in Advertising found that 12.9% of employees in the ad industry were from a black or ethnic minority background. |
Sarah Jenkins, the chief marketing officer at advertising agency Grey London, doesn't believe any brand would put out a racist ad on purpose. | Sarah Jenkins, the chief marketing officer at advertising agency Grey London, doesn't believe any brand would put out a racist ad on purpose. |
Her agency has set up a diversity task force - which has the support of around 20 advertising agencies - to help the industry attract more representative employees. | Her agency has set up a diversity task force - which has the support of around 20 advertising agencies - to help the industry attract more representative employees. |
Like Kubi, she thinks a lack of diversity within the industry means some brands may not realise their ads could be seen as inappropriate. | Like Kubi, she thinks a lack of diversity within the industry means some brands may not realise their ads could be seen as inappropriate. |
She says: "Although we're seeing some bad campaigns there are some brilliant agencies and initiatives in place. | She says: "Although we're seeing some bad campaigns there are some brilliant agencies and initiatives in place. |
"I think what we've done with the diversity task force is pull together the biggest and most forward-thinking ad agencies in the UK and we're working together and using our skills to attract the best talent. | "I think what we've done with the diversity task force is pull together the biggest and most forward-thinking ad agencies in the UK and we're working together and using our skills to attract the best talent. |
"That's not because we're worried about getting things wrong, it's a more positive reason. It's because when we are diverse we get better ideas, we get different perspectives and different approaches and the work simply gets better." | "That's not because we're worried about getting things wrong, it's a more positive reason. It's because when we are diverse we get better ideas, we get different perspectives and different approaches and the work simply gets better." |
Follow Newsbeat on Instagram, Facebook and Twitter. | Follow Newsbeat on Instagram, Facebook and Twitter. |
Listen to Newsbeat live at 12:45 and 17:45 every weekday on BBC Radio 1 and 1Xtra - if you miss us you can listen back here. | Listen to Newsbeat live at 12:45 and 17:45 every weekday on BBC Radio 1 and 1Xtra - if you miss us you can listen back here. |
Previous version
1
Next version