This article is from the source 'guardian' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2018/apr/18/victoria-polices-body-cameras-attacked-as-pretend-accountability
The article has changed 5 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 2 | Version 3 |
|---|---|
| Victoria police's body cameras attacked as ‘pretend accountability’ | Victoria police's body cameras attacked as ‘pretend accountability’ |
| (4 months later) | |
| The rollout of body cameras by the Victorian state police is an example of “pretend accountability” because officers maintain discretion over when to use the devices and sanctions for misuse are not clear, critics claim. | The rollout of body cameras by the Victorian state police is an example of “pretend accountability” because officers maintain discretion over when to use the devices and sanctions for misuse are not clear, critics claim. |
| On Wednesday the police in Melbourne’s north became the first in the state to be equipped with the cameras, part of statewide rollout expected to be complete by 2020. | On Wednesday the police in Melbourne’s north became the first in the state to be equipped with the cameras, part of statewide rollout expected to be complete by 2020. |
| The Victorian government and police force said the cameras will function as an accountability tool, and help to “de-escalate violence in interactions between the police and criminals”. | The Victorian government and police force said the cameras will function as an accountability tool, and help to “de-escalate violence in interactions between the police and criminals”. |
| Officers will not be able to delete or alter the footage and it will be kept for a minimum of 90 days. | Officers will not be able to delete or alter the footage and it will be kept for a minimum of 90 days. |
| • Sign up to receive the top stories every morning | • Sign up to receive the top stories every morning |
| “Police will be turning the cameras on whenever they are exercising police powers, collecting evidence or when it would provide transparency to a police interaction,” the Victorian police commander, Russell Barrett, said on Wednesday. | “Police will be turning the cameras on whenever they are exercising police powers, collecting evidence or when it would provide transparency to a police interaction,” the Victorian police commander, Russell Barrett, said on Wednesday. |
| But lawyers and MPs remain critical of the policy because, they say, officers both in Victoria and in other jurisdictions have been given too much discretion about when to use the cameras. | But lawyers and MPs remain critical of the policy because, they say, officers both in Victoria and in other jurisdictions have been given too much discretion about when to use the cameras. |
| “From an accountability perspective it’s only effective if there are very clear stipulations about when the camera is turned on and off, and repercussions for officers if it’s misused,” said Anthony Kelly, the executive officer of the Flemington and Kensington Community Legal Centre’s police accountability project. | “From an accountability perspective it’s only effective if there are very clear stipulations about when the camera is turned on and off, and repercussions for officers if it’s misused,” said Anthony Kelly, the executive officer of the Flemington and Kensington Community Legal Centre’s police accountability project. |
| “From our perspective there remains a lot of discretion around use, and that’s still a concern.” | “From our perspective there remains a lot of discretion around use, and that’s still a concern.” |
| Paramedics to be fitted with body cameras after violent assaults soar | |
| The Victorian police minister, Lisa Neville, said officers in Victoria “will turn the cameras on whenever they are exercising police powers, collecting evidence or when it would provide transparency to a police interaction”. | The Victorian police minister, Lisa Neville, said officers in Victoria “will turn the cameras on whenever they are exercising police powers, collecting evidence or when it would provide transparency to a police interaction”. |
| At a press conference on Wednesday she said that in instances where the cameras are not turned on police “will have to indicate why they haven’t activated”. | At a press conference on Wednesday she said that in instances where the cameras are not turned on police “will have to indicate why they haven’t activated”. |
| Barrett said that decisions about whether officers could face punishment for not turning on the cameras would be made “on a case-by-case basis”. | Barrett said that decisions about whether officers could face punishment for not turning on the cameras would be made “on a case-by-case basis”. |
| But neither Neville or Barrett outlined what kind of sanctions would be applied to officers. So far the only legislative change made by the Victorian government was when it used surveillance laws to allow officers to use the devices. | But neither Neville or Barrett outlined what kind of sanctions would be applied to officers. So far the only legislative change made by the Victorian government was when it used surveillance laws to allow officers to use the devices. |
| It’s the moments when police don’t want to be recorded that are often the most important | It’s the moments when police don’t want to be recorded that are often the most important |
| In other jurisdictions where officers have been given broad discretion over use of the cameras, critics of the policy say it has stunted their effectiveness. | In other jurisdictions where officers have been given broad discretion over use of the cameras, critics of the policy say it has stunted their effectiveness. |
| In New South Wales, the state government has been rolling out the cameras since 2014. Guidelines for their use state that officers can “activate the record function of the camera at their discretion”. | In New South Wales, the state government has been rolling out the cameras since 2014. Guidelines for their use state that officers can “activate the record function of the camera at their discretion”. |
| “Generally this will be incident-specific or to capture something of relevance,” the guidelines state. | “Generally this will be incident-specific or to capture something of relevance,” the guidelines state. |
| David Shoebridge, a Greens upper house MP from NSW, said the usefulness of body cameras has been limited because of that discretion. He said Victoria and NSW should follow the example of states in the US, where officers are required to have the cameras on whenever they are in public. | David Shoebridge, a Greens upper house MP from NSW, said the usefulness of body cameras has been limited because of that discretion. He said Victoria and NSW should follow the example of states in the US, where officers are required to have the cameras on whenever they are in public. |
| “It’s the moments when police don’t want to be recorded that are often the most important,” he said. | “It’s the moments when police don’t want to be recorded that are often the most important,” he said. |
| “We know that the ability of police to turn off these cameras at will substantially reduce their effectiveness in protecting the public and improving accountability. | “We know that the ability of police to turn off these cameras at will substantially reduce their effectiveness in protecting the public and improving accountability. |
| “There is an expectation officers will have cameras on when exercising a police power or using force, but there is no legal requirement that they do so, and no sanction for any breach.” | “There is an expectation officers will have cameras on when exercising a police power or using force, but there is no legal requirement that they do so, and no sanction for any breach.” |
| Australian police and policing | Australian police and policing |
| Victoria | Victoria |
| Melbourne | Melbourne |
| Victorian politics | Victorian politics |
| Law (Australia) | Law (Australia) |
| news | news |
| Share on Facebook | Share on Facebook |
| Share on Twitter | Share on Twitter |
| Share via Email | Share via Email |
| Share on LinkedIn | Share on LinkedIn |
| Share on Pinterest | Share on Pinterest |
| Share on Google+ | Share on Google+ |
| Share on WhatsApp | Share on WhatsApp |
| Share on Messenger | Share on Messenger |
| Reuse this content | Reuse this content |